The Birthday Gift (5 page)

“God, babe.”
Jake cupped her head and started pumping his hips again. “Yeah, just like that.
Take it all.”

Jake’s semen
hit the back of her throat. Patrick dug his fingers into her hips and cursed
softly. Knowing both men were coming at the same time sent Amanda over the top
again. She greedily swallowed Jake’s semen as another orgasm rushed through her
body.

It should’ve
been enough. Jake knew it should’ve been enough.

It wasn’t.

Watching his
cousin touch his wife, lick her, fuck her, did something to him that he’d never
experienced…something almost animalistic. Thinking about Patrick being with
Amanda had been exciting, a taste of the forbidden, a fantasy. The real thing
had been raw, earthy, beyond anything sexual he’d ever experienced.

Earth-shattering.

He loved sex
with his wife. Making love with Amanda was always amazing. Tonight, it went
beyond amazing.

Jake looked
down at his wife. She lay on her stomach, her cheek resting on his thigh, her
eyes closed. The candlelight reflected off her sweat-glazed skin. She had to be
exhausted. So should he, yet he wasn’t. He wanted her again.

He looked at
his cousin. Patrick was still on his knees between Amanda’s spread legs. His
chest rose and fell rapidly from his heavy breathing, his skin was bathed in
sweat. He stared at her pussy as if he were starving and it was a steak dinner.

Patrick
raised his head and gazed at Jake. The wild look in Patrick’s eyes told Jake
that his cousin wasn’t finished either.

Jake and
Patrick had already discussed in detail everything they planned to do tonight,
so Jake knew what came next. He reached for the pillow on the floor behind him
and slipped it under Amanda’s cheek. Picking up the bottle of massage oil, he
moved over next to Patrick. “Want this?” he asked.

“Yeah.”
Patrick took the bottle and tipped it upside down, allowing a thin stream of
oil to flow between her buttocks.

Amanda
shifted when the oil touched her. “No way, guys. I’m pooped.”

Jake scooped
some of the oil on his fingertips and spread it over her buttocks. “It’s still
your birthday. Pat and I want to draw out your present for awhile longer.”

“Jake—”

“Just lie
still, Mandy, and let us play a little.”

Jake slid his
fingers between her legs. The oil, mixed with her own body’s wetness and
Patrick’s semen, let him easily glide two fingers inside her pussy. He slowly
pumped them in and out as he watched his cousin slide his thumb through the oil
and press it against her anus.

Amanda
tightened her buttocks, but Patrick didn’t stop. He held his thumb against her
until she relaxed again and allowed his touch. Patrick pressed his thumb a bit
farther inside her, withdrew, and pressed again. Anal sex wasn’t Amanda’s
favorite thing, but she did enjoy being touched and licked there. Jake had
fucked her there only a few times in their four years together, and only when
she was very aroused.

She had a
feeling the “very aroused” bit wouldn’t be a problem tonight.

Patrick
pushed his thumb all the way inside her. Amanda bucked once, and Jake heard her
sharply indrawn breath.

“You okay,
Mandy?”

“Yes.”

“Does this
feel good, Amanda?” Patrick asked as he began moving his thumb faster inside
her.

“Mmm,
yesssssss…”

Jake
increased the motion of his fingers. He withdrew them every few moments and
dipped down to touch her clitoris, then plunged back inside her. Amanda began
to lift her hips in time to their movements. When she raised up to her knees
and spread her legs farther, Jake knew she wanted more. He looked at Patrick
and nodded.

Patrick
removed his thumb and picked up the bottle of oil. He poured a generous amount
on the fingers of his left hand, and more between Amanda’s buttocks. She moaned
when Patrick pushed his index finger inside her ass. Jake increased the pumping
of his own fingers as he watched Patrick add his middle finger to the first.

“God, she’s
tight,” Patrick said, his voice husky.

