Authors: Joyce Carol Oates
Far above her he regarded her. Her hands tried to reach him but could not. Her fingers were weak, her wrists broken. Still he was inside her, she was impaled upon him as upon a hook that pierced her lower body. Now his hands moved onto her torso, her breasts, as if he were a blind man, curious to see her in this way, in the way of touching, sculpting with his fingers. He ran his hands over her, he gripped her breasts as if to test the resiliency of her flesh. Her breasts ached with sensation, the nipples felt raw, as if she'd been nursing, hungry mouths had been feeding from her, tearing at her. She was writhing, darkness opening at the back of her skull. She understood then why she had no name for him, why he had not once spoken her name. When she'd begun to speak his name, at the start of their lovemaking, he'd covered her mouth with the heel of his hand, lightly yet in warning: No.
Beyond the tall windows whose drapes had been pulled back the sky was shot with a vivid chemical light. Below was the river, invisible from where they lay, so chopped by wind you could not have said in which direction it flowed. Her eyeballs shifted upward, a death had come over her brain. She saw only a portion of her lover's face, the glisten of oily sweat on his forehead. Only a portion of the ceiling where shimmering water reflected, live-seeming as microorganisms. How ragged her breath was, short and frayed like cloth that has been ripped! As if she'd been drowning, the man had saved her. No one had brought her to such a place before. He had brought her there as if by chance, negligently. The knowledge was crushing to her.
She heard moans, whimpers. She heard a woman's choked sobs. He laughed at her, there was little tenderness in him.
Still he observed her, curiously. As a pilot might observe the ground far below, at a distance at which everything is in miniature, inconsequential. At such a distance there are no individuals. No cries can be heard. She could not bear it, this distance. She reached for him, he gripped her wrists and brought her arms down, spread outright beside her head, so she was helpless. He moved into her, she began to shout, guttural cries that scraped like gravel against her throat. She was a sinewy snake, every
inch of her flesh quivering, her skin a damp scaly glisten. He'd pulled a pillow free of the tangle of bedclothes, it must have been caprice, he must have miscalculated, he lowered the pillow over her sweaty face, her anguished eyes and opened mouth, he was pumping hard between her spread thighs as if there was a fascination in him, what he might do to her, the woman, what was emerging between them in this place. Desperately she pulled at his hands, his wrists that were too thick for her fingers to close about, there were hairs on the backs of his hands, wiry hairs on his wrists, she was blinded by the pillow, she was frantic to breathe. Now her body, in which her soul was mute, dazed, swollen tight against her skin like a balloon blown nearly to bursting, began to struggle for its life. The man held her fixed, she was impaled upon him, a great sinewy snake helpless beneath him, the heavy pillow seemed to enclose her head, she was being suffocated. Tendons stood out in her neck, her arteries swelled. She lost consciousness, in a moment she was gone.
Â
Like companions they lay side by side. Like companions who are strangers, thrown together in the same wreck. For a long time she could not move. Her eyelids fluttered weakly, she could not see. Sensation had obliterated her, in the aftermath of sensation there was nothing. Her heartbeat, that had madly accelerated, was slowed now, almost imperceptible. A match had flared into flame, the flame had touched her, exploded inside her, now the flame was extinguished, her body was numbed, she could barely lift her head. The soles of her bare feet seemed to burn as if she'd been walking on hot sand. She spoke to the man, she was helpless not to speak, hearing with a kind of pitying astonishment the hopeless words in a voice barely audible
I love you.
It was something of a plea, an argument, yet there was no one with whom to argue, the man seemed not to hear as if sparing her.
She lay as if beneath the surface of shallow water. Sun played upon the water, that was warm, unthreatening. She could not drown in this water, it would protect her. She was drifting into a stuporous sleep.
Mommy? Mom-
my
? the little girl was looking for her, though Mommy stood before her, squatted before her, the little girl stared through her, the little boy, the boy whose name she'd forgotten for the moment, he was looking for her, anxious Mommy where are you?âshe'd become a wraith, they could not see her. Someone touched her as if accidentally, in his abrupt way the man was rising from the bed, walking away. He was barefoot, he moved with a negligent ease, no more self-conscious than if he were alone in the hotel room. Weakly she spoke to him, he did not seem to hear. She heard faucets, a toilet flushing. At least she forced herself to move. Her limbs that were paralyzed, broken. Something warmly sticky as blood between her thighs, on her belly.
