Enticing Their Mate (11 page)

Once inside her bedroom, Jay set her down and turned her toward him. “Have you ever had two men at once?”

She was so turned on right now that he caught her off guard with his abrupt question. Sarah knew her cheeks wore a slight blush, but she wouldn’t shy away from his question. Honesty was best. “A few times, but none were memorable. You should know I’m thirty-two years old and I like sex. I hope that doesn’t put you off.”

His eyes brightened, and his scruff darkened. “Not at all. It makes it all the more fun and interesting.”

Everything seemed to be going just the way she wanted. Lightly running her hands down his muscular arms, she leaned in close. “Since I’ve had such a tragic day, how about letting me take care of you both first?” Using Russ’s attack was lame, but one she hoped they’d buy. Torturing them first would be a huge thrill.

Jay cupped her face. “Anything you want.”

“Anything?” She’d never met a man who would let her be in control for long. These two wouldn’t be an exception.

“Yes.” His breathing increased and his hair sprouted on the back of his hands and neck, which was a polite way of saying
no chance in hell
.

Riley stepped behind her, palmed her breasts, leaned over, and then whispered in her ear. “The longer you take, the rougher I’ll be.”

She loved it rough and dirty. “In that case, it might take me hours to get you two naked.”

He pinched her nipples through the bra. “You have no idea how you’re testing my resolve.”

She loved the way Riley made her feel so wanted. “Oh, yeah?”

He pushed the bra above her tits, cupped her shoulders, and leaned her back. “Let’s see if we can drive Jay crazy. What do you say, baby?”

She loved the idea. “I’m game.”

Jay’s teeth elongated. Some men were so easy. “Holy fuck, you’re perfect.”

She was about as far from perfect as the earth was from the moon, but why spoil it by telling him so. Sarah lifted her chest even higher, and when his lips latched onto her nipple, she planted her hands on his head. Holy shifters!

Each tug and lick sent pinpricks of delight all over her body, but if she let Jay continue to lavish his attention on her breasts, she’d be the first to break. She huffed out a breath. “I need to get you two naked. You promised.” Sort of.

Jay stepped back and Riley released her. “Help yourself. I’m all yours,” Jay said.

This might be the only opportunity she had to savor these two men, and she wanted to make the most of the time she had. “How about you both take off your shoes?”

Faster than either of them could shift, their boots tumbled across the room, followed by their socks. She tugged her bra back down over her tits for more comfort, but then decided she could tease them better if she removed it all together.

As soon as her fingers reached behind her, Riley was there. “Let me help.”

“You only get to take off this one item.”

Riley leaned over and gently bit her shoulder. “Telling a werewolf what he can and can’t do could be dangerous.”

She laughed. A playful Riley was a real treat. “I’ll be careful.” Once he unhooked her bra, he slipped the strap down her arms and tossed it on the floor next to Jay. Riley’s fingers set her skin on fire.

Jay bent over, picked it up, and inhaled deeply. “I love your scent.” His voice sounded close to a growl.

She thought he was just being nice, but his nails seemed to grow right before her eyes, and swirls of lust stabbed her belly. He wanted her. Testing their control might not be in her best interest, so she stepped away from both of them. “How about you two stand next to each other and close your eyes?”

Riley moved in front of her and clasped her shoulders. “You have a lot to learn about us. If we did as you asked, we wouldn’t be able to keep in human form.”

Riley had shown a lot of restraint in the storage closet. “Are you afraid of losing control?” she asked.

Jay’s eyes were hooded as he approached. “Hell yeah. No telling what we’d do once we let our animal loose.” He looked over at Riley. “I think we’ve let her have enough fun. Now, it’s our turn.”

She planted her hands on her hips. “Not until I’ve stripped you. Then you two can have at me.”

Jay cracked up. “We’re going to have a good time with you, Sarah Osmond.”

No more than she was with them.

T
o Sarah’s delight, Riley backed up, but when he started to unbutton his shirt, she raced over to him and swatted away his hands. “Uh-huh. That’s my job.”

