My Two Men (Polyamory, Erotic MMF Threesome)

My Two Men

Lilah
Wynter

Copyright 2013
Lilah Wynter

All rights reserved.

My Two Men

Book design by
Lilah Wynter

Cover Image Copyright 2013, Katie
Tegtmeyer,

used
under a Creative Commons Attribution License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0

I paced back and forth, from the kitchen to the dining room, never staying
still for more than a second. The dinner I cooked was already finished, the table set. All that was left to do was wait, and that was the hardest part. My guys would be here soon, and it would change everything about our relationships.

See, I consider myself polyamorous, meaning I can love more than one person at a time. I have two
boyfriends, Dan and Matt, and I am serious about both of them. I have been with Dan for almost two years. We talked about having an open relationship for a while before I actually met someone I liked enough to date. Her name was Katie. We dated for a few months, but it was not working out. We ended it mutually. A week later, I met Matt at a coffee shop. That was two months ago. I was afraid that Dan would be uncomfortable with me dating another man, but he did not mind it as long as I was happy. So far everything has been great – and tonight, they would meet for the first time.

The doorbell rang and I quickly answered it, finding Dan with a big grin on his face.
Good, he seems excited,
I thought.
This should go well.

He followed me past the dining room and into the kitchen.

“What smells so good?”

“I made pasta with vodka sauce, with some garlic bread,” I said.

“Yummy. Garlic wouldn’t be my first sexy food choice…but I’m up for it.”

He started to laugh and I blushed. I had
not even realized I made garlicky food on a night when I anticipated a lot of sex. I figured it would not matter much anyway, since I had a bottle of Sauvignon Blanc already waiting on the table. With wine in our systems, bad breath would not kill the mood.

Dan wrapped his arms around me
from behind and pushed me up against the sink. I let out a loud moan as he traced his tongue from behind my ear down to my neck. I pushed my ass up against him right as the doorbell rang again. I felt his hardness and did not want to pull away, but I had to.

“Damn it,” Dan said.

I giggled. “Don’t worry baby, there’s more of that for later.” I sauntered out of the room and to my front door. Matt was standing outside holding a small bouquet of roses. He was definitely the more romantic of my two boyfriends, in the traditional sense. Both treat me so well – I feel like the luckiest girl in the world.

Matt seemed a little nervous as he walked in.

“Don’t worry, everything’s going to be great,” I said.

We entered the kitchen and I took the roses from Matt’s hands, mouthing my thanks. I found an empty vase and ran some water into it. Then I went back to my two boyfriends and stood between them, feeling like a mediator.

“This is Dan,” I said to Matt. “Dan, this is Matt.”

“Nice to meet you, Matt.”

“Same here.”

They shook hands and I instantly filled with glee.
Neither of them were acting like they felt jealousy or anything else besides happiness. I could not believe this day had finally arrived and they could get to know each other. A thousand dirty thoughts about the two raced through my head, but I told myself to save it for after dinner.

We all sat down at the dining
room table and began to eat. I had placed the roses in the center of the table, next to an open bottle of wine and three glasses. I broke the ice between the guys by telling them they did not need to feel weird. They seemed to already be comfortable around each other. Matt was noticeably less nervous.
Things might work out perfectly!
I thought.

Both of them loved the meal I made. We must have spent over an hour at the table, slowing eating, chatting and drinking lots of wine. We finished the bottle and started on another.
The conversation was not awkward at all. It felt wonderful to see them getting along so well, talking about everything from sports to books to weird quirks they had noticed about me. I laughed and called them both mean for talking about me like that. When all of us were noticeably tipsy, I decided to end the dinner portion of the evening. I did not bother to clean the dishes, since it would mean taking precious time away from my guys. I decided I would save that for the next morning. I beckoned them to follow me into the living room.

I sat down on the couch in between them. Matt seemed to get a bit nervous again. Dan noticed it and began kissing me, starting with where we had left off in the kitchen: my neck. He reached out and grabbed Matt’s shirt, pulling him closer to me, as a way to let him know to get in on the action. Matt loosened up
and started kissing me as well, our lips meeting as Dan continued to work on my neck. It felt heavenly. I am a huge fan of kissing, but never had two people kiss me at once. I was not sure if I would ever be able to go back to just one.

Dan grabbed the hem of my blouse and pulled it up over me. I went braless specifically for this moment and it paid off. Dan kissed down my back, with Matt now working on my breasts.
I could not handle just kissing any longer – I needed them both.

