I tighten my grip around Paul's chest and wipe all thoughts of parallels from my mind. It's only two hours until I have to get up and tackle the day and when I finally nod off, my sleep is fitful. I wake up as Paul leaves the bed.
âI thought we could go up to the graveyard for eleven, Grace.'
âNo problem.' I swing my feet on to the floor. âI'll make us all some breakfast first.'
The day is warm, the sky high and clear. The family join me for breakfast and afterwards we all climb into the car. Ed sits in the middle of the girls, bolt upright. For the last day or so he has been avoiding me. Every time I look at him, he looks away. I don't know whether it's something to do with the Alzheimer's. I tried to have a word with him about it but when I asked him what was wrong, he gave me a withering look and said, âIf you don't know, then I'm not the one to tell you.'
We gather in front of Rose's grave. Paul, the girls and I sit on the grass. Ed is busy digging up the small plot in front of her headstone and is arranging some bedding plants in the newly turned soil. Emotions swirl around inside me like a sea gathering to a storm. Coming to the graveside reminds me that my whole life revolves around Rose and what happens next is dependent on keeping what happened all those years ago a secret.
âMum!' Daisy calls. âYou keep drifting off. Is everything okay?'
Paul is watching me. Everybody is. âI'm fine.' I pull my lips back into a smile. âI'm sorry, what were you saying?'
âHow did you two end up getting married?' Daisy says. âYou've never really told us.'
âWe met in La Farola a few months after Rose died,' Paul says. âWell, in fact, it wasn't La Farola's then. It was called Donnie's Bites.'
âDonnie's Bites? Sounds like a greasy spoon.'
âIt was better than that, wasn't it, love?' He looks over at me and I nod.
âDonnie was a bit of a gourmet on the quiet,' I say.
âAhead of his time, was Donnie,' Paul continues. âHe had quite a cordon bleu repertoire for a dyed-in-the-wool Scot. No haggis or stovies for Donnie. He had an Italian mother-in-law if I remember rightly.'
âShe lurked in the kitchen in her black headscarf,' I say. âAnd the only English she ever uttered was “you lazy girl” or “you good-for-nothing boy”.'
âYour mum was a waitress. She wore a dinky little uniform that showed off her legs.'
âDo you still have it, Mum?' Daisy says. âIt might come in handy for fancy dress.'
âIt's probably in the attic somewhere.'
âIt's my birthday coming up,' says Paul. âAs a special treat, perhaps?'
I laugh and Ella screws up her face. âDo you
mind
?'
âSo?' Daisy says, leaning across and shaking Paul's knee. âDid you eat there a lot?'
âI had nothing to go home for. And as you know, I'm not much of a cook.'
âYou can say that again,' Daisy says.
âI'm not much of a cook.'
She laughs obligingly.
âI spent a couple of nights a week in there. We got talking.' He looks at me and smiles. âWe found out that we had a lot in common. We started to play squash together, went for long walks, your mum would bring her sketchbook, I always had a camera with me.'
âNot the most exciting of courtships then?' Ella says. We all ignore her.
âAnd were Granny and Grandad okay about you marrying so young, Mum?'
âThey didn't take much persuading.' Paul holds my eyes. âWhen they saw how much we loved each other' â he leans over and kisses my lips â âany reservations they had melted away.'
âCan we go easy on the mush?' Ella says. She is pulling the petals off a buttercup. âAnd anyway, shouldn't we be talking about Rose?'
âI remember Rose,' Ed says, swivelling around on his knees. âShe had her own little set of garden tools and she would wash them down with the hose so that she could take them up to her bedroom at night. She loved to help me in the garden.'
I stand up to stretch my legs while Paul takes up the story. The path ahead is clear, all the way to where the land slopes down to the sea. In the other direction is the church. It's stone-built and weather-worn and has stood on the hill battling the elements for more than two hundred years. It's the church I was married in and in my mind's eye I can still see Paul standing at the altar, turning around to take my hand, holding my gaze all through the ceremony. I loved him so completely then, so utterly and completely. And I love him still. But it isn't the same. And I was the one to spoil it, not him. When Euan came back into my life, part of me was reborn. I can't explain it even to myself but he gives me something, a feeling, a love, an affirmation that is nigh-on impossible to live without. How can I love two men at once?
