Eye Candy (City Chicks) (20 page)

"That," I bit out when he finished his tale, "is the most ridiculous story I've ever heard."

Gavin looked taken aback that I didn't believe him. He had truly thought I would accept that fabrication as an explanation of what happened. And why did he insist on lying? It's not as if he had anything to prove with 
me
. I just wanted the truth. For my own mental health.

For several long, uncomfortable moments he just looked at me. Watched me. Assessed me.

"You never knew me at all," he finally said. "You couldn't have understood the depth of my love, or you never could have believed I would do such a thing." He ran his hands roughly through his hair, sending the neat locks in every direction.

I hadn't wanted to, that was for sure. It broke my heart into a million little pieces, leaving a box of Nerds rattling around in my chest.

Was it any wonder I hadn't dated anyone since we broke up.

When his eyes met mine, they shone with wetness.

"The truth is," he sounded resigned, deflated, "
you
 never really loved 
me
. Because love is trust, and you clearly didn't trust me."

My mouth dropped open.

His lies were impressively elaborate. Who but a pathological liar could turn his own adultery into an accusation that I'd never loved him? I had loved him more than I thought possible, and I got a great big dose of heartbreak for it.

This was not how I expected this conversation to turn out.

I wanted answers, not blame.

Gavin was not the injured party in this failed relationship.

"Tell yourself whatever you want," I said airily, shrugging Dyllie onto my shoulder with an indignant huff. "We both know what really happened."

"No, we don't—" He frowned. "Is your bag whining?"

I looked down to find Dyllie struggling to peek out of the tote, probably curious to see who I was talking to.

"It's nothing." Reaching into the tote, I tried to settle her back into her nap, but she was apparently up and ready for action. Faster than I could think, let alone react, she pulled herself up over the edge of the bag and let out a friendly 
yip
.

"When did you get a dog?" Gavin sounded like it was beyond the realm of comprehension that I would have a pet. Guess he hadn't noticed all the puppy-covered shopping bags.

"Last night," I answered sweetly. "Phelps gave her to me."

He scowled.

The perfect opportunity for my exit.

"Goodbye, Gavin."

I tried to sound decisive. Final. But he stood and collected the shopping bags from the corner.

"I'll walk you home." He waved off my protest. "I can't let you struggle to carry all these home. Especially this one," he hoisted the bag containing the food, "it weighs a ton."

As I left the café, Gavin on my heels with my shopping bags, I wondered how the conversation that had gone so wrong had ended with him helping me home.

"He even had the nerve to question the validity of my love for him." Swirling the ice in my Lemon Drop, I wondered how I had ever believed Gavin Fairchild was the picture perfect prince of my dreams.

He was a cad and a liar and I was well rid of him.

Bethany tapped a preoccupied finger on the bar. "I still can't believe Phelps gave you a puppy."

"A puppy is serious business," Fiona added. "Giving a girl a puppy is practically a billboard announcing he wants to be around at least as long as the dog."

From her sleek black tote, Dyllie whined at the sound of conversation she innately knew was about her. As much as I was growing to love her, and wondered what had prompted Phelps to think I needed or wanted a dog, my mind was preoccupied with the late afternoon conversation with Gavin.

"
I
 still can't believe," I announced in a loud and authoritative and conversation-redirecting voice, "Gavin denies having an affair. And that he walked me home."

"Maybe he thinks you're lonely," Bethany mused. "It has been over two years since you... you know."

"Yes I do know, thank you. But Gavin doesn’t." Really, at the moment a nonexistent sex life was the least of my problems. "And I am not lonely. I am very satisfied."

Next to me Fiona sputtered pink drink all over the bar. "So you 
have
 been using your Christmas gift." As she dabbed at the mess with a cocktail napkin she threw me a conspiratorial smile. "The reviewers at thehotteststuffaround.com gave it a top rating for ease of use and explosive org—"

"That was not what I meant!" Sometimes I felt like life was one big joke at my expense. "I am not lonely and I don't need a man to—"

"A man?" Bethany's brow furrowed in puzzlement. "I thought we were talking about a dog."

"Both," Fiona added.

That was enough! "Neither." 

Slamming a ten on the bar, I shoved my stool back and tried to stand so I could stalk out of the bar. I was not in the mood for Bethany's single-minded focus on the dog and Fiona's single-minded focus on sex. There were more important things going on, like, say, a weekend with my parents, a trip to Milan, and a lying late-fiancé.

Unfortunately, as the Fates looked down on me with malicious hoots of laughter, the stool caught on the sticky floor and I went flying. Landing on my back on a bar floor with a stool between my legs was not the indignant exit I was going for.

Bethany and Fiona leapt into action, Bethany lifting the stool out of the way and Fiona pulling me upright.

In some ways this was all too familiar. Only unlike the first time I had to been pulled upright from a sticky bar surface—first the counter, now the floor—my problem was no man in my life. Now I had two, and I kind of missed having a short list of zero.

"What was that about?" Fi asked as she dusted some questionable material off my gray cashmere cardigan.

"Nothing," I mumbled. Humiliation was bad enough without having to explain your motivation after the fact.

"Has Gavin really upset you that much?"

Leave it to Bethany to see past the muck and get right to the point.

"I just—" I frowned, trying to figure out to put into words why the conversation with Gavin had gotten me into such a knot. "I just wanted him to admit it, that's all. Just a simple, 'Yeah, I was a letch.' so I can forget about it and move on."

So much for that much needed closure.

Fiona assessed me with her soul-exposing brown eyes. "You wanted him to say it wasn't your fault."

