Authors: Patrick K. O'Donnell
An innovative two-hose breathing device (the Italian device had a single hose that only worked for short distances) that enabled the swimmers to remain underwater for long periods of time was critical for a successful underwater swimmer program. The apparatus needed to be lightweight and maneuverable so the swimmers could adroitly move through the water, set charges, and accomplish other tasks. Most importantly it needed to help the swimmers avoid detection by eliminating the usual bubbles that accompany underwater swimming. And because lives would be on the line, the device had to be totally dependable.
Woolley first began his efforts to develop a new underwater breathing apparatus by inspecting the equipment the Navy already had on hand. He recalled, “
Soon after I was put in charge of maritime training, I came across [a] diving mask. I found this could be used as a self-contained unit and arranged with the Navy department so that I could carry out tests with it at the diving school and at the [Washington, D.C.] Navy Yard. This unit did not last very long and showed [a] considerable amount of bubbles. The diving school put me in contact with Mr. Browne of Diving Equipment and Salvage Company (DESCO). I explained to him the requirement and he produced a mock-up unit.”
Jack Browne, a young, pioneering underwater diver, had an extraordinary gift for innovation. He fabricated his first diving helmet from tin cans. Browne later designed a diving suit to be used for salvaging the
Lusitania
, a passenger ship sunk in the Irish Channel by a German U-boat in 1915 during World War I, killing nearly all aboard. In 1937 he had formed DESCO, based in Milwaukee; however, he had to put off formally incorporating the company until 1938, when he would reach twenty-one years of age.
The OSS conducted the first official test of Browne's “lung” at the Washington Navy Yard's diving tank on October 20, 1942. Commander Woolley and Lieutenant Jack Taylor stood around the tank as Browne remained underwater “
for thirty minutes, swimming leisurely in the confined area of the tank at an average depth of eight to ten feet.” However, the mask leaked, causing more bubbles than would be expected.
Browne tested the equipment again at the Annapolis Natatorium on October 21, 1942. “The apparatus was demonstrated by Mr. Browne and one of the divers [from the Navy diving school]. Very few bubbles appeared [in the swimming pool], and the dive was entirely successful, except for some water getting into the canisters, making it slightly more difficult to breathe,” recalled Taylor. While the canisters used as CO
2
scrubbers were being dried, Jack Taylor donned the standard Navy diving mask with a hose connected to
a cylinder at the edge of the pool and swam underwater with ease for several minutes. Taylor suggested that the mask “
might possibly be incorporated into the apparatus.” Once the canisters were ready to go, Browne then strapped the lung back on and transported two limpet mines underwater, demonstrating an important technique of covert underwater sabotage. Woolley succinctly summed up the trial, saying Browne's lung “
appeared to have good possibilities of being satisfactory for underwater swimming.”
Woolley then approached the OSS chief of the Research and Development (R&D) branch, Dr. Stanley Lovell. A natural inventor renowned for his sometimes wacky yet ingenious ideas, Lovell and his team developed everything from a “truth drug” made from marijuana to a special project using bats as miniature drones to carry tiny incendiary bombs to ignite Japanese wooden houses. After Lovell scrutinized and ultimately blessed the breathing device, the OSS issued a contract to Jack Browne, paying him $400 for delivery of a refined lung. Browne returned to Milwaukee and continued to make modifications to his device based on the trials, including adding a luminous compass that the swimmer could see underwater. Though commonly found on diving equipment today, this useful feature was a very novel idea at that time.
Despite the promise of Browne's lung, the OSS wisely did not put all its eggs in one basket. As Browne continued development of his lung, another breathing device caught the attention of the OSS. On November 17, Christian Lambertsen, a young medical student from the University of Pennsylvania, arrived at the OSS office in the Q Building, located in downtown Washington, DC, and presented a rebreather of his own design to Woolley and Taylor. The next day, the three men tested Lambertsen's rebreather at the Shoreham Hotel and made history.
Lambertsen had grown up in New Jersey during the Great Depression, and he spent many summers at the Jersey Shore with his uncle. In 1939 he entered the medical school at the University of Pennsylvania, where one of his first classes covered respiratory
physiology. “
To learn about oxygen (O
2
) and carbon dioxide (CO
2
), the students breathed hypoxic gas to unconsciousness, hyperventilated to become hypocapnic, and conducted breath-holding contests to feel the effects of hypoxia and hypercapnia.” Given his experience at the shore, “
Chris was impressed by ten-minute breath-hold times after hyperventilation with O
2
, and found O
2
and CO
2
particularly interesting for their control of ventilation.”
Soon thereafter he began experimenting with rebreathing devices at the Jersey Shore. His first model relied on a couple of cousins to operate a bicycle pump, but he soon discovered the benefits of compressed oxygen. That still left the problem of expelled carbon dioxide, which made breathing underwater uncomfortable, but Lambertsen soon found a solution in the form of a scrubber made from a material used in anesthesia.
Impressed by Lambertsen's inventions, his mentor, University of Pennsylvania physiology professor Henry Bazett, brought the young student to the attention of the Ohio Chemical and Manufacturing Company. They offered him a job for $30 a week, which he gladly accepted. Lambertsen and the company set out to produce an underwater breathing apparatus for use in lifesaving situations. Ironically, in one of the device's first tests Lambertsen nearly needed lifesaving himself when he began to notice strange twitches in his eyes and legs as well as catches in his breath. He attempted to tug on the emergency rope to receive assistance but found he had forgotten to attach it to the boat. Amazingly, he managed to surface safely.