As I turn to walk back towards my family, I notice that someone else is there â a woman. The way she is standing, the tilt of her head, jolts me back into the past. Angeline. The holiday we shared in Le Touquet when Orla and I were fourteen; Orla suppressing her agitation as her mother chatted to men and then disappeared for days without so much as a word.
But this woman can't be Angeline â she is too young. She is wearing red three-quarter-length trousers and a white blouse. Her hair is straight and lies loose around her shoulders â that's why I don't recognise her immediately. She's straightened it and, with no curls to soften the edges of her cheekbones, it makes her face more angular. As I draw closer, I see that not only has she dropped the plain clothes but she is wearing make-up. Her eyes are grey across the lids, her lashes long and curled with black mascara. Daisy and Ella are both admiring her shoes and she holds on to Paul's arm as she slides them off her feet. Ella immediately puts them on and starts to parade up and down.
âYou look fantastic in them!' Orla exclaims. âI can tell you the name of the shop where I bought them.' She claps her hands. âEven better! Why don't I take you both on a shopping trip? Now that I'm home to stay, your mum and I can be friends and I can beâ'
âLike a surrogate auntie?' Ella says, handing the shoes to Daisy.
âExactly!'
âMum?' Daisy spots me watching them. âWhat do you think?' She walks towards me. âShe could come with us onâ'
âOrla! What a surprise,' I say, interrupting Daisy before she mentions Sunday's shopping trip. âBack in the village.'
âWhere else?' She turns a full circle, her arms out, eyes closed. âThere's nowhere quite like it.'
âWe felt the same when we came back.' Paul looks towards me. âWe lived in Boston when we were first married, didn't we, Grace?'
âYes.' I am tight-lipped, both hot with fury and cold with a steely, focused anger that I have never experienced before. The feelings alternate inside me, rising and falling with my breath.
Orla reaches forward and hugs me, brushes my hair aside with her fingers and whispers, âRelax! I won't tell him. Not yet.'
I hold myself still, stop short at pushing her away.
âA picnic!' she exclaims. âHow wonderful! Is this a special day?'
âIt's the anniversary of Rose's death,' Paul says.
âOf course. I'm so sorry.' She lays a hand on Paul's forearm. âHow stupid of me.' Her expression is solemn as she looks around at all of us. âI'm intruding on family time.'
âNot at all,' Paul says. âWe were just about to walk down to the beach and enjoy our picnic. Why don't you join us?'
âI couldn't possibly. I'm sure Grace is a wonderful cook' â she throws me an admiring glance â âbut I really don't want to intrude.'
âYou won't be intruding,' Paul says, looking to me for confirmation. âGrace has packed more than enough, haven't you, love?'
âI'm sure Orla is busy with her move,' I say. âPerhaps another time.'
âGrace is right. The cottage will need a lot of work done to it before I can call it home.' She sighs happily. âBut I'm not planning on moving anytime soon so I have all the time in the world.'
I don't react. She really is laying it on thick, each comment set to scare me further. But it isn't working. I feel strangely powerful as if I can tackle anything, anyone.
âRose was such a lovely child,' she says, her eyes on Paul. âGrace and I enjoyed looking after her at camp, didn't we?'
I say nothing.
âDo you remember how much she loved that song we were all singing? What was it again?' She pretends to think. âIt was a folk song. She wanted to learn to play the guitar.'
âI didn't know that.' Paul looks at me quizzically.
âI'd forgotten,' I say, knowing full well that Orla is lying but I'm damned if I'll contradict her and open myself up to more games. Ed and the girls start to drift down towards the beach and I follow them with my eyes.
âYes, we must be off,' Paul says, lifting the picnic basket up off the ground. âDid you mention Sunday lunch, Grace?'
