Bachelorette for Sale (13 page)

The gun or whatever he had pushed harder into her back. “I know exactly who you are. The Midnight Burglar. You’ve been breaking into houses all around here for weeks. Well, this time you messed with the wrong house, because I’ve been waiting and now I’ll get the reward.”

Wonderful. A whack-a-doo, and she was going to be
that
girl. The one from the movie who ran into the woods/basement/dark alley and got chopped to pieces. “What midnight burglar? I live a couple of streets over and haven’t heard anything about any break-ins. Plus, it’s not midnight, it’s seven, and I’m not a burglar.”

“Then what are you doing lurking around here in the dark?” He pushed the sharp object harder into her back.

“My dog had to pee.”

Faint sirens headed her way. Great. Twenty-eight years of never getting into trouble, and now this. Pathetically embarrassing. If she had to have a record and a mug shot, surely she could have picked a better crime. Bank robbery? No, too clichéd. Stalking Joe Manganiello? Now, that held some appeal.

Barking and a man’s voice in the distance gave her hope. The voice was rough and soothed her trembling nerves. Jason coming to her rescue, again. Never had she heard a sweeter sound. Bam hit the other side of the fence with a fierce impact, snarling and growling, clawing at the wood. Cherry jumped, not expecting the protective behavior.

“Hey, girl, how are you doing?” Cherry asked in a soft voice. The dog’s growls changed to whines.

“What is it, girl? A crazed squirrel?” Jason asked.

Bam continued to whine and paw at the fence until Jason commanded her to sit. His voice sent warmth through Cherry’s chilled body.

“That’s my friend. He’ll explain to you I’m not your midnight thief.” Cherry prayed he’d hurry up; her arms were cramping from holding them up over her head.

The gate squeaked as Jason opened it and stepped into the space in front of her. Cherry’s captor shifted his flashlight and she could see her would-be knight. Gorgeous blue-green eyes looked down at her. Little crinkles formed at the corners as if he were smiling. Great, she was being held hostage by a crazy man, and Jason found humor in it. Cherry flashed her pageant smile and gave a little finger wave.

“What’s going on, Dail?” Jason asked.

“Caught the Midnight Burglar trying to break into your place. Police are on their way, should be here any second now.”

Sure enough, blue and red lights flashed through the night sky, the sirens now making it hard to hear.

“Jason, could you please tell your neighbor I’m not who he thinks I am so I can put my hands down?”

The latch clicked on the gate as Jason stepped fully into the alley. “Stay.” At first Cherry thought he meant her, and then she realized he was talking to the dog. He caught her gaze before letting his drift down, taking in her appearance. A grin spread across his face. He reached up and scratched his chin, head cocked to the side.

“Jason?” the neighbor asked.

He walked around her in a full circle, coming to a stop in front of her. “She is dressed all in black. I thought Old Man Waters said the thief was six feet tall. She’s kind of short, don’t you think?”

Cherry couldn’t see what Dail was doing, but she knew one thing. He hadn’t removed whatever he had poking into her back. “Jason, stop it,” she ordered. “Tell him who I am, please. If I get arrested my one phone call is going to be to George, so laugh it up now because you won’t be laughing when he finds out you let me get hauled off to the slammer.”

A chuckle escaped his lips. “Dail, you can put that thing away. She’s not your thief. This is a friend of mine.”

The pressure on Cherry’s back disappeared. Slowly she dropped her arms; every ache and pain made itself be known as the pins shot through her system while blood flowed back into her limbs. Cherry turned around to face her accuser, slipping the beret off her head.

“I have to admit you are too pretty to be a thief. My apologies.” Dail started shaking his head. “I’m never going to hear the end of this from my wife. Wait, I know you. You’re that woman from the TV show. Oh, my wife is a huge fan, she’s going to be thrilled. Hang on a second. I gotta call her and tell her to come down and meet you.”

Why? Why did she ever go on that stupid, stinking show? Would there ever be a time when it wouldn’t come back to bite her in the butt? She could see it now. This little innocent incident would spread like wildfire across social media. That was how it worked. The world forgot about you until something embarrassing happened. And did Cherry really feel like meeting fans right now? Heck no. Pain shot through her shoulders and back. If she didn’t hit a bathroom soon, she’d be doing the happy dance. What she really wanted was to go home, soak in a hot, soapy tub, and forget this moment.

