House Reckoning (11 page)

“I need to see you,” Tony said.

“Why?” DeMarco asked.

“I know who killed your father.”

14

The last time DeMarco had seen Tony Benedetto, they’d been sitting in Tony’s kitchen and Tony had been checking his blood pressure, bragging about what great shape he was in for a seventy-four-year-old. He wasn’t in such great shape now. He was dying.

He was wearing house slippers and a dark blue jogging suit, the clothing loose on his long frame. He had a big nose and a thin-lipped mouth and was now completely bald —a by-product, DeMarco assumed, of chemo or radiation or whatever medical procedure was being used to keep him alive. DeMarco knew the hair loss had to bother Tony: he’d always been vain about his thick head of hair. He used to have a small paunch, too. Like his hair, the paunch was gone and his face was beginning to take the shape of the skull beneath the skin.

“Lung cancer,” he told DeMarco. They were sitting in Tony’s living room, Tony in a brown La-Z-Boy that faced a television set too big for the room. There was a green oxygen tank next to the recliner and clear plastic tubing fed the gas to his nose. A sour smell permeated the room, a smell DeMarco couldn’t identify; maybe it was the smell of a man decaying right before his eyes.

“It seems like everybody I know died from cancer,” Tony said. “My wife, Carmine, Enzo Marciano. Carmine, it was his lungs, too. Enzo got skin cancer, which seems weird for a guy who lived like a vampire.”

“Tell me what you know about my father,” DeMarco said. He wasn’t in the mood for a stroll down memory lane, nor was he in the mood for commiserating with Tony about his illness.

Mahoney had been pissed yesterday when DeMarco had told him he was flying to New York the following morning. Mahoney wanted him to pursue the veterans’ scam not only because he genuinely cared about the issue but because it would generate favorable headlines, something that could matter in terms of him continuing to get reelected from his district. As a congressman with a two-year term, Mahoney was always running for reelection. So when DeMarco said it was a family thing and he had to go, Mahoney had said, “Well, can’t it wait a couple of days?” A normal person would have asked: What’s the problem? Can I do anything to help? Not Mahoney. He was too self-centered to care about any problems other than his own.

“No,” DeMarco had said. As he was closing the door to Mahoney’s office, he heard Mahoney yell, “Hey!” Whatever he had said after that was muffled by the door, and DeMarco knew he was going to get a severe ass chewing the next time he saw his boss.

“The man who killed your father is a guy named Brian Quinn,” Tony said, pausing every couple of words to get air into his lungs. It was painful watching him talk. “Carmine was the guy who ordered the hit.”

“What?” DeMarco said.

“Yeah. And Quinn was a cop at the time. In fact, I guess you could say he still is.”

While DeMarco was still trying to get his head around the fact that his father’s boss was the one who had him killed, Tony proceeded to tell DeMarco the whole story. He told him about Jerry Kennedy and why Kennedy had to be killed and how Carmine forced Quinn to kill him. He also told DeMarco how Carmine got his hooks into Quinn in the first place—about a woman seeing Quinn shoot an unarmed man and how the NYPD had covered up the shooting. Lastly, he told him how Carmine had set up Gino DeMarco so Quinn could ambush him.

It took Tony almost an hour to tell the story because DeMarco kept interrupting to make sure he understood all the details. By the time Tony finished, the old man could barely keep his eyes open, exhausted by the effort of speaking for so long.

As Tony sat there with his eyes shut, struggling to get air into his ravaged lungs, DeMarco was remembering his father’s funeral and how Carmine Taliaferro had lied to him. “I swear on the heads of my wife and daughter,” Carmine had said when DeMarco asked him if he knew who’d killed his father. He also remembered that Tony had been standing right next to Carmine that day.

“How long have you known about this?” DeMarco asked.

Benedetto opened his eyes. “I don’t know, exactly. All the stuff about Quinn sort of came out, bit by bit, over the years. Some I learned from Enzo, some from Carmine. But I didn’t learn about Carmine setting up your dad to be killed until just before Carmine died. At the end, when Carmine was in worse shape than I’m in now, he was taking lots of drugs for the pain, and I’m not even sure he knew what he was saying half the time.”

