Escape from the Land of Snows (34 page)

Read Escape from the Land of Snows Online

Authors: Stephan Talty

Tags: #Tibet Autonomous Region (China), #Escapes, #Bstan-Dzin-Rgya-Mtsho - Childhood and Youth, #Tibetan, #Tibet, #Dalai Lamas, #Asia, #General, #Escapes - China - Tibet, #Religion, #Buddhism, #China, #Biography & Autobiography, #Religious, #History

BOOK: Escape from the Land of Snows
13.55Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
NOTES
Introduction

  
1
“dizzying, frightening blur”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 135.

  
2
“between two volcanoes”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 172.

  
3
“They were almost”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 124.

  
4
“I feared a massive, violent reprisal”: Ibid., p. 117.

  
5
“There was an unforgettable scent”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 33.

  
6
“driven into barbarism”: Ibid., p. 137.

  
7
Some 40,000 Chinese troops: Dunham, p. 264.

One
AN EXAMINATION OF PRIOR MEMORIES

  
1
Details of the death of the Thirteenth Dalai Lama and the search for the Fourteenth are drawn from the Dalai Lama’s two memoirs, from Goodman, and from Avedon.

  
2
“everywhere else is to be feared”: Gyatso, p. 13.

  
3
“In 1950”: The population figures are from French, pp. 278–79.

  
4
“ ‘Good,’ he said”: quoted in Avedon, p. 9.

  
5
“Clear springs”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 16.

  
6
“I used to torture”: Q&A with the Dalai Lama, University of California at Santa Barbara, February 24, 2009.

  
7
“I have memories”: Quoted in Chhaya, p. 52.

  
8
“I’m packing”: Quoted in Goodman, p. 13.

  
9
“Now that we had witnessed”: Ibid., p. 14.

Two
TO LHASA

  
1
What the Dalai Lama especially remembered: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 14.

  
2
“gargantuan mountains”: Ibid., p. 13.

  
3
“as if I were in a great park”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 33.

  
4
“huge monastery”: Quoted in Hopkirk, p. 13.

  
5
“organized gold-bricking”:
Life
magazine, April 6, 1959.

  
6
And one young monk: The reference is to Tashi Tsering’s memoir
The Struggle for Modern Tibet
. Armonk, N.Y.: East Gate Books, 2000.

  
7
“the last temporal liberty”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 15.

  
8
“a solid, solemn”: Quoted in Goodman, p. 64.

  
9
“So strong”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 19.

10
“I missed my mother”: Quoted in Craig, p. 176.

11
“It was pitifully cold and ill-lit”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 21.

12
“My only interest was in playing”: Q&A with the Dalai Lama, University of California at Santa Barbara, April 24, 2009.

13
“When he left after each visit”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 20.

14
“Those children”: Quoted in Craig, p. 54.

15
“They unnerved me”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 40.

16
“He laughed enthusiastically”: Harrer, p. 250.

17
“From the first day”: Dalai Lama and Carrièrre, p. 162.

18
“not yet human”: Smith, p. 21.

19
“a mere puppet”: Petech, p. 285.

20
“very often”: Lixiong, Wang, “Reflections on Tibet.”
New Left Review
, March–April 2002, p. 81.

21
“Many of them”: Laird, p. 280.

Three
ACROSS THE GHOST RIVER

  
1
“[They] were held to be like butchers”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 52.

  
2
“liberate our compatriots”: Quoted in Knaus, p. 47.

  
3
“What is meant”: Norbu, Dawa, “The 1959 Tibetan Rebellion: An Interpretation.”
China Quarterly
, no. 77 (March 1979), p. 90.

  
4
“The relationship”: Quoted in Shakya, p. 70.

  
5
“When Great Heroes”: Quoted in Chang, p. 14.

  
6
Watch us kill:
Ibid., p. 54.

  
7
“The noblemen were getting truckloads”: Interview with Gray Tuttle.

  
8
“The challenge filled me”: Quoted in Levenson,
Tenzin Gyatso
, p. 78.

  
9
“If you don’t make”: Quoted in Goldstein, vol. 1, p. 705.

10
“I had to leave”: Quoted in Craig, p. 78.

11
“began to realize”: Ibid., p. 127.

12
“I could not believe”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 63.

13
“Some of your advisors”: Quoted in Shakya, p. 81.

14
“He was isolated”: Quoted in Strober, p. 107.

15
“If Tibet is to be saved”: Quoted in Knaus, p. 97.

16
“Tibet will once again”: Quoted in Shakya, p. 80.

17
“half convinced”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 66.

18
“Regardless of all the suspicion”: Ibid., p. 67.

