Authors: William G. Tapply
Close to the Bone
A Brady Coyne Mystery
William G. Tapply
for Vicki
who’s on every page with thanks and love
J
USTICE, THOUGH DUE TO
the accused, is due to the accuser also.
—Benjamin Cardozo
I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately, to front only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived. I did not wish to live what was not life, living is so dear; nor did I wish to practise resignation, unless it was quite necessary. I wanted to live deep and suck out all the marrow of life, to live so sturdily and Spartanlike as to put to rout all that was not life, to cut a broad swath and shave close, to drive life into a corner, and reduce it to its lowest terms, and, if it proved to be mean, why then to get the whole and genuine meanness of it, and publish its meanness to the world; or if it were sublime, to know it by experience, and be able to give a true account of it in my next excursion.
—Henry David Thoreau
1
J
ULIE KEEPS TELLING ME
I’ll never be a proper lawyer if I keep driving out to the suburbs to meet my clients at their homes whenever they request it. The clients, she maintains, are supposed to come to the lawyer’s office in the city. They should make appointments, preferably weeks ahead of time because, according to Julie, any lawyer who can see a client at a moment’s notice can’t be very busy, and if he’s not very busy he can’t be much good, and if he’s not much good then clients will not be inclined to make appointments with him in the first place. When it’s done properly, says Julie, the clients who appear in their lawyer’s office at their appointed time should be kept waiting while the lawyer accrues billable hours with another client, who has also been kept waiting.
Julie is probably a better legal secretary than I am a lawyer. I know that if I listened to her I’d accrue more billable hours, which is how Julie measures the success of a law practice.
So when Roger Falconer called on a gray Tuesday afternoon in November and said he needed to confer with me immediately, I said, “I’ve got an opening at four-thirty, Roger,” as Julie had trained me to do.
My heart wasn’t in it, of course. Roger Falconer, I knew, simply didn’t sit in the waiting rooms of lawyers or doctors—or governors or senators or the CEOs of multinational corporations, either.
Hell, Roger Falconer had been the CEO of a multinational corporation before he retired. Back in the sixties and early seventies he had also been the state attorney general and the Republican candidate for governor and, apparently encouraged by losing that one, for United States senator. He lost that election, too, but, as he liked to point out, what could a Republican expect in Massachusetts, the only state that failed to cast its electoral votes for Nixon in 1972?
In fact, a lot of people who courted Roger’s influence or money, or both, still called him “Senator,” and he didn't bother to correct them.
I called him Roger. He didn’t try to correct me, either.
“Four-thirty, huh?” he said. “Your last appointment of the day?”
“Uh huh.” I knew what was coming, and I was helpless to avoid it.
“You should be able to be here by five-thirty, then,” he said.
I sighed. “Sure, Roger. I guess I can be there around five-thirty. What’s up?”
“A matter of utmost gravity, I’m afraid. I’d rather not discuss it over the phone, Brady.”
When I slipped into my trench coat and headed out of the office a few minutes after four-thirty, Julie arched her eyebrows from behind her computer monitor.
“I’m off to see Roger Falconer,” I said. “I’ve got to be there at five-thirty, and I don’t need any shit about which of us is the mountain and which is Mahomet. It’s a matter of utmost gravity.”
“I didn’t say anything,” she said.
“Yeah, but I know what you’re thinking.”
She flashed her pretty blue-eyed Irish smile. “Utmost gravity? Did you actually say that?”
“Roger’s words.”
“Hey,” she said with an elaborate shrug. “It’s your law practice. If you want to go traipsing around the countryside at the summons of doddering old political has-beens, why should I care?”
“You should care, of course. That’s your job. And I’m glad I’ve got you to do it.”
“I don’t see why the old poop can’t come to the office like everyone else.”
“Well, he won’t. If I didn’t go to him, he’d just get himself another lawyer.” I bent and kissed her cheek. “I’ll fill you in tomorrow.”
It took over an hour to negotiate the rush-hour traffic from Copley Square, out Storrow Drive onto Route 2 and thence to Lincoln. I turned onto Route 126—Thoreau had called it “the Walden road”—and drove past the pond and the acres of fields and forests that the Lincoln town fathers and mothers have preserved from development so that folks like Roger Falconer can live thoroughly insulated from the riffraff.
Roger’s long driveway wound through the dark oak and pine woods, past the tennis court and the swimming pool and the putting green, and ended in a turnaround in front of his big, square Federal-period colonial. Floodlights mounted under the eaves lit the flower gardens and the lawn, now mostly frost-killed and brown and littered with dead leaves. Orange lights glowed from every window.
