TITHONIUM BASE: THE TRANSLATION
Jamie helped Carleton and his team to tenderly lift the fossilized bones out of the grave, together with the beads and shards of pottery that lay with the body, and carry them inside the dome. Under Carleton’s exacting direction, they laid everything on the big stereo table in exactly the same positions as they had been in the grave.
Two technicians spent the next hour taking stereo photographs of the remains, while Carleton’s people gathered in the cafeteria to relax after a long, exciting, tension-filled day. Jamie went with them.
“Well, they buried their dead, all right,” said Alonzo Jenkins as he lounged back in a cafeteria chair, legs stretched out and a plastic glass of fruit juice in his hand.
“With trinkets,” added Shirley Macintyre, one of the medical technicians who had volunteered to help at the dig. She was in her midtwenties, and had dropped out of astronaut training in Britain to join the medical team on Mars. Tall, lean and muscular, she had been pursued by several of the men but stayed aloof from them all.
“They must have believed in an afterlife,” Billy Graycloud said softly. Eyebrows went up; people looked surprised that Graycloud would speak up.
Jamie smiled at the young man and said, “So they must have had some form of religion.” Everyone nodded.
“I wonder how much they were like us,” murmured one of the men.
“Or we’re like them.”
“Not physically,” said Jamie. “We don’t look anything alike.”
“But mentally?”
“Spiritually?”
“They lived in villages,” Jamie said, ticking off points on his fingers. “They had a rudimentary form of writing. They buried their dead — “
“With beads and pottery,” Macintyre interjected.
“Like Billy said, they believed in an afterlife,” said Jenkins. “So they must have had some kind of religion.”
“That’s the basis for religion, sure enough.”
They looked up to see Carter Carleton walking toward them from the juice dispensers, a glass in his hand, a happy smile on his handsome face.
“The promise of life beyond death,” Jenkins said. “That’s what religion’s all about.”
“It’s a powerful lure,” Carleton said, joining the conversation as he sat himself next to Macintyre. “It’s pure nonsense, of course, but it’s certainly suckered people into accepting religion everywhere, even on Mars.”
“What do you mean, it’s nonsense?” Macintyre asked. “How can you be sure?”
“Catholic, aren’t you?” said Carleton, frowning slightly. “You’ve had it pounded into your skull since before you could walk.”
Jenkins objected, “That’s not fair, Dr. Carleton. Everyone’s entitled to their beliefs.”
“Besides,” Macintyre said, “there’s a lot more to religion than the promise of an afterlife. There’s the whole ethical basis. Society would be impossible without religion’s ethical teachings.”
Carleton smirked. “Like ‘Thou shalt not kill’? Except when your church says it’s okay. Like the Crusades: kill the Saracens! Or the suicide bombers: kill the unbelievers!”
“They were extremists.”
“Were they? How about the good Christians back in the USA who’ve made homosexuality a crime in their states? Outlawed abortion. Hell, they’re even trying to make all forms of family planning illegal.”
“They’re acting on their beliefs,” Macintyre insisted.
Jamie got to his feet and left them arguing. To himself he thought, How about the religious believers who don’t want us here on Mars? How about the terrorists who set off those bombs back at the university? How about—
“Dr. W?”
Jamie broke out of his thoughts and saw Billy Graycloud walking beside him.
“Had enough of the debate?” he asked.
Graycloud smiled shyly. “I figure they’ll start asking me about my religious beliefs pretty soon. I don’t want to get involved in it.”
“Smart lad,” Jamie said. “We’ve got enough to do without getting into arguments over religion. They’ll start yelling at each other pretty soon.”
“I guess. Nothing like religion to start people fightin’.”
Jamie smiled bitterly. “When you’re sure you’re right, when you’ve been told all your life that these beliefs are the absolute truth . ..” He shook his head. “People have done horrible things in the name of religion.”
They walked side by side toward Jamie’s quarters.
“I guess that’s why they’re scared of science,” Graycloud muttered, as much to himself as to Jamie. “Scientists don’t talk about truth. They look for facts.”
“And we change our minds, too, when new facts contradict what we believed.”