Twisting his
wrist, Patrick drilled his fingers farther inside her. Amanda pushed her hips
back at them. Seeing his wife so open, so hot, made the animal rear up inside
Jake again. He pulled his hand from her and crawled to her side. Lying next to
Amanda, he brushed her hair from her face. Her eyes were half closed and burned
with hunger.

Leaning over
her, Jake kissed her jaw, her cheek, her temple. “Ride me, Mandy,” he breathed
in her ear.

* * * * *

Jake’s
whispered request penetrated Amanda’s lust-fogged brain. He couldn’t mean… They
couldn’t be thinking of her taking both of them at the same time. She’d read
books with double penetration and had seen it in an X-rated movie Jake talked
her into watching, but she didn’t think it was even physically possible for her
to do that.

The thought
intrigued her…and excited her.

Tonight, she
wanted to try everything.

Jake lay on
his back. “C’mere, Mandy.”

Amanda swung
one leg over him and straddled his hips. Grasping his cock in her hand, she
slowly slid down until he was all the way inside her.

Jake cradled
her face and pulled her head down to his. She lay sprawled on his chest, her
buttocks in the air, while he kissed her over and over. Patrick kept moving his
fingers in and out, in and out, getting her ass ready for him.

When Patrick
removed his fingers, Amanda tensed. Jake must have felt her reaction for he
kissed her again and nuzzled her neck. “Relax, Mandy,” he whispered. “Let us
love you.”

Amanda stared
down into her husband’s handsome face. He would never hurt her, and he would
never let anyone else hurt her. She trusted him, and she trusted Patrick.

Patrick’s
cock brushed her anus. Concentrating on total relaxation, Amanda took a deep
breath and let it out slowly. He pressed a bit harder, and the head slipped
inside her.

“Ohhh…”

“Okay, babe?”
Jake asked.

Amanda
nodded. She laid her head on Jake’s shoulder. He grasped her behind her knees
and pulled them closer to his waist. The new position raised her buttocks
higher in the air.

The oil on
her skin made it easier for Patrick to move. He withdrew and advanced several
times, entering her a bit farther with each stroke. Amanda bit her bottom lip
when his thighs touched the back of hers and she knew he was all the way inside
her.

Both men
remained still for long moments. Jake was the first to shift beneath her. He
lifted his hips, driving his cock deeper. He lowered his hips at the same time
that Patrick moved forward. They repeated the action until they developed a
rhythm with her. Slowly, so slowly, they moved inside her. As one withdrew, the
other one drove in.

Amanda
practically purred. It felt incredible.

Their thrusts
picked up speed, and so did Amanda’s heartbeat. She listened to their breathing
become more ragged, watched as sweat pooled in Jake’s hairline and neck.
Reaching for the pinnacle of pleasure, she joined in their rhythm, slamming her
hips down on her husband, then back up at his cousin.

It must have
been the signal Patrick needed. He gripped her hips and began fucking her hard
and fast.

Jake came
first, bucking beneath her as he growled low in his throat. Patrick soon
followed, pressing his groin tightly against her buttocks and groaning loudly.
His last thrust send Amanda over the edge into oblivion.

* * * * *

Amanda
drained her glass and held it out for Patrick to refill. The cold white wine
tasted wonderful. She didn’t think she’d ever been so thirsty.

“Better be
careful with the wine, Amanda,” Patrick said as he poured the last of the
bottle into her glass. “Too much wine will loosen your inhibitions.”

“
What
inhibitions? I don’t have any of those.”

“Especially
after tonight,” Jake said.

“That’s
true.” Amanda sipped her wine. She felt deliciously light-headed and weak after
two glasses of wine and three hours of astonishing sex. Five orgasms. She’d
never
had five orgasms, not even when she and Jake had first gotten together and
couldn’t keep their hands off each other.

Patrick lay
stretched out on his side on the quilt. Jake sat propped against the recliner,
his legs out in front of him and crossed at the ankles. Amanda sat so she could
see both of them with her legs drawn up to her chest. No one had bothered to
put on any clothes. Looking at two gorgeous nude men was almost as good as
having sex with two gorgeous nude men.

Almost.

