Fat Chance
Authors: Deborah Blumenthal
Fat Chance
“Food and men are two of Maggie O'Leary's favorite pastimesâ¦. To snag her star, she ignores her own antidieting dictates and sheds the pounds but eventually finds that you can get a man and eat your cake, too.”
â
People,
Spring's Best Chick Lit, 2004
“Light as a cupcake and as fun to devour, Blumenthal's debut novel (and Red Dress Ink's second hardcover) will likely find many fans.”
â
Booklist
“Maggie is likable throughout the story line, but especially when she tries to live life to the fullest without concern to her size, and the support cast adds insight into what makes Maggie tick. To learn whether she got her hunkâread the book.”
âHarriet Klausner on
reviewcentre.com
“Deborah Blumenthal's deliciously amusing novel offers a refreshing chick-lit twist: a heroine who embraces with gusto her innerâand generously proportioned outerâfood-loving self. Zaftig Maggie O'Leary happily devours barbecued ribs rather than obsessing about whether her own will be visible to the naked eyeâand builds a high-profile career encouraging fellow females to do the same.
Fat Chance
is as much sparkling, laid-back fun as good champagne sipped from a bottle!”
âWendy Markham, author of
Slightly Single
and
Slightly Settled
Deborah Blumenthal
There are several people that I would like to thank for making this book possible: Claudia Cross, my agent at Sterling Lord, for her quick and spirited response to the book, and Sarah Walsh, her assistant, for handling business so quickly and efficiently, even when computer glitches threw themselves in our path. Renni Browne and Mary Costello are writing teachers extraordinaire, and I thank them both for their vision. My editor, Ann Leslie Tuttle, deserves special thanks for being such a hearty supporter of the book from the start. She is a joy to work with. She is gracious, elegant, supportive, sensitive and always available. I would also like to offer deep-felt gratitude to Margaret Marbury and her associates at Red Dress Ink for their unswerving enthusiasm.
My husband, Ralph, my best friend and mentor, is always having drafts of my work dropped on him and, as ever, I am eternally grateful for all his guidance. Our daughter, Annie, is also a faithful reader and editor as well as an overall great kid, and much love and appreciation goes to her for her unflagging support. Our younger daughter, Sophie, also deserves thanks and love for putting up with seeing my back at the computer for as many years as she has been with us. Thanks to Connie Christopher for offering her wise counsel. To all my other friends and family who have been willing to listen to the whining all these years, thanks for staying on the line.
To Ralph
Chewing the Fat
H
ow could I forget the way it started? We chewed the fatâon our filet mignons that were charred to blackened perfection outside, bloodred inside, topped with a pebbly crust of crushed green peppercorns. We were having lunch at Gallagher's, Bill's favorite steak restaurant, and the more excited he got about the idea, the more he waved his fork through the air like a conductor's baton, never mind that the end of it held a wedge of baked potato enveloped in sour cream that I feared he might inadvertently fling down on my head.
“The entire planet is fat, Maggie,” Bill said, shaking his head. “Between 1991 and 1998 alone, the incidence of obesity almost doubled, and you know better than I do that the only people who benefit from bestselling diet books are the people who publish them.” I opened my mouth to answer, but he went on.
“So here's my thought,” he said, pausing just long enough to reach for the salt sticks. “Why not cover it in a regular space? But not the pap weight loss stuffâ”
“A counterculture perspective,” I said, finishing Bill's sentence.
“That's right, that's right,” he said, the fork alighting once again, this time precariously freighted with a dollop of creamed spinach. “Your audience is bigger than everâone out of every four adults is fatâand they're crying out for compassion.”
“Bill, it's time for someone in the media to stand up and offer America an alternative vision about their overweight: âLive with it and love it.'” I could almost hear the first stirring strains of “America the Beautiful.”
“Exactly! You'll be their counselor, Maggie, you're perfect for the job.”
I put down my fork and pressed my hand to my fluttering heart, as if to recite the pledge. “I'm speechless, Bill, it's brilliant. I'm behind it a hundred percent.”
“We'll move you into a new office,” he said with mounting excitement, “and you'll have carte blanche to indulge yourself at the city's finest restaurants.”
With a fine stroke of the knife, I teased off a sliver of beef. “I can't wait to get my teeth into it.”
Within a week of my lunch with the managing editor, my column was announced in the paper, and from then on my wit and wisdom sparked nationwide attention, leading not only to an outpouring of calls and letters from desperate readers, but also radio and TV interviews, and speaking engagements. In January, just nine months later, yours truly's face adorned the cover of
People
with the headline, The New Face of Fat: Is Maggie O'Leary America's Anti-Diet Sweetheart?