He went away from her, he wanted her gone. While she was in the bathroom running water, the hottest water she could bear staring at her dilated eyes in the steamy mirror, she heard him on a telephone. His easy laugh, the murmur of his voice. A man among men he seemed to her, unknowable.
She left him. He wanted her gone, she understood and so she left him. Hey: he gripped her chin, kissed her mouth as you might kiss the forehead of a plain child. At the elevator she turned back, the door to 2133 had shut. In the rapidly descending glass cubicle she wiped at her eyes, angry fists in her eyes. She had restored the damage to her mascara, her eye makeup, now it was damaged again, a teary ruin. Her body wept for him, a seepage between her legs. She thought I am soiled, fouled. I am a woman who deserves harm.
She left the hotel quickly, the revolving door seemed to sweep her out. She imagined faint muffled laughter in her wake but heard only a doorman invisible to her calling after her in a voice of scornful familiarity
Good evening, ma'am!
Â
Evening! She wouldn't be home until nearly seven o'clock.
On the expressway, wind buffeted the station wagon. Other vehicles veered in their lanes. She was too distracted to be frightened. Fumbling to call Ismelda on her cell phone but the battery had run low. She was
thinking, If the children have been hurt! It was not a rational thought yet she was thinking if The Babysitter had taken them, this was punishment she deserved.
The Babysitter was an abductor and killer of children in the suburbs north of the city, he'd never been identified, arrested. He had taken nine children in all but he had not taken a child in several years, it was believed that he'd moved away, or was in prison, or had died. He was called The Babysitter for his methodical way of bathing the bodies of his small victims after raping and strangling them, positioning them in secluded places like parks, a golf course, a churchyard, he'd taken time to launder and even iron their clothing which he folded neatly and left beside them. Always their arms were crossed over their narrow pale chests, their eyes were shut, in such peaceful positions they resembled mannequins and not children who had died terrible deaths, it was said you could not see the ligature marks on their throats until you knelt beside them. The Babysitter had not abducted a child from the suburb in which she lived for at least a decade and yet she was thinking almost calmly
If he has taken them, I will have to accept it.
The house was made of fieldstone, mortar, brick that had been painted a thin weathered white. Most of the house had been built in the mid-nineteenth century, on a large tract of land which was now reduced to three acres, the minimum for property owners in the township. She was relieved to see the warmly lit windows through the trees, of course nothing had happened, they were waiting for her to return and that was all. Her husband had a dinner engagement, he wouldn't be back until the children were in bed. Yet relief flooded her, seeing her husband's car wasn't in the garage. She'd had her revenge, then! She would love her husband less desperately now, she knew herself equal to him.
Rich cooking aromas in the kitchen, the sound of a TV, children's uplifted voices and Ismelda calling: Ma'am?âbut quickly she slipped away upstairs, before the children could rush at her. She showered as she hadn't in the hotel. She soaped every part of her body, she was giddy with relief. She had a lover! He hadn't given her his number, vaguely
he'd promised to call her the following week. No one knew, no one had come to harm, the family was safe. Bruises and red welts had already begun to show on her body as if a coarser skin were pushing through, her husband would never notice.
She hurried downstairs, she was kneeling with the children. Hugging the little girl, the little boy. Mommy? Mom-
my
? In two arms she hugged them, what did they have to show her? Easter eggs? So many? Yes they were beautiful but hadn't Ismelda understood that Mommy wanted her to wait, they would make the eggs together? She spoke sharply to Ismelda at the stove, Ismelda didn't seem to hear, it was a maddening trait of hers, seeming not to hear so her employers had to raise their voices, invariably you sounded like a bully, a fool, raising your voice to a Filipina woman scarcely five feet tall, staring at you with hurt eyes. And the children were clamoring at her, suddenly she wished them gone, all of them gone, banished from her so that she could think of her lover.
I am a murderer
she thought.
I am the one.
Her children crowded her, adoring.
