Undeniably Asher (The Colloway Brothers Book 2) (8 page)

Then Livia left me too. She left everyone without any reason, without any forewarning, and without any explanation. Just like our mother did. It was a heart-crushing, devastating blow. To this day I still don’t know why, even though I talked to her several times during her absence. All I know is her story about needing some time away was pure bullshit.

Livia was always a caretaker. What she did was completely out of character for her. It’s a secret between us that has caused a huge rift, one that I’m trying to let go, because after her three-year absence, I’m simply glad to have her back in my life, but some days it’s difficult.

Like today.

I see how happy she and Gray are and obviously he has fully forgiven her, so why can’t I? I see acceptance in the actions and words of the Colloway family, so what’s wrong with
me
?

In one way or another, everyone I have ever loved has deserted or betrayed me.

My mother.

My father.

My sister.

My lover.

So is it any wonder that with every relationship I have, I’m always waiting for the other shoe to drop? Is it any wonder I don’t let myself fully love another person?

I’ve never let anyone see one hundred percent of Alyse Kingsley. Not one. I’ve had secrets from
every single person
in my life. Even Livia. I show people what I want, keeping the rest hidden, protected. Never putting myself completely out there. Never really exposing my thin skin, my inner brokenness. I excel at appearing open, while keeping people firmly at arm’s length. It’s just easier that way. It hurts less. I was with Finn for almost a year and it was a fight that we had constantly. He wanted in, I pushed him out. I was never in love with him. I was just lonely.

If I let Asher into my life, I can’t help but wonder if he’ll be next in a long line of people who have been unreliable. Will he dump me on the side of the road like a pile of trash and drive away without a second thought, without a look back?

Why wouldn’t he? Everyone else has.

I’m honestly not even sure I have the ability to let him into my heart.

My body?
Yes
. I have a feeling that’s inevitable, but my heart?
I simply don’t know
. Though if I could see anybody there, I think maybe it would be him. I often think back to that day at the boathouse so long ago. I almost gave myself to Asher that day without a second thought and I wonder if our lives would have been different if Conn hadn’t interrupted just in the nick of time.

Taking a sip of my Chardonnay, I think back to last night when I foolishly asked Asher to come in. It’s almost as if I become someone entirely different when he’s staring into my eyes, stealing my thoughts. His intense gaze burns my barriers to ash like they’re made of nothing but tissue paper. It’s like he sees me. The
real
me. The one I’ve kept hidden away from any other human being. And that’s highly unnerving, because I’ve never felt more vulnerable around another person as I do Asher. Which means he has all the power to hurt me, to destroy me. Irrevocably.

In hindsight, I’m glad he declined my foolish proposal. For so many reasons I never should have asked in the first place, but I can’t find it within myself to truly regret it either. I think I would do it again, given the chance. My feelings are on a goddamn seesaw, bouncing erratically from one side to the other. One minute I want him. The next, I want to forget I ever met him.

He makes me
feel
. And that’s not an easy feat.

God, and his wicked words…I haven’t stopped replaying them ever since. I think I remember them verbatim. I’ve not had any other man ever speak to me like that. I liked it.
More
than liked it. After I watched him drive away, I barely made it inside before my hand was down my tights, bringing myself to orgasm after orgasm against the closed front door until my legs were like jelly. It was empty and unsatisfying, and even today I still ache for his touch, though he’s had his hands all over me all day in one way, shape, or form. Just not in the way I want or need.

His attention has not gone unnoticed by the entire Colloway family, either. Livia cornered me in the bathroom earlier asking me what was going on between us. I had to tell her the truth.

I don’t know
. But something is, and as much as I need to I’m not sure how to stop it. I don’t think I can. He is a mystery that I want to solve. Or maybe it’s simply just the girlish instinct to corner the untamed boy and make him fall in love with her. Everyone wants to attain the unattainable.