Carmine Taliaferro had died eight years ago at the age of eighty-two—which meant that Tony had known about Gino DeMarco’s killer all that time. DeMarco felt like ripping the oxygen tubes out of Tony’s big nose and watching him slowly suffocate.

“So why’d you decide to tell me now?” DeMarco asked.

“Aw, you know. It’s time to make things right before I—”

“Do you know anything else Quinn did for Taliaferro?” DeMarco asked, interrupting Tony. It didn’t really matter why Tony had suddenly grown a conscience, but DeMarco was wondering if there was any way to prove that Quinn had been in collusion with Carmine on other matters. He knew it was pretty unlikely that he’d be able to prove that Quinn had killed his dad.

“No, nothing for sure,” Tony said. “All I know is, after Jerry Kennedy and your dad were killed, Carmine never had a major problem with the law and he made millions, mostly off dope, and he didn’t share much with anybody else. I just remember we were sitting in a bar one day and Quinn was on the TV, and Carmine laughed and said, ‘I own that mick prick.’”

“What did he mean?” DeMarco asked.

“I don’t know what he meant. I just know what he said.”

“And why was Quinn on television?”

“He’s on all the time. I thought you’d know who he was as soon as I said his name. Brian Quinn is the commissioner of the NYPD.”

“You gotta be shittin’ me!” DeMarco said. It had never occurred to him that Tony meant
that
Brian Quinn. It was bad enough to learn that his father’s killer was a cop but now he knew he wasn’t just any cop: he was the most powerful cop in New York.

“Do you have any idea if Carmine was bribing Quinn?” DeMarco asked. He was thinking that maybe some of Carmine’s money could be traced to Quinn.

“Maybe, but I doubt it,” Tony said. “Based on what he said about how he owned the guy, it sounded like he was probably blackmailing him or something. But I don’t know for sure. I do know that Carmine didn’t pay people unless he had to.” Before DeMarco could respond, Tony laughed and said, “All the money Carmine had, he still lived in that same little house in Queens just a couple blocks from your mom’s place and I don’t think he bought a new piece of furniture after his wife died. He had a nice place down in Florida, a condo he went to in the winter, but the house in Queens . . . I guess he just didn’t see the point in moving. His daughter ended up with all his money. She and her husband own a bunch a businesses—legit ones, as far as I know—and she’s a big-shot politician now.”

DeMarco didn’t care about Taliaferro’s daughter, but if she was big in politics it must be something local because he’d never heard of her.

DeMarco sat for a moment just listening to the sound of Tony breathing, and wondered what he should do next. Only one thing occurred to him. “The woman who saw Quinn shoot that guy in the alley, the paint store guy, is she still alive?” DeMarco asked.

“As far as I know,” Tony said. “But if you’re thinking you can get her to testify against Quinn, you’re dreaming. I mean, that happened almost twenty years ago. Who’s going to believe her coming forward now and especially when you look at all the things Quinn’s done since then?”

“What’s the woman’s name?” DeMarco asked.

“All I remember is Janet something. You’d have to ask Sal Anselmo. I know he’s still alive. He’s just a little older than you. He’s straight now, sells cars out on the island.”

DeMarco rose to leave. He started to tell Tony that if he wasn’t a frail old man, he’d beat the shit out of him, then figured: Why bother? He turned and headed for the door, but before he reached it, Tony said, “Kid, the only way you’re going to be able to make things right is if you become who your dad was. What I mean is, you’re not going to get Quinn by going after him with some bullshit legal thing. You’re going to have to kill him. You think you got the stones for that?”

DeMarco didn’t answer. He didn’t know the answer.

15

After DeMarco left, Tony wondered if he’d done the right thing telling DeMarco that Quinn had killed his father. Maybe he shouldn’t have, but if somebody had killed
his
old man, he’d want to know.

He could tell DeMarco was pissed because he hadn’t told him years ago, right after Carmine died, but at that time there was no way he was going to put himself in a position where some lawyer could subpoena him to testify against Quinn. Now he didn’t care about a subpoena; he’d be dead before they could drag him into a courtroom.

