Rattled (11 page)

“But he couldn’t have! Not unless someone has been here.”

“I know.” His arms tightened around her. “I believe you.”

She let herself lean against him and felt her heart slow. Finally she said, “But the police wouldn’t.” She hadn’t had much contact with the police before. She didn’t know how busy they would be in a town this size or how they prioritized their calls. But on a Friday night they’d have drunk drivers, accidents, fights. A hysterical woman with no evidence of a break-in except a large orange cat probably wouldn’t make the top of their list. And what if they went in and found everything normal? She’d be like the boy who cried wolf and they might not take her seriously when she really needed them.

Drew waited, gently stroking her back. Erin smiled a little. She recognized that a man could easily resent a woman holding him back when he wanted to play the hero. Drew didn’t brush her off or get huffy and storm away because she’d insulted his manhood according to some mysterious man-logic. He was waiting for her to come to terms with the situation. She had to admit he was right about the police. But she didn’t want him hurt.

Tiger wove around their ankles, purring. Would he be more anxious if someone were still there? No sound came from the house. Any thief should have heard them drive up, maybe heard their voices. They’d had plenty of time to sneak out the back by now.

Erin took a deep breath and straightened. “All right, we’ll go in. Together.” She wondered if he’d refuse. She met his gaze, determined not to back down. No way was she going to sit in the truck worrying while he searched the house.

His lips parted in a slow smile. He rubbed a thumb over her cheek. “You’re one hell of a woman.” He gave her a quick, hard kiss and turned toward the door.

Erin almost staggered backward off the steps. She pressed a hand to her heart, glad his back was turned, and fished her key out of her pocket.

Erin unlocked the door. Drew held up a hand to keep her back as he opened the door a few inches and listened. Erin let him go through first, to make up for challenging him before. And, if she had to admit it, she much preferred to hang back. She thought she’d been tough enough for one evening.

Drew stepped through the door quickly. He flicked on a light and glanced into the living room and her office before darting back to the kitchen. He returned moments later. “Back door’s locked.” He headed up the stairs.

Erin hesitated. Perhaps she should follow him, be there in case—well, she had no idea what she would do if he actually found someone. Scream and run, probably, and she could do that from downstairs. In fact, the best thing might be to retrieve her phone and have it ready in case she needed to call for help. She’d left her phone on the desk in her office, which was where she really wanted to go anyway.

She grabbed her phone and leaned over her desk to see the bottom corner of the bookshelf. The book lay right where she’d left it. She sighed with relief and hurried out of the office as she heard footsteps coming down the stairs.

“Upstairs is clear. Nice bedroom, by the way.” He studied her. “You look happy now.”

Erin tried to pull her smile down a notch. “Relief, I guess. No one’s here, nothing’s been trashed or taken. That makes it a good night by recent standards.”

Drew kept studying her. “There is a window open in the living room.”

“What!” Erin rushed into the living room. The side window was open a foot. The screen had been popped out at one corner. She shook her head. “I checked all these windows before I left. And I never open it halfway like that. An inch to help ventilation if the swamp cooler is on or all the way if it’s nice out and I want the breeze.” She couldn’t look at Drew. She knew she was right, but she still felt like a fool.

He walked to the window and poked at the loose corner of the screen. “I doubt that big cat could have gotten out this way without doing more damage, at least popping out the other corner of the screen.” He grabbed a lamp from a nearby end table, switched it on, and held it close to the window. “No orange hairs on the screen or the outside of the window sill. One on the inside of the sill, but that’s the least to be expected with a cat like that in the house.”

“He prefers to sit in the front window to watch the world go by. And he’s only been here for a couple of days. He’s Camie’s cat.”

“Oh?” Drew turned and looked down at Tiger, who gave a curious meow. “You’re cat sitting?”

“Camie left him for my protection. She says he’s a guard cat.”

“Is that right?” Drew bent down and scooped Tiger into his arms. He leaned the big cat against his shoulder and scratched behind his ears. “Yep, pretty ferocious, aren’t you?”

