Authors: P. E. Ryan
“Well, I'm his mother.”
“And I totally respect that. But I was thinking that an outside voiceâfrom someone in the familyâmight be helpful. I'm sure it took a lot of guts for Garth to tell you, and maybe there's room for him toâ”
“Mike,” she said, “I know you mean well, but don't overstep your bounds.”
“No, no, no,” Mike said, holding up both hands now. “I don't mean to do that at all.”
“Lisa has gay friends,” Garth suddenly blurted out.
His mom glared at him.
“She even broke up with a guy she was dating last year because he called her gay friends âfags' and said they should all be put on an AIDS island,” he said. “She told him to get lost.”
“That kind of person is
exactly
why I worry about you telling people,” she said. “What do you think
that boy would have done if he'd known that, or even thought that, about you? He and his ignorant friends could decide to go after you, and how would you defend yourself?”
“Well,” Mike said, sounding much calmer than Garth's mom; he almost sounded like the good-guy attorney on a TV drama, exploring all the angles of a situation, “he could defend himself with words. He could be ready to say, âHey, guys, just look at me as one less man in competition for all those girls out there.'”
“That sounds like the perfect way to get into a fight,” she said. “Honestly, Mike, you don't know what you're talking about.”
“Times have changed.”
“They haven't changed that much.”
“Well, Garth was telling me about this organization. What's it called? Rosemary?”
“ROSMY,” Garth said.
“They apparently have all these services for teenagers
and
parents, and it sounds to me likeâ”
“You know what?” Garth's mom said, the volume of her voice raising slightly. “You're not a parent. You don't know what it's like to have an immediate family, lose half of it, and be worried about the safety of the other half. And I do. Soâ¦forgive me for putting
my foot down, but I don't want to hear about ROSMY anymore. I'm Garth's mom, his only parent, and he's my responsibility until he's an adult.”
Garth looked at Mike, who was still staring down at what was left of his spaghetti, his mouth not grinning now but pursed. Was he irritated? Pensive? Regretting that he'd brought up the subject in the first place? He put his elbows on the table and folded his hands together over his plate. “Actually,” he said in a softer voice, “I
do
know what it's like to lose half my family. My dad passed away, so I've got my mom and my twin brother. Then my brother's suddenly gone. So I know what it's like. But you're right: I'm not a parent. I just want what's best for Garth here.
Garth was still feeling grateful, but he also had the vague sensation of being an objectâlike a piece of furniture in an empty room, with two people standing over it, deciding where it should reside. Yet he thought Mike understood him better than his mom did, or at least was willing to acknowledge that the decision about
where
the piece of furniture was placed wasn't so obvious, soâ¦cut and dry. Neither Mike nor his mom was saying anything. He wanted to break the silence, so he said, “I want what's best for me, too.”
His mom cleared her throat, pushed up from her
chair, and said, “There's ice cream, if anyone saved room for dessert.”
Â
His uncle stopped by his room that night, just as he was getting ready for bed. “Got a minute?” Mike asked.
“Sure.” Garth was sitting on his unmade bed reading an old dog-training manual.
Mike looked at the title. “You going to teach Hutch some new tricks?”
“Nah. I just like reading this stuff. Did you know you shouldn't give your dog a one-syllable name because it'll take him longer to learn it?”
“Good thing neither one of us is a dog, then.” Mike was in cargo shorts and a Grateful Dead T-shirt. He had a little bit of a gut, Garth noticed for the first time. He wasn't holding it in, either. He seemed comfortable with himself.
Garth folded his legs up and Mike sat down at the end of the bed. His brow was furrowed and his hands were working around an imaginary object, as if he were shaping clay on a spinning wheel. “I don't want you to think your mom and I are at odds,” he finally said. “That's the last thing you needâyour uncle coming into town and fighting with your mom.”
“I don't think that,” Garth said, even though that was exactly what he'd perceived at dinner.
“The thing is, when it comes to the whole gay thing, I know you don't agree with your mom.” He looked Garth directly in the eye until Garth nodded. “And neither do I. But I understand where she's coming from. She's exhausted. I mean, she's overworked, and she's worried about you, and she loves you; I get all that. I mean, that's real stuff. There's a burden on her. I can see it when I look at her and hear it when she talks. What she's been throughâ¦honestly, I can't imagine what it was like for her. Or for you. Right now, I just want to be there for you and her both, you know?”
