Dead of Winter Tr (9 page)

‘Tough bloke, Ebb.’

‘Yes, but this is what I can’t find out, Sarge. I can’t find out where he was after he left the SBS and before he joined the Police Force for almost a year, October 1992. I
can’t find any mention of it. It’s one of the things I’d like to ask him tomorrow. Harding seems to think he was definitely suffering with PTSD. But none of his workmates made any
observations about strange behaviour or a change in his attitude around the time of the murders. He did have an affair, though.’

‘Is that our motive then, Ebb? Kill the wife and kid and start again with wife’s money and the new woman?’

‘Except the new woman left for Australia soon after and according to her statement at the time, the affair had been over for a few months. Carmichael has never remarried. So I don’t
know really. I have the full autopsy reports now. I’ll read them through and be ready to clarify things with Carmichael tomorrow. It will take me a few hours to go through it and then
I’ll bring my bag into the office, ready to leave early tomorrow morning, Sarge.’

‘Stay there, get a few hours’ kip.’

‘Okay, Sarge . . . and Sarge, I talked to Mr Simpson, the letting agent: Chichester bought the bed in the cellar himself. That means the Arsenal shirt is down to him and nothing to do with
the previous tenant. We were right about the room with linoleum – he had the carpet removed before he got there and had the linoleum put down, and more shelves put up in the
bathroom.’

‘What about the curtains in that room, Ebb? He left them in every other room, why not there?’

‘I asked Simpson about those – he said Chichester told him he’d be bringing his own.’

‘Sandford’s found what looks like the remnants of a plastic curtain up at that bedroom window. We need to find out what that room was intended for: don’t think it’s a
bedroom. Maybe it was a place to store something that needed to be kept germ-free.’

‘I’ll talk to Simpson again. He needs leaning on; he made money out of Chichester that he doesn’t want to talk about. He also deleted emails that went between him and
Chichester.’

‘Did you manage to find out what Harding really thinks about Davidson and the situation? Davidson still doesn’t want to reopen the case.’

‘I think she’s keen to get it right this time – she gave me the full autopsy reports – but at the same time she supports Davidson.’

‘Covering her arse then . . .’

‘Looks like it, Sarge. I’ll talk to her again when I get back tomorrow. She wants me to let her know how he is.’

‘Pass by me first. There’s only one person Harding cares about. And only one back she’s watching, and that’s her own.’

‘But she does care about doing her job, Sarge. She doesn’t like getting things wrong.’

‘No, well, good luck with getting to know Harding. It would take a braver man than me.’

‘What time are we leaving tomorrow, Sarge?’

‘Not me, Ebb . . . just you. You are a fresh pair of eyes, no preconceptions. You can see it as it is. Anyway, I’ll be more use here. You alright to go on your own? You were trained
as a FLO.’

‘Yeah, but it was decided I wasn’t really cut out for it.’ She paused, turned towards the window. She was thinking. She caught her reflection in the glass. She looked like a
frightened rabbit: all eyes. She looked away quickly. ‘Okay, no problem.’

‘Take an overnight bag. There’ll be plenty of motels to stay in nearby. You’ll be fine. Ring me.’

Ebony put down the phone and got into bed, pulling her duvet around her as she snuggled down for a few hours work. Tina knocked in the door.

‘You free?’

‘Sorry, Teen. Give me an hour or two and I’ll take a break then. You okay?’

‘Just need a girly goss and a catch-up that’s all. I want to show you some of the other guys I’ve been looking at on the dating sites. Some really gorgeous ones – be
great for you.’

‘Okay, give me a while. I’ll come and find you when I’m done.’ Three hours later she heard Tina moving around in the bedroom below, getting ready for bed. Ebony felt a
pang of guilt. She thought about getting up and going to say goodnight and spending ten minutes trawling through Tina’s choice of men on the internet – men who were always flashy and
fancied themselves much more than they did Tina. But Ebony knew it wouldn’t be just ten minutes and she still had a lot of work to do. She’d gone through Carmichael’s file a
hundred times and still she hadn’t found the answers she was looking for. Why would someone kill them in that way and why did they leave the little baby alive? She spread out the pictures of
Louise and Chrissie and looked at them again. Her eyes went from one to another. Something was bothering her. Blood. Where was the blood? The women should have been lying in pools of it; it should
have been everywhere. But it wasn’t. She looked at the list of forensic samples that had been deemed to be cross-contaminated. In death the women had touched one another. Their backs had
touched somehow. Ebony began re-writing her findings. What if the samples were not corrupted? It was getting light when she finally slept where she sat on the bed, surrounded by pictures of the
dead.