“Hey, you’d be surprised.” She decided not to explain about the earlier attack. What kind of woman suffered two break-ins and two violent attacks in less than a week? She wasn’t sure what impression it gave, but it definitely wasn’t one that fit her normal life. “There could be a crook fleeing right now with scratch marks all over him.”

“I’ll keep an eye out for some guy with shredded skin.” Drew headed into the kitchen. Erin followed and stood in the doorway as Drew deposited the cat near his food dish and opened the back door. He crouched and examined the lock for maybe 15 seconds. “Yep, it’s official. I know absolutely nothing about lock picking.”

Erin laughed. “You fooled me for a minute there.”

“I read a lot of mystery novels. I see scratches around the lock, but damned if I can tell how long they’ve been there or if they mean anything.” He closed the door and locked it. “It’s possible someone broke in and let the cat out by accident.”

Or on purpose, Erin thought, if that person happened to know just how violent Tiger could be.

“He might have opened the window and popped the screen to try to fool you into thinking the cat had gotten out on his own,” Drew added. “Maybe he panicked after letting Tiger out and took off, or maybe we came home just in time and scared him away. You might want to make a thorough search to be sure nothing was stolen. But unless you find something missing, I’d say you don’t have anything worth reporting to the police.”

“Yeah, you’re right. And you were right earlier too, so thanks. I’m glad we did it this way.” He was much more sensible than the police had been. All right, the main difference was, he’d believed her completely. She didn’t know if that was sensible, but it was comforting. She didn’t feel scared anymore. She felt safer than she’d felt in days.

For a long moment they gazed at each other across the kitchen. Erin felt a warmth in her belly. The slow, steady beat of her heart seemed to echo in her ears.

“Erin,” Drew said softly, “I wish you would tell me what’s going on.”

She swallowed hard and tried to keep her gaze steady on his. “What do you mean?”

“Average, innocent women do not have their house broken into, probably twice, after being thrown into a ditch by a mysterious hit and run driver. Do you have enemies?”

“No....” Did Mitchell count? A week ago he’d practically been her boyfriend. She didn’t know how to explain everything, or if she should. “I don’t understand why anyone would want to hurt me. It seems unbelievable.” That much was true.

Drew leaned against the counter and folded his arms. “What about the treasure?”

Erin’s heart lurched. She’d never told him about the treasure. Was he one of them after all? She stumbled back on legs that threatened to collapse.

“Erin!” He crossed the kitchen at lightning speed and grabbed her in the entryway. Erin tried to twist out of his grip and opened her mouth to scream. He let go and stepped back, his hands raised in surrender. “Okay, okay, don’t panic. I’m sorry I scared you. Just hang on a minute and let’s talk.”

Tiger stalked in from the kitchen. He planted himself at Erin’s feet and stared at Drew, his tail lashing. She felt oddly safer and took a moment to catch her breath, leaning against the wall until the trembling eased. “How did you find out about the treasure?”

“I overheard you and Mitchell talking.” When she just stared at him, he had the grace to look embarrassed. “Tonight at the bar, I was at the next table, listening in. I wanted to find out what he wanted.” He gave an uncomfortable shrug and looked away. “And at the hospital. I was listening outside the door.”

Erin took a deep breath and tried to straighten, but she wasn’t sure her legs would hold her if she pushed away from the wall. “So you’ve been spying.”

He winced. “Not exactly—yeah, okay. I wasn’t thinking of it like that, but I guess I was. It was rude, and I apologize.”

She stared, trying to figure him out. All she could think was
Why?
What possible reason could he have had, as early as that first meeting in the hospital? Or did he just spy as a matter of habit? Was he some kind of con artist, looking for weaknesses he could use? “Was that your interest in me all along? The treasure?”

“No!” He took a step toward her, but she held up her hand and he stopped. “I was just curious,” he said. “I already had a weird feeling about the whole situation because of seeing that guy come out of the ditch and drive away after your accident. When Mitchell came to the hospital and brushed off my story, I got suspicious.”