“Yeah,” Garth said. Was he agreeing to something? Committing to something? He wasn't sure; he was just glad Mike had stuck up for him and was glad this late-night visit wasn't to say anything bad about his mom. “She works really hard. And, like I said, she's been kind of overprotective since Dad died.”
“She's been through hell,” Mike said. “So have you. I just hope I can help
both
you guys out while I'm here.”
Again, Garth had no idea what the right response might be.
“Seriously,” Mike said, and tapped his index finger against his temple. “I've got the wheels spinning on how to help.”
“Thanks,” Garth said.
“There's a mall nearby, right?”
“Willow Lawn isn't too far away.”
“Do you want to go with me tomorrow? I could really use some new clothes. My shirts are played out, and I have some other shopping I need to do.”
Tomorrow was a Wednesday, his volunteer day at Bone Sweet Bone. But what was one more day at the dog shelter compared to a day with Mike, who wasn't going to be here for very long? The more time Garth spent around him, the more he liked him. He could call Lisa in the morning and explain. He could call the shelter's number and leave Ms. Kessler a message saying that he needed one of the other volunteers to replace him. No big deal.
“Sure,” he said. “Let's go.”
M
ike recognized the part of town they were in. Garth was directing him toward the mall, and while Broad Street pretty much looked like Broad Street block after block, Monument Avenue, west of I-95, became very suburban: apartment complexes, ranch houses, two-story homes with wide lawns, chain-link-fence-lined yards, oaks and pine trees growing in abundance.
“We're near the cemetery, aren't we?” Mike asked, guiding the Camaro with one wrist resting casually on top of the steering wheel.
“Sort of. This is the way we took to get thereâ”
“âthe day of the funeral. I remember this stretch of road. I got to the funeral home just in time to follow you guys out here.”
They rode along in silence for a mile or so. The sky was bright and clear, the sun burning through the windshield despite the car's air-conditioning.
“Would you mind if weâ¦?”
“No, it's fine,” Garth said. He'd been half expecting the request. “I can tell you how to get there.”
They passed the turnoff for the mall and drove up Monument till they reached Three Chopt Road. Ten minutes and a few turns later, they were at the entrance.
Garth had been out here with his mom frequently, at first, and then once a month since she'd taken on the second job. It wasn't a fancy, old-fashioned cemetery. It was clean and meticulously laid out and overwhelmingly levelâas if someone had steamrolled the land before digging the first grave. There were very few upright headstones; most were just flat marble markers with brass plates, barely visible from a distance. Mike slowed the Camaro to a crawl and followed Garth's directions for which lane to take.
“It's right here,” he said, and they rolled to a stop.
“Hard to recognize the spot without the canopy and folding chairs,” Mike remarked, peering through Garth's window.
They got out, and were immediately engulfed in heat. Garth knew the way by heart: five markers over, four in. Then they were standing in front of the marble square fixed with the brass plate that bore his dad's name. The brief thirty-five years his life had spanned. The engraved phrase that they couldn't afford but that
his mom had insisted on adding:
LOVING HUSBAND, DAD, AND FRIEND
.
The two of them stood at the foot of the grave in silence for a little while. Then Mike said, in a soft, uncharacteristic voice, “Hi, Jer.”
“He can't hear you,” Garth said, embarrassed by his uncle's presumption that he could just “talk” to his dad so easily.
“I know whatever's in
there
can't hear me,” Mike said. “But that doesn't mean he isn't”âhe stirred the warm air with a finger, indicating the cemetery, the surrounding suburb, the whole world, for all Garth knewâ“listening.” He cleared his throat and said, “Anyway, Jer, I came through town for a visit, and Sonja and Garth have been nice enough to take me in. They're doing great, by the way. I think your boy's grown a couple of inches.”
He's lying to the dead,
Garth thought. For his sake or his dad's? He stepped around the grave to the marker, bent down, and began pulling at the weeds that had grown up around the base.
“I'm sorry we didn't always get along, Jer. I think about you a lot. If I'd had any idea something was going to happen toâ¦eraseâ¦either one of us so suddenly, I would have, you know, made more of an effort to stay in touch. Keep on good terms. I don't know.
I guess you just can't predict anything. You take the most important things for granted without even knowing you're doing it.”
Garth stood up and dusted his hands together. When he looked back at his uncle, he saw that his eyes had gone damp.
