Signature Kill (19 page)

Every damn one of them looked guilty, each a monster hiding in plain sight. Every one of them capable of horrific acts …

Behr had just stepped back inside from the parking lot, where he’d used his phone to snap pictures of license plates and now surveyed the group that had assembled.

Then again, every person alive was. And these were just people
—
concerned, scared people, dressed in their bland blue and beige and tan clothing, sitting in the stale air of the church basement that smelled of coffee, hoping for some information that might protect them and those they loved, none of them likely responsible for any crime beyond speeding or cheating on their taxes
.

The competing thoughts were pointless, and Behr tried to shake them and turn his attention to the front of the room and the Indy police officer addressing the group.

“There are only so many of us, and there are many, many more of you, which is why we look to you for some help in moments like this,” Sergeant John Odoms said to the group, nearly finished with his remarks. The burly, bald-headed fifteen-year veteran was shift mates with Officer Hawkins, the young patrolman who’d discovered the remains in Northwestway Park. Hawkins had been asked to appear initially, but he’d been on administrative leave since the incident and wasn’t up to talking about it publicly yet.

“We’re here to protect, but that starts with you as individuals and as a community being aware and looking out for suspicious
behavior, men or groups of men lurking in public parks, around bars, around certain types of hotels …” Odoms went on.

The event had been previewed in the
Star
—both the print version and online. Behr had e-mailed Susan, letting her know he planned on asking their friend Neil Ratay, the reporter, to place it.

“Do what you want,” had come her terse reply. “You will anyway.” And so he had. Behr sent along a fairly banal wide shot Quinn had taken of the Donovan-Grant crime scene, which the paper had run, one that featured the police investigating but avoided the gore of the remains. Behr had also put up a temporary website that offered information and a chance to look at more pictures, but one had to register with name and address and obtain a password in order to do so, and the
Star
ran the link. That way if the perpetrator couldn’t be drawn out in person but couldn’t help taking a look, there would be some cyber trace of him, even if he used a fake address.

As for his friend, Behr hadn’t let on to Ratay the true motivation behind the meeting, and whether the reporter had guessed it or not, all he had said was “I’m sure the paper will be happy to get behind a concerned citizen such as yourself.” Ratay had also given Behr the name of the volunteer in the church office who oversaw the space, which was also where Ratay attended his AA meetings.

Then, when it was time, Behr went ahead and dug into his own pocket and paid for a few large boxes of coffee and six dozen doughnuts. Until a half hour ago he’d had no idea whether he had nearly enough or would be tossing the bulk of it in the trash. More important, he had taken a pair of pan-tilt-zoom wide-angle surveillance cameras he owned, and borrowed two more, and wired the place. He’d rigged one over the spread of food, another at the door, and one near the photo display, with the fourth set to capture the audience while seated. The digital images would download directly to his laptop.

Behr had arrived early that afternoon, made the preparations, and braced himself for the humiliation of a poor turnout. Quinn
showed up a while later and displayed more than a dozen of his photos printed at sixteen by twenty inches. They used a room divider to block off the exhibit from the main seating area, because unlike the one in the
Star
, these shots included graphic images of the victims.

Mistretta got there a bit later, looking too good in a black dress and short leather coat, a laptop case slung over her shoulder. Behr introduced her to Quinn and they’d made small talk until people started to show up. Behr had begun clicking a handheld counter as the attendees entered, and saw the numbers had stopped at seventy-eight. Thirty-five women, twenty-seven men, young adult to middle-aged. The rest were teenagers and the elderly.

Should I be looking for the strong ones, the smart ones, the sick ones?
He didn’t know.

Sergeant Odoms had rolled in with only moments to spare before the announced start time, just when Behr thought
he
might need to get up and do the talking. Big and serious in his dark uniform, Odoms didn’t seem eager to be a part of the thing.

“Thanks for coming out,” Behr said, introducing himself and shaking his hand.

“Anything for Lieutenant Breslau,” Odoms said, an unnecessary reminder of how much a law enforcement career was built upon contract and favor bartering. Behr couldn’t help but remember how poor a job he’d done of that when he’d been on the force.

“You have any questions about the type of remarks?” Behr asked, trying to be helpful. It hardly mattered what Odoms said, Behr just needed something to draw them in with and keep them stationary for long enough to get their plates and picture and for Mistretta to eyeball their behavior for telltale signs.

“I think I’ve got it, pal,” Odoms said. “I’ve done this plenty. Usually at nursing homes and schools.”

“Good,” Behr said.

“I’ll talk about the crimes for ten minutes, rattle some stats, then take questions. I’ll finish with precautions and send them to the photos.”

And that’s just what Odoms had done.

“Do the police have any leads?” asked a man in the front row with the affect of a high school football coach.

“None that we can share with the public right now,” Odoms responded.

“What are you doing to catch the perpetrator?” a middle-aged woman asked.

“We’re devoting tremendous departmental resources to this, believe me,” Odoms said.

“Oh, well that’s a comfort,” a man in a Craftsman work jacket said. “Talk about incompetent!” There was a murmur of agreement in the crowd.

“All right, folks, that’s not what this is about.” Odoms scowled. “Tell it to your councilman.”

“How many more women have to die before you’re gonna do something about it?” a middle-aged woman with glasses called out. This sentiment got even more support.

Odoms’s face set in a mask of tightly controlled disgust, and his eyes, hot with anger, found Behr where he stood.

