Authors: Sharon Creech
So much depends upon
making words
without
sounds
Happeeeee Valentine's Day!
I liked when you said
we could try
turning the metaphors
upside down or inside out
and I liked when you used
my chair poem as an example
so
instead of saying
the chair is like a pleasingly plump momma
we could try
my momma is like a pleasingly plump chair
except that now
everyone thinks
my mother is very plump
and looks like a chair
and it doesn't mean the same
when you turn them around
because while the chair
is a lot like a plump momma
my own mother
is like
so
much
more
than a chair.
Well, okay, I will try it.
Here goes:
My mother is like a plump chair
all squishy soft and huggy
when you sit in her lap
(Just so you know:
I am too old to sit in her lap.
I'm just saying this for the poem.)
Her arms hold you in
so you won't fall
and will feel
safe
And she has sturdy legs
(although I want to make it clear
that my real mother has two legs
not four)
and a straight back
She is proud
but not too proud
and she is there
waiting for me
always
quietly
waiting
for
me.
End of Poem.
So here's the problem:
My real mother
can't always be
waiting for me
because she works at night
and my mother
doesn't sit in the same place
day in and day out
like a chair doesâ
she is always
moving moving moving
her hands
          wav                   air
                   ing      the
                           in
talking to us
          with                 hands
                      those
and she isn't plump at all
and like I said
she has two legs, not four
and so
really
she is not very much
like a chair
at
all.
I will never be
a
real
poet.
Today the fat black cat
up in the tree by the bus stop
dropped a nut on my head
thunk
and when I yelled at it
that fat black cat said
Murr-mee-urrr
in a
nasty
spiteful
way.
I hate that cat.
I am getting
a little worried
about poor
Mr. William Carlos Williams
(is he alive?)
I mean:
first there was the
poem about the
red wheelbarrow
and the chicky chickens
and it's true I like that poem now
(it grows on you)
but
those two poems about the
PLUMS . . . !!!???
I think Kaitlyn was crying
because she felt stupid
and to tell you the truth
I felt stupid, too,
because even though
those were nice little thingies
that Mr. William Carlos Williams said
about the sweet plums
and the old lady
and even though I could see
little pictures
in my mind
when you were reading
the plum poems
it would be very very hard
to explain to my uncle Bill
why those are poems
and not little notes
scribbled on scrap paper.
And did you notice that
Mr. William Carlos Williams
does NOT use much in the way of
ALLITERATION
or
ONOMATOPOEIA
or
SIMILE
or
METAPHOR?
Mm? Did you notice that?
This morning I left
a note
for my mother:
I have eaten
the pudding
that was in
the fridge
and which
you were maybe
saving
for dessert
Forgive me
it was so yum
so thick
so creamy
Those non-poems
of
kookoo Mr. William Carlos Williams
are running in my head:
crunching on a pickle
in the middle of the room
juice running down her arm
It tastes good to her
It tastes good
to her. It tastes
good to her
You can tell by
the way she closes her eyes
and licks her lips
and then her arm
Refreshed
a song of dill pickles
filling the air
It tastes good to her
You know WHAT?
Today in the library
I found some more poems
by Mr. William Carlos Williams
and do you know what he wrote?
A poem about a cat
A CAT!
The title is POEM
(Is Mr. William Carlos Williams
a little lazy?)
and it is only about
a cat climbing over a jamcloset
(what is a jamcloset?)
and into a flowerpot!
That is IT.
That is the p-o-e-m.
But as soon as I read it
I saw in my head
Skitter McKitter
my black kitten
so
here is a
non-poem
about her:
As the kitten
leaped over
the pot
of blue violets
first the front
paws
gracefully
then the hind paws
landing
into the bottom of
the kitchen sink
The fat black cat
crouched on a limb
of the maple tree
needle claws
scratching
the bark
menacingly
then the tail
whacking
at the branch
in warning.
Just as I expected
my uncle Bill
is not a big fan
of Mr. William Carlos Williams.
Uncle Bill says Mr. WCW
is a “minor poet”
and
a “foe poet”
(later my dad explained
he meant
faux
which means “fake”)
and I said
“What about the
âso much depends upon'
poem
and the plum poems?”
(which are stuck in my head
and I can say them from memory)
and Uncle Bill said
“Tuh! Overrated, highly
overrated!”
And I found myself
sticking up for
poor Mr. William Carlos Williams
and the small ordinary things
he writes about
and the small ordinary moments
that you don't notice
until you read his poems
and Uncle Bill said
“Small things? Small moments?
Tuh! Give me LARGE things!
LARGE moments!
Give me poems about
death and dying
about war and tragedy
and philosophical metaphors
give me sonnets
give me odes . . .”
blah blah blah
The only interesting thing
he said while he was visiting
was that he is allergic to cats
and he sneezed a lot just to
prove it
and he made us lock Skitter McKitter
in my room
and
when he left, my dad said
two things.
First:
“Sometimes I envy your mom
not being able to hear”
and
Second:
“If Uncle Bill
is allergic to cats
maybe he won't be able
to visit us anymore.”
Ha ha ha.