Ashley was losing interest, but for politeness' sake he found a question or two.
“Dr. MacKenzie, how could a liar and a thief be of any use to people who are dying?”
“Greek, Greek. Very Greek. Each of these gods and goddesses had two sides. Even Pallas Athene can be a raging fury when she's aroused. Hermes was the god of roads and journeys and milestones. Mischievous though he was, he liked to conduct people to their destinations. Look at this picture. It's an engraved gem. See him there? He's holding his staff in the air and leading that veiled woman by the hand. Isn't that beautiful?”
Yes, it was beautiful.
“My father was a Saturn. Wise. Gave advice all dayâon the street, in the home, and on Sundays from the pulpit. Bad advice, perfectly awful advice. My mother was a Heraâhearth and home, nestbuilding. But a rulerâyes, indeed. Terrible woman. I had two brothers, both Apollos. Saturns tend to beget Apollos, have you noticed that?”
“No, sir.”
“Maybe I imagine it. One of them is serving a long sentence. His lightâhis illuminationâtook the form of being an anarchist. My sister was a Diana. Never grew up. Still a schoolgirl! Had three children, but marriage and motherhood couldn't touch her.âBut to get back to you, Tolland. Maybe you take after a god in some other religion. The Greeks didn't know everything. There are types of personality that the Greeks hadn't observed. They were rare in Greece so they weren't elevated to gods. Take Christianity, for instance. Christianity is a Jewish religion. Most un-Greek thing in the world. Maybe that's where you come in. You Hebrews came along and tossed us off our thrones. You brought in that unhappy conscience of yoursâall that damned moral anxiety. Maybe you're a Christian. Always denying yourselves any enjoyment, always punishing yourselves. Is that it?”
Ashley made no answer.
“The rest of us are fallen. We're shorn. We're decayed. It's an awful thing, Mr. Tolland, to be robbed of one's divinityâawful! There's nothing left for us to do but enjoy ourselves in our miserable way. Saturns without wisdom, like my father; Apollos without joy, like my brothers. We become tyrants and troublemakers. Or cranky and erratic, like Mrs. Wickersham.”
“Dr. MacKenzie, what's the matter with those . . . ? those ânestbuilders'?”
“Those Heras, those Junos? Why, they treat all their men as though they were boysâtheir husbands, their sons, and their fathers. Once they've produced a few babies they think they know everything. They think all the problems of the human race have been solved. Their aim is to soothe. They call it âkeeping everybody happy.' They try to rob their menfolk of sight and hearing and thought. Beware of the word âhappy' in Hera's mouth; it means âdozing.'”
An all but insupportable pang rent Ashley's headache. He rose to say good night.
“But, Dr. MacKenzie, you don't believe . . . ? all this, do you?”
“No, of course not. But, Mr. Tolland, in Edinburgh we have a philosophers' club. At our dinners we talk a great deal about what others believe and have believed; but if any member uses the verb in the first or second person of the present tense, he has to pay a fine. He has to put a shilling in a skull on the mantel. We soon get out of the habit.”
Time did what Ashley asked of itâit sped.
The company ruled that at the end of every eight months each engineer should descend for a month to lower altitudes to give his heart and lungs a rest. On the eve of his departure Ashley shook hands with his fellow engineers. They were unexpectedly cordial. Many persons are at their most amiable when saying goodbye. He shrank from taking formal leave of the villagers, but a deputation of men, wrapped to their noses, stood waiting for him outside the door of the club room. They gave him presents. They kissed his hands.
He called on Dr. MacKenzie.
“I hope you can stay at Mrs. Wickersham's hotel. Wait a moment! I'll write a letter to introduce you.”
“Thank you, Doctor. I'm going to Santiago. I'll stop in Manantiales next time.”
As Ashley was leaving the room the managing director called him back. “Tolland, don't you think it would be a good idea if you brought back a little companion?”
“What, sir?”
“A little âhillwife.' You know what I mean. The company approves of it, makes provision for it.”
Dr. MacKenzie was born to blunder. The friendship had been cooling; he killed it. In that realm no man gives advice to a man over twenty-fiveâasked or unaskedâand Dr. MacKenzie knew it.