“Then hurry. I’m burning for you.”

She worked to suppress a smile at his words. As she eased the next button through the loop, Jay snuck behind her and cupped her breasts. “I can’t get my fill of these.”

“Hold on. They’ll still be there in a minute.” Without warning, Jay dropped to his knees behind her and tugged down her shorts. “Whoa. I never said anything about removing
my
clothes.” Jay tapped her leg. With the material down at her ankles, she didn’t have much choice but to step out of them.

“We took a vote. We won,” Jay said, and this time she did smile.

“Okay, but no playing around yet. I’m not finished with Riley.”

“Take your time,” Jay said. “I plan to.”

He nipped her ass and she jerked. “Easy there.”

Hooking his thumbs in her waistband, he lowered her panties and her pussy nearly convulsed with need. This intense reaction had to be a carry over from this morning’s romp. She’d never been this turned on before and was having a hard time concentrating.

Her need drove her to finish undoing Riley’s shirt faster than she’d planned. As she reached up to slip the material off his shoulders, he lifted her by the waist and carried her straight-armed to the bed. She marveled at his strength especially since she was no lightweight.

Riley tugged off her panties. “You’re ours and we decide how we want things done.”

His command took her breath away. In truth, Sarah was perfectly fine with them taking the lead, but she didn’t want to appear to be someone who easily gave into their demands.

Naked, she stretched out on the bed. As they stripped before her, she was treated to double eye candy. Their abs and broad shoulders looked as if Michelangelo himself had chiseled their bodies then polished them to perfection. While she’d seen Riley mostly naked, watching him in all his glory brought a lump to her throat. As for Jay, his rigid cock seemed even bigger than Riley’s ginormous one, and had her pussy in a tizzy.

“Holy crap, guys. I’m not sure both of you will fit.” She could see that she hadn’t thought this through.

Jay crawled onto the bed. “Don’t worry. We’ll try to contain ourselves until you’re ready.”

She appreciated the sentiment, but now she was having second thoughts—that was until Jay spread open her legs and slid onto his stomach. The first lick had her clutching the spread and fighting for control. Her sensitive nub was slightly swollen from earlier in the day, but the bite of pain brought on a strong need, making her want them more.

“Don’t hog her, Jay.” Riley knelt on the bed and dragged the top half of her body toward him. “Need me some tits and lips.”

She shook her head. He was such a guy. The first tug on her nipple had her combusting with pleasure. She’d wanted to suck on their cocks to drive them crazy, but they seemed to have other plans. Tongues licked and teeth nipped. Damn men must have communicated because just as one let up the pressure, the other would pick up the slack. Between the two of them, she was embarrassingly close to a climax.

Sarah might have succeeded in holding on had Jay not slipped a finger into her wet hole at the same time he nabbed her clit. As she was shooting upward toward ecstasy, Riley dragged his lush lips between her breasts straight up across her chin and drew her lower lip between his teeth. His fingers pinched and rolled her nipples, and the intense pleasure burned in a good way.

She clutched the back of Jay’s head with one hand and grabbed a fistful of Riley’s hair with the other. Stars formed behind her lids as her orgasm swooped in.

On cue, both men sat back, as if to let her regain some composure. “Wow, that was incredible, although I really wanted to do that to you both first. Sorry I didn’t last longer,” she said.

Jay dragged himself next to her until his lips were inches from hers. “Don’t worry about us. It’s all about pleasuring you.”

At a loss for words, she reached out and twisted toward him. As she wrapped her arms around Jay, Riley climbed onto the bed and spooned behind her, slipping his cock between her legs.

“Oooh,” she said tightening her thighs to keep a good hold.

“Careful,” he growled.

He slid a hand between her arm and body and cupped her breast. When he pinched a nipple, heat raced straight to her core. Being sandwiched between two wonderfully talented men made her pulse race, and while their touches were beyond her wildest dreams, she wanted the sensations, too. As she dragged a palm down Jay’s rather thick stubble, enjoying the bristled texture, he twisted his head and slightly bit her palm. Oh, my, but his teeth were sharp.

