Deceptions: A Cainsville Novel (20 page)

G
abriel stood in Rose’s parlor, looking out the front window at Olivia’s apartment. Inside, she was telling Ricky everything. He’d spent the last twenty minutes thinking of nothing except what was happening in that apartment, and yet each time he let it coalesce into a clear thought, his jaw clenched tight enough to set it aching.

“I need to tell him,” she’d said. “It’s gone too far, and he’s too involved. Not knowing exactly what’s going on puts him in danger.”

“So you’re going to tell him that you can read omens . . . and the town of Cainsville is populated by fairies.”

He won’t believe you. He’ll think we’re both mad and get as far away as possible.

“You’re right,” he’d said. “You should tell him.”

Even as the words came out, he’d felt a stab of guilt. As unfamiliar an emotion as the jealousy that roiled in his gut, thinking of her sharing their secrets with Ricky.

But they’re ours. Damn it, they’re ours.

Their
secrets. The part of her life Ricky didn’t share. As long as Gabriel knew about the omens and Cainsville, and Ricky did not, Olivia would stay with Gabriel. He had a purpose.

Now he would not.

Unless, in telling Ricky, she lost him.

Which Gabriel should not want.

He’s good for her. Good to her. He makes her happy.

But why
him
?

Because it’s always been him.

Gabriel rubbed his temples. It’d been two days since he’d started hearing that internal dialogue. It wasn’t the proverbial “voice in his head.” He’d handled cases where his clients claimed that’s what compelled them to commit crimes. They were lying, of course. But he’d researched the phenomenon enough to counsel them on how to present their symptoms in a believable fashion.

Gabriel knew he was hearing his own unbidden thoughts. Yet they made no sense.

“You’re hoping it doesn’t go well.”

That
voice came from right behind him. Rose.

“You’re hoping he won’t be able to handle it, and he’ll leave her.”

Ice seeped into his voice. “I realize you may not think much of my ability to empathize with others, but I would never wish to see Olivia hurt like that.”

“Good. Because the only acceptable reason for hoping
that
is if you planned to take advantage of the situation and offer yourself as a replacement, which I doubt.”

“That would be correct.”

“Then stop staring out that damn window, hoping you’ll see Ricky Gallagher storm out of her life.”

He fixed his aunt with a look known to make even expert witnesses quail. She didn’t flinch.

“You want her all to yourself,” she said. “Her time and her attention. If you wish to speak to her, she’d better be there to take your call. If you wish to see her, she’d better be available. And she sure as
hell
better not be sleeping with another guy, even if you can’t bring yourself to cross that threshold yourself. That’s not fair, Gabriel. You might be accustomed to getting what you want, but you aren’t going to lock Olivia up on your terms. You just aren’t.”

“I have never expected—”

“Then step away from the window. Because if it doesn’t go well with Ricky tonight, she’ll find someone else. Someone you’ll like and respect a whole lot less than him. Someone who will be a hell of a lot less understanding about how much time she spends with you. Olivia appreciates men. Unlike some people, she’s not going to be content to bury herself in her work.”

“I’m well aware of that, too.”

“Then, as I said, the only reason you should be at that window is if you plan to offer up yourself as a replacement.”

“Olivia is an employee and a friend. My feelings for her don’t extend beyond that.”

“Save the bullshit for a jury, Gabriel. Your feelings extend well beyond that. You just won’t do a damn thing about them, because you’re terrified of trying.”

“Terrified?” He gave a short laugh. “While your choice of words is highly dramatic—”

“—my sentiment is dead-on?”

“Hardly. I have no interest—”

“You have every interest, and it’s driving you crazy. Would it change anything if you knew she’d reciprocate?”

“No.”

“So it’s not fear of rejection. It’s fear that it won’t work. That you’ll drive her off. That in trying for more, you’ll lose her completely.”

I always do.

He rubbed his temples again.

“Gabriel . . . ?” Concern in her voice now as she stepped forward.

He moved away from her. “As entertaining as it might be to try extending your powers to mind reading, I find the need to continually defend myself against groundless accusations irritating.”