T
hat day, I met my “estranged” mother in the lobby of the Carlyle Hotel on Madison Avenue, New York City. It was a few weeks following the last in a series of surgeries to correct a congenital malformation in my spine, and one of the first days when I could walk unassisted for any distance and didn't tire too quickly. This would be the first time I'd seen my mother since Fall Fashion Week nearly two years ago. Since she'd divorced my father when I was eight years old my motherâwhose professional name was Adelinaâspent most of her time in Paris. At thirty she'd retired from modeling and was now a consultant for one of the couture housesâa much more civilized and rewarding occupation than modeling, she said. For the world is “pitiless” to aging women, even former
Vogue
models.
As soon as I entered the Carlyle Hotel lobby, I recognized Adelina
waiting for me on a velvet settee. Quickly she rose to greet me and I was struck another time by the fact that my mother was so
tall
. To say that Adelina was a striking woman is an understatement. The curvature of my spine had stunted my growth and even now, after my last surgery, I more resembled a girl of eleven than thirteen. On the way to the hotel I'd become anxious that my beautiful mother might wince at the sight of me, as sometimes she'd done in the past, but she was smiling happily at meâjoyouslyâher arms opened for an embrace. I felt a jolt of love for her like a kick in the belly that took my breath away and left me faint-headed.
Is that my mother? Myâmother?
Typical of Adelina, for this casual luncheon engagement with her thirteen-year-old daughter she was dressed in such a wayâcream-colored coarse-knit coat, very short very tight sheath in a material like silver vinyl, on her long sword-like legs patterned stockings, and on her feet elegantly impractical high-heeled shoesâto cause strangers to glance at her, if not to stare. Her ash-blond hair fell in sculpted layers about her angular face. Hiding her eyes were stylish dark glasses in oversized frames. Bracelets clattered on both her wrists and her long thin fingers glittered with rings. In a hotel like the Carlyle it was not unreasonable for patrons to assume that this glamorous woman was
someone
, though no one outside the fashion world would have recalled her name.
My father too was “famous” in a similar wayâhe was a painter/sculptor whose work sold in the “high six figures”âfamous in contemporary Manhattan art circles but little-known elsewhere.
“Darling! Look at
you
âsuch a tall girlâ”
My mother's arms were thin but unexpectedly strong. This I recalled from previous embraces, when Adelina's strength caught me by surprise. Surprising too was the flatness of Adelina's chest, her breasts small and resilient as knobs of hard rubber. I loved her special fragranceâa mixture of flowery perfume, luxury soap, something drier and more acrid like hair bleach and cigarette smoke. When she leaned back to look at me her mouth worked as if she were trying not to cry. Adelina had not
been able to visit me in the hospital at the time of my most recent operation though she'd sent cards and gifts to my room at the Hospital for Special Surgery overlooking the East River: flowers, candies, luxurious stuffed animals and books more appropriate for a younger girl. It had been her plan to fly to New York to see me except an unexpected project had sent her to Milan instead.
“Your back, darling!âyou are all mended, are you?âyet so
thin.
”
Before I could draw away Adelina unzipped my jacket, slipped her hands inside and ran her fingers down my spine in a way that made me giggle for it was ticklish, and I was embarrassed, and people were watching us. Over the rims of her designer sunglasses she peered at me with pearl-colored eyes that seemed dilated, the lashes sticky-black with mascara. “Butâyou are very
pretty.
Or would be ifâ”
Playfully seizing my lank limp no-color brown hair in both her beringed hands, pulling my hair out beside my face and releasing it. Her fleshy lips pouted in a way I knew to be distinctly French.
“A haircut,
cherie
! This very day.”
Later I would remember that a man had moved away from Adelina when I'd first entered the lobby. As I'd pushed through the revolving door and stepped inside I'd had a vague impression of a man in a dark suit seated beside the striking blond woman on the settee and as this woman quickly rose to greet me he'd eased away, and was gone.
Afterward I would think
There might be no connection. Much is accident.
“You're hungry for lunch, I hope? I am famishedâ
très petit dejeuner
this morningââjet lag'âcome!”
We were going to eat in the sumptuous hotel restaurant. Adelina had made a “special reservation.”