“I have some
questions.”

“I figured
you would,” Jake muttered. He drained his own glass of wine and set it on the
floor. “Shoot.”

“When did
y’all plan this?”

“I am
completely innocent,” Patrick said. “This was all Jake’s idea.”

“Innocent, my
ass. You thought the idea was great when I told you about it.”

“I didn’t say
I didn’t think it was a great idea. I said it was
your
idea.”

“Okay, guys,
I get the picture. It was Jake’s idea.” She looked at her husband. “Did you
plan this before Patrick got here?”

“No. Pat had
been here several days before I approached him about doing this for you. I
wasn’t sure if he’d want to, and I wasn’t sure I’d be able to share you.”

“But you
decided to.”

“Yeah,
because you said it was your fantasy. I wanted to give you what you wanted.”

His words
warmed her heart. How she loved this man. Her gaze flickered from Jake to
Patrick and back again. “You’ve never done anything like this?”

She saw
Patrick glance at Jake before he turned back to her and said, “No.”

“Wait a
minute. I saw that look you gave Jake, Patrick. You’re lying to me.”

“No, I’m not.
Jake and I have never been in a threesome before tonight.”

“I hear a
‘but’ after that sentence.”

When he
didn’t say anything else, Amanda faced her husband. “Jake?”

He rubbed his
chin. Amanda recognized that stalling tactic and waited for him to speak.

“Patrick and
I have been close all our lives, Amanda. We’re both only children and there’s
less than a year between us. We grew up like brothers. Brothers…share things.”

“Explain.”

Jake ran his
hand through his hair, another stalling tactic Amanda recognized. “We went
through school together in San Diego. We went to college there for two years
before Patrick moved to Colorado. College can be…” He stopped.

“Entertaining?”
Amanda supplied.

“Very,”
Patrick said with a wicked grin.

“So y’all had
sex with the same women?”

“Maybe once,”
Jake said. Amanda arched one eyebrow at him. “Okay, maybe more than once. We
were young and healthy with raging hormones, Amanda.”

She looked
from one man to the other again. They were both incredible lovers. In her
opinion, they still had raging hormones. “Are you talking orgies, Jake?”

“We…did that
a time or two, yeah.”

Amanda
thought about that a moment. They’d grown up together. They’d had orgies together.
She’d wondered why they were so at ease with each other. She doubted if many
men sat around naked on the living room floor. “That explains it then.”

Jake frowned.
“Explains what?”

“Why y’all
are so comfortable together naked. I’m not speaking from experience, but I
would imagine two guys in a situation like this would be uneasy to be so close
to each other. They’d be afraid if they touched each other, it meant they were
gay or something.”

“Shit, Pat
and I practically grew up naked. I’ve seen his wanger as often as I’ve seen
mine. It’s no big deal.”

“I beg your
pardon,” Patrick said. “It is too a big deal.”

Amanda lifted
her glass towards him and grinned. “I’ll drink to that.” She took another sip
of wine and set her glass on the coffee table behind her. “So, how detailed did
you get with Patrick about me?”

A guilty look
flashed through Jake’s eyes. “What do you mean?”

“I mean, he
knew exactly how and where to touch me.”

“Amanda,
every woman has tits, an ass, and a pussy.”

She scowled
at him. “Don’t be crude, and don’t act dumb. Different women need different
things sexually. Patrick couldn’t have touched me the way he did to make me
come so quickly if he hadn’t known some details.”

Jake quickly
glanced at his cousin before looking back at Amanda. She could still see the
guilt in his eyes. “I may have…coached him a bit.”

Patrick sat
up. “Amanda, don’t be angry at Jake. You’re right. Women are different. Jake
told me some things about your body and how you like to be touched, but only
because he wanted to be sure you were completely satisfied tonight.”

“I’m not
angry, Patrick,” Amanda said softly before smiling at her husband. “I love Jake
for being so unselfish and so caring. And I was most definitely completely
satisfied. You were both amazing. It was a wonderful birthday present.”