More Than a Fling [Uniformed and Blazing Hot 3] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting) (15 page)

They positioned her on the floor so that she was straddling Tanner’s waist. She felt the bulbous head of his sheathed cock brush the super sensitive flesh of her sodden folds and whimpered into Nick’s mouth as she attempted to lower her hips and draw Tanner’s cock inside her. Tanner’s continued hold on her waist prevented the movement.

“I’m going to play with your sexy ass tonight,” Nick said against her lips as he broke the kiss. “I’m not going to fuck you there. Not yet. I’m just going to play, okay?”

Everything in Alyssa’s very being screamed for her to tell him no, it wasn’t okay. Fear sent icy darts shooting through her veins. The muscles in her ass clenched tight as if it refused to grant him any sort of entrance. Neither of those surprised her. However, the rush of juices she felt leak from between her pussy lips and the naughty anticipation that fluttered through her shocked her to her toes. So did the word that left her mouth.

“Okay.”

Nick held her gaze as he laced his fingers in her hair and gently massaged the back of her head. “I’m going to do it while Tanner is fucking you. I want you to get an idea of what it will feel like to have both of your tight holes pleasured by us at the same time.”

Alyssa swallowed hard. Realizing she couldn’t find her voice around the mix of trepidation and anticipation clogging her throat, she nodded.

“You can stop me at any time. All you have to do is say the word. I don’t want to hurt you, sweetheart. I want to make you feel good.”

But it would hurt. She already knew it would. Still, as she gazed at Nick and saw the desires swirling in the depths of his eyes, she couldn’t bring herself to tell him so. She would let him try. She had to at least give him that.

Tanner’s grip tightened on her hips as he picked that moment to pull her body down. His massive cock pushed inside her pussy, stretching her and invading her until it was buried inside her to the hilt.

A moan escaped her lips and her eyes widened as pleasure zinged off every erogenous zone in her body.

Nick smiled. “Ride him, sweetheart. Let’s see how long he can hold out when your sexy body is bouncing on his dick.”

“You are so fucking wrong for that,” Tanner said through clenched teeth.

Alyssa giggled and turned to look down at Tanner as Nick’s fingers slid from her hair. Nick’s hand flattened on her back and he gently pushed her forward. She caught the weight of her upper body with her hands on either side of Tanner’s head.

“And you said I was devious,” she said as she smiled down at him. “It sounds to me like he’s the one with the devilish streak.”

“He’s an asshat that seems to have forgotten he didn’t last any longer than I did last night when he got inside you.”

Alyssa attempted to lift her body off of Tanner’s cock, but his hold still hadn’t let up on her hips. “You’re going to have to loosen those hands.”

“Uh-uh, not yet, baby.”

He might be holding her tightly, but that didn’t mean she couldn’t move. Alyssa stared at him as she flexed the inner muscles of her pussy around his shaft. His eyes glazed over and his body shook with the sound he made. She bit her lower lip to keep from laughing. Then she forgot all about laughing when he lifted his hips to meet her body, driving his cock even more deeply inside her.

“Holy shit! Yesss!” She drew out the
s
like a snake as the pleasure of the thrust rocketed through her. “Do it again.”

His chuckle sounded strained as he finally loosened his hold on her hips. “You do it this time.”

“Mmm, with pleasure.” Alyssa lifted her hips until only the bulbous head of his cock remained inside her pussy and let her body fall down, taking his full length inside her in a single, rapid thrust that had her eyes rolling back in her head as a sound she had never heard herself make before escaped her lips.

“Fuck!” Tanner growled, his chin lifting as he buried the top of his head in the carpet. Every muscle in his handsome face went tight as he squeezed his eyes shut and his hands clamped her hips again.

“Don’t you do it,” Alyssa warned him, biting back a smile.

His eyes flew open. “Do what?”

“Don’t you start thinking about PSI or structure fires or payroll or whatever it is you’re trying to use to take your mind off of me right now.”