As if the two had choreographed it, Jay rolled onto his back and pulled her on top, while Riley scooted behind, and then wedged his dick between her legs again.

“Why don’t you entertain Jay while I take care of that sweet ass of yours,” Riley said.

The thought of sucking on Jay’s cock while Riley widened her back hole had her dripping. “I’d love nothing more.”

Jay elbowed his way toward the head of the bed to give her better access to his cock. “Please don’t judge me if I’m weak. You do something to every cell in my body,” Jay said.

Both men were able to make her feel as if she was the only one for them. “I’ll be careful.”

“No, you need to be fast. I’m serious. I’m so fucking on edge and I want you more than words can express.”

If his eyes hadn’t been swirls of gold and his body didn’t keep switching between human and almost animal, she would have thought it was just another come-on line.

Riley moved off the bed. “Need a condom. You don’t have any lube do you?”

“That would be a no.”

“It’s okay. I’ll use your natural lubrication.”

Without Riley’s distracting presence for a moment, she grabbed Jay’s cock and leaned over. When she dragged her tongue along his length, he snatched a hunk of her hair, tugged, and growled. “What you do to me.”

She loved how sensitive both of her men were.
Both of my men?
Sarah wanted to live in the moment and not think about where this could lead.

As she drew Jay deep into her mouth, Riley returned and immediately slipped two fingers into her slick opening and then wiggled them around, causing a riot of wild need to course through her. She clamped down on his fingers to keep him there, and electric bolts sizzled across her body. Here Jay thought he was the one who wouldn’t last. Sarah was even weaker.

Riley withdrew his fingers and dragged them between her butt cheeks. On instinct, she squeezed her ass tight.

He tapped her rear. “None of that. You have to relax or I won’t be able to get my cannon into your delicious ass.”

Hearing him call his cock a cannon made her chuckle.

“You think that’s funny?”

She had to be honest. “Yes.”

“You just wait and see.” He rimmed the outside of her puckered hole with his lubricated finger, slowly lulling her into almost forgetting about what was to come.

Jay tightened his grip on her hair. Oh, crap. She’d been so into what Riley was doing that she’d forgotten about poor Jay. “Sorry, I was distracted.”

“That’s okay. I needed that moment to catch my breath.”

Which meant he needed time to return to his fully human form. Appreciating that, Sarah refocused on loving his hard dick. She pumped her fist up and down as she sucked on his length, swirling her tongue around his wide girth, while enjoying his tangy flavor. The harder he held her hair, the tighter and deeper she drew him in.

Jay then stiffened and growled. “Enough. I need your pussy now.”

Riley grabbed her waist and pulled her up. “Sit on him, love, and fuck him hard while I prepare you for true pleasure.”

Sheer joy at being with both men nearly overwhelmed her. Straddling Jay, she edged her way toward him until she was able to place his rigid cock at her entrance. The moment his big head breached her opening, she creamed all over him, making his entry easier. With controlled effort, she lowered herself but was met with resistance half way. He was too damned big.

Jay clasped his hands on her waist while Riley reached around her and pinched her nipples. Bolts of electricity skittered up and down her spine, releasing some of the tension in her inner walls.

Riley pressed her tits together and then leaned over and nabbed her earlobe between his teeth. “Enjoy the ride,” he whispered.

He was right. She needed to let go and love both men the best she could. With newfound determination, she lifted up, opened her legs wider, and lowered herself on Jay’s cock. Holy balls of fire, but the man was huge. His size stretched her to the max, but the friction on her inner walls was divine.

Riley pressed on her back to bend her over, giving him access to her rear. Chest to chest with Jay, she kissed him. He opened his mouth and met her lips with a gusto that caused streaks of riotous lust to go straight through her. His minty breath ignited something inside of her and she delved in, exploring what he had to offer. Their tongues tangled and jockeyed for position, and with each second that passed, desire flooded her and her heart rate increased.