Authors: Frank Moorhouse
âGeorge McDowell.'
âGeorge McDowell. Full of verve. Do you hear from him?'
âHe's married now. Battling through the Depression. He's in the aerated waters business.'
âYou won't be leaving us right away? You'll stay on for a while?'
This was the time to tell him. âRobert and I will not be having a family straight away.' She watched to see how Sir Eric would react.
âGood. We'll need you. But you know that you can stay on after you have a child?'
âYes. Williams explained that to me.'
Within a minute of being in his office she had told him she
was practising birth control. Within minutes they were talking about her most private bodily processes.
It again linked everything together in a confusion. What if she had a row with Sir Eric and then had to face him at the wedding? Well, too bad.
She spoke out, but her voice was not as firm as she would have liked. âI'm unhappy with what's been happening about the World Population Conference.'
Sir Eric was surprised. âHow so?'
She said that she considered it to be League business but she feared that he was blocking debate.
Sir Eric was cautious. âWhat in particular do you see as League business?'
âWell, the world is rapidly filling up. Except for France. More importantly, we should be concerned with the quality of the people being born into the world.'
âYou support that line of thinking?' He seemed surprised that she did. âYou support the thinking of the eugenicists and all that?'
âPeople say, that is, people who should know, say that the national stock is deteriorating. That more people with mental and physical defects are being born.'
âBerry, you are a first-rate officer. I admire you and so do others. I don't see how this concerns your work now with Bartou. I was simply seeking Bartou's personal advice.'
She nearly said that all the problems of the world were related. But it echoed Ambrose's pathetic presentation on famine. That way lies madness. There be monsters.
âBartou suggested that I be sent along and you vetoed that.'
âOnly to keep this out of the League.'
âBecause of the Catholic members?'
âI think that we should let this matter mature outside the
League first. I don't believe that the debate is at a point where it could be successfully considered by the League.' He didn't respond to her mention of his religion.
She could no longer find her indignation. She realised that in confronting Sir Eric, she was carrying through some sort of personal formality. She could no longer see what she wanted as an outcome. She was no longer sure that she wanted to be put in a position of resigning. She thought that she might simply want to be able to say to herself that she had registered her position. She went on with her case but her voice became that of a junior officer seeking guidance, not that of a birth control reformer. âDon't you think, Sir Eric, that controlling the quality of the human stock is important? If you had a magic wand, wouldn't you remove the suffering of deformity and insanity from the world?'
He thought for a second or so. âI believe that we can feed all the children of the world if we become less wasteful. Surplus population could be allotted to the new countries and to Japan. I would rather we rely on compassion for those who enter life regardless of their “quality”.' He then added, uncomfortably, âIn extreme cases, I would rather rely on the humanity and compassion of doctors and nurses exercised with wisdom. Not on broad laws.'
She said, âI really wanted to say that we should be listening to what scientific people are saying on this.'
âI was about to give you advice,' he said, a wry smile coming to his face, âbut I then recalled an embarrassing piece of advice I once gave you which proved not to be wisdom at all. I think about that day very often.'
She smiled. âI too. But I would still like to hear your maxim.'
âI was going to say to you that even the supreme values of mankind are not necessarily always compatible. Rain may be
good for the farmer and bad for the cricketer. Serious discussion may be good in one arena and dangerous in another. Listening to scientists on eugenics or racial purity may be intriguing for individuals such as yourself and Dame Rachel but bad for the League at this point in history. The Secretariat should not introduce onto an agenda those things which will disrupt our other work. But what do you advise?' he asked.
âThat officers go in a private capacity.'
âYou know that while the League invites “observers” to our activities, it is impossible for the League to ever be simply an “observer”. Our presence is always a form of recognition.'
She nodded. âWe could send technical people. Or junior officers. That would temper the League's presence?'
âDo you wish to go?'
Suddenly she did not. âNo.'
He seemed pleased. âMay I ask if you have a position on the matters at the conference?'
âI suppose I'm swayed by scientific thinking on racial hygiene but I still have trouble seeing how governments could do it.'
âForced sterilisation has begun in South Dakota in the United States. Sterilisation clinics for people who are considered not capable of parenthood,' he said with obvious disapproval. âI don't like the idea.'
Edith said, âPerhaps colonies could be set up for the unfit. With segregation of men and women. Only to prevent genetic contamination and racial pollution. Or maybe financial incentives should be offered.'
âOr penalties? Regardless of my Catholicism, I believe that some questions should be for ever put out of the reach of scientific experiment and government officials. And of the League.'
They sat in silence for a moment or so. Her mind was blank.
The issue had for her closed. Tiger knocked and put her head around the door. âSorry, Sir Eric, sorry, Berry, but Monsieur Avenol is here.'
She stood up. Sir Eric stood up. âThank you for giving me your views, Berry. You're always welcome in this office.'
She looked about the office. She had first entered this office as a thief in the night, illicitly signing letters in the name of the Secretary-General. She had then been here on that remarkable morning when she had become a daughter. Or was it that she had become almost a wife? She was here now as an officer making her point with a confused heart.
They shook hands and he held her hand that second longer which said that he and she had a compact and were above being separated by disagreement on policy. And that her personal practices would not change anything between them.
As she went up to her office to call Robert, she realised that there had been an even deeper purpose behind her confrontation with Sir Eric. It had been to reconnect with him, to discover if her special tie with Sir Eric still existed and to silently reconcile her own controlling of birth with what she knew to be Sir Eric's view. She had gone to his office to seek his blessing. How petty and personal her behaviour seemed. And would she have behaved differently if that blessing had not been offered and if the compact had not been reaffirmed?