Carter came off the phone to Ebony and walked into the Major Incident Room. Robbo was sitting at his desk with his cafetière. When he saw Carter coming he slid his chair
from one end of his desk, picked up a sheet of paper, and slid back.

‘Here’s how far I’ve got.’ He read from the sheet in his hand: ‘The vehicle in the driveway at Blackdown Barn: a man . . . Mr Arnold Williams . . . delivers the
bi-monthly parish paper to Blackdown Barn. He remembers seeing a van in the driveway on several occasions. It was a large Transit type, almost like a Tourer, but regular-shaped, not fancy: no
windows; it was white.’

‘Number plate?’

‘No . . . he says the back doors of the van were always covered.’

‘We know its length. Find me a make and model. Use the moulds from the tyre tracks to see what tyres it took.’

Robbo pointed to the screen. Carter came round to have a look.

‘I fed in the information from the tyre prints and it came up with a basic model of van; most of the major manufactures made a Transit-type vehicle like this. It’s a working van
rather than a run-around. The tyres indicate that it’s less than three years old. Meant to carry a lot of weight.’

‘Ebony says that when she went back to Rose Cottage she met a gardener there who says he repaired the gatepost after that night. It took out the whole upper section in a clean chunk. Could
it be this van type?’

‘There was no mention of that in the case file. I never saw a statement from him.’

‘Yeah, I know. We need to get the exhibits from the Carmichael case back over here from the warehouse and see for ourselves.’

‘So how’s it going working with Ebony Willis?’

‘Yeah . . . I’m sending her up on her own to interview Carmichael tomorrow; she’s swatting up on the case tonight.’

Robbo gave him that look that said:
interesting but risky.

‘She’ll be alright.’ Carter sucked his finger where the cuticle was bleeding.

‘Hopefully . . . She’s a bright kid.’

‘Funny how you see her as a kid.’

‘Everyone’s a kid to me. I’m not long after Davidson when it comes to retirement. Of course I don’t have any choice, being a DC. He could stay on. You help solve this
one, Dan, they should seriously consider you for promotion.’

‘Maybe. I won’t hold my breath. Just passing my exams doesn’t seem to be enough. Ebony will probably get there before me.’

‘Ebony’s going to have to battle against prejudice. She’s going to have to prove herself every step of the way if she hopes people will forget what happened to her. If she
hadn’t already joined the Force when it happened she would never have been allowed in.’

‘That would have been a tragedy,’ said Carter. ‘I can see how much she loves it. She wants this career so badly. She’ll make it, despite what she’s been through
– or maybe because of it.’

‘Yeah,’ said Robbo. ‘She’s a sponge when it comes to info, techno stuff. She’s been asking me about the latest in this and that. Even though it’s not her
department.’

‘You should have seen her around the bodies . . .’ Carter smiled. ‘She practically climbed in beside them to interview them.’

Robbo sat back in his chair, shook his head. ‘You’d think seeing your mum stab someone forty-seven times would put you off bodies for life.’

The sky was steely grey and the further north Ebony drove the thicker the snow fell. She wasn’t a confident driver. She’d only taken her test when she wanted to
join the Force and she didn’t own a car. The hire car was new: a poppy red Renault Clio. It smelt much too clean and chemical-y and the unfamiliarity did little to reassure her that she was
capable of driving in conditions that no amount of driving lessons could have prepared her for. It was already nearly dark at only two in the afternoon. Ebony looked at the sat nav for
encouragement. It hadn’t talked to her for ages, not since it sent her on several turnoffs and then abandoned her on what looked like a road that no one had used for a hundred years. The
hedges rose to block her view of anything but the winding lane in front.

She needed a pee. She slowed right down at the entrance to a field then she got out and waded through the snow, knee deep in places. Crouching behind the hedge, she dropped her trousers and peed
into the snow. The icy wind started her teeth chattering. She wasn’t happy. She was a London girl, not meant to go more country than Kew Gardens. This was proper countryside. She cursed
Carter. He had known it would be like this, miles from anywhere and anyone. She pulled up her pants and walked back to the car.