“Fat Chance” was launched, and I was becoming a rising media star. And readers? Well, they were eating up my words.
F
ive minutes to deadline and adrenaline surges through my gut. Eyes on the screen, I pound the keys with my usual vigor, stopping only to sip my Rhumba Frappuccino VentiâStarbucks' malted-rich, soda-fountain-sized coffee drink that tamps down a leaning tower of reader mail. A perfect marriage with the cinnamon-dusted apple pie from the Little Pie Company down the street. Mmmm⦠Nobody could beat their pie crust. And they got the chunky consistency of the apples just right. Texture. That's what perfect apple pie is all about. I turn back to the computer, dropping a few flakes of crust between the keys. The phone rings.
“I'M FED UP, YOU HEAR ME?”
I jerk the phone arm's length from my ear, but the voice rockets. “I CAN'T LOOK AT MYSELF ANYMORE. I'M FAT ANDâ”
“Wait, please Iâ”
“I'M DESPERATEâ¦NO ONE UNDERSTANDS⦔
“
I
do, butâ”
“I'm all alone and unpopular. None of the friggin' dietsâ”
“âLISTEN, I'll call you back,” I insist, wagging my foot. “I'm just onâ”
“So what do you suggest, huh? You say live with it and love it, but how am I supposed to love fat dimpled thighs that are like,
so repulsive,
you know?”
“DEADLINE. I'm on D-E-A-D-L-I-N-E! Eat some comfort food, and call me in the morning.” I slam down the phone, and check the clock. Minutes before deadline I finish, hit the send key and feel the familiar rush of having dodged another bullet.
I lean back, exhale and reach around to close the button on the waistline of my skirt. Time for dinner. I reflexively tap out Tex Ramsey's extensionâ1-8-4-5âthe year that Texas was admitted to the Union. I know he arranged that, but how? As it rings, my eyes sweep the corkboard wall speckled with bloodred pushpins piercing ads for dubious achievement products: Dr. Fox's Fat-Blocker System, Appetite Suppressant Brownies and Seaweed Thigh-Slimming Cream. A magazine article, “Ideal Weight is an Ordeal Weight,” takes center field, with a quote from Phyllis Diller: “How do I lose unwanted pounds? I undress.”
Framing the perimeter is eye candy: Brad Pitt on the cover of
Vanity Fair,
his tanned, sinewy torso sheathed in a sleeveless white undershirt; a Marlboro Man, weathered complexion, cowboy hat tilted provocatively shadowing soulful green eyes; James Dean, the prototype haunted bad boy in
Rebel Without a Cause.
Dreamboats. That's what girls used to called alpha hunks like that. Taut, archetypical physiques, suggestive gazes that held your eyes promising long steamy nights ofâ¦
“Metro.”
“Tex,” I say, coming up short. “Dinner
ce soir?
”
“Barbecue?”
“Mmmmm. Virgil's?” I ask, naming a popular joint in the Manhattan Theater District.
“Great, pick me up.”
Dinner plans on short notice. No pretense. No frantic search for something to wear:
“Does this skirt make me look like the back of a bus?”
Why couldn't romance be as easy?
I ring Tamara, my assistant and trusted confidant. “What are you doing?”
“Answering your fan mail.”
“Do I have to call the producer from
AM with Susie
back?”
“You dissed her when she called.”
“I was on deadlineâ”
“âshe's doing a show on the fat phenomenon.”
“Get her on the horn, I'll grovel for forgiveness.” I turn back to a talk I'm preparing on the traumas of extreme weight loss, prompted by the story of a surgeon who was not only overweight but also a smoker. Facing the upcoming wedding of his daughter, he went on a crash diet, quickly dropping fifty pounds. The morning of the wedding as he dressed to go to the church, he slumped to the ground suffering a massive heart attack. His death was caused by the drastic diet, doctors ruled, not his excess weight.
The intercom beeps. “Wanna play cover girl for the Lands' End plus-size catalog?”
“Fat chance.”
Another beep. “Wanna talk to a South Carolina group about leading the next Million Pound March?”
“Not in a million years.”
I search my mail for readers' stories on the perils of extreme weight loss. It's one thing to champion fat acceptance,
but another to convince readers. Actually, a tiny microcosm of them sits right outside my office.
The cherubic Arts secretary is slightlyâbut only slightlyâover her ideal weight. Still, every bite is contemplated, measured out and then double-checked using both the imperial and metric systems.
“It's simply a matter of sheer willpower,” she says.
I want to strangle her.
