Penance (Long Slow Tease, #2) (2 page)

“Thank you, James.”

“My pleasure, Mistress.” He knelt before Yuki and she gave him a soft kiss on his cheek.

Wyatt’s erection had faded when James put the blindfold on so Michelle nudged Wyatt’s legs further apart, making him widen his stance. He flinched when her stocking-clad foot rubbed against his balls, then groaned when she ran her big toe over the three connected gold rings encircling his organ, his balls, and a third ring pressed against the base of his pelvis. A constant visible reminder of his devotion to her.

Blood began to rush to his
dick and she heard Yuki's pleased murmur. Jealousy struck her and she had to resist the urge to tell her friend not to look. After all, she’d seen James in much more compromising positions over the years and had enjoyed the visual treat without ever violating Yuki’s strict ‘no touching’ policy. Michelle needed to get into the proper headspace and stop coddling Wyatt.

“Yuki, did you know my sub has never had anything in that tight, delicious ass of his?”

“Wait!” Wyatt shouted. “I don’t want anything in there.”

She gripped a handful of his hair and jerked his head forward, placing her lips by his ear but speaking loud enough for James and Yuki to hear. “You do want to fuck me in my ass, don’t you Wyatt?”

His dick jerked against her foot and she smiled. “Yes, Domina.”

“Well I’m not going to just let you shove that big dick into me. You have to earn it, just like everything else.” He trembled slightly, pulling against her grip. “Wyatt, give me your hand.”

Still holding him, she took his hand and pressed it between her legs, cupping her bare, wet sex with his palm, her breath hitching when he pressed the heel of his palm against her clit. “Can you see how much the idea of you taking a small toy in your ass turns me on? I’m going to make it good for you, Wyatt, so good that you’ll be fighting not to come the second I start to fuck you.”

He groaned, his head rolling back on his shoulders and the thick muscles of his chest contracting. “I will stay as hard as long as you need me, Domina.”

She looked over at Yuki and found her friend attaching nipple clamps to James. “Would you like to race?”

Giggling, Yuki nodded and gave the chain
attached to James’ collar and now dangling between his nipples a hard yank. “I would love to.”

“Wyatt, turn around and get on your hands and knees. Crawl two paces forward.”

Yuki raked her nails down her husband’s chest. “I want you next to him.”

Once the men were in place Michelle dug through her bag and pulled out two metal anal plugs. She gave the larger one to Yuki since James was used to having his ass stretched and kept the smaller one for herself. The plug she wanted to use on Wyatt had a slight curve to it, made to find the prostate and put a constant pressure on it.

Anticipation sizzled through her blood and she got down on the floor, moving behind Wyatt.

“Spread your legs.” He did, just a little bit and she smacked his ass hard enough to leave a red handprint. “Wider.”

Deep growling noises came from him, but he finally complied, giving her enough room to move behind him. Gripping his hips, she pulled him backwards like she was the one with the cock, ready to fuck him. Oh she couldn’t wait to use a strap-on with him, but they had plenty of time for those pleasures. Besides, she didn’t want to rush it.

Laying her head on his back, she reached around and began to stroke his cock
, teasing the gold rings with her fingertips. “You have no idea how much your surrender means to me, Wyatt. Knowing that you’re fighting your nature for my pleasure, knowing that you trust me enough to do something to you that you wouldn’t let anyone else in the world do is an aphrodisiac like no other. I can’t wait to have this big cock inside of me, but first, we need to put something inside of you.”

Next to them, James grunted as Yuki poured lube down the crack of his ass. She handed the small bottle to Michelle. Squiring out a palm full of the slick liquid, she began to work it into the crease of
Wyatt’s delectable ass. As expected, his muscles tightened up and she gave him another slap with her hand covered in liquid.

“E
ither you open up for me or I’ll watch Yuki fuck James and masturbate myself to an orgasm with my hand instead of your body.”

He shivered, his arms shaking and his breath coming out in heavy pants. “No, Domina, I can do this.”

