Authors: Maeve Binchy
“I was wrong, Peter. You did know her. Did she everâ¦was there everâ¦?”
“She never told me anything, she never asked me anything that you should know aboutâ¦I swear it. Like I have sworn it for twenty-eight days to you. You ask me every single day and every single day I say the same thing.”
“Do I ask you every day? Every day?” Martin McMahon looked pitiful.
“No, I exaggerate. You may have missed out a few.”
“I'll not come for a pint until they find her body, Peter.”
“Then I will be drinking alone for some considerable time, won't I?” The doctor looked resigned.
“Why do you say that?” The words seemed bleak and full of horror.
Peter Kelly wiped his brow. “Jesus, Martin, it's only her body. Her soul, her spirit, had gone long ago, soared way up over us all. You know that, man, you know it. Won't you admit it?”
Martin wept, his shoulders shook.
Peter stood beside him, unwilling to reach out. Theirs had not been a friendship where a man held another man through a storm of tears. Eventually the shaking stopped.
Martin looked up, his face tear-stained and red. “I suppose I won't admit it because I keep hopingâ¦Let's go to Paddles'.”
        Â
Emmet told Sister Madeleine that he couldn't concentrate on poetry. It all seemed to remind him ofâ¦ofâ¦well, what had happened.
“Well, that's all right, isn't it?” Sister Madeleine said. “You wouldn't want to forget your mother.”
“But I don't seem to be able to say it, feel it, the way I used toâ¦.” His stutter was as bad as it had ever been. Sister Madeleine never gave any sign that he was taking any extra time.
“Well, don't say it at all.” To Sister Madeleine everything was simple.
“Don't I have to? Isn't this a lesson?”
“Not a real lesson. More a chat. It's you reading to me because my old eyes can't see to read all that well by the candle and firelight.”
“Are you very old, Sister Madeleine?”
“No, not very old. Much older than you, much older than your mother.” Sister Madeleine was the only person who ever mentioned Mother, everyone else avoided the subject.
“Do you know what happened to Mummy?” he said hesitantly.
“No, child, I don't.”
“But you sit here all the time and look out at the lakeâ¦you might have seen her falling out of the boatâ¦maybe?”
“No, Emmet, I didn't. Nobody saw her, it was dark, remember.”
“Would it have been terribleâ¦like choking?” He couldn't ask this to anyone else. They would have hushed him up or soothed him down.
Sister Madeleine appeared to give the matter some thought. “No, I think it would have been very peaceful, you know, a lot of dark water just falling over, like silk or velvet, sweeping you away. I don't think it would have been very frightening⦔
“And would she have been sad?”
“I don't think so. She might have been worried about you and about Kitâ¦mothers always worry, you know, about silly things like people wearing warm, dry socks and doing their homework and having enough to eatâ¦all mothers I have known worried about those kinds of thingsâ¦but not, not when she was drowning.” If Sister Madeleine noticed that Emmet's stutter had gone she gave no sign. “No, no of course not, but just hoping that you'd all be all right, that you'd carry onâ¦that kind of thing, I'd imagine.”
“Imagine her thinking of that⦔ His voice was shaking.
Sister Madeleine looked at him expectantly, as if she were waiting for him to say something else, something positive. And right on cue Emmet McMahon said: “Well, she needn't have been worrying, of course we can carry on.”
Father Baily gritted his teeth when he saw the McMahons at Mass on Sunday. He was fast running out of words of consolation for the family. There were just so many times a priest could explain to a bereaved family about things being God's will.
And the more he heard, the less he could accept it as the will of God. It was much more the will of that poor disturbed woman, Helen McMahon, who had come to Confession to him and knelt in the dark, telling him that her heart was heavy. What kind of way was that to confess sins? Father Baily felt that he had often given the woman absolution when she had not really sought it, when there was no contrition, no firm purpose of amendment.
He couldn't recall now what she had to tell.
If only people knew how similar and unremarkable their sins were to a confessor. But what did stand out was that she seemed to think she was not in control of her life. She accused herself of feeling distant, detached, of being an outsider instead of a participator. But she had not followed his suggestions of joining the sodality, getting herself on the flower-arranging committee, or cooking for the sales of work.
After Mass he greeted his parishioners by name.
“There you are, Dan. Cold day, isn't it?”
“It is, Father. Perhaps you'll come and have something to warm you up in the hotel?”
“Well, I'd love to, but I have a few sick calls to make after my breakfast.”
Father Baily would have liked nothing better than to sit in the obscurity of the back room of the Central Hotel and have three brandies to keep out the cold. But a breakfast table had been set by his housekeeper, and then he had to go up to Mother Bernard's convent to see an elderly nun, out to a farm in the back of beyond to bring the Blessed Sacrament to a farmer who had not thought to cross the door of a church until he had got a diagnosis of terminal cancer and now wanted the Church to come to him.
And everywhere he went people asked him what would happen when Helen McMahon's body was found. Always he had been vague and hopeful, committing himself to nothing, saying that the poor woman must always be in everyone's prayers.
He made a great point of shaking the hand of Martin McMahon warmly. “Good man, Martin, a tower of strength, that's what you are. I pray every day that you'll get the grace you needâ¦.” The man looked pale and wretched. Father Baily wondered what good his prayers were doing.
“Thank you, Father.”
“And Kit and Emmet. Good, good.” The words were meaningless, he knew it. But what could he give in the way of comfort? The only merciful thing was the woman had left no note. When they found the body, the coroner would surely be discreet enough to talk of accidents and misadventure. They could bury Helen McMahon in the churchyard, where she belonged.
