Read The Man Without a Shadow Online
Authors: Joyce Carol Oates
“âMedical guardian'? No-oo. Not a thing in her will about that, Doctor.”
“Lucinda didn't have time to prepare the codicil! But she intended to . . .”
“There's no evidence of that, Doctor. And if you don't mind, I would prefer that you call my mother âMrs. Mateson'ânot âLucinda.' You were not her friend, or I would have known of you.”
“I was your mother's friendâfor years! I drove Eli home from Darven Park to Gladwyne, your mother and I had tea together two, sometimes three times a week . . .”
There is an awkward silence. Margot is made to wonder if she has invented everything.
Out of her yearning, an entire world has been invented.
Coolly Jonathan Mateson says, “Wellâthere is no codicil. There is no amendment to the trust my mother established for Eli Hoopes in 1987.”
Weakly Margot protests, “But Mr. Matesonâdon't you owe
anything to your mother's wishes? How can you be so cruel to someone who has already suffered terribly? Eli Hoopes is your own relativeâplease rethink your decision to sell the house.”
Margot worries that she has gone too far, and that Jonathan Mateson is about to hang up. The property is immensely valuable, surely it's folly to imagine that the Matesons and the Hoopeses would wish to maintain Eli Hoopes as he'd been for thirty years.
No one cares for him but me. And I have no power.
“What business is it of yours what happens to Eli Hoopes, Doctor? Seems to me that
Project E.H.
has wrung the poor man dryâhow much longer are you going to âexperiment' with him?”
Margot protests that
Project E.H.
has been funded by the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Endowment; it is one of the most crucial neuropsychological projects in history. Already many of the
Project
's findings have been beneficial in the field of post-stroke therapy, for instanceâhow amnesia happens in the brain, and how the amnesiac might be treated. She tells him that Eli Hoopes has always been fully cooperative with researchers and that she, Margot Sharpe, as the principal investigator, closely overlooks all testing. “Eli's visits to the Institute are the high points of his life, you must know. Tests to the brain-damaged are immensely beneficial to them. Otherwise Eli would have seen virtually no one for years except his aunt Lucindaâhe has few visitors. He'd have vegetated at home watching TV.”
“Ridiculous! Eli has plenty of visitorsâexcept he can't remember who we are, so what's the purpose of âvisiting' him? It's damned depressing. And he can read perfectly well, he can read his favorite books over and over againâhe can watch his favorite moviesâmy mother said he was very happy seeing the same old classics again and again. And he could take photographs again, if he used his old camera. He could take a bus to the art
museumâhe knows his way around Philadelphia from before his injury. It's no good coddling him, and infantilizing him, as my mother didâthat's the reason his condition never improved. In fact, Eli has a life that's enviableâsomeone always takes care of him. He doesn't worry about the future, and he doesn't worry about the past.”
Margot protests, “Of course Eli âworries' about the past. It is all he has to think about.”
“All right, thenâhe âworries' about the past. But he can't remember anything that happens to him now, so the âpast' is getting smaller in his life.”
This is a nonsensical remark which Margot ignores.
“But without your mother, he will be so lonely . . .”
“In the facility we'll find for him he will have plenty of company. People like himself who are âdisabled'âhave lost parts of their personalities, or bodies. He'll get along just fine.”
“But Eli isn't mentally ill! He will be miserably out of place.”
“He will make new friends. Just give him a chance.”
“He won't be able to remember his new surroundings. He won't be able to remember new people he meets. He will just beâlost.”
Margot's tone is so forlorn, it seems that Jonathan Mateson can't bring himself to hang up just yet. Desperately Margot continues, “IâI could bring your cousin home with me at least temporarily. I could make a home for him. I'm a professor at the universityâI have a private house near campus. When I had to be away from home, I would hire someone to care for himâhe would have twenty-four-hour care. If I were to receive the paymentâoh, just a fraction of the paymentâyou would be making to this facility, it would be a good compromiseâdon't you think?”
Mateson is silent. Is he confounded, stunned? Is he insulted?
“Of courseâit would all be clearly designated in a contract . . . I would meet with you and any of Eli's other relatives, and we could work out a plan . . .”
“Jesus, Doctor! Why'd you take on such a burden? I haven't seen Eli Hoopes in years, my mother has said he was âgradually deteriorating' . . . I don't understand this at all.”
“If it were a matter of, ofâmoneyâif you didn't want to pay me out of the trustâI could use the grant moneyâin any case, I could support us both on my university salary . . .”
Margot is speaking rapidly, helplessly. She is so warm now, she tugs off the heavy-knit sweater. A flush rises through her body, groin to face. Almost, she fears that Jonathan Mateson can see her: a woman of late middle age, untidy dark hair shot with white wires, the former girl's face contorted in an expression of yearning, hope, and shame.
Mateson is embarrassed for Margot Sharpe, it seems. He has heard the raw yearning in her voice.
He asks her again why she would take on the burden of caring for an afflicted man who is no relative of hers and Margot tells him stiffly:
“It is the right thing to do, Mr. Mateson. Eli needsâsomeone to care for him.”
How close she has come to saying
Eli needs me.
Madness, desperation, folly.
Jonathan Mateson seems to be weighing the situation. Perhaps he feels sorry for her, suddenly. He tells Margot that her suggestion is unorthodox, he doesn't really think it's a feasible solution to the problem of Eli Hoopes but he will think about itâ“I'll discuss it with Eli's brothers and sister tomorrow. My
impression is they're all pretty much fed up with coddling their âbrain-damaged' sibling. In the meantime, thank you for calling, Doctorâis it âSharpe'?”
“Yes. âSharpe.'”
