Mary Turner had been on her knees in prayer for over an hour when she saw the police carriage pass by the front window of her cottage.
âThey're leaving, oh Lord,' she moaned. âThey're leaving, and now there will be no justice for my Joseph.'
She realized, with horror, that what she had just said might well be interpreted by the Almighty as a complaint.
âI know, oh Lord, that my Joseph will get his reward in heaven, and that those who took his life will burn forever in hellfire,' she said quickly, âbut is it so wrong for me to wish for justice in this world, as well as the next?'
She waited for an answer, but though she was practised in praying, she did not know how to listen.
It had always been Joseph who'd listened â who'd got the answer directly from God and had passed it on to her. And now Joseph could tell her no longer, because he was dead.
She rose stiffly to her feet, and walked over to the table, where her Bible was resting.
She was as poor a reader as she was a listener, but she knew there were countless examples in the Good Book of the wicked being punished for their sins on earth.
Perhaps it was not part of the Lord's plan for Joseph's murderers to be punished in the here and now, she thought. Perhaps, by striving for that herself, she was going against His wishes. But if she was, He would forgive her in time, because that was what an all-merciful God did.
She paced the room, and slowly the life came back to her aching knees.
She had no idea what to do next, she thought, almost in despair.
There had been times when â weak woman that she was â she had silently questioned the wisdom of the rule that the womenfolk of the Soldiers of God should be kept well away from the affairs of the corrupt world in which they lived.
Not any more!
She'd needed that protection, because she was useless â because she couldn't think of a single way in which she could help avenge her husband's death.
Unless . . .
Unless his unexplained trips to New York really
had had
something to do with his murder.
â
He was not killed because of
who
he was, he was killed because of
where
he was
,' she had said to Blackstone.
And part of her â most of her â still believed that.
But there was also a small â insistent â voice nagging away at the back of her mind, which said if there was even the
slightest
chance he could have died for another reason, it was her duty to find out what that reason was.
She came to a halt at the table, almost as if it had been preordained that she should do so.
It was at this table that Joseph had spent hour upon hour studying the Holy Writ. But it was at the same table that he had written his reports to the Vicar General, and nightly recorded his efforts to carry out God's work in his journal.
She had never seen the journal â it was another of the things she was to be shielded from.
But she knew where he kept it!
It was in the locked drawer under the table top.
She found herself wondering â for the first time in her married life â
why
Joseph had kept the drawer locked.
Was it that he hadn't trusted her?
No, that couldn't be it!
He had trusted her, but he hadn't trusted the
Devil
,
who might find a way to tempt her at any time.
And was it the Devil who was tempting her at that moment, now that she no longer had her husband's protection?
If it was, she didn't care. She wanted to see her husband's journals â more than she could ever remember wanting
anything
.
The drawer was locked, as it always was, and no amount of tugging would force it to open.
But she was not to be deterred. Not now.
Using her husband's hammer and chisel, she set to attacking the drawer. She was not very adept â this, again, was man's work â but she was determined, and kept at it even after she cut herself.
At the end of five minutes, the drawer and a chunk of the table top were all but destroyed â but she had the journal in her bloody hand, and had never felt so empowered in her life.
The animated conversation between Blackstone and Meade â which Flynn had so accurately noted from his hiding place in the woods â continued as the police carriage drew ever closer to the Coney Island streetcar terminal.
âHolt's kidnapping just has to have been a professional job, Sam,' Meade argued, for perhaps the fifth or sixth time.
âI'm not saying it wasn't
carried out
by professionals,' Blackstone countered, âonly that it wasn't
commissioned
by them.'
âSo the guys who Holt had ruined finally decided to have their revenge on him?' Meade asked sceptically.
âIt's a possibility.'
âWhy would they wait seven years?'
âI don't know,' Blackstone admitted. âPerhaps, after they had the bookkeeper killed, they lost their nerve.'
âThat's a weak argument even if Rudge
was
murdered,' Meade said. âAnd if he wasn't . . .' he added with a shrug.
Blackstone felt a sense of pride that his protégé had enough confidence to argue his case so strongly â and also a sense of grievance that this still-wet-behind-the-ears pipsqueak was daring to question his judgement.
âIf it
was
them â and if they
do
hate him so much â why didn't they just have him killed?' Meade demanded.
âIf they'd had him killed, they'd never get the ransom money, which they probably see as a small return for what they lost,' Blackstone said. âBesides, they may not want him dead. They may just want to see him humiliated. They may want to show that they can buy and sell him â just as he bought and sold them!'
âAnd if a couple of guards get killed along the way, that's no concern of theirs?' Meade asked.
âIf the businessmen
are
behind it, I don't think they ever intended the guards to die,' Blackstone said.
âThey must have known that if you employ thugsâ'
âThey knew
nothing
! That's the point! They come from the cosy civilized world of New York society â they have no idea of just how violent some men from outside that world can be.'
âI still don't see it,' Alex Meade said stubbornly.
âSo let's look at
your
theory,' Blackstone said, trying not to sound irritated. âA gang of criminals, somewhere on â say â the Lower East Side, decide to kidnap a rich man and hold him for ransom. Right?'
âRight,' Meade agreed cautiously.
âThey sit around and discuss their possible targets. They know that they only have to go along Fifth Avenue, late at night, to see any number of millionaires returning from a party, guarded only by their coachmen. But they reject that idea. And what do they choose to do instead? They choose to go way beyond their normal stamping ground and snatch a man from a bunker which is guarded by two armed Pinkertons!'