That wasn't Lambertsen's last brush with death. He and the company thought the unit might also be useful to rescue miners from potentially deadly situations. To test their theory, Lambertsen, wearing the rebreather, along with a dog and a canary, entered an air-tight chamber, which was then filled with cyclopropane, a highly flammable anesthetic gas. “
The demonstration was filmed, with the local press and fire department in attendance. The canary fell off its perch; the dog fell off its shelf. When [Lambertsen] leaned over to check the dog, he, too, fell over. Something was
wrong, and fire axes quickly dismantled the chamber where [the young medical student] was found unconscious. No one had realized that cyclopropane would penetrate the latex breathing bags and be inhaled. Mr. Sholes [the president of the Ohio Chemical and Manufacturing Company] issued a stern reprimand, âChris, you shouldn't have done that.'”
Soon after that disastrous encounter, England entered World War II. Lambertsen's mentor, Professor Bazett, immediately saw the military implications of his student's invention and wrote about it to the British Admiralty and the U.S. military. Soon Lambertsen was involved in talks with the U.S. military, and he adapted his device into the model that would become the Lambertsen Amphibious Respiratory Unit (LARU). He continued his dangerous practice of testing the device himself, diving ever deeper underwater in an attempt to ascertain the pressure limits of the rebreather. After one such test he reported, “
My pressure tests went very well. CO
2
absorption was fine but O
2
poisoning came on at 80 feet. I was almost a goner.”
In 1940 Lambertsen patented the device and continued his studies at medical school. He also worked steadily on the rebreather, making it his top priority. He noted in one letter, “
As one of my professors put it, I do not intend to let my medical course interfere with my education.” He continued to perfect the LARU, making minor modifications that improved its operation.
By the time the OSS became interested in the LARU, Lambertsen's rebreather was more refined than Browne's, which Woolley noted. The day after the youthful medical student arrived in Washington, “
tests were carried out . . . at the Shoreham Hotel. Mr. Lambertsen remained underwater for forty-eight minutes, during most of which time he was swimming across the deep end of the pool. The apparatus appeared to be satisfactory. Lieutenant Taylor, who had never used this apparatus before, then put it on and appeared to have no difficulty swimming underwater with it.”
T
HE
LARU
WAS A CLOSED-CIRCUIT
rebreathing carbon dioxideâabsorbing system, similar to Browne's lung. It consisted of a face mask, breathing tubes, soda-lime canisters, breathing bag, and several valves of special function. A canvas vest held the main parts of the “
apparatus in a proper position relative to the diver's body; an oxygen supply; and the respiratory system. The oxygen supply system comprises a small oxygen cylinder, which when full, contains pure oxygen at a pressure of two thousand pounds per square inch. Oxygen is breathed and the carbon dioxide formed is absorbed in the soda-lime canister, permitting rebreathing of expired gases. Oxygen is added to the breathing system from the oxygen cylinder as needed as to replace that used by the diver.” The use of pure oxygen is quite different from today's modern SCUBA gear, which contains air from the natural atmosphere. In addition, an internal Maritime Unit memo noted, “
The Diving Unit is so designed that the wearer retains his natural balance and buoyancy equilibrium underwater. This permits him to work or swim in any conceivable position without interfering with respiration.”
The main difference between Lambertsen's and Browne's devices was that the LARU outperformed Browne's lung in the trials. Accordingly, OSS requested that the young medical student produce additional devices and issued a contract to Lambertsen and the Ohio Chemical and Manufacturing Company to develop several more of his rebreathers.
News of the LARU spread. The Britishâparticularly a high-ranking officer in the Special Operations Executive (SOE), Colonel John Frank, who knew Woolleyâalso expressed their interest in the device. The SOE was OSS's experienced British equivalent that conducted espionage, sabotage, and reconnaissance in Europe. “
[When Frank] had heard about this apparatus . . . [he] asked about it and the Browne apparatus and was anxious that he could obtain two of the apparatus as quickly as possible.” He then stated “
that cash would be paid for them.” The orders were placed.
For months, Lambertsen and Browne would be competitors. Both worked on improving their equipment with additional trials. Ultimately the
OSS recognized the genius of both men. Keenly aware that collaborative efforts could exponentially increase the potential for innovation, Woolley encouraged the inventors to partner together.
*
Christian Lambertsen may have been the first to coin the term SCUBA. In 1943 underwater pioneer and explorer Jacques Cousteau improved an aqua-lung design, developing an open-circuit demand regulator that refreshed air when the diver breathed. But the open-circuit design left a stream of bubbles. The Italians developed a rebreather, manufactured by Pirelli, for the Gamma men to use.
DECEMBER 1942, SANTA MONICA, CALIFORNIA
With some anxiety, lifeguard George Peterson put on Browne's lung and held on to the side of the boat. Slowly he submerged into the Pacific under the watchful eyes of Lieutenant Jack Taylor, inventor Jack Browne, and Fred Wadley, who was a former national champion swimmer, a member of the Santa Monica Sheriff's Department, and Browne's close friend. Peterson swam around the boat under the surface of the water for about twenty minutes, relying solely on the lung to breathe. He could have remained underwater, except the frigid 53-degree water “
made it impossible to stay in longer.”