A dozen of the engineers, like Dr. van Domelen, had installed “native” women in the Chilean or Indian villages. The men never went into the villages; they did not take their hill wives to the lower altitudes on their vacations; they seldom saw their children. There was a general pretense that the system did not exist.
Dr. MacKenzie had blundered worse than he knew. Ashley, in his own eyes, was a family man and little else. Yet he was a family man who, for reasons beyond his control, had proved to be a total failure. Was Beata protected against insult? Did the family have enough to eat? Did the children have adequate clothing in winter? He was saving his money; he would see them again in seven years. In the meantime there was one thing he could doâone absurd impassioned thing: he could remain faithful to his wife. This was what he thought of as “holding up the walls.”
Many men and women can live out their lives without any resort to superstition, magic, prayer, or fetish. They remember no anniversaries, salute no flags, and bind themselves by no oaths. They submit themselves totally to blind Circumstance, who takes away without thought what it gave without plan. Ashley's fidelity was not supported by any vow undertaken before church or state, forâas we shall see laterâJohn and Beata Ashley were never married. The truest virtues are supererogatory: compassion not toward the good but toward the wicked, generosity to the ungrateful, fidelity without formal commitment. Continence, for Ashley, was a deprivation like blindness or immobility. He maintained it by rigorous strategy. It was to this end that he so organized his life that he went nightly to bed “dog-tired,” “log-tired.” He governed sharply what our ancestors called his “conversation.” But any resolute person can conquer the demands of the flesh; he had a harder battle to win. He had known only one woman; he had had no experience of disassociating love from its train of attendantsâcompanionship, courage, consolation, unfolding knowledge, andâin parenthoodâcreation. Time and time again on his trips southward these fair promises had been extended to him. Women had seen these expectations in his eyes. He remembered hearing in Coaltown that Dr. Gillies was accustomed to say to patients addicted to alcoholism, “Don't deprive yourself of anything until you find something better to put in its place.” Ashley felt his deprivation keenly; in its place he put this absurd superstitionâif he failed,
the walls of “The Elms” would sway, totter, and collapse.
The continentâthat is, the resolute and dedicated ones, not the pining continentâhave a way of recognizing one another. Later, when Ashley worked himself “dog-tired,” repairing and reinforcing and embellishing Mrs. Wickersham's hospital and schools, what friendships arose with the sisters!âwhat laughter, what complicityâyes, what airy courtships, what coquetry!
So Dr. MacKenzie blundered. He knew he had blundered and his contempt for Ashley turned to hateâone of those hatreds nourished by self-hatred.
“Thank you,” said Ashley, “I'll think it over.”
In Antofagasta he changed trains without calling on Mr. Andrew Smith of the Kinnairdie Mining Company. His first task in Santiago de Chile was to find work. His appearance had altered during the eight months. He had agedâthat is, he now looked his age, which was forty-two. He was blackened by the sun to the degree so rapidly acquired at high altitudes. His hair had darkened and had lost its youthful curls. The pitch of his voice was lower. He was taken for a Chilean of the Irish or German admixture so frequent in the country. He applied without success for work as a nursery gardener, a stable hand, a gravedigger, a handyman at the “Eden” pleasure park. Finally he was hired to work on the new road toward the north, toward ValparaÃso and Antofagasta. When his vacation drew to an end he left the road with regret; he had contributed to mixing and pouring the cement for twenty culverts. Again he changed trains in Antofagasta and spent the night in the inn he had known. The next morning he called on Mr. Andrew Smith, who did not at first recognize him and who was displeased at seeing a responsible engineer of his company wearing the clothes of a laborer. He had much to talk over with Mr. Tolland, however. Whatever the company did it did cautiously and, as far as possible, secretly. Mr. Smith and the mysterious Board of Directors would have suffered untold agonies if they had learned that loose idle talkers were spreading the rumor that Rocas Verdes was running into ever richer seams of ore, and that there were plans for large expansion. Ashley was directed to draw up designs and estimates for many more miners' huts. In fact large quantities of lime and timber were already ascending the mountains. The problems of housing were discussed at length. When Ashley prepared to take his leave, Mr. Smith's manner acquired a measure of warmth. He expressed a guarded commendation of the young man's work. He intimated that the Board of Directors might soon give concrete expression to their appreciation.
