Authors: Horatio Clare
âWhy have you come here?'
âJust to see, to find out, I have read much about Algeria, and I have always wanted to see it.'
âAh, it's good, it's good. What would you like?'
âCoffee, please.'
âGive me a coffee here! So what do you think of Algiers?'
â
Formidable!
It's beautiful . . .'
âYes, yes, beautiful . . .'
âHave you lived here long?'
âAll my life â ha! A long time.'
âSo you have seen a lot.'
âHa! A lot! Yes, everything. I live in the Kasbah. Have you seen the Kasbah?'
âNo, I am going there next. So â you remember the war?'
âBut of course. It was here. It was on this street. People died there, and there, shot down by the paratroopers. Did you see on the corner? There is a plaque. And another across the street. I remember the boys who died there.'
âIt must have been terrible . . .'
âTerrible. They did us wrong.'
âThe soldiers?'
âThe French did us very wrong,' he said, with a sorrow, not an anger, as though he was not describing an assault so much as a betrayal.
âHow did you â live?'
âIn the walls. We lived in the walls. Do you understand? We lived in the walls to survive.'
He would not let me pay for the coffee and when we shook hands he held mine for a moment. âYou must go into the Kasbah and see. It is good that you are here.
Bon courage!
'
â
Merci, monsieur. Et à vous aussi.
'
The war began in 1954. By 1962, when it ended, more than a million Algerians had died, six French governments had been brought down by it, de Gaulle had been returned to power to face it, and his solution to it, the eventual return of Algeria to the Algerians, had come extraordinarily â amazingly, it seems now â close to bringing a civil war to French soil, as entire regiments of the French army in Algeria mutinied against what they saw as a surrender which made meaningless all the terrible things they had done, and betrayed all those they had lost.
The war in the Kasbah â called the Battle of Algiers â can be seen as the paradigmatic heart of the conflict. Up and down the tiny streets, which seem to wind, rise and fall in three dimensions through the packed, stacked, clay-coloured nest of this ancient town within a town, a maze of tiny doors, peeping windows and secret staircases, French paratroopers and the Front de Libération National engaged in a pitiless struggle. By all the rules of insurgency, in the midst of a hostile population, against an enemy that was born to the battlefield, the French, not long since defeated in Vietnam, should have lost the Battle of Algiers. But they did not, and this has come to be seen by the mighty but mired occupying armies of our own time as the terrible lesson of Algeria: the model of how guerrillas can be beaten on their own ground. The formula is as simple as the great negation of evil itself. You win by torture and summary execution.
A paratrooper, Pierre Leuillette, recorded his experiences in an interrogation centre, in a disused sweet factory.
All day, through the floorboards, we heard their hoarse cries, like those of animals being slowly put to death. Sometimes I think I still hear them . . . All these men disappeared . . .
The numbers of the disappeared are still disputed. From the summer of 1956 when FLN fighters gunned down forty-nine civilians over three days in June, to the end of March 1957, around 3,000 men and women were seized and killed, many having first been tortured. Had the FLN won the battle it is likely the war would have ended that year: instead it continued for another five.
Before she was killed in 2006 the Russian journalist Anna Politkovskaya wrote about what she called the Chechenisation of Russian society. The horrors Russia visited on the little republic have warped and perverted Russia's own soul, she said: in killing and torturing, beyond any law or justification, Russia has carved a capacity for numbness at horror and debasement into its national psyche. Something similar seems to have begun to happen to France: the difference was that those who spoke and wrote about it did not themselves become state targets. French soldiers, writers and intellectuals drew parallels between French methods in Algeria and those of the Gestapo. Something in the heart of morale, any army's ultimate weapon, died in the torture chambers, in the shallow graves, in the body-dumpings at sea, in âthe work in the woods', as the soldiers called the business of secret execution. In crushing the Kasbah, all sides later agreed, France won the Battle of Algiers and lost the war for Algeria.
