Their Little Girl (5 page)

Just the thought of having Daddy’s hard cock inside me was all the visual I needed to send me spiralling into a climax so intense that my body shook uncontrollably for what felt like hours until warm liquid began to gush from my quivering pussy.

What was that?

“Oh yeah... fuck. Did you see that?” Daddy praised, unable to tear his eyes away from the area between my legs. “Our little girl is a squirter.”

“Fuck. That looked so hot, Erica,” David agreed. “I think I’m gonna need a taste.”

My eyes widened at his words, surprised at what he was planning. No one had ever touched my pussy before today, much less
tasted it
...

I felt a twinge of anxiety then excitement as he lifted my leg off his and helped to settle me on Daddy’s lap so that I could lean back against his broad chest, positioning me the way he wanted me, my heels resting on Daddy’s knees, holding me so that when his legs moved farther apart,
my legs
would spread further.

He didn’t hesitate to make sure I opened wide for David.

“Oh fuck,” I whimpered as he bent in front of me, his eyes dark and seductive as he stared down at my exposed body, making me shiver at the thought of what he was about to do.

“Try not to squirm too much, Erica. You don’t want to fall off Daddy’s lap now, do you?” David teased before running his large hands up and down my thighs soothingly. My body shuddered in response, but I didn’t move as he leaned forward and skimmed his nose over my slit, breathing deeply as his eyes rolled back in pleasure. “Intoxicating.”

Within seconds, David warm lips enveloped my clit, and he began to kiss and lick the sensitive spot, swirling his tongue around it as if my little nub was a sticky-sweet lollipop.

This time around,
my
eyes were the ones rolling back, my breath catching in my throat as my body stiffened in response to the wave of pleasure that had my pussy clenching harder than ever before.

“Did David make you come?” Daddy whispered in my ear before his hands began to wander the expanse of my breasts, fingers tugging and massaging.

The sensation of having Daddy’s strong hands and David’s talented tongue simultaneously working my body into a frenzy of pleasure was nearly enough to drive me mad with lust.

I’d never felt so much desire in my life.

Just as I was coming down from that pulse-pounding climax, Daddy announced that it was his turn to show off his tongue-twisting talents and proceeded to hand me over to David, placing me in the same position I’d been in before, but on my stepbrother’s lap this time.

Unlike David, who took his time focusing on my clit, Daddy seemed to go straight for my tight little hole, licking the juices from around the entrance before he plunged his warm tongue inside, making me whimper and whine pathetically in response to the soft thrusting sensation that was almost on the verge of tickling me with every single flick and curl.

Then, as if I’d been shocked, my body jolted as Daddy’s finger began to probe my other hole. It was slippery though, and with a small amount of pressure, his finger slid right in, making me moan and writhe in David’s lap.

Oh... that feels so good!

Daddy pulled his finger out of me and began to squirt some clear liquid into his hand from a small bottle he’d been keeping in his pocket. Once his fingers were coated, he slid one back in again, but then immediately began trying to slip in a second.

“Daddy!” I gasped, tensing.

“Just relax, baby. It’ll feel so good if you relax,” he soothed. I did as he said, ignoring the slight burn, until finally, my body turned to jelly allowing me to accept the second finger with ease.

After a moment, Daddy’s fingers began to slide in and out, scissoring, widening and expanding in a way that had me gasping in pleasure with each thrust.

He was stretching me.

“Did you enjoy watching my little movie, Erica?” David asked suddenly, shocking me with the confirmation that Daddy had, in fact, shared my most private secret. Had Daddy’s talented tongue not been buried deep in my pussy, I might have kicked him for embarrassing me like that, but at the moment, I was too far gone to care.

My inner walls clenched at the thought of either Daddy or David fucking me for the first time, spilling their cum deep inside. I didn’t care which one did it, as long as they did it soon.

Already I craved it, ached for it.

“Yes, “ I admitted finally, my voice quiet and shy as I intentionally avoided David’s eyes “and I want... I want you to do that to me.”

“You want me to fuck you?” David asked, and I felt Daddy pause, his mouth no longer moving against my pussy as he waited to hear my answer.

“Yes,” I gasped. “And...”

“And what?” Daddy asked, pulling away.

He looked at me the way a starving man would look at a juicy steak, his chin glistening and wet with my juices as his eyes held me in place with their intensity.

“And... Daddy... I want you too, Daddy,” I told him quietly, feeling embarrassed by my admission. “Can’t I have you both?”

“Of course you can, sweetie. I already told you that your present was
us
. So you’ll get us both.”

“At the same time?” I hedged hopefully, my voice rough and filled with lust.

“Before we try anything, David and I have to make sure our little girl is ready to take both our cocks at once. We don’t want to hurt you. Okay?” His reassurance made me relax immediately, and I nodded, knowing instinctively that Daddy and David would never intentionally hurt me. They only wanted to protect me and make sure I was safe and happy and loved.

“Okay,” I replied with a grin, but cried out in pleasure as Daddy’s slick fingers began drilling my asshole again, pumping in and out, stretching me so I’d be prepared for either him or David to fuck me there. His mouth went back to work, licking and sucking, teasing my body into a frenzy till I thought my heart might beat it’s way right out of my chest.

...

My body was feeling nice and relaxed as I luxuriated on the couch. Daddy and David seemed to be having a bit of a discussion, and it sounded as if they were deciding what to try next.

“Would you like David to be the one to fuck your pussy for the first time?” Daddy asked suddenly. I looked up, wondering if I’d see jealousy on his face, but he looked too excited and horny for that.