She reminded herself that she had not betrayed Dame Rachel or Rationalism.
She stood on the landing and rested her forehead on the glass of the window looking out on Geneva. She loved both Sir Eric and Dame Rachel. And Bartou. It was essentially subaltern love, the gratification of giving loyalty. Yet over the years it had become more that distinctive love which grew among âa band of brothers'. Perhaps it was both of these forms of love. She saw
that she was reluctant to let go of her subaltern status. But soon age would not allow her to serve and shelter there.
She went to her office and called Robert on the telephone. âI'm not resigning.'
âGood. I think that's the right thing to do. Did you have a row?'
âNo.'
Â
In bed that night she felt close to screaming. It was all so contrived and extraneous. âI will get up and try again,' she said.
âIt's all right. It isn't worrying me.'
It plainly was worrying him. She stopped herself talking about it but thought, I must get it right. From the very start.
She eased him away and he withdrew from her gently and rolled on to his back, sweating, a hand on her stomach, still aroused. He leaned over and kissed her, perhaps to keep the mood of concupiscence alive. She pulled down her satin nightdress and left the bed and went to the bathroom. The nightdress had been meant for their wedding night but she had decided that this night would need something of powerful feminity and voluptuousness to see them through. She had been right. For a moment she thought about removing the cap and leaving it, forgetting about the whole business, but knew that would be spineless. She crouched and went through the procedure again. She applied a little of the oil which had been supplied, washed her hands, and returned to the bed, still on the edge of tears.
They coupled again, she wanting to have done with it, and to put behind them the first time with the device. She didn't expect to be able to surrender to it but he whispered that he felt nothing, and then went on to whisper strange lascivious things, caressing her with provocative words about the hot suck of
her opening and its tightening, and soon, contrary to all her expectations, she was deep in waves of sensation which rolled through her and without straining, she used the lessons given to her by Dr Monet. Soon nothing much was in her mind and she relaxed away, knowing that it would be all right, and their physical love was complete.
Â
They sat there at breakfast, Robert reading the day-old London
Times
, she reading the
Journal de Genève
. He was dressed in his dressing gown and regimental pyjamas. The pyjamas were the only thing he and Ambrose had in common, although of different regiments â that is, on the occasions when Ambrose had worn pyjamas.
âAbout last night,' he said.
âYes?'
âOne thing,' he said.
âYes?'
âI liked what you did, while we were together in bed. Was I enjoying the proceeds of your worldly experience?'
She smiled and said, âNo. Womanly arcana.' She pulled a tantalising screen across it all. She was, perhaps, learning when not to speak.
A feeling warmed and encompassed her like a cloak, the feeling that her personal life and bodily person, were in order and were safe. There over coffee, in the chilly sunlight, with the newly baked rolls, the blackberry jam and the good white salty butter from the market, she could see now that things were in order.
She told him that Caroline Bailey had written from London congratulating them and saying she and Liverright would be coming to the wedding although she âdidn't believe in marriage'.
John had sent congratulations on the letterhead of Leader of the Opposition. Her father had written, saying that if the good Rationalist Bernard Shaw could be a pallbearer at Thomas Hardy's funeral in Westminster Abbey, he could attend to give his daughter away in the English church of Geneva. Her father was thrilled and envious that she'd met Bernard Shaw at the last Assembly. The invitation to her brother, not unexpectedly, was returned ânot known at this address'.
She said that Ambrose had not replied to their invitation.
He made a consoling face. She experienced the bewildered sadness which came to her now and then about Ambrose. Some nights she awoke and lay in bed in alarm, fearing that her conduct about the spying and about Ambrose's illness had been misjudged. What if his spying had been harmless and of no consequence? Done for foolish but well-meaning motives? What if she had been ignoring his love for her over the years for her own purposes? What if she had broken his heart? Before she could return to sleep she would have to go over every detail of it again to assure herself that she had behaved honourably and compassionately, to convince herself yet again that it was not in her power to heal him.
Â
On the Monday morning they always had a hurried breakfast.
âI must catch the tram and go to work,' she said, looking at her watch.
âAnd you're not resigning,' he confirmed.
âI am not resigning. I promised Bartou I would stay until the disarmament conference.'
âIf you stay until the world is disarmed, we will be here in Geneva for quite a while,' he said without looking up from his newspaper.
âWe shall see. I intend to disarm the world only “to the lowest point consistent with national safety and the enforcement by common action of international obligations”.'
He laughed. âGood.'
She stood behind his chair, her arms around him. He kissed her hands. She said, âCan you think of a better way for us to spend this time of our life?'
She knew that part of her still wanted him to say, yes, that he could think of another way for them to spend their time and their life. He looked up and back at her from his newspaper, and seemed to be seriously considering this question and to be preparing an unexpected answer. After a few seconds, he said, âWe could just go off. We could let the world look after itself.' But his voice said that he was not seriously offering this, yet he was
saying
it.
Her heart beat hard. She nearly said, yes, let's go. Let's go now. âOff to where?' she said, using the same unserious tone that he had used, yet also
saying
it.
âWe could go to Australia. Buy a sheep station. You talked once about going back and helping to “make the ethos”. We could have a large family. And lots of sheep. Write books.'
She forced down the impulse to say yes. She said instead, âThat'll have to wait. The sheep will have to wait.'
She kissed his hair and let go of him. She gathered up her files and papers. âAnd I am not from sheep country. I come from milk, butter and cheese country.'
Maybe if he now said, let us have a dairy with many cows and goats and make cheese, she would say yes.