She kept her voice low. “I only want you to be happy.”

“Then allow me to continue this vigil in peace, because what I’m doing, had you asked, is waiting until they finish their conversation so I can return to the task of making sure I don’t go to jail for murder.
That
would make me happy.”

“No, that would just be a relief. What makes you happy is her.”

She walked away before he could reply. He turned back to the window.

She was right, of course. Not about all of it. Any sexual attraction was an unavoidable matter of biology. He was spending his days in the company of an attractive young woman and it had . . . been a while.

Sex was a problem for someone uncomfortable with physical intimacy. When he’d been a teenager or a college student, the drive overrode the revulsion. As he got older, the edge wore off that drive, and the anonymity he needed became much harder to come by when he made a conscious effort to get as much public exposure as possible. Women might pretend to have no idea who he was, but afterward he’d often get a “Remember me?” call at the office. The last one had actually shown up there. That had been almost a year ago. Which explained the “issues” with Olivia. He could solve them by breaking his dry spell but he recoiled at the thought. And he had a feeling it wouldn’t be more than a very temporary solution. Because, if he was being honest, there was more to his attraction than biology. That didn’t matter, though. Having such a relationship with Olivia introduced far too many uncontrollable variables into the equation.

She won’t stay. She never does.

The other night, when he’d insisted Ricky join Olivia in her room upstairs, it had been, admittedly, an effort to prove their relationship didn’t bother him. Of course, as soon as Ricky had climbed the stairs, and Gabriel realized how quiet the house was, and that he’d hear them if they engaged in anything, he’d felt very differently about the situation. Sure enough, the sounds from their room did drive him out of the house. But they weren’t “that” sort of sound at all, simply them whispering and laughing, their voices too low for him even to make out what they were saying. That was enough, those whispers and laughs pounding through his skull like red-hot spikes.

That was exactly what he wanted from Olivia. That casual intimacy. That connection. They would go to dinner, and they’d relax and talk, share a bottle of wine, and it wouldn’t matter if they were surrounded by people—it felt like just the two of them, wrapped up in the meal and the conversation. Or they’d be someplace together, talk turning light, teasing, and he’d see that glow in her eyes, feel the warmth of it. Then circumstances would intervene and the mood would evaporate, and he’d have no idea how to get it back again.

Ricky did. Effortlessly. In the midst of the worst situation, Ricky could engage Olivia as easily as flicking a switch. Change her mood. Make her smile. Win a laugh. He made it seem so easy.

It was not easy. Not at all.

But she’d spent the night in the police station for Gabriel. The officers occasionally came by his holding cell to tell him his “girlfriend” was still hanging around. He told them Olivia wasn’t his girlfriend. Finally, one had said, “Well, then someone should tell her that, because she sure as hell acts like it.” To have someone do that for him . . . it was confounding and almost unfathomable. He kept trying to tell himself that she had to have a reason beyond not wanting to abandon him. But she hadn’t. She’d stuck by his side simply to say she was standing by him.

Gabriel checked his phone in case Olivia had texted, perhaps to say things were going poorly and she needed his help, his advice. He had messages. None from her. As he put his phone back, he noticed Ricky crossing the street, moving fast. Walking away from Olivia’s building. Away from Olivia.

Ricky pulled on his helmet, climbed on his bike, and drove off without a backward glance.

Gabriel got as far as the front door before Rose made a noise behind him.

“I’m just going over—” he began.

“I heard the motorcycle.”

“Yes, Ricky has left, which means Olivia is free. We have work to do.”

Rose shook her head, looking very tired. “If there is anything worse than racing over because you’re hoping she’s been dumped, it’s racing over to tell her to get back to work right
after
she got dumped. How about this: you’re going over there to support her because she’ll be upset, and she should have someone to talk to about it?”

Gabriel paused. Then he said, “Exactly.”

Rose shook her head again. “Go on.”

—

Gabriel tried to check his pace as he crossed the road. When he reached the apartment building, Grace called from the stoop, “Barely even waited until he got around the corner, did you?”

Gabriel ignored her. When he reached for the door, she said, “Presuming you want the girl, you’re going the wrong way.”