Quietly as an indrawn breath, Margot breaks the phone connection. She finishes the glass of whiskey, sticky-fingered. And then so light-headed, she can manage only to stumble to her bed before collapsing on it.
THE RAVENOUS LOVER.
In her sleep she feels him. The man's touch, his mouth, his body hot and aching with life, and with desire. Everywhere against her skin she feels him.
It is a terror to her, the feeling comes so strong. She has been a cowardly woman, terrified of such feeling, the sex-sensation, that annihilates her, and leaves her desperate, helpless. It is how she knows that she loves the manâthis annihilation. It is a risk she will make for him, the risk of utter abnegation.
He is so much stronger than she. His arms close tight about her like the wings of a great bird, folding and clasping its prey.
The pen falls from her fingers to the floor. The notebook falls to the floor.
What has passed between us will not be recorded. It will be lost to all memory.
AXEL HIS NAME.
Skinny stoop-shouldered boy twisting Eli's arm behind his back. Whimpering with pain and Axel McElroy laughed. And pressing the canvas cushion from one of the heavy wooden Adirondack chairs against his face. Dirty cushion Axel said smirking, people's asses on it. Terrified he'd be suffocated forced onto the ground and the canvas cushion against his face and Axel leaning
on it, hardâit was a joke (he wanted to think it was a joke) but it continued too long so his skin was scraped, his nose bleeding and he was trying to scream but could not.
The bishop's grandson they said of him. Axel he'd hated, and was frightened of for Axel was like no one else they knew, his brothers too were fearful of the older boy for Axel would say and do anything but never so adults knew. Nasty gestures with his hands like pulling at himselfâat his crotch. The girls looked away, disgusted. Eli had tried to make Axel go away but he was too small and too weak. Upper arm so skinny, Axel could close his fingers around it laughing. The girl cousins were laughing. His cousin Gretchen looked away. She was laughing at poor shamed Eliâwas she? Would not ever forgive her. Wished she would die. In a canoe, he'd tip over the damn canoe and she would drown in the lake. Wanted to run from Axel but Axel'd catch his arm, grab his hair pretending he was going to “scalp” Eli. He was such a little boy, and a coward. The older cousins laughed at him if but tenderly feeling sorry for him. And Averill laughed at him, and Harry. Hiding beneath the porch and they had no idea where he'd gone. Through slats in the lattice he spied on them. Girls' bare legs, hair tied back in ponytails for swimming. His cousin Gretchen only eleven but tall for her ageâ“mature”âtrusted with little children. Flat little breasts in a pink halter-top, elastic-ribbed pink swimsuit panties. Bright fair-brown hair shining in the sun, ponytail trailing down her back. Her pale legs, bare feet. Her family had just come to the lake, it was their first week that summer. “Eli? Eli?”âshe'd called for him. And he had not crawled out.
Telling the other children not to play on the dock, she'd be right back. Maybe she'd been flattered by the older boy Axel McElroy the bishop's grandson who was seventeen and wore his hair in a pompadour like Elvis Presley.
He had not seen where she'd gone. Not in which direction she'd
gone. Hiding beneath the porch embarrassed and ashamed and filled with hatred for them all not just Axel McElroy the bishop's grandson but all of themâGretchen too.
And later he had more reason to be ashamed. No way to make it right. No words for how cowardly he was, more contemptible than anyone knew.
Shameful too, their father drank too much. When Gretchen was missing Byron Hoopes drank too much and could not keep up with the other adults searching in the woods. And there was Granddaddy's chrome-yellow Beechcraft single-prop. An airstrip had been cleared on the Hoopes property for Granddaddy's aircraft. Convinced that they would find the missing girlâthey would find Gretchen where she'd wandered in the woods and they would bring her home in the little prop-plane. Except the plane lost altitude suddenly above the lake and Granddaddy had to “crash-land.” And they did not find Gretchen.
They had not found her in the woods. Not then.
He had not seen her in death. He had abandoned her, he'd been angry with her and had not seen her ever again.
Prayed to God, to bring Gretchen back. But God was higher than the highest white pine and paid him no heed.
(Where is this place? Why is he here? He has a vague memory of his office at Hoopes & Associatesâstaring out the window at high-rise buildings in the near distance. Windows of winking glass. Behind these windows, who?)
The view from the window here is very different. Not downtown Philadelphia, but an older residential neighborhood. He is in a “hospital” or a “clinic”âhe thinks. At this height he can see a short distance. The tree line is ragged. Badly he regrets the days of his youth, he'd felt the presence of God so easily. And he'd lost God out of carelessness and self-absorption and now it is too late, he is damned.
In his white skin he is damned.
Trying to raise the window. But it is not a window that one can raise. Frustrated and furious brings his head against the plate-glass pane. Forehead against the paneâhard enough to draw blood, and harder.
She is very frightened. Her throat is very dry.
In San Francisco she is addressing the AAEP (American Association of Experimental Psychology) in a ballroom so vast, the farther, facing wall is barely visible. In Chicago she is addressing the NICN (National Institute of Cognitive Neuroscientists), rows upon rows of uplifted faces blurred and indistinct as the faces in dreams. In Washington, D.C., the NIH (National Institutes of Health)âwaves of applause lapping at her feet, rising swiftly to cover her mouth and engulf her. In Orlando, Floridaâin Seattle, Washingtonâin Denver, Coloradoâin Boston, New York City, Philadelphiaâshe feels the rush of blood in her ears, the rapid drumbeat of her heart, as she makes her way through a glare of lights to a podium and a figure darts beside her whose face she can't see gripping her elbow tightly to steady herâ“This way, Professor. Watch that step.”
She is giving a keynote address. She is accepting an award. She is reading a paper. She is participating in a symposium. She is answering questions posed to her by an interviewer even as a part of her mind yearns for
him.