4-Ever Theirs: Four to Score, Book 1 (6 page)

Chapter Eleven

Andi’s life was starting to feel like some bizarre rendition of
Groundhog Day
.

She woke up alone again. Of course.

The only reminder that last night hadn’t been a filthy dream was the slight discolorations that decorated her wrists and ankles.

It was like each of her roommates had given her a glimpse of what her future might be like three very different ways. If she committed to any one of them, she could be sickeningly happy.

Their generosity had taught her to be greedy, though. Trying all of them in a single bite, like some decadent version of Neapolitan ice cream, was sure to become her insta-favorite dessert.

If she was honest, she’d admit that some sliver of her had spent her time with each guy wondering about her other two roommates and what they were doing at those moments, or how they would feel if they could see what kind of naughty hijinks she was getting into courtesy of their buddy. Would they get off on watching her with their friends?

Would letting them do so amplify the already monumental pleasure they’d given her?

The ache between her legs said
hell yes
.

She hoped they didn’t make her wait very long to find out the answer to her questions.

Adrenaline chased away any lingering grogginess. She bolted to the bathroom to take care of business, including a scorching shower, before wandering into their shared space.

An envelope made of fancy stationary with bits of flower petals in it caught her attention right away. She lifted it from the table and traced her finger over her name, written in Cooper’s script on the front. When she got up the nerve to open it, carefully so she could save it for a premier spot in her scrapbook, she withdrew an elegant invitation from inside.

Congratulations!

Come celebrate with us.

After four years of hard work, now it’s time to play. An afternoon of working up an appetite will be followed by dinner at Coeur. Wear your pretty purple dress for us…please.

Reed * Cooper * Simon

Her hands shook as she read the note. Not only because she’d drooled over classmates’ photos from the swank restaurant forever, but also because she’d finally get to experience it with the only people who mattered to her.

Tomorrow she’d walk across the stage at graduation, accept her diploma, toss her cap, then close this chapter of her life. But tonight—they were right—was for celebrating their accomplishments. Including the very personal ones she’d made with the help of her roommates in the past few days.

Andi knew more about herself than she had thought possible.

She was prepared to go out into the world and…adult.

But somehow the thought didn’t thrill her as much as it had previously.

A sniffle escaped as she ran her fingers over the trio of signatures on the invitation again and again.

“You can pick somewhere else if you don’t like it,” Simon startled her from her thoughts.

“Or wear anything you like.” Reed glared at Cooper.

“Guys, it’s the perfect going-away present. Thank you.” She beamed at them, picking up the slack when their short-lived smiles faded at her uncouth reminder of their brief remaining time. Fortunately, she had an idea about how to lift their spirits. “And I think I have something you’ll like too.”

Without a single ounce of reluctance—they’d also gifted her with a newfound certainty of her allure—she lifted her shirt over her head and let it dangle from her index finger before allowing it flutter to the floor.

She wasn’t wearing anything else.

Giving them the full view, she rotated slowly before sashaying into her bedroom.

Andi hadn’t even made it to her bed before they were there, falling on her like a pack of wolves. Sexy wolves. Like maybe the werewolf variety. Because together they morphed into something downright beastly.

Reed nipped her breast while Cooper claimed her mouth and Simon sank to his knees to worship her ass. He was also the first to comment on her freshly shaven mound. “This is new.”

She laughed into Cooper’s mouth, sharing her joy with him. It’d only been two days, but she’d missed him and forgotten exactly how sensual his kisses were. Or maybe she hadn’t had a point of reference until she’d taken the other guys for a test drive.

As prepared as she’d thought she was for this experience, Andi found herself awed as the three men worked together as a team. They played to their strengths and eliminated their weaknesses.

Cooper’s polite seduction balanced Reed’s rough touches, and Simon lightened both of their too-serious moods. All she had to do was be. They took care of the rest.

“Bring her to the bed,” Reed commanded.