Gabriel followed her finger to see Olivia heading up Rowan. He calculated time and distance, trying to determine whether she might have left first—walking out after a fight. No, Ricky had, leaving Olivia upset, wanting to walk it off and . . .

And she was heading in the direction of the Carew house.

Gabriel took off at a slow lope, with Grace calling, “You’re welcome!” behind him.

Ricky must not have believed what Olivia had told him about the omens and visions, and that had set her own doubts swirling again. She was wondering if she was imagining things. Heading to the Carew house for proof that she wasn’t.

Olivia didn’t need this. Ricky hadn’t been there, not for any of it. He had no right to judge, goddamn him.

At the corner, Olivia stopped. Her head swiveled in the direction of the Carew house. Then she turned around and started heading back. It took a few steps for her to notice him. When she did, he tried to read her expression, but the sun was just beginning to drop, and long oak-tree shadows hid her face.

As she came close, he saw a tired, almost wry smile on her lips.

“Hey,” she said. Before he could speak, she lifted a hand to stop him. “Yes, I was going to the house. Now I’m not.”

“What happened?”

“I realized it was a very stupid idea.”

He fell in step beside her. “Telling Ricky?”

“Hmm?” She looked over. “Oh, right. No. That’s fine.”

“You’re all right with him taking off?”

Another vague look, as if her mind was elsewhere.

“I saw him leave,” Gabriel said. “Clearly, he didn’t take the news well and—”

“Oh, that. No. He’s fine. He just went to grab dinner.”

“Dinner?”

“Pizza, I think. Can’t find that in Cainsville. I’m sure he’ll bring plenty, so you’re welcome to join us if you want some.”

There were many things Gabriel wanted. Pizza was not one of them.

He cleared his throat. “So you told him everything and . . .”

“Not everything. Just about the omens and Cainsville. The omens part was fine. He’s struggling a little more with the fae. As one would. I think he offered to go get pizza to take time to process everything. But he’s not questioning it. He’s more like you that way. I may have grown up with those superstitions in my head, but that was my only exposure to anything preternatural. You have Rose and her second sight. Ricky grew up with the stories, including the Wild Hunt.”

“What?”

Olivia slowed as they neared her apartment. “When I was out at his cabin, we went . . . for a walk at night. We heard the Hunt. The Cwn Annwn. He joked about it being the Wild Hunt—he knew the stories from his grandmother. Of course, he rationalized it away—just nighttime hunters—but I think he said that for my benefit, that deep down he suspected what it really was.”

Of course he did.

He squeezed his eyes shut, forcing the voice to be quiet.

“Gabriel?” Olivia said.

“A slight headache,” he said.

“I’m not surprised, given the last forty-eight hours. If you want to rest, I promise I won’t go to the Carew house. I might go for a run, though. Or we could walk, if you need fresh air more than a rest.” She grinned at him. “I know better than to suggest you join me in a run.”

“I would, but my sweats are at home.”

Her grin grew, as if she thought he was joking. Then she saw that he wasn’t.

“You run?”

He shrugged. “Not much lately.”

“And you never mentioned it?” A short pause, then a wry smile. “You were afraid I might ask to join you, right?”

He didn’t know how to answer that. He would happily run with her. He just never wanted to presume. There was, too, always the possibility that he overthought these things. It was foreign ground to him. He did recall a couple of tentative childhood friendships. There’d been a girl before he was old enough for school. She lived down the hall. That lasted until his mother took advantage of his access to their apartment to steal everything that wasn’t nailed down. Then there’d been a boy in first grade. That ended when his mother slept with the boy’s father.

Thus began the slow process of learning to avoid anything that could be taken as an overture to friendship. It hadn’t bothered him, really. He wasn’t sociable by nature, and to be honest, his “friendships” had been more “playing in the same room as an equally unsociable child.” Learning what might constitute an overture had been profitable later in life, as a way to manipulate marks into thinking they’d earned his friendship. The result, though, was that he was, perhaps, a little hyperaware of his interactions with others. Even Olivia. No,
especially
Olivia.