Half a dozen more questions and comments, variations of the first, followed before Odoms said with finality:

“Anyone else? No? Good.”

There was a mass scraping of chairs and shuffling of feet toward the photo display. Some attendees left straightaway, but most stayed and started viewing the pictures. Sergeant Odoms was among the first to go. Behr tried to catch him on the way, calling out, “Thanks and I’m sorry, John.”

“Yeah, that’s fucking great, Behr,” Odoms said over his shoulder and disappeared out the door.

Behr, along with Mistretta, had
wanted
to shock people with the display, and specifically determine who
wasn’t
shocked. Now he watched, as most of them grew wide-eyed and pale from what they were seeing. There were murmurs of “Oh my,” and “my God,” and many less polite exclamations.

Behr drifted over and joined Quinn, who was just breaking off a conversation with a Goth-looking college-age girl with spiky blond hair as he leaned against a room divider and watched people react to his photos.

“So, yeah, I like to close off a stop, to get some more contrast from time to time. And I’ll use a tripod for wides because the department requests it, but I prefer to hold the camera, to make it an extension of myself,” he said.

“Well, cool, thanks,” the girl said and moved for the door.

“Closest I’m gonna get to a gallery show, or a fan, in my line of work,” Quinn said, turning to Behr, betraying perhaps a trace of bitterness.

“Glad you’re enjoying yourself,” Behr said.

“Watching people shit themselves? Definitely.”

Behr cut across the room toward Mistretta, where she was set up in a corner watching the crowd and currently engaged in conversation with a man with thinning hair in his early forties and dressed in an inexpensive gray business suit.

“… dangerous times for women in this city,” Behr heard the man say. “I live in Broad Ripple too, so if you ever need a ride home, or company when you’re out, look me up.” Then he handed Mistretta his card. “You could consider me your personal Guardian Angel.”

“Thanks, Bill, I’ll keep it in mind,” she said with finality, and the man wandered away.

“Who am I following out of here?” Behr said, taking Bill’s place.

“Me, when we go to a bar,” she said.

“Could he be our man?” Behr asked of the guy who’d just walked off.

“If I was profiling a lame-o with an orange belt in tae kwon do, maybe. Only thing Bill’s guilty of is using weak-ass pickup material,” Mistretta said, tearing the card in two and letting it flutter to the floor. “Why’s everybody so fucking hatty?”

Behr took a glance and saw what she meant: at least two dozen attendees wore baseball hats and Irish Eight Piece caps, and even some fedoras, which had been back in style for two years, which also meant they were just getting to Indianapolis.

“Can’t ask them to take ’em off,” Behr said.

“You sure?” she wondered.

“You seeing anything? Would our guy be last to leave or would he get out early?”

“Not sure. This part’s interpretive, not frigging exact,” she said.

“I didn’t mean it like that.”

“I know.”

For another moment things seemed as natural as could be expected, but then everything changed. A menacing figure under a baseball hat and dressed in a Carhartt coat slid in the door, surveyed the room, and moved toward the display. Behr recognized him right away and fell back behind a pillar in order to not be seen. The man’s arm was in a sling. He was Jerold Allen Prilo. Behr’s eyes locked onto him as he moved among the other viewers. Behr didn’t know if he was imagining it, it was hard to tell at this distance, but he could swear Prilo wore a slight smirk.

“Listen, I know you never liked my Prilo idea …” Behr said to Mistretta.

“Thought you gave up on it too,” she said.

“I did. But he’s here.”

“Son of a bitch,” she said. “Where?”

“Big guy over there in the tan coat. The one wearing a sling on his arm.”

They looked and saw him, his broad shoulders rolled forward and looming above other attendees, as he browsed the photographs. Behr felt his heart pounding at the presence. There was a literal wolf in the barnyard. Behr left Mistretta and circled around to get a better look. Prilo seemed like just another citizen in the crowd, but Behr had the distinct impression that he was there to stalk. Perhaps having a premonition he was being watched, Prilo looked up and surveyed the room, a sickly grin on his face now plainly visible, and then his eyes met Behr’s. Before he could duck away, Behr felt himself get recognized.

“Shit,” Behr muttered, and moved toward the man.

The smile ran away from Prilo’s face and then he turned and headed quickly for the door. He was gone before Behr reached him.
Behr saw him from the doorway, lumbering off into the night. The whole thing just felt wrong. In fact, Prilo’s presence was as wrong as wrong got. Behr considered chasing him down, but it was a public meeting and Prilo—his past excepted—had done nothing actionable. Besides, Behr knew where he lived and the event was almost over.

Before long the place had emptied, and Behr, Quinn, and Mistretta were the only three left.

“Well, nobody fell down on the floor and confessed,” Quinn said, as he broke down his prints.

“Is that what was supposed to happen?” Mistretta asked while she plugged Behr’s phone into his computer and synced the license plate photos. “I just came for the free doughnuts—which this crowd mowed through.” There were only crumbs left on the table.

“May as well have,” Behr said, in the midst of removing and packing up the PTZ cameras. “We did have a bona fide murderer in the room.”

“Who?” Quinn asked.

“Name Jerold Allen Prilo sound familiar?”

“He was here?” Quinn said. “You think he’s pay dirt?”

“Let’s just say Behr’s idea about him is a lot less gamey right now,” Mistretta said, as she zipped her computer into its case. “Is it drunk o’clock yet?”

Quinn and Behr caught eyes and smiled.