His face relaxed, but the expression that claimed his face was so serious it took her breath away. “Baby, it doesn’t matter what I try to use to take my mind off of you. Nothing has worked since the first day I saw you.”

Oh, fuck.

Alyssa held his gaze, unable to believe what he had just said. What exactly had he just said? She supposed there were a number of different ways she could interpret that statement. Before she got the chance to settle on one, she felt Nick’s large callused palms close over her ass. Every muscle in her body went rigid.

“Relax,” he told her softly as his palms glided over her sensitive flesh. “Remember, all you have to do is say the word and I’ll stop.”

He hadn’t even started with whatever he planned to do yet and the word was already on the tip of her tongue. She swallowed it, determined to at least give it a try before she let the fear and pain get the better of her.

“You’re scared, aren’t you?”

She was still looking at Tanner and saw the compassion that filled his eyes. She nodded.

“Don’t be. We promise, if you let it feel good, it will.”

She knew better and yet a dark part of her she had never felt before wanted so much to enjoy whatever Nick was about to do.

One of his hands parted the cheeks of her ass as he slipped a finger between them. The finger was cold and greasy and she realized he must have covered it with lubrication. That must have been what he had tossed on the coffee table when he came back into the living room.

She tried her best not to stiffen as the well-lubed digit found the tingling entrance of her anus. The tip of his finger circled the hole in a massaging caress before it slowly dipped inside. Sensations prickled through her. Fear, pain, thrill, and desire collided to create a heady concoction in her system. Her arms shook as the weight of her upper body nearly became too much.

“Lay on top of me if you need to, baby,” Tanner told her softly. “It’s okay.”

She shook her head, wanting to stay as she was. In this position, she could keep looking at him. It helped to stare into his eyes, she realized. Something in their hazel depths made her feel comforted and safe. Not that she thought Nick would go any further than she allowed. Still, the hope and heat and tenderness she saw in Tanner’s gaze as he stared up at her helped her to overcome at least a molecule of the fear.

“Damn, sweetheart, your ass is gorgeous.” Nick eased the finger deeper, wiggling it to spread the gel inside her entrance. “The pleasure and pain will mix if you let it. It will be like nothing you’ve ever felt before.”

It already was. She could feel the nerve-laden tissue of her ass loosening in response to his gentle probing. The pain was bittersweet, a sensation that zinged to her pussy and caused her muscles to tighten around Tanner’s shaft and her clit to throb.

Tanner’s lips unfolded in a slow, pleased grin. “You like it, don’t you, baby?”

Alyssa swallowed hard and had to lick her lips before she could answer him. “I’m working on it.”

Behind her, Nick chuckled softly as he wiggled the digit deeper. “That’s all I ask, sweetheart. Give it a chance.”

The hope and tenderness in his tone left her unable to deny him anything he asked. What were these men doing to her? Last night had felt completely different. They had fucked her. Until she had forced herself to come to terms with what was happening and accept that the desires overtaking her body were okay, she had even felt like a slut. Tonight was different. Something about the way they were being so gentle and sweet was making her feel…

Oh, hell no. She would not allow herself to think about that particular four-letter word.

“Let it feel good, sweetheart,” Nick instructed as he buried his finger deep in her ass.

Alyssa’s breath hitched as the pain and pleasure sent her to the brink of insanity.

He twisted his finger inside her, pulled it free, and slowly worked in another to work the gel deeper. Together, his fingers stretched her anus until she wanted to plead with him to stop, to give her more, to do something to relieve the talons of confusion clawing through her body.

“Oh, God, Nick!” She bowed her head and squeezed her eyes shut. The pleasure blinded her. The pain was a burning craze that shouldn’t feel good, but somehow did.

His fingers stilled. “Do you want me to stop, Alyssa?”

“Yes. No,” she corrected quickly. “Holy fuck, I don’t know.”

He chuckled as his fingers parted deep inside her, separating to stretch her as they circled and eased back only to pump inside her once more. “I need a straight answer, sweetheart.”

