East to the Dawn (87 page)

Read East to the Dawn Online

Authors: Susan Butler

BOOK: East to the Dawn
8.74Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
page 45: “All I knew ...”: GPP, S W, p. 24.
The End of Childhood
page 47: the three men would retire ...: Patricia Antich interview.
page 47: “I didn't like him,”: KCP interview.
page 47: what manner of man ...: Ibid.
page 48: “the happiest of times.”: MEM,
CITP,
p. 26.
page 48: still he needed more money ...: Ibid., p. 28
page 48: “This news is a terrible ...”: Ibid., p. 27; Edwin's letter is dated May 12, 1903.
page 49: a vacation spot ...: GPP, SW, p. 31.
page 49: Lucy called them horse pies ...: GPP,
SW,
p. 31.
page 49: calling her Dr. Bones.: GPP,
SW,
p. 10.
page 50: “Dear Madam: ...”: Edwin Earhart, letter to MEM, Aug. 2, 1909.
page 50: contingent on moving ...: Des Moines city directory, 1908; Edwin Earhart is listed as a claims agent living at 1443 Eighth Street.
page 50: after “Millie” Earhart left ...: interview with Orpha Tonsing, Martin,
Family Tree.
page 50: they lived in four houses....: Des Moines city directories for those years. Muriel, writing many years later, claimed that they had lived in only the one house on Cottage Grove Avenue, but she was writing fifty years after the fact. The Cottage Grove house was the last happy home for her and her family for many years.
page 51: “He bore on his nose ...”: AE,
FOI,
p. 8.
page 51: “an end to the pinchpenny days ...”: MEM,
CITP,
p. 55.
page 51: “Bring the girls ...”: JM,
LITHW,
III p. 7, SLRC.
page 51: They traveled in it ...:
AG,
July 20, 1976.
page 51: a sumptuous dinner ...: MEM,
CITP,
p. 72.
page 52: The same year the Earharts ...: Drake Neighborhood Association,
From Keokuk On: The History of the Cottage Grove Area,
p. 27, published by the Association.
page 52: They found Von Sol ...: GPP,
SW,
p. 28.
page 52: silk party dresses ...: MEM,
CITP,
p. 77.
page 52: she liked the German composers ...: AOE interview, SLRC.
page 53: an expensive set of Kipling's ...: MEM,
CITP,
p. 69.
page 53: “wrote him the most hysterical appeals ...”: Mark Otis, letter to Charles Otis, Sept. 17, 1913: “It is only two years ago that he left her and although Mother offered to make suitable provision for her and the children at the time, she would have none of it and wrote him the most hysterical appeals to return, one of which he was graceless enough to send to me.” Forwarding the letter to Mark backfired—badly. Mark had thought little of Edwin to start with and even less now—he thought him contemptible for committing such a “graceless” act. And he thought less of his sister. He would later use the information to undermine her credibility with the family.
page 54: “although Mother offered to make ...”: Ibid.
page 54: “It is a great deal more ...”: E. W Howe,
Country Town Sayings,
p. 294.
page 54: Theodore, who sat all day ...: KCP interview. “It is my
will
that only the net income of the shares of my estate devised to my children Amy O. Earhart and Theo. H. Otis shall be paid over to them annually and that the entire principal and capital thereof shall be managed and controlled by my said Trustee Mark E. Otis for the said period of fifteen years after my death upon the trust hereinbefore described.”
page 54: she dictated a letter: Letter given to author by Nancy Balis Morse.
page 55: the terms of her will ...: On file, District Court, Atchison County, Kansas.
page 55:
The Atchison Globe
printed ...: AG, Feb. 24, 1912.
page 55: wasn't totally accurate ...: Exhibit A, case #11220; District Court, Atchison County, Kansas.
page 55: Ephraim even agreed ...: AOE, letter to Charles Otis, Mar. 18, 1913. (“I felt sure uncle Eph would not have spoken as he did about them if they had not been thoroughly trustworthy.”) Mark Otis, Margaret Balis, and Amy “agreed by and between the parties hereto that all necessary and proper steps be immediately taken for the appointment of said The Northern Trust Company [of Chicago, Illinois] as such Successor in Trust.” Given to author by Nancy Balis Morse.
page 56: On the first Sunday in May, ...:
AG,
May 7, 1912.
page 56: “he sat on the porch ...”: AG, May 8, 1912. Mark Otis, letter to Charles J. Conlon, Apr. 17, 1912: “I am also enclosing herewith the bond required by the State of Kansas duly signed by my father, the Northern Trust Co. and myself.” Given to author by Nancy Balis Morse.
page 56: the family members who attended ...:
AG,
May 11, 1912.
page 56: a lengthy document ...: was filed in Probate Court in Atchison County, June 28, 1912.
page 57: “All the old bitterness ...”: MEM,
CITP,
p. 83.
page 58: raced to meet him ...: Ibid., p. 79.
page 58: “It was our ‘old' Dad, ... : Ibid., pp. 82—83.
page 58: “I am now safe ...”: Ibid., p. 84.
page 59: Before long ...: Ibid., p. 83.
page 59: “We did have such a delightful ...”: Charles Earhart, letter to AOE, May 22, 1912; given to author by Nancy Balis Morse..
page 60: I cannot depend ...: AOE, letter to Charles Otis, Jan. 21, 1913; given to author by Nancy Balis Morse. The text of this letter is as follows:
My dear Uncle Charlie