Then there's fashion reporter Justine Connors, a former model who works in a Fortuny-swathed cubicle down the hall. She isn't fat, just obsessed with it. Every nugget of food is eyed as a bullet destined to destroy her reed-like shape. The only other thing you have to know about her is that she swears thong panties and stilettos are comfortable, a physiological impossibility, as I see it. When the office was chipping in to buy her a thirtieth-birthday gift, my suggestion:
“Why not a gift certificate for a colonic?”
Tamara is yet another veteran waist-watcher whom someone at the coffee cart once described as a slightly overblown version of sultry model Naomi Campbell. She's category three: Lost. The New York Lotto slogan is her own. “Hey, you never know.” Tamara's bookshelves are a Library of Congress for the overweight, holding every weight loss tome ever published. It starts with golden oldies, like the quacko
The Last Chance Diet,
by Robert Linn, advocating a liquid protein regimen that the U.S. C.D.C. later pronounced could lead to sudden death;
Triumph Over Disease
by Jack Goldstein (stop eating altogether);
The Rice Diet
by Walter Kempner (nutritionally unsound, but lowers blood pressure); the
U.S. Senate Diet
(no promise of a Congressional seat);
The Prudent Man's Diet,
by Norman Jolliffe M.D. (became the basis for the Weight Watcher's diet);
Live Longer Now
by Nathan Pritikin (tough to follow);
The
Amazing Diet Secret of a Desperate Housewife
(you don't want to know);
The Paul Michael Weight Loss Plan
(“If your intake of carbohydrates is low, some of the fat will pass right through your system without being broken down and stored in adipose tissue”â“Pure nonsense,” said
Consumer Guide
magazine); and on and on, up to and including prestigious tomes of today such as
Eat, Cheat, and Melt the Fat Away,
and
The Zone.
Tamara can leave any diet bigwig on the mat with her grasp of diet lore, but all for naught. None of the regimens work for long, and the proof hangs limply in her closet. Dresses starting at size 12, barreling out to 18. Yo-yo couture.
A copy editor pokes his head into the office, jarring me from my thoughts. “You sure the fat doctor you mentioned is affiliated with Yale?”
“Let me check.”
I press Play on the VCR and am about to fast-forward it, but I freeze. What's wrong with this picture? Instead of a medical conference, the screen explodes with an odd menagerie of Great Danes, goats and horses jumping, panting, pushing, heaving, whining and neighing in the midst of sexual delirium.
“WHAT IN THE WORLD?” I pop out the tape:
Mammals Mating.
Barskyâ
that
animal!
I peer into the newsroom to make sure Alan Barsky is there, then grab the
Yellow Pages
and phone a West Village sex boutique. For the next hour, I monitor the newsroom until I see a delivery man hauling a carton in his direction. The bold black typeface reads: CONDOMS FOR SMALL PECKERS: ONE GROSS. Over the hush of the newsroom, a single voice rings out.
“WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?”
I ring his extension and at the sound of his voice, I sing the Marvin Gaye song “Let's Get It On.”
Â
Time to get serious, and I turn back to my work. I make a note to do a column on the down side of exerciseâin rats, anyway.
Science News
reported that rats who were forced to run on treadmills had lower antibody levels than the ones free to run at will. Of course. Can't trick the old immune system. If exercise makes you miserable, you might get thinner, but your killer cells pay the price.
Another column I'm sketching out looks at the pressures of dieting on women as a form of oppression. By starving, they put themselves at a distinct disadvantage to their energetic, burger-and-fry-packin' male counterparts in the workplace. In effect, dieting is political suicide. It not only reduces women's stamina, but also leaves them handicapped because they crave satisfaction.
That hits close to home. After living under the tyranny of a diet binge, I once walked into a chocolate shop and bought a giant replica of the Statue of Liberty. Bitter chocolate. First I bit off Ms. Liberty's head, then I devoured the rest of her. It feltâ¦liberating.
Reggie, the mail carrier, empties a canvas sack of letters on my desk. “You really read all this crap?”
“It's my bread and butter.”
From the day I started the column, the mail was my window on the world. Hard to imagine that it's been only four years since giving birth both to the column and the realization that in losingâagainâthe war against fat I've fought all my life, nature has the upper hand. The size-sixteen rack was my destiny, and the only real choice I had was whether or not to accept it. But instead of looking at fat in terms of defeat, my publisher and I used it as a springboard to offer
America a fresh take on obesity. As I made that quantum leap to fat acceptance, I've been crusading to carry overweight America with me. What I never imagined was that I would become not only a columnist but also a “Dear Abby” to the weight challenged.
Dear Maggie:
I'm twenty-five years old and fat. I've been trying to lose weight since I was six. I diet and diet, lose a few pounds, and then gain it all back. Everyone makes fun of me. My parents nag me all the time about controlling my eating, and it drives me insane. They say they'd stop if I just lost the weight, but I can't. What should I do?