Erin considered. He’d been right, the first person to suspect the accident was more than an accident or to feel suspicious of Mitchell. Such insights didn’t make her entirely comfortable. What else had he seen, or suspected under the surface? Did he read her as easily? She pushed the thought away and tried to concentrate on putting together all the pieces. “Do you think Mitchell was the man at the ditch?”

“No,” he said with regret in his voice. “That man was shorter and stockier, with dark hair.”

Erin felt a cold tickle down her spine. The description could fit the man who’d attacked her that morning. “All right. And at the bar tonight?”

Drew shrugged. “Same kind of thing. I wanted to know what Mitchell wanted, why he was so eager to get rid of me. If you’d been happy to see him, I would have left you alone. But you weren’t, were you?”

She shook her head. She could hardly fault him for interfering there, when she’d been so grateful for it at the time.

He gave her a tentative smile. “You were great, by the way.”

Her lips twitched but she forced them straight again. She took another deep breath, feeling steadier, and decided she trusted herself to move. She pushed away from the wall and turned toward the kitchen. “I want some tea.” She tensed as she passed within arm’s reach, but he didn’t move until she was past. Then he followed her into the kitchen and sat at the table.

“You haven’t kicked me out yet,” he said. “I’m considering that a good sign.” Tiger yowled and jumped up into his lap. “And the cat likes me. I’m sure this guy is a very good judge of character.”

Erin turned to the cupboard to hide her smile and got out a box of tea. “I’ll take his opinion under consideration. For now, you’re on probation.”

“Fair enough.”

She filled the kettle with water. “Do you want tea or coffee?”

“Whatever you’re having. Don’t forget your painkiller. How’s the hand?”

She turned and glared. “I’m not taking anything that will knock me out until you’re out of here.” But he’d remembered, and he cared. She felt her anger slipping away. She wished she knew why Camie had thought he wasn’t dangerous. Erin suspected Drew could be very dangerous—she just wasn’t sure whether he was a danger
to her
, or what kind.

She busied herself getting out mugs and tea bags, stealing some time to think. She wanted to trust him. Her heart told her to trust him. But could she trust her heart? She’d believed in Craig for five years and realized later that he’d probably been cheating on her before she even left town. She didn’t have experience with the current craziness in her life, or with men like Drew. She couldn’t afford to make a mistake.

The kettle screamed and she poured hot water over herbal tea bags. She sat across from him and slid his mug over the table. “I have no reason to trust you.” She kept her eyes steady on him. “I don’t know anything about you, except what you’ve told me. I don’t know if any of it is true.”

His brows drew together. Erin held her breath. Would he get angry, defend himself? Play the “I saved your life” card? Storm out? Whatever he said might tell her something about him, if she could only figure it out. She raised her mug to her lips, glad her hand was steady.

His expression cleared. “I know. You can call my mother.”

She almost choked on her tea. “Your mother?”

“Of course. She can vouch for me. Who knows me better?” He fished in his jeans pocket and brought out a phone.

Erin slammed down her mug and held up both hands. “Whoa. Hang on a minute. Do you even know what time it is in Montana?”

“Same as here.” He peered at the phone and winced. “Okay, she may be a bit cranky. I’ll get her calmed down before I put you on.”

“I don’t want to talk to your mother!” Good Lord, what would she say to the woman? Your son is sitting in my kitchen at midnight and I want to know if he’s a violent criminal because he couldn’t possibly be as good as he seems?

“You’ll like her. She won’t be at her best after only a couple of hours sleep, but she’s really nice.”

The boy loved his mother. Well, that was something. And he hadn’t tried to persuade her by bringing up all the things he’d done for her. “Put your phone away.” She took a deep breath. She didn’t have to tell him all her secrets. But given what she’d already told Mitchell, what people around the college seemed to know, a lot of it wasn’t a secret. “Let me tell you about a treasure.”