I had expected to run in and see you for a little while tomorrow, but at the last moment some housekeeping matters prevented my coming to St. Paul with my husband, so I am asking him to leave some papers with you which I wish you would look over for me, and see if everything is being done as it should be. I cannot depend on my husbands opinions in this matter as the feeling between Mark and himself is so bitter than an unbiased opinion would be impossible while when I ventured to ask Mark for explanations of certain things, he immediately felt that I had been incited to ask by my husband, and has been suspicious and angry ever since.
I have no intention of breaking dear mother's will, and while I cannot help feeling that she would have been far more careful about guarding poor Theodore's and my interest if she had been her normal self when the will was written,
I understand only too well her great anxiety that we be protected from the dangers that seemed to threaten me especially but on the other hand I spent so many years of my life near her and was with her weeks and months at a time, and knew so well her opinions of the business ability of each of us children that I know it was only in a spirit of desperation that things were left as they were. Mark does not realize and has blamed me for an atmosphere of seeming distrust of his business ability, which he had found lately in Atchison but Dear Uncle Charlie I have absolutely nothing to do with it, and have myself had letters urging me to look out for Theodore and myself as at the end of fifteen years there would be nothing left for either of us. I have been very careful not to say anything that would at all show any distrust to anyone and even to my husband I do not dare show any anxiety but there seemed such discrepancies between the appraisement of the properties at first and the reports to the State Department and the Trust Company that I felt as if I would like you to look over the papers for me and tell me whether it is only that I do not understand the statements that make them seem at variance.
page 60: I know truly ...: AOE, letter to Charles Otis, Mar. 18, 1913; given to author by Nancy Balis Morse.
page 60: “Plain, modest, ... :
St. Paul History and Progress
(Pioneer Press Co., 1897), p. 167.
page 60: Charles had at various times ...: Biographical reference data filed by Charles Otis for
The Dispatch and Pioneer Press,
St. Paul Public Library.
page 61: “the combination of a sick maid ...”: AOE, letter to Charles Otis, Mar. 18, 1913; in author's possession.
page 61: Mark, in a preemptive strike, ...: Mark Otis, letter to Charles Otis, Sept. 9, 1913; records of Atchison County Court. She gave 1021 Ann Street as her residence in 1916.
page 61: “While the same is on the order ...”: Mark Otis, letter to Charles Otis, Mar. 12, 1913; given to author by Nancy Balis Morse.
page 62: the chauffeured Rolls-Royce ...: Morse interview.
page 63: Dear Mark; You will be ...: AOE, letter to Mark Otis, Sept. 3, 1913; given to author by Nancy Balis Morse.
page 64: “this will be supplemented ...”: Mark Otis, letter to Charles Otis, Sept. 9, 1913; given to author by Nancy Balis Morse.
page 64: Now, about Amy, pray ...: Mark Otis, letter to Charles Otis, Sept. 17, 1913; given to author by Nancy Balis Morse. The text reads:
I am just in receipt of a long letter from Amy which I have only had a chance to hastily glance over, but which points out
most distressing conditions. It seems that E. lost his position last October and has done nothing scarcely for the family support since. She writes that she is penniless and speaks of a grocery bill and woman-like says nothing about any judgements or liens that may be outstanding against her interests under the trustee-ship. I immediately wired her to see you, as you have full power to act for me and as I stated in my first letter, any sums that you may advance for her temporary needs will be promptly repaid by myself immediately upon knowledge of the amount advanced....
Hastily and sincerely yours, [signed] Mark E. Otis
page 64: He took another day to ...: Mark Otis, letter to AOE, Sept. 19, 1913; given to author by Nancy Balis Morse. The text reads:
My dear Amy:
I have your letter and can assure you that there is no bitterness in my heart towards you and the children; I only regret your present straits and trust through the good offices of Uncle Charlie some means may be devised to intelligently assist you. You had better see him at once and give him the true statement of all your debts and promises to pay for rent, etc., any papers you may have signed relating to your interests under the trusteeship, then a statement of what is necessary for your immediate needs. Those together with your last reports from The Northern Trust Co. as to the amounts they let out at interest for you. This, then will enable him to determine how I can assist you in my capacity as President of The Otis Real Estate Co. or personally. However, from whichever source, it must be in the nature of a secured loan to be repaid in manner and time to be specified.
Amy would never know that it wasn't her uncle's fault but her brother‘s, never know just how devious Mark had been, how he had smeared her reputation with her uncle. Thus years later Muriel would write: “Mother's wealthy and prominent uncle and his family paid us one surreptitious ‘duty call.' They then ignored us completely. This was a bitter pill for Mother, who had never been treated as an unwelcome poor relation before.” So painful was Charles's snub that when I asked Muriel, some seventy years later, for the name of the uncle, she set her lips and refused to answer.
 