The other thing was, he’d never liked Quinn—Quinn was a prick—and he had liked Gino DeMarco, although he hadn’t really known him all that well. Gino never had much to do with the rest of the guys on Carmine’s crew; he didn’t drink with them or go with them down to AC to play craps or on those fishing trips they used to take to the Bahamas. If you didn’t know he was Carmine’s button man, you’d think he was a civilian, like a guy punching the clock at a factory. But Tony had respected Gino, and if his kid could cause Quinn problems, that would be sweet. It was a shame that he probably wouldn’t be around to see what happened. The thing was, he didn’t think Joe DeMarco would be able to do anything about Quinn unless he whacked the guy and he doubted, like he’d said to Joe before he left, that he had the stones to do that. But then you never know.

The phone rang but Tony didn’t reach for it immediately. Talking to DeMarco had just worn his ass out; it felt like he had gone ten rounds with fuckin’ Tyson. If the phone had been across the room he wouldn’t have bothered, but since it was right next to his chair and kept ringing, he reached out slowly and picked it up. He hoped it wasn’t DeMarco calling to ask more questions.

“Yeah,” he said.

“Pop, it’s me. It’s Anthony. I’m in a lot of trouble, Pop.”

Aw, jeez. That’s the last thing he needed right now.

Anthony Benedetto Jr. had always been a loser. Tony didn’t know what he and his wife had done wrong, but Junior just didn’t seem to have anything going for him. He wasn’t very bright, and he did awful in school. He didn’t have the size or the athletic ability to play sports. Tony had known teenage girls tougher than his son.

He’d tried his best to steer the kid into a straight job, but Junior couldn’t to do anything right. For a while, Tony had let him manage an apartment building he had in Woodside—all Junior had to do was collect the rents and call the maintenance guy when something broke—but then Tony had to fire him after he stole all the rent money one month and spent it on dope.

Junior was a junkie, and had been one since he was fourteen—and he was forty-two now. He was addicted to booze and pills and anything he could snort or smoke, but especially cocaine. Tony had stuck him in treatment places three times but they didn’t do any good, and after his wife died, Tony just gave up on him.

“So what’s the goddamn problem this time?” Tony said.

16

DeMarco’s head was spinning, his mind flooded with thoughts of his father, with things he hadn’t thought about in almost twenty years.

As much as he’d loved his father, he had never made any attempt to track down his killer and avenge his death. Partly this was because at the time his father died, he was young and didn’t have either the skills or the connections to do something like that. But there was also another reason. Over time, he had come to accept what the newspapers had said: that Gino DeMarco had been Carmine Taliaferro’s enforcer.

Joe had called Detective Lynch one time—the detective who had informed him and his mother about his father’s death—and asked Lynch who was feeding the papers this crap that his father was a hit man. Lynch, who he found out worked in Organized Crime, not Homicide, had said that even though he was never able to obtain the evidence needed for a conviction, he knew—he was positive
—
based on logic, circumstantial evidence, and hearsay testimony, that Gino DeMarco had been a killer. “The only good thing I can say about your old man,” Lynch had told Joe, “was that as near as we can tell, he only whacked other hoods. But he whacked ’em. There’s no doubt about that.” Joe had called Lynch a liar and slammed down the phone—but in his heart, he knew the man hadn’t been lying.

Joe never forgot one night, when he was about twelve or thirteen. He couldn’t sleep and heard someone down in the basement and discovered it was his dad, wearing just a sleeveless T-shirt, washing his hands in the basement sink. It looked as if he’d cut himself and was washing away the blood from the cut, and lying on the floor was a shirt Joe had given him for Father’s Day splattered with more blood. But Gino didn’t have a cut on his hand.

Joe had said, “What did you do, Dad? Are you okay?” Gino whipped around, surprised to see him there, and said, “Go back to bed, Joe. Right now.” That’s all he’d said but he looked ashamed—like Joe had caught him doing something wrong. He’d never seen a look like that on his father’s face before. For days afterward, his father barely spoke to him and his mother, and Joe never saw the shirt again although he knew it had been one of his dad’s favorites and his mom could have washed out the blood.