Ashley sat down again abruptly and said, “Mr. Smith, there are two things that I'd like to propose to you.”
“Indeed?”
“I think that it would be a very wise measure to announce an increase in the miners' payâeven though it be a very small one.” Mr. Smith stared at him angrily. “You know how many hours are lost every week because of illness.”
“I do. That is malingering, Mr. Tolland. The miner is incorrigibly lazy. Dr. van Domelen has a constant struggle with them.”
“No, this is different. These men are not lazy. When they are working with me on some project for their own village, it is hard to make them stop. All they need is some sign that they are respected as human beings. The Indian, sir, is subject to spells in which his mind and will âgo blank'âthat's the only way I know how to put it.”
“That's the way to put itâincorrigible laziness.”
“His whole life stretches before him, working underground, without possibility of change. The monotony is bad enough; the loss of hope is worse. But”âand here Ashley roseâ“the lack of human consideration is killing. Mining engineers, Mr. Smith, have no blood in their veins. The Indians
do
fall ill. This sense of being shut off and despised takes the form of an illness.”
Mr. Smith opened and shut his lips several times; finally he said, “A man has to earn his living on this earth, Mr. Tolland, just as you and I do. A raise in their wages is none of your concern. They'd spend it in drink. They somehow manage to smuggle it in, I don't know how.”
Ashley walked about the room. He approached Mr. Smith's desk and said, in a lowered voice: “
Chicha
is not the only thing that is smuggled in. Information finds its way in, too. I don't know how. Our miners have heard of the wages at La Reina and San Tomás and Dos Cumbresâespecially our Bolivian Indians, who are our best workers. You are building new huts; you may have trouble filling them. The best investment in a mine is the self-respect and well-being of the miner. They have a saying, âOre does not come to the surface by itself.'”
Mr. Smith swallowed. He shifted the pen and inkwell on his desk. He coughed. “You said you had a second suggestion.”
“There should be a priest living at Rocas Verdes. Those irregular visits aren't right.”
“What do they want with their wretched priests? The priest charges them so much for a wedding and a christening that most of the miners aren't even married. They hate their priests. A visit once a month's good enough for them. Mr. Tolland, let me tell you something: Roman Catholicism is childish superstition at best; in Chile it's beneath contempt.”
“I think we're all bad judges of what goes on in other people's minds about God, Mr. Smith. It's a bad thing to force a God on a man who doesn't want one. It's worse to stand in the way of a man who wants one badly. I know them! I live there!”
Suddenly Ashley was seized by a splitting headache. He closed his eyes and almost fell from his chair. Again Mr. Smith stared at him as though he had been struck. If there was to be any moralizing, Mr. Smith was accustomed to doing it. It's what he did best. Scotland is heavily populated with Saturns. No young whipper-snapper from Canada could tell him anything about religious matters.
“Are you ill, Mr. Tolland?”
“Might I have a glass of water, please.”
Mr. Smith watched him drink. At last he said, “How would we get a priest there? Everybody knows there aren't enough in Chile to go round. They have to ship them over from Spain.”
Ashley had given no thought to this. To his own surprise he heard himself saying offhandedlyâ“I suppose you write to the Bishop. Maybe you give him a present. You promise to pay the priest's salary for the first five yearsâsomething like that.” Mr. Smith stared at him somberly. Ashley went on: “Ask for a young one. Give me permission to build him a hut; and give me permission to enlarge the chapel. It looks like a pigsty. And I think it'd be useful in the long run if you gave me permission to stay one more day in Antofagasta so that I could look at some churches and talk to some priests.”
Mr. Smith struggled with himself. When he spoke, his Scots speech, which I have omitted to reproduce, returned pronouncedly: “I give you that permission. But don't be getting too many fancies, Mr. Tolland.”
At the door Ashleyâtotally recovered, ten years youngerâturned with a smile. “Rocas Verdes could be as beautiful inside as it isâoutside.” He flung his hand into the air as though describing a coronet of peaks.