19
“What comes naturally”: Quoted in Goldstein, vol. 2, p. 199.

20
“I had still had no theoretical training”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 97.

21
“His Holiness is very humble”: Quoted in Laird, p. 322.

22
“He thought people were so good”: Interview with Tendzin Choegyal.

23
“Absolute selfishness”: Chang, p. 14.

24
“Of course there are people”: Ibid., p. 13.

25
“truly respect”: Quoted in Goldstein, vol. 2, p. 180.

26
“When the Chinese first came”: Tibet Oral History Project, testimony of Thupten Chonphel, interview #26.

27
“We had a saying”: Interview with Topgay, Tibetan refugee and former security official in the Tibetan government-in-exile. Dharamsala, India, January 2009.

28
“Make every possible effort”: Quoted in Shakya, p. 93.

29
“The more I looked”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 93.

30
“If you’ve ever been”: Interview with Gray Tuttle.

31
“There is everywhere”: Quoted in Shakya, p. 117.

32
“old and ruined”: Dalai Lama interview with
Welt Online
, July 10, 2009.

33
“I felt”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 88.

34
“the pace of reform”: Ibid., p. 89.

35
“How could he”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 99.

Four
EASTERN FIRES

  
1
“We could not even look up”: Tibet Oral History Project, testimony of Dorji Damdul (alias), interview #16.

  
2
“They would say”: Ibid.

  
3
“The Chinese captured”: Ibid.

  
4
“were brought on yaks”: Ibid.

  
5
“most precious possession”: Quoted in Feigon, p. 32.

  
6
“You never heard the name mentioned”: Harrer, p. 93.

  
7
One Khampa refugee: Tibet Oral History Project.

  
8
As the buglers: Quoted in Dunham, p. 255.

  
9
“Many of our loved ones”: Ibid., p. 207.

10
“Gyalo said”: Athar’s unpublished memoir, unpaginated.

11
“At one point”: Ibid.

12
“I could see”: Ibid.

13
“We pulled out”: Ibid.

14
“A word from the Dalai Lama”: Peissel, p. 70.

15
“When you have a piece”: Quoted in Craig, p. 210.

16
“If I was recognized”: Athar’s unpublished memoir, unpaginated.

17
“We’d send a message”: Interview with John Greaney.

18
Phala remembered: Volume 2 of an unpublished history of the Tibetan resistance movement by Lhamo Tsering, translated by Warren Smith, Jr. A rough draft of the relevent passage was published on
mikeldunham.blogs.com
.

19
“As things stand”:
Indian Express
, December 15, 1958.

20
“an unguided missile”: Interview with Ken Knaus.

21
“a constant source”: Quoted in Craig, p. 180.

22
“My classmates were all talking”: Interview with Tendzin Choegyal.

23
“What could happen?”: Quoted in Goodman, p. 274.

Five
A RUMOR

  
1
This city:
Journal of the American Geographical Society of New York
, 1905, vol. 37, p. 184.

  
2
“Hail to the liberation”: Quoted in Dunham, p. 119.

  
3
“You are people who are lagging”: Tibet Oral History Project, testimony of Sonam Dorjee, interview #86.

  
4
“No one could speak their mind”: Quoted in Goodman, p. 274.

  
5
“Gradually, life in Lhasa:” Quoted in Tsering, p. 168.

  
6
“I would sacrifice”: The quote, and details of the morning of March 10, are from an interview with Lobsang Yonten.

  
7
“It had been our painful experience”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 165.

  
8
“By 1959”: Interview with Narkyid.

  
9
“The Tibetans were out of their minds”: Khetsun, p. 23.

10
“It is time”: Quoted in Shakya, p. 187.

11
“Will you be responsible”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 167.

12
“What are you doing?!”: Quoted in Goodman, p. 295.

13
“I didn’t know”: Interview with Tendzin Choegyal.

14
“puffs of vapor”: Gyatso, p. 49.

15
“All the people”: Interview with Lobsang Yonten.

16
“I was surprised”: Interview with Narkyid.

17
“Chamdo had disappeared”: Gyatso, p. 50.

18
“Some in the crowd”: Interview with Tenpa Soepa.

19
“Tibetans were angry”: Interview with Pusang, former Tibetan army doctor and refugee. Dharmsala, India, January 2009.

20
“I remember saying”: Quoted in Craig, p. 215.

21
“The Lhasan people”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 173.

22
“From my window”: Shan Chao,
Peking Review
, vol. 18, May 5, 1959.

23
And he secretly admired: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 160.

24
The CIA agent Ken Knaus: Interview with Ken Knaus.

25
“I could feel the tension”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 172.