page 66: Forty years later Muriel ...: MEM,
CITP,
p. 88.
page 66: the church provided Amelia ...: JM,
LITHW,
III p. 14, SLRC.
page 66: friends and activities: ...: Patricia D. Brynteson, parish secretary, St. Clement's, letter to author; Marion Blodgett, interview with author.
page 66: Blessings on thee ...: AE, letter to Virginia Park, Mar. 6, 1914, SLRC.
page 67: Her 91 grade point average ...: Transcript, St. Paul Central High School.
Teenage Years
page 68: Upon arrival Edwin went ...: MEM,
CITP,
p. 94.
page 69: The family rolled around ...: AE,
FOI,
pp. 17-18.
page 69: She arrived at the train station ...: Katch Challiss, diary, Aug. 6-Sept. 7, 1914.
page 71: over a glass of milk ...: GPP,
SW,
p. 26.
page 71: Its student body ...: All material on Hyde Park High School, including
The Aitchpe,
the yearbook, was provided by Tom Staniszewski.
page 71: Amelia participated in none ...:
The Aitchpe,
1915. All school activities are noted beside each student's picture; Amelia's is blank.
page 72: In
The Aitchpe,
...: Many books, starting in 1937 with George Palmer Putnam's
Soaring Wings,
give the yearbook caption as “The girl in brown who walks alone.” Putnam presumably got it from Muriel; whether she made it up out of whole cloth is not known. But most biographies since have faithfully reprinted it, without ever seeing the yearbook.
page 72: She kept so much to herself ...:
Hyde Park Weekly,
vol. 25, no. 1 (Sept. 14, 1928).
page 73: (She laughingly remarked ...: Ibid.
page 73: attempted to resurrect his law practice ...: St. Paul city directory, 1915.
page 73: he moved to Kansas City ...: Kansas City directories, 1915-1918, in Kansas City, Missouri, Public Library.
page 73: Edwin joined them....: Address given on court documents, Atchison, Kansas.
page 73: Amy had never given up ...: Records of District Court, Atchison County, Kansas.
page 73: In September 1915 Amy ...: Petition #11220, District Court, Atchison, Kansas.
page 74: “a very silly place ...”: KCP interview.
page 74: Nor did Ogontz appeal ...: Morse interview.
page 75: she alone claimed the house ...: AOE quoted in Martin, Family Tree, p. 5. Philadelphia city directories for the years locate the house of Gebhard Harres, “cabinetmaker,” on South Third Street.
page 75: When Muriel wrote ...: MEM,
CITP,
p. 71.
page 75: she was almost totally deaf ...: Morse interview.

Other books

His Stand In by Rebecca K Watts
The Big Bite by Charles Williams
Man of My Dreams by Johanna Lindsey
On the Grind (2009) by Cannell, Stephen - Scully 08
The Oath by John Lescroart