“Need some time away from my handsy brother?” a low voice penetrates my rampant thoughts. I look up to see Conn walk in, taking a seat in the cream-colored chair across from me.

“Something like that,” I reply with a forced smile. If he senses my Debbie Downer mood, he’s gentleman enough not to mention it.

“You having a good time?”

“Yes.” I smile, because despite my glumness at the moment, it’s honestly been a great day. Watching the Colloway brothers banter is like reality TV, only ten times better.

“So, did Asher tell you about the Colloway Thanksgiving tradition?”

Tucking my right foot under my left leg, I set down my wine and shift my complete attention to Asher’s twin brother. Conn is devastatingly handsome, like all of the Colloways. He is definitely the most laid back of the four brothers, but I can also see he’s an instigator. And I have a hunch he can easily manipulate any situation to his advantage.

“No. He failed to mention it.”

“Probably didn’t want to scare you.” He winks, a broad smile lighting up his gorgeous face, which I return. If there’s one thing I’ve learned about Conn, it’s that he’s an incorrigible flirt. More than one innuendo has been thrown down today, and at one point I thought Asher and Conn were going to come to blows. “In case you couldn’t figure it out, we’re all pretty competitive.”

“Really?” I laugh. “I hadn’t caught onto that at dinner when you challenged everyone to a timed pie-eating contest. Or when you put two hundred bucks on the line for whoever won at HORSE. So what’s your tradition?” And why do I even care? I had planned on asking Asher to take me home shortly anyway. All of a sudden I don’t feel like I’m very good company.

“Bowling, followed by a wicked game of laser tag.”

“Laser tag? Aren’t you boys a little old for that?” The look on Conn’s face is so serious, I can’t help but laugh.

“Who are you calling old, babe? I’m the reigning champ, five years running.”

“Yeah, because you cheat,” a velvety deep rumble calls from the other side of the room. It’s a voice that goes straight to my sex every time I hear it. “And she’s not your babe,” Asher growls, taking a seat next to me on the couch.

He puts a possessive arm around my waist, pulling me close to his side. I turn my head, glaring daggers at his clear statement of ownership, but all he does is wag his eyebrows and wink.

“Has Asher told you about his performing arts days yet, Alyse?”

“Conn,” Asher growls in warning.

“No really, it was practically Tony worthy,” Conn quips on a bark. Yep, definitely an instigator.

“Shut the fuck up, Connolly.”

He doesn’t. “Yeah, he played Putzie, one of the lesser known members of the T-Birds in the ninth grade musical
Grease
. You should ask him to sing ‘Summer Nights’ for you sometime. Epic.” Conn can barely get the last part out because he’s laughing so hard, as am I.

The only one not laughing is Asher.

“Wow, I didn’t know you had so many hidden talents. I’d like a performance.”

Asher looks at me and I expect anger, but all I see is heat. And hunger. “I’d be happy to give you a performance. A private one.”

I make an embarrassing noise that’s somewhere between a huff and a laugh. He continually throws me off my game.

“Well, you boys have fun. I think it’s probably time for me to go home. I don’t want to overstay my welcome.” I wiggle my way out of Asher’s ironclad grip. He frowns, which makes the inner girl that’s been crushing on this guy for years giddy as hell.

Pulling me back to him, he cups one cheek with his free hand. It’s intimate. It’s intoxicating, and the temperature in this cool windowed room has suddenly risen a dozen scorching degrees. Once again, I’m lost.

Out of my peripheral I see Conn stand and exit the room, quietly chuckling.

“You’re going with us.”

The effect Asher has on all of my senses is confusing. Every single time he touches me my pulse races. I have a hard time remembering to breathe. I have no idea what we’re doing here and I have to start working for this man in just a few short days, yet he’s almost acting like we’re a couple. I need to get myself together or I’m going to be completely lost to him.

“Why?” I breathe.

“Alyse,” he moans, his eyes searching mine. They penetrate my soul, pilfering a little bit of it into him. “Because I’m not ready to let you go yet.”