Just as she put the car into gear and began pulling away, a woman appeared at her window. She had eyebrow and nose piercings. She wore layers on layers, and wellington boots. Her henna-red hair
fell in snow-flecked plaits from beneath a bobble hat.

‘Hi . . .’ Ebony wound down her window. ‘I’m looking for a farm owned by a man called Callum Carmichael?’

The woman stared at Ebony for a few seconds, checking her out, before walking around the front of the car and opening the passenger door. She got in as if she had been waiting for a taxi, and
Ebony was it.

‘Go straight . . .’ She took out a packet of tobacco and started rolling a cigarette. ‘You a friend?’

‘Of Carmichael’s? Not really, just need to see him about something. You? Sorry . . . you can’t smoke in here . . .’

‘I’m not going to. I help him sometimes.’ Ebony looked sideways at the woman. She was a ‘once wild’ teenager. She was pretty but neglected. She smelt of patchouli
oil and bonfires. She was beginning to defrost, her plaits were now steaming. ‘I help him with the lambing.’

‘Is it lambing time now? It’s the winter.’

‘Carmichael produces lambs early. Saves buying foreign. People like to eat lamb for Easter. Got to be fattened in time. Not me. I never eat ’em. I know ’em all by name. Be like
eating one of my own family.’

‘What about him, Carmichael? Does he know them all by name?’

‘He does but he pretends not to; it’s easier to kill them that way.’

Carmichael stopped chopping wood to listen. Rusty, his Jack Russell terrier, had begun the low growl that signalled the approach of visitors. Carmichael put down his axe and
came out of the log store. He wiped his brow on his shirtsleeve as he watched the car lights coming up the lane from half a mile away. He held his hand up for Rusty to be quiet. He glanced across
at his rifle resting on the inside of the woodshed door.

Ebony turned the car into the yard, narrowly missing the wheelbarrow full of steaming horse manure, and came to a stop outside the stables. Rusty ran over, barking excitedly. Carmichael watched
Bridget, his farm hand, and a young woman get out of the car; he made no attempt to call Rusty away. Ebony wasn’t fazed. She lived in an area where pitbulls came out at night. She reached
down to pet him. His barking turned into excited whines, his tail wagged. Bridget walked across the yard, head down, and merely glanced Carmichael’s way as she said:

‘Police . . . found her taking a piss in the lower field.’

‘Inspector Callum Carmichael?’ Ebony pretended she hadn’t heard.

Carmichael didn’t answer. He picked up the handles of the wheelbarrow and wheeled it across to the far end of the courtyard so that he could tip out its contents on to the dung heap.

‘I need a few words please, sir.’

He put down the wheelbarrow and looked at her. ‘ID?’

Ebony pulled out her warrant card and held it up for him to see. He appeared to look at her face rather than the card yet her name still seemed to register.

‘DC Ebony Willis?’

‘Yes . . .’ Ebony replied.

He finished filling hay nets and tied them inside the horse’s stall then he picked up his rifle from the woodshed and walked past her.

‘Follow me.’

Ebony had her eye on the gun. It was very like the rifles they used in the Police Force, with a shorter barrel and only a metre in length. But it was definitely made for hunting: it had a
powerful looking scope attached. Judging by his eyesight and the way he’d read her warrant card, Ebony thought that he could probably hit her running at a mile away with or without a
scope.

She followed him into the house. The farmhouse was Spartan, austere. It was certainly never going to make it onto the top of a biscuit tin.

‘I won’t take up much of your time, Mr Carmichael, and then I’ll be on my way.’ They walked through the tack room, up a step and into a stone-floored scullery. Carmichael
propped the rifle next to him as he sat on a stool and pulled off his boots. He said nothing as he washed his hands in the sink.

He looked at her as he dried them on a towel above the sink.

‘Relax . . . If I wanted to kill you I’d have done it by now.’ She watched him with the same intense look she always had, but he didn’t know her. He took it to be
anxiety. ‘Besides . . .’ He hung the towel on a hook to the right of the sink. ‘There’s no way you’ll be going anywhere tonight. The lane is almost impassable already;
surprised you made it. In half an hour it will be sheet ice. In that car – you’ll be lucky to get ten metres.’ He wiped the mud and debris from the gun barrel with an oiled cloth.
‘It will be more trouble to drag you out of a ditch than it will be to put you up for a night.’