“Get up,” I said. They both obeyed and I pulled my skirt off, throwing it onto the floor. I had not worn panties, either, and they both seemed appreciative of it. I
laid down on the couch, nude and a little chilly. It would not be so bad, since I knew in a matter of minutes they would both keep me warm. Matt moved my coffee table a couple of inches out of the way and both kneeled down in front of the couch. This time, Dan went for my breasts, alternating between soft kisses and bites. Matt positioned himself so he could easily get his head between my legs. He inserted two fingers inside me, which let me realize just how wet I was. This was far better than anything I had ever done before. Why did I take so long to do it?

He gently moved his fingers in and out of me, going a little faster each time I moaned. Dan was continuing to explore me, licking my body anywhere from my neck to my hips. Matt’s tongue was on my clit and I knew I would climax soon. There was no way I could put it off with both men pleasuring me exactly how I liked it. They could tell, too, and amped up their behavior accord
ingly. Before I knew it, I felt my muscles contracting and my head felt wonderfully foggy. I came with both of them touching me at the same time. It was the most amazing orgasm I had so far in my life, and I needed a minute to catch my breath. They both continued to sit by me, stroking me lovingly and smiling.

When I felt myself regaining energy, I said, “So, who wants to fuck me?” They looked at each
other, each hoping the other would bow out.

I could tell that Dan wanted Matt to feel welcome and comfortable. He told
Matt to go right ahead. He did not need to be given permission twice, and immediately started removing his shirt, pants and boxers. Dan followed and took his clothes off, too. I was so delighted to be in the same room as two sexy naked guys that I loved. Matt maneuvered himself onto the couch so we could both be comfortable. I felt his cock enter me, and still reeling from the orgasm, I closed my eyes and enjoyed the sensation. That is when I felt Dan’s cock near my face and I snapped out of it. I took as much of him into my mouth as I could. I could not give him as fantastic of a blowjob as I normally would, with Matt on top of me, but I managed to wrap one of my hands around his cock as he started to fuck my mouth. This was exactly what I had dreamed would happen when I decided to have my boyfriends meet.

My ultimate dream was coming true. Matt was already incredible at sex, but it felt twice as amazing – everyone was turned on by the situation, amplifying all sensations.
We all fell into a rhythm. As Matt pulled out of me, Dan pushed himself into my mouth. I could hear myself moaning as loudly as I could with a cock muffling most of the sound.

I do not even know how long we continued like this. It felt like hours, but I know there is no way it was that long. I was hoping we could go on like that forever – a silly thought, but in the moment it was all I could wish for.

I knew both of their bodies as well as if I had drawn maps of them, so I could tell when they were nearing orgasm. Matt seemed to be ready to cum first. His moans were getting louder and he was fucking me as hard as he possibly could. I grabbed Dan’s cock out of my mouth for a moment and told him to cum on me. He nodded, no objections there. Matt and I locked eyes and he seemed to be wondering if the same was true for him as well.

“No, you cum inside of me,” I said.

“Anything you want.”

I smiled, then
went back to sucking Dan’s cock, knowing Matt would be erupting inside of me any second. It made me only work harder at making Dan cum. Matt started to moan even louder and I knew he was about to have an orgasm. A few seconds after Matt came, Dan was cumming on my breasts. I was delighted to have them both with me like this, and even happier to know they both came nearly at the same time.

We stayed in the same positions for a few seconds, before Matt pulled out of me and leaned back against the couch.
I moved my legs to accommodate him and let out a deep sigh, exhausted but still wanting more. Dan moved the rest of me over a bit so he could sit down, too. I looked down at my chest, dipped a finger into Dan’s cum, and brought it back up to my mouth to taste.
Delicious.

I heard him grunt at the sight. Matt was much quieter, still calming down from his orgasm.
Beads of sweat dripped off of him and glistened.

Dan leaned over to gently kiss my lips. Matt followed his lead and kissed me, too – both of them were on part of my lips at the same time. I could feel both their lips slightly touching each other
’s – there was really no way to avoid it – and I felt my face blushing from giddiness and joy. They pulled away from me and we all got comfortable on the couch, laying against each other and catching our breath.

It was the most erotic, fulfilling night of my life – so far. There is no way I am letting either of these guys go, and I think they feel the exact same way. They both told me that it was incredible for them, too. I have a feeling they might be interested in experimenting with each other after that kiss. Next time, they might
actually
kiss each other. Now that was not something I really ever imagined could happen, but I am very excited for it.