Mike dragged a thumb over each eye and said, “I'm sorry.”
Should he take his hand? Hug him? Garth had never thought much about it before, but he wasn't very good with physical contactâor hadn't been for the past year and a half. When people touched him, he tended to flinch. When he felt moved to touch someone elseâeven his momâhe did so awkwardly. “You don't have to apologize,” he said.
Mike sniffed. “I, ah, wasn't talking to you.”
“Oh. Sorry.”
His uncle smiled. “
You
don't have to apologize, either. None of this is easy⦔
Garth nodded. “Mr. Holt is buried over there,” he said, pointing to a marker several rows over.
“Who's Mr. Holt?”
“The other man. The one whoâ”
“Oh, right. Of course.”
They walked over and paid their respects to the man who had died with Jerry Rudd. “We used to
be pretty close to the Holts,” Garth said. “I went to school with Sarah, and Mr. Holt and Dad were good friends.”
“You don't see them anymore?”
“They moved to Atlanta not long after the accident.”
Mike squatted down next to Mr. Holt's marker and dragged a hand over it, as if reading Braille. He raised his head, and peered around at the expansive sea of graves. “You guys went out too far,” he said in a low voice. Was he talking to Mr. Holt now as well? “You took too much of a risk.”
The accident slide-showed through Garth's mind all over again. “I have this nightmare,” he said. “I see them in the storm. I see them struggling, and thenâthey go down.”
“That's not good.”
“It's awful. But I haven't had it once since you got here.”
Mike noddedâbut cautiously, as if unsure whether or not it was okay to take credit. “All right,” he finally said, and stood up. “Enough with the heavy stuff. Want to move on?”
Garth did. He never minded going to the cemetery, but once there, he never wanted to linger. Going seemed to serve a purpose; lingering was just depressing.
They followed the narrow asphalt strip, circling the grounds as they made their way back to the front entrance. At the other end of the cemetery, a funeral was under way. It wasn't a large affair: maybe half a dozen cars behind the hearse, a single row of chairs, the familiar blue canopy.
“You never know where the day's going to take you,” Mike said softly as they crept past.
Â
At the mall, Mike bought himself a few dress shirts and a pair of pants. He tried on some shoes, decided against them, then eyed Garth's worn-out sneakers and said he could do with a new pair. Garth didn't want Mike spending any money on him, but Mike insisted and wouldn't even let him pick out anything that was on sale. Did he know his mom's shoe size? Garth had no idea, so Mike bought Sonja a gift card she could bring to the store and use whenever she wanted. Garth carried his old shoes out in the box and wore the new ones, which were white with blue laces andâhe had to admitâlooked pretty cool. He thanked Mike repeatedly, until Mike finally waved him off: “They're just shoes.” Before leaving the mall, they ducked into a gift shop, and Mike bought an oversized, decorative photo album for Garth and his mom to fill with the photos he'd given them.
“Where's a good lunch place?” he asked as they were nearing home.
“Turn here.”
They parked on Cary Street, and Garth led the way to the Galaxy Diner.
Just as he'd done at The Tobacco Company, Mike told Garth to “order large.” Here, that meant a bacon double-cheese burger, curly fries, a few side orders, and a chocolate milk shake. Mike ordered the same.
“I don't think I've ever had a fried pickle before,” he said when the food came. He bit into it.
“Like it?”
“Yeah, actually.” Mike's chair faced the street, and he gazed out the window as he ate. People flowed in and trickled out. “Hoppin' place.”
“You mean the diner?”
“Yeahâand the whole block. It's like another mall, but without a roof.”
“It's called Carytown. It's sort of like its own little village.”
“A village with some beautiful ladies,” Mike said, his eye following a woman as she walked down the sidewalk past the diner. Garth glanced behind him. Two more women were coming from the opposite direction, walking together, both on cell phones. “Yeow,” Mike said. “That one on the right looks like my ex. Reminds
me of why I hooked up with her in the first place.”
The comments sounded just as crude to Garth as when he heard jocks talking about girls at school. Then again, he'd probably be doing it too, if he could. Somehow, Mike picked up on this. “It must be a bummer not being able to
say
anything, when you see some guy you think is good-looking. Not even being able to make a casual remark.”
“Yeah, it pretty much sucks,” Garth said.
“Mind if I ask you a personal question?”