Sister Madeleine was at Mass too, quietly in the back of the church, a gray cloak wrapped around her thin shoulders.
“Will you come back and have your Sunday dinner with us?” Kit said to her suddenly.
“Thank you, child, but no. I'm not much good at going to people's houses.”
“We need you,” Kit said simply.
“You have each other.”
“Yes, but it's not enough these days, it's gone on too long. We just sit and look at each other.”
“Wouldn't you ask one of your friends, Clioâ¦young Philip O'Brien from the hotel⦔
“You're my friend. Please come.”
“Thank you. That would be very nice,” said Sister Madeleine.
Rita carved the meat, a big piece of beef from Hickey's.
“I never saw so much meat in my life.” Sister Madeleine was full of wonder.
“It's not extravagant. It's for today, then cold tomorrow, and mince on Tuesday, and there's often enough for rissoles on a Wednesday.” Rita was proud of the way she ran the house.
Sister Madeleine looked around the kitchen where they sat at the table, a home with a tragedy hanging over it so heavily that you could almost see it there in the air.
“The travelers are still looking, you know,” she said. They all seemed to sit up startled, shocked that a visitor was mentioning what everyone else wanted to avoid. “They go all around the lake. If there's anything to be seen they'll see it.”
There was a total silence. The McMahons were not able to respond when someone spoke about the subject uppermost in their minds. Sister Madeleine waited. She never minded silences, she didn't rush to fill them with words.
“That's good of themâ¦to take such an interest,” Martin said eventually.
Sister Madeleine appeared not to notice his unease. “Helen was always very courteous to them on her walks, she knew their names and the names of their children. She often asked them about their ways, the language they spoke.” Kit looked at her, amazed. She had never known this about her mother. And yet Sister Madeleine spoke with total sincerity. She wasn't making up a story to console them, to wrap the dead up in soothing phrases. “They know the need for a funeral,” Sister Madeleine said. “They have wonderful funerals of their own people. They travel all over the country to be there, it's a way of saying good-bye, of finding a resting place up in the churchyard.”
“That's ifâ” Kit began.
Sister Madeleine interrupted: “That's if they find her. But they will, either the travelers or someone else, and then you'll be able to pray at her graveâ¦.” Sister Madeleine's tone was firm.
She was having no dealings with the idea that Helen McMahon would be buried outside the walls of a churchyard. A grave without a tombstone. Marking her as someone who had taken her own life.
That night Kit sat with her father.
“It's so long nowâ¦it's over a month. Would there be any of Mother left to bury?”
“I asked Peter Kelly that, Kit, the other night in Paddles' bar. He said we mustn't think of that, we must think your mother's spirit and soul left her that night, and what's left of the body doesn't matter.”
“I suppose he's right.”
“I suppose he is. Kit, I suppose he is.”
        Â
Mother Bernard was called out of class.
The conversation in the classroom rose to a high level. There was great excitement anyway because Deirdre Hanley, a senior girl, had been seen in a hedge with Stevie Sullivan, sort of wrapped around him, not just kissing, mind, but more, much more. They were so anxious for more details that they didn't notice Mother Bernard coming back and were startled by the crack of her voice, like a whip across the classroom.
“I expected big grown-up girls of your age to be able to continue with your work. But I was wrong. Very, very wrong.” They had crept shamefacedly back to their places. Mother Bernard's face was white. She must be very angry indeed. “This time however I shall put you on your honor. Each girl is to take out her composition book and write one full page about Advent. The season of waiting, the preparation for Christmas.” They looked at each other in despair. A whole page about Advent. What was there to say about it except that it went on forever and was nearly as bad as Lent? “And there shall be no blots, and no big spaces between words. This will be a work of which we will all be proud.” Mother Bernard spoke with menace in her tones.
They picked up their pens, knowing that this time she meant it. There would be no more news about Deirdre Hanley at this time.
“Katherine McMahon, could you come with me for a moment,” Mother Bernard said to Kit.
        Â
Brother Healy had told Kevin Wall that he would be a very fortunate lad if he were to see the day out without feeling the weight of a stick on both his hands. The boy looked fearful, but not fearful enough. He busied himself making pellets out of blotting paper soaked in ink.
Brother Healy was called to the door.
“I'll be back in five minutes. Is that clear?” he roared at his class. And then went to find young Emmet McMahon and tell him what he had to tell him.
No training could prepare you for this kind of job. Brother Healy sighed to himself as his cassock swished down the corridors to the room where second class were sitting with Brother Doyle, not knowing what lay ahead.
        Â
By nightfall everyone in Lough Glass knew.
A body had been found in the reeds. It was already badly decomposed. There wasn't any way that anyone would have to identify it.
Dr. Kelly had gone to his friend Martin McMahon. Everyone heard and said that there was no way he should look on something that bore no relation to what his wife had been. The state pathologist had come from Dublin; he had agreed. It would take some days, they were told.
A section of the lake had been cordoned off. People told each other how they had heard the ambulance coming. As if an ambulance would be any use after a month, but still, what other way could the poor woman's body have been brought to the morgue in the hospital.
Everyone had a story to tell about the McMahon family.
Kathleen Sullivan from the garage said that the lights were on in that house all night. None of them must have gone to bed. Clio Kelly said that things were much different there now, more normal. They had all stopped speaking in funny tight voices. Mrs. Hanley from the draper's said she had gone to pay her condolences and that very pushy maid of theirs hadn't let her in, she said the family were suffering from nervous exhaustion.