So many rings on Adelina's fingers, including a large glittery emerald on the third finger of her left hand, there was no room for a wedding band and so there was no clear sign if Adelina had remarried. My father did not speak of my “estranged” mother, and I would not have risked upsetting him with childish inquiries. On the phone with me, in her infrequent calls, my mother was exclamatory and vague about her
personal life and lapsed into breathless French phrases if I dared to ask prying questions.
Not that I was an aggressive child. Even in my desperation I was wary, hesitant. With my S-shaped spine that had caused me to walk oddly, and to hold my head at an awkward angle, and would have coiled back upon itself in ever-tighter contortions except for the corrective surgery, I had always been shy and uncertain. Other girls my age hoped to be perceived as beautiful, sexy, “hot”âI was grateful not to be stared at.
As the maître d' was seating us in the restaurant, it appeared that something was amiss. In a sharp voice Adelina said, “No. I don't like this table. This is not a good table.”
It was one of the small tables, for two, a banquette seat against a mirrored wall, close by other diners; one of us would be seated on the banquette seat and the other on the outside, facing in. Adelina didn't want to sit with her back to the room nor did Adelina want to sit facing the room. Nor did Adelina like a table so close to other tables.
The maître d' showed us to another table, also small, but set a little apart from the main dining room; now Adelina objected that the table was too close to the restrooms: “I hate this table!”
By this time other diners were observing us. Embarrassed and unhappy, I stood a few feet away. In her throaty aggrieved voice Adelina was telling the maître d' that she'd made a reservation for a “quiet” tableâher daughter had had “major surgery” just recentlyâwhat was required was a table for four, that we would not be “cramped.” With an expression of strained courtesy the maître d' showed my mother to a table for four, also at the rear of the restaurant, but this table too had something fatally wrong with it, or by now the attention of the other diners had become offensive to Adelina, who seized my hand and huffily pulled me away. In a voice heavy with sarcasm she said, “We will go elsewhere,
monsieur
!
Merci beaucoup!”
Outside on Fifth Avenue, traffic was thunderous. My indignant mother pulled me to the curb, to wait for a break in the stream of vehicles before crossing over into the park. She was too impatient to walk
to the intersection, to cross at the light. When a taxi passed too slowly, blocking our way, Adelina struck its yellow hood with her fist. “Go on!
Allez!”
In the park, Adelina lit a cigarette and exhaled bluish smoke in luxurious sighs as if only now could she breathe deeply. Her mood was incensed, invigorated. Her wide dark nostrils widened further, with feeling. Snugly she linked her arm through mine. I was having trouble keeping pace with her but I managed not to wince in pain for I knew how it would annoy her. On the catwalkâ
catwalk
had been a word in my vocabulary for as long as I could rememberâAdelina had learned to walk in a brisk assured stride no matter how exquisitely impractical her shoes.
“Lift your head,
cherie.
Your chin. You are a pretty girl. Ignore if they stare. Who are
they
!”
With singular contempt Adelina murmured
they
. I had no idea what she was talking about but was eager to agree.
It was a sunny April day. We were headed for the Boathouse Restaurant to which Adelina had taken me in the past. On the paved walk beside a lagoon excited geese and mallards rushed to peck at pieces of bread tossed in their direction, squawking at one another and flapping their wings with murderous intent. Adelina crinkled her nose. “Such a
clatter
! I hate noisy birds.”
It was upsetting to Adelina, too, that the waterfowl droppings were everywhere underfoot. How careful one had to be, walking beside the lagoon in such beautiful shoes.
“Not good to feed wild creatures! And not good for the environment. You would think, any idiot would know.”
Adelina spoke loudly, to be overheard by individuals tossing bread at the waterfowl.
I was hoping that she wouldn't confront anyone. There was a fiery sort of anger in my mother, that was fearful to me, yet fascinating.
“Excuse me,
cherie
: turn here.”
With no warning Adelina gripped my arm tighter, pivoting me to
ascend a hilly incline. When I asked Adelina what was wrong she hissed in my ear, “Eyes straight ahead. Ignore if they stare.”
I dared not glance back over my shoulder to see who or what was there.