The burn spread, her pussy leaking juices she knew had to be sliding down Tanner’s cock. The intensity of it drove her to a crazed state of need. She opened her eyes as her clit begged and her hips jerked at the invasion of Nick’s fingers that started pumping methodically into her rear. The jerk rocked her pussy on Tanner’s cock, sending another mix of confusion racing through her system.

“No,” she heard herself say. “I don’t want you to stop.”

“That’s my girl.”

His
girl
? Alyssa had a nanosecond to wonder if he realized what he had just said. Even more, what had he meant by that? The questions flittered from her mind as he pulled the fingers free of her ass. She nearly whimpered but didn’t get the chance as more coolness added to the inferno he built in her ass. He worked it into her, the grease making a squishing sound as he fingered her deeper and faster.

“I’ve got two fingers in your tight little rear now. God, I wish it was my dick instead. We’ll work at this as long as we have to until you feel comfortable with it, but I want to fuck you here, Alyssa. You’re going to have to let me do it one day, sweetheart.”

She wanted him to now. If she could’ve found her breath and voice around the sexual calamity he had created her in body, she probably would have told him so. She couldn’t believe the dark need that was unfolding in her very soul to feel his cock buried as deeply inside her as his fingers were right now.

“Please.” It was the only thing she managed to say as her hips rocked back, pushing on his fingers and drawing them even further inside her ass. Movement being what it was, her hips thrust forward on the rebound and ground her pussy on Tanner’s cock.

Fiery sensations tore through her, compelling her to repeat the move. She rocked back on Nick’s fingers, thrust forward on Tanner’s cock, and felt the pressure build in her womb.

“That’s it, baby,” Tanner said through clenched teeth. “Fuck me.”

He helped her out, lifting his hips off the floor to meet her thrust for thrust as Nick pounded his fingers in her ass.

Alyssa lost it. In a blinding rush of pleasure and sheer astonishment, every muscle in her body tensed as the fiercest orgasm she had ever experienced claimed her very soul. Seconds later, Tanner’s eyes slammed shut as his body went rigid beneath her and he growled his own release.

Alyssa finally let herself collapse on top of him, only to find herself lifted off his cock a nanosecond later, flipped in the air, and gently placed onto her back beside him. She opened her eyes as Nick settled himself between her legs and folded his body over hers.

“I know you’re not ready for what I really want, but you have to give your pussy now, sweetheart.”

The sheer anguish in his eyes and voice tore at her heart. She wound her arms around his neck and pulled his head down until their lips were but a breath apart. “Fuck me, Nick. I need to feel you inside me now, too.”

His gaze locked with hers, he angled his hips, thrust inside her, and sent her climbing the orgasmic mountain for the second time tonight.

* * * *

“Listen up, everyone.”

The firefighters and paramedics of A-shift paused in their act of shoveling the morning’s breakfast onto their plates as Nick and Tanner followed Captain Stacy Knox into the common room.

Aiden Reeves, firefighter and Rescue Squad 16’s engineer, was the first to speak as he settled into a seat at the long, rectangular table with his breakfast. “What’s up, Cap?”

Stacy Knox stepped aside and turned slightly. “I’ll let Nick and Tanner be the ones to answer that.”

“Thanks,” Nick muttered.

Knox flashed him a grin. “You’re quite welcome.”

Nick shoved his hands in the front pockets of his uniform pants and rocked back on the heels of his boots as he addressed his fellow firefighters and paramedics. “There’s a reporter with the Cherish Times coming by any minute. She’s wanting to interview all of you for some kind of human interest piece she’s writing for the paper in recognition of the upcoming centennial anniversary of the fire service.”

A few of the firefighters grumbled as everyone went back to fixing their plates.

Nick had known talking with a reporter wouldn’t sit well with some of them. Nosy reporters that pushed their way in where they didn’t belong at fire scenes gave the whole profession in general a bad name with a lot of rescue responders.