The songs of caged goldfinches trickle sweetly through the alleys of the Kasbah. Then the rain comes, hard cold curtains sweeping in from the west, and wind: climbing steep, cracked steps I turn around and the sea seems vertiginously close, as if a backward slip would tumble you to the streaming waves. A gas tanker rides the swells, no sign of life on her, as if the crew have deserted. I duck from shelter to shelter, hiding from the rain in cafés and, once, a workshop, where an old man
fondles the ears of a tiny dog. In each place I meet the same questions, the same bemusement, which each time turns to something like friendship. In three stops in the Kasbah I am warned three times to be careful in the Kasbah, as if it is a den of thieves. I see no thieves. Veiled women hurrying out of the rain, children being called in, a shouting group of sixth formers coming home from school. I will not be here long enough to gain an invitation: I can only climb steps, wander alleys, stop, start and peer and try not to be seen to pry. I keep seeing the same wry smile on the faces of the men I speak to, but I cannot quite ascribe it. Am I the first tourist of the year, a premature sign â or am I an irony?
In my new book,
Ten Walks in Algiers
, a French resident of the 1920s mentions swallows. âThey love the old Turkish walls of the Kasbah', he says. I climb up when the clouds begin to break, and a washed white sun shines on gutters running black, into a smell of pines, and suddenly a shadow flies across the street at my feet and I know before my gaze finds them that they are here. Two, five, seven at least â and there are the old Turkish walls and there they are â and they still love the walls of the Kasbah! The light makes their breasts and backs shine brilliantly as they throw themselves up and over the street in that way they have, as if the downbeats of their wings render them weightless, to catch and redirect themselves forward on the upswing.
In the next three days I come to know their habits. A small population of âour' swallows, Barn Swallows, breed on the North African coast. Among those I watch in Algiers, some appear to be prospecting for nest sites: there is no other explanation for their attachment to certain parts of the city. In the coffee shop square the lone female now has companions; higher up three or four birds hunt a particular switchback street near the Kasbah walls, and then one morning in a sun bright as knives, which would have been hot were it not for the wind, I find others between the city and the shore. These do not seem to be prospecting. They are on their way north, I guess, and feeding up for the flight across the sea.
The long white arcade pullulates with people and the traffic is thick
on the road beside it, overlooking the port, and the square around the corner is packed. I am coming to terms with the city's strange rhythm. Friday is mosque day so everyone is off, which means Thursday night is a bit like Friday night in the West. Saturday is off and the week starts again on Sunday, unless you are on a European time, which much of the city is, in which case you do not go to work until Monday. If I lived here, I daydream, I would only work Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday: the rest I would give to writing, reading, walking and making love.
In Algiers whoever is young and alive finds sanctuary and occasion for triumphs everywhere: in the bay, the sun, the red and white games on the seaward terraces, the flowers and the sports stadiums, the cool-legged girls.
The intense physical beauty of Algiers, which Camus caught perfectly, still sings through the movements of people: in the way they carry themselves, the way they look at you and each other â the moment-to-moment seems very vivid here; a migrant such as I can only speculate but it is as though years of unemployment and war and horror have culled people's faith from the future and focused their concern on the present.
Or perhaps it is only that this is such a sparkling late morning, and that coffee tastes particularly rich in the mouth and cigarette smoke particularly satisfying; that the ship docking at the quay is particularly huge and its manoeuvres particularly delicate. The rushes of sea wind seem to fan the sunlight and brighten the glare. And the swallows â were they human you would have said they were high on it all: dozens, darting in and out of the colonnades, flinging themselves into the traffic, dodging buses and scooters with equal unconcern, sling-shooting themselves in the strongest wind at the corner, whipping back 90 feet only to skew sideways and back under the arcade. All the thousands of miles they have flown seem to have distilled into confidence: there is an exultation in their speed and fitness, as though they are playing in the waves of the air, as though they have mastered
all they have crossed: the savannahs and hills, the storms of the forests, the deserts, the mountains â as though they have conquered Africa. I stood at the corner grinning like a fool and watched them dive into the square. Suddenly they were down, no more than 3 feet from the floor, cutting through the crowd at leg-level. Either they played, flew for fun or were showing off to each other â this could be courtship or celebration. They do indeed find sanctuary and occasion for triumphs in every square inch of the air.