"Pretty much."

"You know it wasn't, sugar." Bethany laid a reassuring hand on my arm.

"I know, I know," I agreed.

We had been through this merry-go-round right after it happened, trying to snap my out of my self-pity and restore my confidence. But something about this conversation brought back all the fears and insecurities and—great—the tears.

"Dubble Bubble damn." With a sniff I reached for a cocktail napkin to mop up the tears.

Fiona beat me to it. She gently patted at my cheeks until they were dry. Then, looking me square in the eyes, she said, "But there's something else you're afraid of. You—" She squinted, as if trying to see deeper into my psyche. "—are afraid it wasn't a lie."

"What?" Bethany and I said at the same time—although mine was more like a high-pitched squeal.

Roused by the excited pitch, Dyllie roused from her nap and poked her head out to look around. I was too taken aback to shoo her back down, even though animals were not allowed in Sweet Stuff. Or any New York bar, for that matter.

No, I was entirely focused on Fiona's outrageous proclamation.

"Are you crazy?" I demanded. "I 
saw
 them, Fi. With my own eyes. 
In flagrante delicto. 
"

"I don't doubt that." Her voice was calm and soothing, and my hackles dropped enough to listen to what she said. "But somewhere, deep inside, you are afraid that maybe you were wrong. Maybe what you thought you saw wasn't precisely what happened, and now Gavin has dredged up those old self-doubts. You are afraid you made a huge mistake."

By the time she was done tears ran rivers down my cheeks, wetting the soft cashmere of my sweater into spots of steel gray.

Was she right? Was I afraid that Gavin hadn't really cheated on me and that I broke off the engagement based on nothing but my own insecurities and misguided assumptions?

"Did I ruin it all for nothing?" My words came out choked with tears and heavy on the sniffles. I dropped my head in my hands as I relived with absolute clarity ever second of that night at Gavin's office.

He stood there with an expression on his face that I interpreted as ecstasy, but could have just as easily been pain. Rhonda was on her knees, fully clothed, and from the doorway I couldn't make out what she was doing. From the movement, I had imagined the worst. But could she have been hastily wiping scalding coffee of his skin?

A cry escaped me as I realized what a horrible mistake I had made.

Instantly, Bethany and Fiona were there, soothing me.

"No, not for nothing," Bethany said.

"There had to be a reason. Even if it wasn't cheating."

"Sugar, your subconscious knew something was wrong."

Fiona wrapped an arm around my shoulder and hugged me close, even as my sobs shook us all. "The affair was only an easy excuse to do something you knew you needed to do anyway."

Several cocktail napkins and wrenching sobs later, what they said finally penetrated.

And it made sense.

For weeks before that night, I had worried that Gavin was having an affair. That he was being distant. That something about our relationship was not right.

Then I had caught him with Rhonda and I felt relieved. Because that became the reason that our relationship was failing. It wasn't my fault—because he was having an affair. It wasn't cold feet—because he was having an affair. It wasn't a fear of commitment—because he was having an affair. That became my excuse for everything.

Most people even bought it.

But the fact that I went two years without even speaking to him, without seeking the closure we both needed, should have been the big clue that all was not right with how things ended.

"Order me another," I asked before downing the remains of my Lemon Drop. Sliding off the stool, I grabbed my purse for a much needed trip to the powder room. "I think I'm gonna need it."

Because whether it was cause for celebration or despair, I was facing the cold, hard truth that I had never been in love with Gavin Fairchild.

The drive to Westchester took ninety minutes. About three times as long as usual, and not just because of the road construction and three traffic accidents on the New York State Thruway.

About halfway there Ferrero decided that he needed to see Phelps in his trench coat. Immediately.

The trench coat was, of course, in the trunk.

Ferrero instructed his driver to pull the limo over at the next possible stop. Which turned out to be a Shell station with an inviting patch of grass.

As Phelps dug through the suitcases in the trunk to find his trusty duffel bag, I snapped Dyllie's leash on and pranced her over to do her business.

You know how sometimes you turn your back for a second and all hell breaks loose?

This was hell and all its suburbs.

15

Q: Why do bees have sticky hair?
A: They use honeycombs.
— Laffy Taffy Joke #95

When Dyllie finished inspecting every blade of grass for the perfect spot to squat, we turned to head back to the limo.

In what couldn't have been more than sixty seconds, the limo had disappeared, leaving Phelps, Ferrero, and the driver standing next to the pile of luggage. One of the bags—mine, of course—had fallen open in a brisk wind, sending my weekend wardrobe flying across the heavily trafficked Cross Westchester Expressway. And a dozen police cars had the parking lot surrounded.

"What the hell happened?" I shouted, running as fast as my Stuart Weitzman's could carry me, and tugging on Dyllie to keep up.

A stern voice on the megaphone stopped my return. "Don't move and raise your hands above your head."

I froze and tried to lift my hands, but Dyllie's leash kept my right hand from rising above shoulder height.

"Both hands above your head."

Stifling a growl of frustration, I shouted back, "I can't, my dog is attached to my—"

"Lydia Vanderwalk?" The voice asked.

"Y-yes," I ventured.

"Hey, it's me," the voice continued, as if that were an enlightening statement of identity, "Rick Pearson."

In the space of two words I was back in high school, crushing on the Bingley Academy quarterback. Rick of the surfer boy good looks, West Coast laid back attitude, and truly generous nature. Always in the nebulous zone between popular and not, I had flourished under the platonic friendship Rick offered when his family moved in next door. After a while platonic wasn't enough.