A little white two-seater Mercedes convertible was parked behind a gunmetal gray Range Rover. I pulled in at the end of the line and got out of my car. A northeast wind hissed through the pine trees and rattled the clumps of dried leaves in the oaks. It felt damp and chilly on my face. It would bring freezing rain or wet snow. In November it could go either way. I climbed the front steps and rang the bell. A minute later the door swung open and a youngish woman I didn’t recognize greeted me with a frown.
She wore a dark blue wool dress with a high neck and a low hem, just a touch of eye shadow and lip gloss, and no jewelry except for a diamond the size of a Brazil nut on her left hand, the hand that was holding a can of Coke. A slim blonde, pretty in a cool, brittle, elegantly fashionable way, early thirties, I guessed. “You are…?” she said.
“Brady Coyne,” I said. “I have an appointment with Roger. And you?”
“Pardon?”
“We haven’t met,” I said.
“I’m sorry.” She tried on a smile that didn’t quite make it up to her eyes. “Brenda Falconer. I’m the Senator’s daughter-in-law.” She lifted her Coke and took a quick, nervous sip.
“Glen’s wife?” I said.
“Yes.” She smiled again, and it worked better this time. “That, too.” She extended her hand and allowed me to touch it for a moment. Then she turned. “They’re in the library,” she said over her shoulder. “This way.”
I followed her down the wide center hallway and through a living room full of clunky old antique furniture and decorated with dark portraits of clunky old men. We stopped outside the open doorway to Roger’s library, which was a room as big as my entire apartment. At the far end a brace of golden retrievers—Abe and Ike, named after Roger’s political heroes—slept on the hearth by a blazing fieldstone fireplace. The walls were lined floor to ceiling with old leather-bound volumes. Rolltop desks and oak tables and leather sofas and armchairs were scattered about, and seated in two of the armchairs were Roger Falconer and his son, Glen. They were studying the fire, apparently ignoring each other.
Brenda cleared her throat and the two men looked up. “Ah, Brady,” said Roger. “Come, sit. Brenda, dear, get Brady a drink.”
“I can get my own drink,” I said to her.
She shook her head. “It’s okay. Really. What would you like?”
“I’ll have what you’re having,” I said to her. “Thanks.”
She left the room and I went over to where Roger and Glen were sitting. Empty highball glasses rested on the table between them. Roger didn’t bother rising as we shook hands. He was almost completely bald now, and I knew he was closing in on eighty, but he still could’ve passed for the man who had run for the Senate back in the early seventies. His pale eyes glittered with enthusiasm and conspiracy, and his grip was strong. “You remember Glen?” he said.
“Sure.” I held out my hand to the younger man. “How are you?”
“Not that good, actually,” Glen said. He stood to shake hands with me. He was several inches taller than my six feet, and his face was longer and more angular than his father’s. His sandy hair had receded perceptibly since the last time I had seen him, which had been a few years earlier.
After we sat down, Glen leaned toward me. “Look—”
“Brady,” interrupted Roger, “we have a problem.”
“I figured,” I said. “A matter of utmost gravity, I think you called it. Sounds like a problem to me.”
“A week and a half ago,” he said, “Glen had an automobile accident. He, um, there was a collision with another vehicle.”
“Who hit whom?” I said, addressing my question to Glen.
But it was Roger who answered. “He hit them.”
“Them?”
“There were two passengers in the other car,” said Roger. “A woman and her four-year-old boy.”
He paused, gazing at me with his eyebrows arched behind his steel-rimmed glasses, waiting for me to figure it out. I did, but I said nothing.
There was a discreet rap at the door, and then Brenda came in. She handed me a glass of Coke rattling with ice cubes. I looked up at her. “Thanks,” I said.
She nodded. “You’re welcome.” She stood there, looking from Roger to Glen.
“Thank you, my dear,” said Roger with a nod, dismissing her.
Her eyes flickered and met mine for a moment before she turned and left the room. The door latched softly behind her.
“Your wife isn’t included in this matter, huh?” I said to Glen.
“Family business,” said Roger, who apparently did not consider wives to be members of his family.
I shrugged and took a sip of Coke.
“The woman was seriously injured in the collision,” Roger said. He cleared his throat. “She died this morning.”
“Right,” I said. “And Glen was drunk.”
Roger nodded.
“And they’re going to charge him.”
“Yes. Vehicular homicide, DUI.”
“What about the little boy?”
“He was in a car seat. He’s okay.”
“Lucky,” I said.
Roger nodded. “I guess so.”
“I don’t do these kinds of cases,” I said.
“I know,” said Roger. “But you’re my lawyer.”
“Did you take a Breathalyzer?” I said to Glen.
He nodded. “I flunked. My license was suspended.”
“But you weren’t charged?”
“No. Not then.” He glanced at his father.
“I took care of it,” said Roger. “But now, with the woman, ah, failing to survive…”