Minutes later, Dail hung up his phone. “Never mind. Look, I’m real sorry about mistaking you for a thief, but you can’t be too careful these days.”

“Your wife doesn’t want to come down?” Jason asked.

Dail had the graciousness to look away when he answered. “Seems I spoke out of turn. She’s a fan of the show—”

“Not of me.” Cherry finished for him. It wasn’t the first time she’d heard it. Ari had stolen the hearts of viewers of all ages, and her refusing to tell her side had only added fuel to his fire. Still, it wouldn’t stop his wife from hitting those sites and spreading the news. “It’s okay, Dail, on both accounts.”

No one had a chance to say or do anything further as a patrol car pulled up in front of them, blinding everyone with their lights. For the next thirty minutes Cherry got to explain first to one officer and then to his partner why she was in the alley dressed by Burglars“R”Us. Once they were satisfied with her story and Jason’s, they gave her a lecture about safety and let them go.

Settled on Jason’s plush couch, she accepted the glass of wine he handed her before he sat down next to her. Things couldn’t have gone more wrong if she’d planned it herself. Almost getting arrested. Playing the damsel in distress. Waiting for her white knight to save her. So not how she had foreseen tonight going down. Not quite the image of the cool, sophisticated businesswoman she’d been shooting for. “Thank you for coming to my rescue.”

“You owe your freedom to Bam. If she hadn’t made a fuss about going outside, I would have thought you blew me off and you would have been hauled down to cop central.”

Cherry set her wine down, wrapped her arms around the dog and kissed her on the head and praised her for being a smart girl.
Maybe this wasn’t such a good idea
. “I know we were supposed to talk about the center, but I’m just not in the mood. I should go, let you have your weekend.” She stood to leave.

Tucker—the dirty rotten traitor—curled up into a tight ball in front of the fireplace.

Jason reached up, took her hand, and pulled her back down on the couch.

“Sit, drink, relax. I stopped and got you a cannoli.”

“Is that a euphemism?”

Laughter, deep and rich, rolled through the air. “No, but it can be if you want.”

She playfully smacked him in the leg. “Thanks, but I’m on a diet.”

“What for? You’re fine the way you are.” His fingers lightly skimmed up and down her arm. His brows furrowed, so serious when he’d answered her.

Maybe she’d break her ban on sweets after all, because this guy was seriously tempting. It was the perfect answer, one she needed to hear, even if she didn’t believe it one bit.

“You handled the situation with Dail gracefully, although I could tell you were uncomfortable when he recognized you.”

The wine in her glass was a rich burgundy color, capturing her attention for several minutes. Somewhere between sharing pad thai and throwing popcorn at aliens they had become friends, so it was only natural for Jason to be curious. Full disclosure? So not happening. “What’s on your mind?” she asked.

“What happened on the show?” Jason’s voice came out a notch above a whisper, as if he didn’t want to spoil the mood.

Somehow, right here, with him, her hackles didn’t stand on edge. She didn’t bristle at the question like she normally did. She’d only talked to three people about what happened with Ari, leaving out anything to do with Jake: her grandparents and Tawny. With everyone else, her guard went up faster than the Secret Service taking one for the president.

“They introduced me to twenty-five amazing guys, well, twenty-four, as I knew instantly one needed to leave.”

“What was wrong with the one?”

“Billy Wallace? Tipsy when he arrived, drunk before the day was over, and had a serious case of roving hands. The others were all great, intelligent, funny, incredible men. From the first night, Ari stood out. He got the first one-on-one date. When he was around the other guys, he came across as friendly with all of them. A happy, easy-going guy. When we were alone, he’d sing to me. Silly little songs he made up. Sweet, romantic ballads.” She took a sip of her wine, staring at the flames as they leapt in the fireplace.

Those were the good days, when she thought all her dreams were about to come true. When anything and everything seemed possible. Days when she woke up on cloud nine and lived like a princess. Only Ari wasn’t the prince of her dream, Jake was.