âI haven't but I will.' I put my arm through Orla's. âI'll walk you to the gate,' I say, allowing her a few moments for a quick goodbye before I steer her uphill and away from the beach. My forcefulness surprises her and I am able to move her out of my family's earshot before she shakes herself free.
âDo you mind?' She glares at me.
âAbout Sunday,' I say, determined that she should still keep the lunch appointment and come up against Euan instead of Paul and me. âWe were wondering whether you have any dietary considerations: vegetarian, vegan, peanut allergy. That sort of thing.'
âReally?' She crosses her arms.
âYes, really.' I match her body language. âDo you have any?'
âNo. But I wonder.' She taps her foot. âYou hustled me away pretty quickly just now. Something you're not telling me?'
She's second-guessing me again. I smile through my irritation. âAll that nonsense back there â we weren't singing folk music at camp.'
âNo, but it sounded good. And it made Paul happy. That's what you do, isn't it? Make Paul happy with a lie?'
âI have never lied to him.'
âNot even by omission?' She tips her head to one side and her hair slides across her shoulders. âThe clock is ticking, Grace.'
âIs it money? Is that what you want?'
âYou think I'm doing this for money?' Her laugh is derisory, contemptuous.
âWhy then? Because of some letters I didn't read?'
She doesn't answer.
I try the obvious. âA guilty conscience?'
She laughs. It's a cackling noise that sets my nerves vibrating. âI'm not driven by guilt. I didn't push her. You did.'
âWhy then, Orla?' I'm right in her face. âWhy are you doing this?'
She thinks for a moment. âBecause I can.' She looks beyond me, down to the shore. âI had a lot of time to think when I was in prison. One of the first things I did when I came out was to come back to the village â just the once â to check up on you. I saw you and Euan walking on the beach. And you looked so' â she searches for the right word, her face twisted with a manic look that is unsettling â âso fucking happy.'
I take a step back. âThis is about me and Euan?'
She doesn't answer me. I watch her. She goes to speak, stops, bites her bottom lip. Her eyes are black, fathomless. Her thoughts are somewhere else. I can see her playing a memory through her mind. I know that this is it. If she doesn't level with me now she never will.
âYou know what?' Her head jerks towards me. âI hope that when Paul discovers the truth, he chucks you out on to the streets. I hope your girls never want to see you again. I hope that you are shunned by everyone.' Red spots highlight her cheekbones. âAnd I hope the regret eats away at you until there's nothing of you left.'
Her hostility is palpable but still I have no trouble taking a breath. âYou hate me that much?'
âI don't hate you. I despise you.' Her saliva spits on to my face. âYou are nothing more than a pawn to me.'
I wipe the back of my hand over my cheek and keep my face lowered as anger swells inside me then drops back and settles to a simmer in the pit of my stomach. âI never saw it before, just how much of a spiteful, vindictive troublemaker you are. And always were.' I look up at her. âYou need to stop now before this gets out of hand.'
âAre you threatening me?'
âIt's more of a warning.'
âAre you going to set Euan on me?' She makes a scathing sound and I wonder just how come she is always able to work out our next move. âIs he going to have a quiet talk with me? And if that doesn't work, will he progress to not-so-gentle persuasion?' Her eyes sparkle. âI know! Why not kill me?' she whispers.
âI don't want you dead,' I say flatly. âI want you gone.'
âEuan was always good at doing what had to be done, wasn't he?' She paces around me, leaning into my body as she speaks. âYou can hold me down and Euan can do the deed. Then his hands will be dirtier than yours. You've lived with one death all these years. Hell! Why not make it two? I won't struggle.' She crosses her heart with her fingers. âI promise.' Then she walks away, laughing, turns to face me again and blows me a theatrical kiss.
November 1983
âThis is a critical year for all of you. The make or break year. Time to separate the wheat from the chaff.'
We're in assembly. We're fifteen going on sixteen. It's our O-level year. The headmaster has been talking for fifteen minutes. The urge to fidget is almost overwhelming but two of the teachers are eagle-eyed, writing down the name of anyone whose back slumps or attention wanders.