I begin to walk along the sea front, determined to follow it westwards until my legs give out. Many men, women and children appear to have had the same idea, or, at least, to have been drawn to the sea. Perhaps it is the weather. Couples sit on benches, not quite canoodling. Families straggle, women lean on balustrades, men fish: it is as though in crossing the road between the city and the sea one steps into a municipal holiday. I walk into one of the many bands of boys playing football on one of the terraces.
âHey!' one of them says.
âHey yourself!' I return, and am instantly surrounded by children.
âWho are you?'
I tell them my name.
âWhere are you from?'
âWales.'
âWhat is Wales? Where is it?'
I explain. They look dubious. Then one boy brightens suddenly, with an excited smile and a cry: âManchester United â Ryan Giggs!'
âYes!' I say, equally thrilled. âRyan Giggs!'
It is not the first time someone has made this connection between the strange and the celebrated, the obscure and the familiar. It has been first a curiosity to me, then a suspicion, then a certainty that throughout Africa it is an absolute fact that the Land of Song, the armoury and workshop of the Industrial Revolution, the country of Snowdon, Gareth Edwards, the Arms Park (as was), the Great Thomases â R. S. and Dylan â the Dragon and Charlotte Church exists only in answer to a question about English football. This is: if England are so rubbish at football, especially compared to the
wonders of its Premier League, why on earth do they not put Ryan Giggs on the left wing?
Ah â some Man. U. fanatic must have answered a thousand times, in a thousand football conversations, in a thousand distant villages and towns â because Ryan Giggs is . . .
âDo you play football?' another boy demands.
âAh. Not really, I'm afraid â I'm a bit rubbish. I play rugby though â do you like rugby? It's the national sport of Wales.'
They were not in the least interested in this.
âOh, come on! Play with us!'
I do my best but become rapidly frustrated at being effortlessly dispossessed by Algerian nine-year-olds, laughing cynically as they do so and calling me âReean Geeggs'. In the end I pick up the ball and charge an imaginary try-line.
They let me go after that, to walk on and ponder that if the homeland you love has to exist merely as a trivia point subordinate to a sportsman it is a great and fitting consolation that he should be the Zidane of the touchline, the Cantona of the cross-in, that human burst of speed and grace â Giggsy.
Next I meet the friendliest secret policeman in Algeria. I am sceptical at first. He hails me from the other side of the road. I greet him in return but he shouts again, dodges through the traffic and accosts me by the sea wall. He wears jeans and a pale jacket, a wide smile on his thin face.
âDon't worry!' he cries. âIt is OK, I am a security man â I am here for your security.'
This phrase is beginning to irk me.
âMy security is fine, thank you,' I say, and make as if to move off.
âDo you know people used to live down there?' He points to a cluster of shacks and houses built below the wall, just above the sea, on collapsing pillars.
âAnd there are some still there, but there used to be lots â fishermen â do you see?'
âI do, yes,' I say, and surrender, gracelessly, to a conversation he seems over-keen to have.
âYou are not the only tourist, no, no!' he says, when I ask him if I am some sort of rarity. âThey come in the summer, now, Italians and French.'
âThe French? Isn't it strange for them?'
âStrange, no â why?'
âBecause of the war.'
âNo, no. This is all in the past! We do not live there now. Every nation does bad things, doesn't it? Every people in history, but we have to forgive. We do not hold anything against the French. I like the French! Do you know, there were French people here during the war who were kind to us, who helped us? Who hid people the soldiers were looking for? Well, there were. There is an old French couple who are my friends who have always lived here. They love it here, they say they never want to leave. And they know they are welcome here â and you are welcome here! We are very happy to see you in Algiers.'