Because of her enormously busy professional life that involved frequent travel to Europe, Adelina had relinquished custody of me to my father at the time of their divorce. It had been a “tortured” decision, she'd said. But “for the best, for all.” She had never heard of the private girl's school in Manhattan to which my father was sending me and alluded to it with an air of reproach and suspicion for everyone knew, as Adelina said, that my father was “stingyâ
perfide
.” Now when she questioned me about the schoolâteachers, courses, classmatesâI sensed that she wasn't really listening as she responded with murmurs of
Eh? Yes? Go on!
Several times she turned to glare at someone who'd passed us saying sharply, “Yes? Is there some problem? Do I know you?”
To me she said, frowning, “Just look straight ahead, darling! Ignore them.”
Truly I did not know if people were watching usâeither my mother or meâbut it would not have surprised me. Adelina dressed like one who expects attention, yet seemed sincere in rebuffing it. Especially repugnant to her were the openly aggressive, sexual stares of men, who made a show of stopping dead on the path to watch Adelina walk by. As a child with a body that had been deformed until recently, I'd become accustomed to people glancing at me in pity, or children staring at me in curiosity, or revulsion; but now with my repaired spine that allowed me to walk more or less normally, I did not see that I merited much attention. Yet on the pathway to the Boathouse my mother paused to confront an older woman who was walking a miniature schnauzer, and who had in fact been staring at both Adelina and me, saying in a voice heavy with sarcasm, “Excuse me,
madame
? My daughter would appreciate not to be stared at.
Merci!”
Inside the Boathouse, on this sunny April day, many diners were awaiting tables. The restaurant took no phone reservations. There was
a crowd, spilling over from the bar. Adelina raised her voice to give her name to the hostess and was told that we would have a forty-minute wait for a table overlooking the lagoon. Other tables were more readily available but Adelina wanted a table on the water: “This is a special occasion. My daughter's first day out, after major surgery.”
The hostess cast me a glance of sympathy. But a table on the lagoon was still a forty-minute wait.
My disappointed mother was provided with a plastic device like a remote control that was promised to light up and “vibrate” when our table was ready. Adelina pushed her way to the bar and ordered a drinkâ“Bloody Mary for me, Virgin Mary for my daughter.”
The word
virgin
was embarrassing to me. I had never heard it in association with a drink and had to wonder if my capricious mother had invented it on the spot.
In the crowded Boathouse, we waited. Adelina managed to capture a stool at the bar, and pulled me close beside her as in a windstorm. We were jostled by strangers in a continuous stream into and out of the dining area. Sipping her bloodred drink, so similar in appearance to mine which turned out to be mere tomato juice, my mother inquired about my surgery, and about the surgeon; she seemed genuinely interested in my physical therapy sessions, which involved strenuous swimming; another time she explained why she hadn't been able to fly to New York to visit me in the hospital, and hoped that I understood. (I did! Of course.) “My life is not so fixed,
cherie
. Not like your father so settled out there on the island.”
My father owned two residences: a brownstone on West Eighty-ninth Street and, at Montauk Point at the easternmost end of Long Island, a rambling old shingleboard house. It was at Montauk Point that my father had his studio, overlooking the ocean. The brownstone, which was where I lived most of the time, was maintained by a housekeeper. My father preferred Montauk Point though he tried to get into the city at least once a week. Frequently on weekends I was brought out to Montauk Pointâby hired carâbut it was a long, exhausting
journey that left me writhing with back pain, and when I was there, my father spent most of the time in his studio or visiting with artist friends. It was not true, as Adelina implied, that my father neglected me, but it was true that we didn't see much of each other during the school year. As an artist/bachelor of some fame my father was eagerly sought as a dinner guest and many of his evenings both at Montauk Point and in the city were spent with dealers and collectors. Yet he'd visited me each day while I'd been in the hospital. We'd had serious talks about subjects that faded from my memory afterwardâart, religion?âwhether God “existed” or was a “universal symbol”âwhether there was “death” from the perspective of “the infinite universe.” In my hospital bed when I'd been dazed and delirious from painkillers it was wonderful how my father's figure melted and eased into my dreams with me, so that I was never lonely. Afterward my father revealed that when I'd been sleeping he had sketched meâin charcoalâin the mode of Edvard Munch's “The Sick Child”âbut the drawings were disappointing, he'd destroyed them.