“Darling, this isn’t about enduring, this is about enjoying. I know Western society is all fucked in the head about sexuality, but none more so than about sodomy. It feels good, has been enjoyed by the manliest of men for centuries, and will make you come like you wouldn’t believe. Now open that sweet ass for me. My patience is just about done.”

She waited for him, rubbing her finger up and down the crack of his
buttocks. What a fine ass it was, with tight muscles extending up to his lower back and those delicious indentations on either side. She bit his shoulder, hard, and he groaned, finally opening for her.

As she worked her hand between his cheeks
, she stayed away from the tempting star of his anus and just slicked the lube from the top of his butt down to his dangling balls, cupping them in her hand and gently rolling them. Wyatt groaned for her and she reveled in the sound, loving that she could bring him pleasure like this, that such an Alpha male was hers to play with however she wished because he trusted her.

Oh, this was going to be so much fun.

There was an art to milking a man’s prostate, and it had been far too long since she’d last had this pleasure. Let alone the pure taboo of doing it to such a big, bad animal like Wyatt. The internal battle between the need to please her and his pride demanding he resist made her wish she could hear his thoughts.

Oh wait, she could.

“Wyatt, tell me what you’re thinking, and don’t lie to me. You lie and you get to hear James come three times before I so much as lick the slit of your cock.”

He trembled and she removed her hand from his ass. While she wanted him highly aroused at this point, she didn’t want him in his subspace yet. She needed to make sure his conscious mind heard her. If he didn’t acknowledge that he wanted it, he could later justify that she’d forced him to enjoy it or some other type of macho bullshit that men use
d to distance themselves from their feelings. While those lies may comfort him in the moment, in the long run trying to ignore the fact that he liked unconventional and kinky sex with would only cause problems. She wanted Wyatt to know that he could ask her for anything, everything, and she would do her best to make it happen.

“I want to turn around and grab your thighs, holding you to my mouth, forcing you to endure one orgasm after another. I can’t fucking understand why you’d rather have my ass than my mouth, my cock, my
fingers.”

Stalling to buy herself some time to stop her hands from shaking, Michelle put on a pair of black latex gloves. Thin enough that she could feel him but thick enough to protect his ass from being damaged. He’d be as tight as a virgin, because in this aspect he was. Being his Mistress meant that every day she had to seduce his willing submission from him. There would always be battles between them, Wyatt’s will was too strong for her to entirely contain, but oh
, how she loved the fact that he hadn’t broken his form during his tirade, only his stiff muscles betraying his tension.

A soft, feminine sigh came from Michelle’s left and she looked over, watching as Yuki sat on James’ face and enjoyed his talented tongue. Wyatt immediately turned towards the sound and his dick jumped. Michelle had to stifle a giggle as
, a second later, his cheeks flushed and he resumed his position. Yuki was rather vocal with her pleasure, and dirty, so poor Wyatt would have a doubly hard time resisting the urge to come. Just to make it even more of a sensual torture session for him, she reached between his heavily muscled thighs with their light dusting of hair and fondled his smooth, shaved balls.

Wyatt let loose
with a litany of angry, hungry curses as she loosened the cock ring. If she milked him right he’d have precum pouring out of him and making a mess. Michelle grabbed the cashmere throw on the couch and had Wyatt lift his knees so she could put it beneath him. Once she was sure of his comfort, she poured more lube over her latex clad fingers. Lube was the number one thing to keep in mind while doing anything with a man’s ass so there could never really be too much.

“Relax, darling. I promise I will bring you nothing but pleasure if you can trust me enough to give your body to me.”

Relaxation flowed through him like water running over smooth stones. “I trust you, Domina.”

Her heart ached with love
, and she allowed herself one small kiss on the base of his spine. She was getting better at expressing her affection, but it was still hard. Old memories of her time with Owen were being stirred up in her mind like a child stirring up the bottom of a stagnant pond with a stick. Unpleasant things kept surfacing and she fought to clear her mind of them.