26
“They are raising”: Shan Chao,
Peking Review
, vol. 18, May 5, 1959.

27
“They were getting”: Interview with Tendzin Choegyal.

28
His mother was growing frantic: For Diki Tsering’s account of this day, see her memoir,
Dalai Lama, My Son
, pp. 168–72.

29
“Many officials”: Shakya, p. 197.

30
“Reactionary elements”: Quoted in Goodman, p. 296.

31
“You’re too young”: Interview with Lobsang Yonten.

32
One Tibetan doctor: Interview with Pusang. 87 “The main fear”: Quoted in Patt, p. 145.

33
“She was very happy”: Interview with Tendzin Choegyal.

34
“The officials kept saying”: Interview with Lobsang Yonten.

35
“You’re too young”: Ibid.

36
“The loudspeakers were saying”: Interview with Lobsang Norbu.

37
“I was a tough guy”: Ibid.

38
“He pleaded with those”: Interview with Lobsang Khunchok.

39
“My spiritual comrades”: Ibid.

40
but they had essentially given up: Dunham, p. 201.

Six
FOREIGN BROTHERS

  
1
“I had an atlas”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 57.

  
2
“I wanted to be like Moses”: Patterson’s story is taken from his memoir
Patterson of Tibet
.

  
3
“George,” the British High Commissioner finally broke in: Ibid, p. 324.

  
4
Among them was: The sketch of Barber’s career is drawn from his obituaries in the
Times
, the
Daily Mail
, and other London newspapers.

  
5
“Publicity,” he notes: Interview with John Greaney.

  
6
“I went over”: Interview with Ken Knaus.

  
7
“Des was very handsome”: The portrait of FitzGerald is drawn largely from Thomas’s
The Very Best Men
.

  
8
I must say: Quoted in Thomas, p. 198.

  
9
“The Tibetans were people fighting”: Interview with Ken Knaus.

10
“They were very reverent”: Ibid.

11
“the heartbeat of every Tibetan”: Athar’s unpublished memoir, unpaginated.

12
“Everybody wanted to be on the Task Force”: Interview with John Greaney.

13
“One of the most romantic programs”: Thomas, p. 276.

14
When Greaney was called: Interview with John Greaney.

15
“It was a flea biting an elephant”: Thomas, p. 278.

16
The Khampas, who kept a photograph: From
The Shadow Circus: The CIA in Tibet
, a White Crane Films Production for BBC Television, 1998.

17
“We really felt”: Athar’s unpublished memoir, unpaginated.

Seven
ACROSS THE KYICHU

  
1
“It looks as if”: Shan Chao,
Peking Review
, vol. 18, May 5, 1959.

  
2
“The independent country”: Norbu,
China’s Tibet Policy
, p. 225.

  
3
“like a magnificent”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 214.

  
4
“down to the last”: Ibid., p. 136.

  
5
“a blatant, outright fabrication”: Quoted in Barber,
From the Land
, p. 110.

  
6
“Within the palace”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 194.

  
7
“the odds against”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 136.

  
8
“I roamed all over”: Interview with Tendzin Choegyal.

  
9
“He must have gotten it”: Ibid.

10
“Everyone was anxious”: Ibid.

11
“stitching bags”: Ibid.

12
“I started saying good-bye”: Ibid.

13
“I have no fear”: Dalai Lama,
My Land
, p. 171.

14
“As I went out”: Ibid., p. 198.

15
“the saddest sight”: Barber,
From the Land
, p. 120.

16
“I felt like blacking out”: Interview with Mingyur, by Lobsang Wangyal, Agence France-Presse, March 17, 2004.

17
“You are like ants”: Quoted in Craig, p. 216.

18
“I needed to be very careful”: Quoted in Laird, p. 335.

19
“I was certain”: Dalai Lama,
Freedom
, p. 139.

20
“I don’t know what”: Interview with Tendzin Choegyal.

21
“All of a sudden”: Interview with Tendzin Choegyal.

22
“He was young”: Quoted in “Tibetan Officer Remembers 1959 Escape with Dalai Lama” by Matthias Williams. Reuters, March 12, 2009.

Other books

Stranded! by Pepper Pace
Journey Through the Mirrors by T. R. Williams
Frozen Teardrop by Lucinda Ruh
My Clockwork Muse by D.R. Erickson
Full Court Press by Rose, Ashley
The Truest Pleasure by Robert Morgan
Jeanne Dugas of Acadia by Cassie Deveaux Cohoon
Australian Hospital by Joyce Dingwell
Fancy Pants by Susan Elizabeth Phillips