Without questioning him, Simon lifted her and placed her on the mattress. He climbed on with his shoulder resting on her headboard then pillowed her head on his thigh. His hand felt divine in her hair, stroking and soothing her jitters as Cooper joined them. He lay down so that his entire body pressed against hers from shoulders to her toes, which reached somewhere around his shins.

“Hey,” he said by way of greeting before picking up where he had left off, kissing her.

Distracting her, she was sure, when she felt the bed dip once more and Reed spooned her from behind. His already stiff cock prodded her ass, reminding her of the promises he’d made the night before.

Sandwiched between the two guys, with Simon at her head, she might have felt claustrophobic. But she didn’t. Not even a teensy bit.

“Still okay?” Cooper paused his kisses to wonder.

“Better by the second.” She smiled up at Simon as she reached for his hand. Fishing around blindly, she found his shaft instead. That would work.

Andi massaged Simon with the same rhythm Cooper’s tongue employed against her lips, gums and the roof of her mouth. Reed matched his tempo to the pace they set. All the while, the guys touched her. Everywhere they could reach was subject to their caresses.

The soft petting soothed her even as it aroused.

She’d never felt so safe or as cared for as she did between them.

That alone was enough to delight her. The physical aspect was pure bonus.

It didn’t take too long for things to progress to the next level as Cooper guided her thigh over his hip. The motion positioned his cock at the apex of her legs. When Reed rocked his hips against her a little harder, he cursed and Cooper jerked. She figured their erections must have collided, given their proximity.

She knew they weren’t bisexual. Still, the thought of them so close, teaming up to enhance her experience, made her even hotter.

Simon chuckled as he monitored the situation. He plumped in her fist, then groaned. “Better watch out, guys. I think she likes that a little too much.”

By his reaction, she’d say he might also.

Andi winked at him and he seemed to flush.

Before she could instigate any additional shenanigans, Cooper drew her mind back to what he was doing. His cock prodded the entrance to her body and she called out his name.

“Right here.” He kissed the tip of her nose when she tried to squirm closer.

“Inside,” she demanded.

“Simon, toss me a condom?” he asked.

“No.” She looked over her shoulder at Reed. “Didn’t you tell them?”

He shook his head. “That’s still what you want?”

“Yes. Please.” Andi turned back to Cooper. “I’m on the Pill. Clean. Reed said you guys are too. I want you bare.”

“Ah, shit.” Simon lifted her head, angling it away from Cooper. He rubbed the tip of his cock over her lips and she licked him in welcome. “I was going to try to wait, to hold out, but…no way. Not if you’re going there. I can’t wait to see them fill you up.”

In response, she opened her mouth and swallowed as much of his length as he fed her with every careful glide of his hips.

“Better catch up,” Reed said to Cooper. “I have a feeling none of us are going to last as long as we’d like and I don’t want to rush things back here.”

A spark of anticipation married with nervousness tingled through her at that.

Would it hurt? Would she like it anyway?

Probably.

The rest of the week had proven that they had no difficulty pleasing her and she trusted that today would be no different. Unless it was better.

Cooper shifted, aiming his cock toward her pussy. But with one hand stuck beneath his side and the other clasping her thigh to keep her open, he kept slipping across her instead of boring inside.

“Need a hand?” Reed asked.

“Do it.” Cooper gave his permission.

The grunt that shook Cooper’s chest, and her breasts at the same time, made it clear he didn’t care who was touching him, so long as it meant the pressure on his shaft increased. Andi wished she could have seen Reed’s fingers wrapped around his friend like that.

It would be fodder for her masturbation sessions for years to come, she was sure.

Then he was there, pressing into her, filling her with warmth and firmness. Giving her something to hold within her and keeping her undulating muscles busy with something to work. Andi sucked Simon harder, loving the feel of one of them at each end of her. She felt stuffed with life and love and pleasure.

And cock.

Andi laughed to herself at that, nearly choking on Simon in the process.

“What the hell is so funny?” he wondered.

“Tell you later,” she said, then got back to work.