Graycloud nodded. He looked to Jamie as if he was about to say something, but he stopped himself and remained silent.
“Is there something else?”
Graycloud pursed his lips, as if searching his memory. “Well, yeah, there is.”
Jamie waited for the youngster to go on. After several silent steps he prodded, “What is it, Billy?”
Frowning slightly, Graycloud said, “The translation.”
“Getting anywhere?”
“Kinda. Maybe. I’m not sure.”
“What’s the problem?”
“Could you come over to the comm center? I can show you what I’ve done so far.”
Nodding, Jamie changed course and walked with Graycloud to the communications center. The place was silent except for the hum of the consoles. Two women were on duty, chatting quietly together, headphones clipped to their ears while their display screens flickered with routine messages. Graycloud sat at an unused console and booted up the computer. Jamie pulled one of the little wheeled chairs over beside him and sat on it.
The screen showed the inscriptions carved into the wall of the cliff structure. Graycloud scrolled the screen’s cursor to the image of a circle with short lines emanating from it, north, south, east and west.
“Okay,” Graycloud said, licking his lips. “That one I call the sun.
“Father Sun,” Jamie murmured. “Like the Navaho sun symbol.”
“Right. Okay. That one’s easy. Now this one . . .” The cursor drifted to a wriggly pair of lines and stopped. “This one might mean ‘water.’ Or ‘river.’”
“That’s reasonable,” said Jamie.
“And this one . . .” The cursor swung to a bulbous symbol that reminded Jamie of a head of broccoli. “Might be ‘tree’ or ‘plant.’”
“Or ‘crops,’” Jamie suggested.
Graycloud’s brows hiked up. “Yeah. Crops. Could be.”
Jamie patted the younger man’s shoulder. “You’re making progress, Billy.”
“Am I?” Graycloud turned toward him and Jamie could see the doubt and worry in his eyes. “Or am I just screwin’ around?”
“Progress,” Jamie said firmly.
Graycloud shook his head warily. “I don’t know, Dr. W. All I’m really doing is assigning our words to their symbols. Arbitrarily. How do we know the circle means the sun? It might mean ‘crater’ or ‘beach ball,’ for all we know.”
Jamie almost laughed. “Probably not ‘beach ball.’”
“But you see the problem?” Graycloud said, almost pleading. “I’m just assigning
our
meanings to
their
symbols. It’s GIGO: garbage in, garbage out.”
For a moment Jamie said nothing, thinking hard as he looked at this earnest young man and considered his problem. At last he said, “The proof will be in the message you get out of the symbols, Billy. When you run these meanings through the computer, will a meaningful message come out of them or will it be meaningless nonsense?”
“But we could be fooling ourselves.”
“How?”
“I mean, even if we get a message that seems to have some meaning to it, it could be just the meaning we put into it. It could have nothing to do with what the Martians wanted to say.”
“I see.”
“I could be wasting my time here.”
Jamie smiled. “Billy, you’ve got thesis blues.”
“Huh?”
“Every graduate student goes through this when they have to write their thesis. At some point in the project it all starts to look like nonsense, garbage, junk. You feel certain that you’re wasting your time, that what you’re doing is all gibberish and it’s never going to go anywhere. You start to wonder if you shouldn’t just toss it all down the chute and go out and sell used cars or paint houses or do something,
anything,
that’s more useful than the crap you’re working on.”
Graycloud stared at him for a long silent moment. Then, “Did you ever feel that way?”
Jamie nodded, remembering. “With my master’s thesis. And especially with the doctorate.
Stratigraphy of the Potential Oil-Bearing Deposits of Northern New Mexico.
I almost quit school altogether when I was working on that one.”
Blinking, Graycloud said, “But there aren’t any oil-bearing deposits in northern New Mexico. Are there?”
“Not much. Plenty of dinosaur fossils, though. I damned near changed my major to paleontology.”
“Really?”
“I thought about it. But I stayed with geology and that thesis earned me my Ph.D.”
Graycloud looked uncertain, troubled.
“Keep plugging at it, Billy. I know it looks like a mess now, but you’ll get there. It’ll be worth it in the end.”
“I sure hope so.”
Silently, Jamie replied, So do I, kid. So do I.