Jason gave her other hand a small squeeze of encouragement.

“I fell head over heels for this guy. By the fifth week, I was just going through the motions with the others. I knew who I wanted to be with and he said he loved me too. Toward the end, when there are only three suitors left, you have the option of an overnight date. It doesn’t mean sex.” Well, that’s the public line anyway.

Tears silently rolled down her cheeks. Bands clenched around her chest, trapping the air in her lungs. Jason’s hand rubbed firm circles on her back until she could breathe again. She turned to face him. Gently he wiped the tears away with his thumbs while cupping her face.

“If it’s too painful, you don’t have to tell me. I didn’t watch the show and I don’t believe what was in the tabloids. You’re not the person they described.”

She reached up and held on to his arms. “Thank you. I want you to know. You should know the truth.” She couldn’t tell him the full truth, it was too personal, too embarrassing, but she could tell him the story she’d told her family.

She settled back on the couch. “I went on the overnight dates with the other two guys, Jake and Zak. I needed to make sure I wasn’t making a mistake with Ari. Nothing happened. In the end, I picked the guy my heart said to choose. When the show aired and we were brought back on the reunion show, he spun this story of how I’d slept with both guys. He told all of America I’d gone on the show with a boyfriend back home, who backed his story, all for fortune and fame. Apparently, I wanted to break into showbiz. The truth was he used me to springboard his singing career. It worked. America loves an underdog, and now he’s a country music sensation—or he was until his latest record came out.”

Silence grew as she let Jason process what she’d told him. His forefinger tapped a steady beat against his leg, a gesture she’d noticed him make on several occasions. She’d been honest, told him the truth. If he couldn’t handle it or didn’t believe her, now was the time to find out. They had chemistry. She couldn’t deny it. Lots of people had sparks, didn’t mean they did anything about it. What if he no longer wanted her? Well, who could blame him? After all, her dog had peed on him and she was a bit of a hot mess. Oh Lord, it was a good thing he couldn’t hear the rambling in her head. Why was she rambling? She’d dated twenty-five men at once, surely she could handle one.

“Who was the boyfriend?”

“I don’t know.”

Jason turned to face her.

“Honestly, I’d never met him before. I think he was an out-of-work actor.”

“Why didn’t you ever tell your side?” He laid his hand on her leg, slowly stroking back and forth.

The warmth from his hand was heading straight to her center, and oh man, did it feel good. Too good, to the point she had to force her brain to remember his question. “What would have been the point? At first, I was in shock, heartbroken and embarrassed. I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. By the time I pulled myself together, I’d already been tried and found guilty by the viewers who claimed to have loved me mere weeks before.”

Jason cupped her cheek, guiding her face to meet his gaze. Those intense eyes bored straight through her, or so it seemed—as if he could see everything inside of her. A bit scary really, letting someone in, not knowing what would happen next.

“I believe you.” His mouth claimed hers in a kiss.

Three little words.

Everything inside her went still as his words registered on her brain. She moved in closer, braced herself by placing her hand on his chest, which was pounding against her palm. She never knew three words could hold so much power. For the first time in over a year she shoved the past out of her mind.

Between his words and his kiss she was a goner. He had an amazing, skilled-—highly skilled—mouth made for kissing. Sparks zinged through her mind and body, and she lost herself in his embrace. She was sure there was something she was supposed to tell him tonight, but right at that moment her brain didn’t want to work. It didn’t want to think, to analyze; it wanted to enjoy. She returned the kiss, losing herself a little more, letting herself feel. She dug her fingers into his silky short hair, breathed in the scent of firewood and musky soap, and let the lingering taste of wine intoxicate her. My God, the man could kiss like nobody’s business and steal your breath away.

She didn’t care if this was a good idea or not anymore. For once she didn’t want to be the good girl, always doing what everyone expected of her, doing what was right and ignoring what she wanted. She wanted to be the bad girl, to go after what she craved, and damn the consequences.

She sank deeper into the kiss as he slipped his hands through her hair to cup the back of her head and bring her closer. No longer a sweet kiss of comfort, but rather one of exploration, of need and passion breaking loose. She let out a moan and pressed in closer.