Reed growled before raking his teeth down the nape of her neck. “I think I should give you something to get serious about.”

She shuddered, a pulse of bliss wringing her and causing her to clench on Cooper.

“Fuck yes, Reed. She wants it,” he said.

“I know she does.” He began to massage her ass, working inward until his fingers danced over her hole. “Distract her while I do this right.”

The next several minutes passed in a blur as Cooper fucked her with artful glides that left her oblivious to any prickles of pain Reed caused as he worked her open with a finger, then two or three. Simon had to take a break, so she switched to suckling his balls. She loved watching his toes curl when she traced the center seam of his sac with the tip of her tongue.

When, finally, Cooper sank deep into her and held still, Reed was right there to take her higher.

He fit his lubed cock to her ass and sank in bit by bit, making her cry out around Simon.

It burned at first. She wasn’t going to lie about that. Still buried to the root, Cooper relaxed her with gentle nuzzles and soft strings of nonsense whispered into her ear.

As her body adjusted to Reed’s girth, the stinging began to morph from pain into something distinctly
not
pain. It was an extreme sensation, one that heightened the rest of the intersections of her guys’ skin with hers. She felt every place they touched acutely.

Even her tongue on Simon’s shaft seemed more alive.

Andi felt as though she had superhuman powers. Doubly so when she saw, and heard, the impact she had on these three spectacular men.

They rode her together, working collectively or in counterpoint but never at random. Everything they did to her was deliberate and well-orchestrated by Reed. She saw how each of their personalities entwined to create the perfect lover for her.

That thought alone was enough to have her hovering on the verge of what promised to be the greatest orgasm of all time.

Reed, so in tune with her and her body, put the others on alert. The instant she was ready, they were right there with her. “We’re going over together. Now.”

Cooper ground against her, increasing the friction across her clit. She couldn’t have stopped herself even if she’d wanted to. The first hot wash of Reed’s come in her ass made her peak with him. And the clamping of her pussy around Cooper did the same for him. Simon squeezed her fingers and tried to withdraw from between her lips.

She refused to let him escape her throat.

Instead, she hummed at the first splash of his seed on her tongue then began to swallow every drop that pulsed from his cock. If she could only do this once, she didn’t want to waste a damn thing. Bruising fingers gripped her hips and shoulders as her roommates clung to her like a life raft in a turbulent ocean.

When they could do more than simply endure the blasts of gale-force passion they’d whipped up together, Simon was the first to break the quiet.

“That looked…amazing,” he sighed, his voice full of wonderment.

Andi pressed a kiss beside his half-hard cock and masterminded a devious plan on the fly.

“Why don’t you let me suck you until you’re ready again? We’ll swap positions. No reason you should miss out on the good stuff.” She grinned up at Simon, who blinked then nodded furiously.

“You’re sure?” Reed hesitated. The other guys waited for her to confirm.

“If you try to stop me, I’ll knee you in the balls.” Andi grinned as he reflexively covered his junk.

“Give the lady what she wants,” he instructed. And they did.

They tried it again, and again, just to be sure every possible combination was equally as marvelous, until she believed she might know how it felt to be an amusement park ride—spun around and ridden endlessly. She loved every moment.

At some point, she lost track of what went where and who was doing those magical things to her each part of her body. The three guys melded into one. Where she went and whoever they were with after this didn’t matter. She would be forever theirs.

Her mind detached from her physical being, ensuring all she could do was feel and react accordingly.

Utter decadence.

The guys didn’t seem to have any complaints either.

A long, long while later they lay wrecked, finally spent.

Andi snuggled among them, replete and drifting for some undetermined amount of time. She figured it was the utter relaxation of her body and the endorphins flooding her brain that made her speak her errant thoughts out loud. “What if there’s a way to make this work long distance?”

It was as if she went from being nestled in a pile of puppies to lying among tombstones for how stiff the guys went. Reed especially. A mask dropped over his face, cutting her off from every genuine feeling he’d exposed previously.