Women of all sizes, shapes, ages and temperaments now seek me out as a sounding board, shrink and diet counselor. But so do some censorious health experts who insist that I'm in perpetual denial, advising me to get my “fat head” out of the sand. Either way, the calls and letters never stop. Yes, I'm popularâat least with readers.
Popularity, of course, is a rare commodity for the overweight, and sympathy is, well, slim. We're blamed for lacking willpower, and self-control. Few can fathom the intractability of the problem. Ironically, the overweight resent each other. One reader said:
Even though I'm heavy, I still feel that I can control myself and can lose weight if I want to. But other overweight people disgust me. I think that they're just indulging themselves, and not showing any self-control.
There is no shortage of themes. Overweight infiltrates every part of one's life, from bedroom to boardroom to the
altar. But who said life was fair? Remember what the jury did to Jean Harris? No, she wasn't fat, she was just mad. Okay, okay, so she killed a man, but you know, not so terribleâafter all, he
was
a diet doctor. In some circles, women thought she deserved sainthood. Personally, I'm not against killing certain men. I doubt that there is any woman over thirty who hasn't
already
come across at least one guy who deserves a toxic martini.
Â
My phone rings nonstop, and even though I'm no longer on deadline, I try to avoid answering it. But where is my so-called secretary?
“Tamara? T A M A R A?” It's futile.
“Maggie, my name is Robert Clancy. I'm an executive producer with Horizons Entertainment in Los Angeles.”
Ugh. “What can I do you for?”
“We're starting production on a new blockbuster movie called
Dangerous Lies.
We're all very excited about it. It's going to be a very, very big film about a diet doctor in a weight-loss clinic who has to care for women obsessed with becoming thin⦔
“Sorry, I can't take the lead. I've already committed to playing Scarlett in the remake of
Gone With the Wind
â¦.”
“Cuteâ¦butâ¦the movie's cast, Maggie. What we'd love to do is hire you as a consultant.”
“Pourquoi?”
“To coach our lead actor about the milieu of the overweight world and bring him up to speed on the mind-set of weight-obsessed women⦔
What? No overweight women in Los Angeles? He had to call me? But to be fair, maybe there were some before they were all forced out of the city limits under the cover of darkness by a death squad of diet police.
“Look, Bob, I'm pretty tied up here with the column andâ”
“Of course, I understand, but this wouldn't take that much of your time, maybe just a couple of weeks.”
“Weeks?” I start opening the mail.
“We pay pretty wellâ¦would you just consider it?”
“Mmmmâ¦I doubt it, but leave me your number.” I grab a Chinese menu and jot it down along the border next to the two-red-chili-peppers rating of the Orange Beef. “I'll get back at ya.” Tamara walks in, as if on cue.
“HOLLYWOOD!”
“Run that past me again,” she says.
“They want me to fly out to Hollywood. Do you love it?”
“I hope you told them that I'm free to go as well. How much moola?”
“Not enough to get me on a plane.”
Celebrating the Gift of Ampleness
Like an overprotective parent who lends you the family car with spare tires in the trunk, nature is looking out on your behalf. Natural selection provides a surplus, and the reason is obvious. Just listen to former Yale surgeon Sherwin Nuland.
“An injured creature is more likely to survive and reproduce if it has a surplus to fall back on.” The human body is made with an abundance of cells, tissues, even organs. “We really do not need two kidneys or such a huge liver, or more than twenty feet of small intestine.”
While Voltaire might not have been thinking about the fleshy woman when he said,
“Le superflu, chose très nécessaire”
âthe superfluous, that most neces
sary stuffâhis words make biological sense too. The generous female body is the fertile one. Anorexics don't menstruate, well-fed women do, a fact that tells us that we need sustenance to nourish our children and continue the species; reserves to carry us through periods of disease; and ample stores to sustain us in case of starvation. So bless your flesh. Look at your generous, sensuous, nubile body as a miracle of scientific engineering, a delicate, responsive, harmonious creation designed to perpetuate life and keep the human spirit burning.
At the very least, your lush human fat cells now come with a newer, higher price. Stem cells, harvested from fat, represent the new frontier for scientists in search of high-tech treatments for disease.
Why? Because they have the magical ability to turn into a variety of other types of cells. In other words, sometime in the near future, stem cells taken from your glorious globules may be used to replace injured or worn-out cells.
“It's not a static spare tire around our waist. It's really a dynamic tissue, and there are a lot of things in it that could help us fix people with diseases,” said Dr. Marc H. Hedrick, a University of Pittsburgh researcher.
So next time you look down at the scale, smile, don't frown.