When I really thought about it, I
did
want David to be the first one inside me, but I wanted Daddy too. My pussy clenched at the thought of having him inside me, of finally finding out, after all his teasing, how big his cock really was, but there was just something about David that drew me in. Something that couldn’t be denied.

Maybe I wanted David more, simply because I’d been fantasizing about him for so long, imagining what it would be like if I ever got the chance to be with him.

Yes... David should be my first.

My mouth didn’t seem to be willing to form the words that rested on the tip of my tongue, so I nodded, unable to look at David just yet. Thankfully, though, I could tell by the look on Daddy’s face that he was okay with my decision.

It was then that he and David both began to move in on me, their eyes hungry as they wandered over my body, taking in my disheveled state.

“Stand up, sweetie,” Daddy directed, as David offered me his hand. I looked up at him shyly, turning my eyes toward his mouth as Daddy began unbuttoning my cardigan. Once my sweater was in a pile on the floor with my panties, he then moved on, removing my blouse as well.

Before I could blink, David wrapped his arms around me, practically embracing me until his fingers began pulling at the hooks on my bra, popping them open so he could free me from the confines of the silky fabric.

Feeling slightly self-conscious, I moved to cover myself from their appraising eyes, folding my arms over my breasts as the silky bra fell to the floor with my shirt and sweater. “Remember what I told you, Erica?” Daddy asked sternly. “You are beautiful, and you don’t need to hide from us.”

“Okay, Daddy,” I whispered uncertainly, but did as I was told and uncovered myself.

They grinned at each other briefly before moving toward me, mouths poised to envelop my stiff nipples. My cries of pleasure were embarrassingly loud as they licked and sucked, tasting my sensitive skin.

“Fuck, Erica. I need to be inside you. Now,” David said suddenly, dropping to his knees slide my skirt down my legs, leaving me in nothing but my black Mary Janes and white kneesocks.

Completely exposed, my body shivered with anticipation as David stood up and moved in as if to kiss me. My eyes were glued to his, thrilled that he wanted me this way, but instead of feeling his lips on mine, I felt the hot breath of his whispered words in my ear. “Now I want you to be a good little girl and lay down over there, okay?” David directed, pointing to the plush rug in front of our family mantle.

I nodded quickly, watching my stepbrother in awe. He could have had his pick of a multitude of women, beautiful women like his friend Kara, but he wanted me. He wanted to be my first, and I found myself smiling at the thought as I moved toward the rug while they both began to undress in front of me.

Shirts were unbuttoned, Daddy’s tie untied. David slipped out of his tennis shoes, and then they each began sliding pants and jeans down masculine legs, exposing their bodies for my appraisal. I couldn’t imagine a more erotic sight than watching Daddy and David strip down to their underwear, their cocks hard and thick, begging for relief. It was almost too much.

“You look so goddamn gorgeous, sweetie,” Daddy said, moving toward me. My eyes were fixed on his grey boxer briefs, unable to look away as his erection bobbed inside them with every step he made. “You wanna see Daddy’s cock?”

Of course he noticed me staring. I tried not to let my embarrassment show and nodded, because I really did want to see it. Daddy smiled at my enthusiasm and began to slowly slide his underwear down over his hips, startling me when his thick cock suddenly sprang out toward me.

“Oh!” I yelped in surprise.

Once the shock had worn off, I quickly sat up a little, hoping to get a better look.

Daddy’s cock was long and thick, and so hard. Now that I’d seen it, I really wanted him inside my mouth. I wanted to taste him just like he tasted me.

I’d been so fascinated watching Daddy that I was startled again when I realized David was standing nearby, already naked, watching me as he stroked himself.

Oh, god
... I wanted to taste his cock too.

“Can I... can I try putting one in my mouth?” I asked shyly, not directing my question to either one of them in particular.

“Soon,” was all Daddy said before brushing a little strand of hair away from my face.

It was then I realized that David was ready, moving closer and closer till he began to hover over me. Working his way up my body, I kept my eyes trained down, wanting to see what it would look like when he slid his thick cock inside my pussy.

Will it even fit?

“Don’t worry, Erica. I’m gonna take it slow, okay?”

My eyes must have been wide with anticipation for him to feel like he needed to comfort me.

“Okay,” I agreed, reminding myself that David would do his best to make sure I wasn’t in any pain.

“Wrap your legs around my hips,” he directed, holding his cock in one hand while he propped himself up with the other. I did as I was told, moving into position so he could line himself up at my entrance.

“You’re probably going to feel a bit of a pinch, sweetie, but it shouldn’t hurt long,” Daddy said as he watched from beside me.

Before, I even had time to respond, David’s cock was pressing against my soaked entrance, and I could feel the head slipping in. Already it felt like a tight squeeze, but so good.

My eyes met his, silently telling him I was ready for him to keep going.

“Fuck... she’s tight,” he growled but began to push forward, sinking into me inch by inch. It burned a little, but in a way it still felt good, especially knowing that it was David who was making me feel this way, that it was David inside me my first time.

I couldn’t help but whimper, though, especially when the pain escalated briefly, and he stopped moving, his gaze searching mine for a sign that I was okay. Even though my eyes had begun to water, I smiled, wanting more than anything for him to push the rest of the way in so he was buried deep inside me. Slowly, his hips surged forward again, further and further until he was finally all the way in.

“Does it hurt much?” he asked, his voice rasping a bit as he struggled to hold still.

“Not too much... it’s just... so big,” I gasped, jerking my hips a little, wanting to feel him moving inside me again. Finally, he did.

He slowly pulled back until he was nearly all the way out, before pushing back in again. David repeated that action, doing it over and over until my hips began moving in response, encouraging him to move faster.