This wasn’t Owen
; this was Wyatt, and they were two very different men who shared the same spirit at the core of who they were.

Seeking to ground herself in the present, she gave in
to the urge to press her finger against his anus. She got just the tip in before he seized up on her, clutching tight. Fuck, she couldn’t wait to take him with a strap-on. When he relaxed she pushed forward again, the increasingly loud cries from Yuki indicating her orgasm was near. Michelle had to bite her lip to keep from laughing. Wait until Wyatt heard the filthy shit that Yuki liked to say when she came.

S
he slowly slid her finger into him and began to gently move, stopping whenever he tensed up. Soon he was pushing back on her and his cock was so hard the veins bulged. And what a big cock it was. She loved to have all of it shoved inside of her until she couldn’t breathe. Her pussy clenched at the thought, and she had to fight her desire to flip him over and ride him to completion. But if she did that, she’d be setting the precedent that she didn’t stick to her word. So she continued to finger fuck his ass, loving his grunts and groans mixing with the soft slurping sound James made as he feasted on Yuki.

They were situated so Yuki could watch Michelle take Wyatt’s ass, and Michelle could see James’ efforts to make his wife come. Right now
, he was lapping at Yuki’s cunt like it was an ice cream cone and Michelle groaned.

“God, Wyatt, you should see how well James is e
ating Yuki out.”

The muscles of Wyatt’s ass clamped around her fingers. “Do I need to brush up on my technique, Domina?”

She slapped his ass. “Open up for me. You do not clench down until I tell you. Master your body, Wyatt. Use that strong will of yours to relax and let me have you.” With a soft sigh she leaned closer so she could whisper into his ear, “Wyatt, if you got any better at eating my pussy I don’t think I could survive it. You almost kill me with how damn good you can make me come with that clever mouth of yours. There is no one in the world that makes me feel the way you do. No one.”

The clench of his inner muscles eased and she squirted more lube onto her hand before she began to work a second finger into him. With gentle, rubbing strokes she located his prostate. It was small, about the size of a quail egg, and had to be handled gently. At least at first. While pressing on it she reached around and began to jack him off, his hot length sliding through her slick fist. His groan became a grunt as she massaged his prostate.
Three strokes later, a long stream of pre-cum dripped from his cock and he shuddered.

Yuki must have liked what she saw because she had James’ hair held in her fist as she lifted his head off the ground and shoved her pussy onto his mouth. “That’s it, my good slut, suck my clit. Oh, I’m going to fucking come. Don’t you dare stop eating me until I’m done.”

Arousal filled every inch of Michelle’s body until she felt almost faint. She laid her cheek on Wyatt’s back and continued to ream him, milking him until a small puddle of pre-cum stained the cashmere throw. She’d have to make sure to set it aside because she wanted to have this memory held in it forever. He thrust into her fist with each stroke and she released him with a last reluctant caress against his throbbing length.

“Wyatt, I need you to lift your knees one at a time for me.”

She tugged the blanket out and carefully folded it so the mess he’d made was on the inside. Some guys freaked out when they saw how much came out of their bodies during a prostate milking and she needed Wyatt deep in the zone for what she wanted next. As she stripped off the gloves she looked over at Yuki, who gave her a lazy smile and nodded.

“Wyatt, James, Yuki and I have a proposal for you.”
She caressed Wyatt’s ass, hoping the next part would intrigue him enough to keep his embarrassment at bay. “You may remove your blindfold.”

Yuki
ground her pussy against James’ mouth with a low purr while Michelle watched, then released him and moved off so he could go sit on the couch. James was a bit longer than Wyatt, but Wyatt’s dick was thicker.  Both were good looking men, but in very different ways. It made watching them together all the more enjoyable for Michelle.

When Wyatt
’s blindfold was removed Michelle gripped him by his hair and lifted his face so she could see his eyes. “I want you to go sit on the couch next to James.”