âFor God's sake, Sam, they knew the Pinkertons would be no problem, because they were working with Fanshawe. And that's also precisely why they selected Holt rather than any other millionaire â because it was
Fanshawe's
plan!'
Blackstone shook his head. âHowever are we going to conduct this investigation when we can't even agree on a starting point?' he asked.
âMaybe we could conduct
two
investigations,' Meade said. âYou follow up any leads you can find on the disgruntled businessmen, and I'll go and listen to the rumblings in the underworld.'
It sounded like a suggestion, Blackstone thought, but it wasn't â it was a challenge!
Apart from a ball of fluffy cotton-wool hair perched precariously over each of his ears, the Dean of the Cornell University Medical School was totally bald. He had a largish â almost Roman â nose, on which rested a pair of half-moon glasses, and he seemed to Ellie Carr to look
more
like a dean than any dean had a right to.
âIt really is most kind of you to give up some of your valuable time to instruct our students,' the Dean said.
âIt's my pleasure,' Ellie replied.
And so it was. The Americans were treating her like a princess, and while she told herself that a serious scientist like her didn't need that kind of adulation, she was rather starting to enjoy it.
âIt has been proposed that we schedule you to perform an autopsy which some of our brighter students would be allowed to monitor,' the Dean said. âWould you have any objection to that?'
âNone at all,' Ellie replied.
The Dean coughed awkwardly. âI must admit that I was opposed to it at first, and it was only with some reluctance that I allowed my colleagues to talk me round to the idea.'
âOh?' Ellie said. âAnd why were you opposed to it, if I may ask?'
âI was afraid you might find our young men a little hard to handle.'
âBecause I'm a woman?'
âPartly. And partly because you're English.'
âWell, there's nothing I can do about either of those things,' Ellie said airily.
âQuite,' the Dean agreed. âBut I thought it was only fair to warn you that, in the past, some of our colleagues from England have found our American ways a little brash for their taste.'
âYer don't know what brash is till yer've been fru the East End of a Sat'dy night,' Ellie said.
âI beg your pardon?'
âI'm sure I'll be able to handle it.'
âThe problem is exacerbated, you see, by the type of young men we have here,' the Dean pressed on. âNaturally, they all come from very good families.'
âNaturally,' Ellie agreed drily.
âAnd no doubt, in time, they'll all make excellent physicians. But their background does tend to give them rather more self-confidence in their own abilities than one might consider desirable in someone who is here mainly to learn.'
âIn other words, they're arrogant little bleeders.'
âI beg your pardon!' the Dean said, for a second time.
âI said, “That doesn't matter, as long as they're good readers.”'
âI'm not sure I quite follow you, but no matter,' the Dean said. He consulted the sheet of paper which lay on the desk in front of him. âThe particular cadaver we have in mind for you is a suicide victim,' he continued. âYou have no objection to that, do you?'
âNo objection at all, but if you have a corpse that's had an argument with an express train â and lost â then you'd really be giving me something to work with,' Ellie said.
âI'm not sure we canâ' the Dean began.
âOnly joking,' Ellie told him. âA suicide will do me fine. After all, we don't want to give your nice young men nightmares. How did this suicide victim die, by the way?'
âHe hanged himself.'
âPoor soul,' Ellie said. âStill, at least he's given me an interesting prop to work with.'
They shook hands, and the Dean showed her to the door of his office.
It was only when she was in the corridor that he placed a hand on her shoulder and smiled.
âBy the way, you were right, Dr Carr,' he said.
âRight?' Ellie repeated. âRight about what?'
âThey are arrogant little bleeders,' the Dean said.
Eileen O'Grady was in her late forties, and was regarded by the Irish community of Coney Island as a fine figure of woman â which was another way saying that she had childbearing hips and the strong muscular legs of a natural potato picker.
She had run her boarding house for eight years.
âThere was no choice in the matter,' she would tell her cronies. âWhat else could I do after that fecker O'Grady had run away with a circus midget?'
Her friends would nod, sympathetically, although they knew that the woman âthat fecker O'Grady' had run off with had been an athletic trapeze artist rather than a midget, and that, as much as Eileen might bemoan running the boarding house, she really rather enjoyed it.
Her favourite lodger was undoubtedly Inspector Flynn, who had been with her for over two years. He was quiet and somewhat withdrawn, but after twenty years of living with her loud-mouthed fecking husband, she considered that something of a bonus.
Occasionally, when they were both in the mood, she would take Flynn to her bed. She did not flatter herself that she was his ideal woman, nor did she particularly want to be
his
woman at all, but it was pleasant and comforting, and when it was all over and they went downstairs again, they found it easy enough to return to their normal landladyâtenant relationship.
It therefore came as something of a shock to her, that late morning, to find Flynn not only in his room but packing his few possessions into his suitcase.
âYou're surely not thinking of moving out on me, are you, Mr Flynn?' she asked.
âMy rent's paid up until the end of the month, Mrs O'Grady,' Flynn replied, avoiding the question.
âAs if the thought of money had even entered my mind, Mr Flynn!' Mrs O'Grady's hands automatically moved to her hips in a gesture of displeasure.
âThe fact is, Mrs O'Grady, that the police force owes me a great deal of leave, and I've finally decided to take some of it,' Flynn said.
âAnd where will you go?'
âTo the city.'
âNew York?'
âIs there any
other
city, on this side of the water, worth talking about?' Flynn asked.