I watch him lower his lips to mine, the whole scene playing in slow motion. Jesus, I shouldn’t let him do this, but I’m going to anyway.

When his mouth touches mine, sparklers ignite behind my eyelids. Low-current voltage flows slowly through my body, lighting me up from the inside. I think it’s spilling out of my pores, like sunbeams.

This is exactly the way it felt last night. This is a million times more intense than it felt eight years ago. My blood literally flares to life with his simple touch, his passionate kiss. It’s dizzying. It’s exhilarating. What the hell will having sex with him make me feel like?

Completely consumed, Alyse. Utterly lost.

Groaning, Asher deepens the kiss, his tongue demanding entry, which I give. Lips never leaving mine, he pulls me astride his lap. I helplessly comply. Both hands now cup my face and I hand over complete control to him. Or he takes it. I’m not sure which and I’m not sure I care as I feel his thick, pulsing want for me in exactly the right spot.

My denim-covered pelvis involuntarily rocks against his hard length. His grip tightens and a low, guttural growl comes from deep within him as his kiss becomes more feverish. My God, the man knows how to use his mouth. I can only imagine how much experience he has with his cock.

Suddenly he’s pulling away, holding me far enough back that I can’t reach his lips. It takes a few seconds to force my eyelids open, but when I do and meet his dark blues, they’re hazy and dilated with lust. His jaw ticks with restraint. Our chests heave with want and exertion. We stare at each other for long moments. I feel the heat in my face and know I’m flushed from head to toe.

I’m fully aware anyone could walk into the room at any second, catching us in this compromising position, but I can’t make myself move or look away. He’s a sorcerer; I’m completely enthralled in his magical spell.

When Asher finally speaks, it’s barely above a whisper and the sincere words he utters make me foolishly want to give myself to him. Every broken, ragged edge of me. “I’m not sure I will ever be ready to let you go, Alyse.”

“Asher…” I close my eyes, trying to get my violent hormones and riotous emotions under control. When I open them, his hunger hasn’t abated a single bit. “What are we doing here?”

A small smile tips his lips. “I don’t honestly know, but I can’t seem to stop. Hell, I don’t
want
to stop.” He pauses, his eyes sweeping to my swollen lips before lifting to capture mine again. “There’s something different about you, Alyse. There always has been. Even when I shouldn’t have been attracted to you all those years ago, I was. And now that I’ve found you again, I need to know what it is. See if we have something else here besides the intense need to fuck each other.”

I suck in a sharp breath, his unfiltered words catching me off guard once again. But for the first time since I met Asher Colloway so very many years ago, his cocky attitude is shed and I see vulnerability in its place. It’s probably the most endearing side of him he’s shown me yet. It makes me want to agree to anything he’ll ask of me, which I’m one breath away from doing. He pulls me to his waiting mouth once again.

“Thoughts of you have utterly consumed me for weeks,” he whispers against my lips before kissing me softly. His kiss is reverent, worshipping. Sweet.

So damn perfect.

Every word he’s spoken is what any woman wants to hear from a man who’s interested in her, but still I hesitate, trying to make one last lame, admittedly
very
lame, effort. “But I’m going to work for you,” I manage to say when he lets me pull back.

“No, you’re going to work on a project for my company.”

“But you own the company.”

“Technically, my brothers and I own the company. I can keep my professional and personal lives separate, Alyse.”

“I don’t sleep with my clients, Asher.”

He sighs, leaning his head back against the couch, eyes going to the ceiling. “Fine, I’ll hire a different audit firm.”

“What?” Shit, now I’ve done talked myself out of a job. “No…I didn’t mean
that
.”

“If it means you’ll consider dating me, then that’s what I’ll do.”

“Asher…” I hesitate, not sure I should confess so much, especially to someone who will be almost single-handedly keeping my company afloat. It will make me look desperate.