“No.”
“Have you ever, you know, done anything?”
“Had sex? That would be a big fat
no.
” He looked down at the table and fiddled with his straw wrapper, a little embarrassed. He'd taken sex ed in the seventh grade and had felt like he'd learned everything he
didn't
need to knowâsort of like suffering through calculus when you never planned on using it. “Why?”
“Just curious. You're definitely at the age where your mind's got to be reeling all the timeâ”
Correct,
Garth thought.
“âand your mom means well, but she's kind of got you in a straitjacket.”
Correct again.
Mike chuckled. “No pun intended. I'm just a little worried you might go nuts in it, at some point. People
startâ¦exploringâ¦pretty young.”
“So I've heard,” Garth said. In truth, he really hadn't heard muchâbut he was curious. “How old were you?”
Mike smiled. “Fifteen. Mary Dalton was her name. I thought I'd have to twist her arm, but she was the one who made the first move.”
Garth stirred a curly fry through the mustard on his plate. “Thingsâ¦worked out okay?”
“Let's just say sex means different things to different people. It can be great,
really
great, and it can be lousy. And it can feel like love when it isn't love at all; it's justâ¦sex.”
“I wouldn't know.”
Mike studied him for a moment. “Let's take a walk,” he said.
He paid the bill, and as he accepted his change, he asked the man behind the registerâpoint-blank, calm as could beâif there was a gay bookstore in the neighborhood.
For as full as his stomach was, Garth felt it fold in on itself.
But the man didn't bat an eye. Yes, he told them, there was a gay bookstore not far away. He gave them directions. Mike thanked him, and they left.
“I can't believe you asked him that!” Garth said,
once they were out on the sidewalk.
“Relax,” Mike told him. “The world isn't quite the battle zone your mom thinks it is.”
They walked several blocks and took the side street the man had mentioned.
“
You're
going in?” Garth asked. He hadn't given it any thought till now, but he'd assumed Mike would just wait outside for him.
“If you're up for it.”
“But aren't you worried people'll think
you're
gay if you're seen in there?”
“What do I care?”
“Are you human?” Garth asked.
Mike laughed. “Last time I checked.”
“You're so not what I think of when I picture the average grown-up straight man.”
“Well, I'll take that as a compliment, too. I just think people should be able to be who they are, and be with who they want to be with.”
They'd reached the bookstore. A large rainbow flag hung on a pole sticking out from the front of the building. “Ready?” Mike asked.
“I guess so.”
They went inside.
Garth, of course, already knew of the store's existence; Lisa had told him about it the day he'd come out
to her and had offered to take him there, but he'd always been too nervous to do it. Somehow, with Mike, he wasn't quite so nervous. In fact, stepping into the store made him feel like one of those kids entering Willy Wonka's chocolate factoryâwhich, he realized, made his uncle Willy Wonka (a hilarious thought). He pictured Mike bursting into song:
Come with me and you'll be in a world of pure imagination.
But Mike had already wandered into the depths of the store and was surveying a rack of books. Feeling embarrassed, even guilty (
of what?
), Garth glanced at the woman behind the register.
“Hello,” she said, and smiled.
“Hi.”
“They've got some good stuff here,” Mike said, waving him over. “Just keep your eyes off anything too racy.”
There
was
a lot of “racy” stuff in the store. Photo books with half-naked men on the covers. Calendars. Comic books that basically looked like porn magazines with drawings instead of pictures. Garth wanted everything his eyes fell on.
“Here,” Mike said. “Some of these books are geared for guys your age.”
Garth read the back flaps, and they didn't sound fantastical or horrific or even dirty; they seemed to be
about guys pretty much like him.
“Will you read them? I don't want to get them for you if you're not going to read them.”
“Yeah,” he said, nodding his head. “I'll read them.”
“Good. Here, you should have some of these, too.” Mike walked over to a table and gathered a couple of safe-sex pamphlets, a copy of the local gay newspaper, andâto Garth's shockâa handful of free condoms. “I'm not saying you have to use them. Well, yeah, you
have
to use them if you're going toâ¦have sex. But the point is to have them. Hide them away in a drawer, if you want. Ohâand throw them out after a few months if you
don't
use them. They're like potatoes: eventually they go bad.”
A few months?
Garth thought.
A few years is more like it.
Still, he felt excited just to have them in his possession.