Newman's Unquiet Grave: The Reluctant Saint (52 page)

Read Newman's Unquiet Grave: The Reluctant Saint Online

Authors: John Cornwell

Tags: #Biographies & Memoirs, #Leaders & Notable People, #Religious, #Catholicism

BOOK: Newman's Unquiet Grave: The Reluctant Saint
4.69Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
When the attempted exhumation of Newman’s remains took place in October 2008, it was an occasion to ponder these circumstances and their significance. The popular media took over the story, obscuring to a large extent the nuanced, spiritual meaning of Newman’s burial instructions. The Oratorian Fathers had announced the need to remove Newman’s remains to a more accessible place for public veneration. But it was widely suggested that the Vatican had been anxious lest Newman’s union in death with his friend in life should be interpreted as evidence of a gay relationship.
My memory of Newman and St John’s grave had no context for me until I came across two more such joint, religious same-sex friendship unions in death. The discoveries occurred a quarter of a century apart, and raised questions about Newman and St John. In 1964 I arrived at Christ’s College, Cambridge, as a graduate student. On the first day of term the Master, the famous chemist, Lord Todd, lectured new arrivals in the college chapel. It was an outlandish pep-talk on the importance of using condoms; there were three young Catholic monks from the Abbey of Downside seated opposite me, whose faces grew redder by the minute. But equally distracting, on the wall above the Communion table, was a magnificent monument. It was dedicated to two seventeenth century former members of the college, Sir John Finch and Sir Thomas Baines, whose remains were buried together in the chapel. The monument depicts two plinths, joined by a knotted sheet, surmounted by portraits in stone of the two men. Above is a single lighted vessel, as if to signify that two flames burn brighter than one. Surrounding and unifying the effigies is a sculpted garland of roses, tended by two cherubs, more suited for a nuptial than a funereal celebration. Finch and Baines, both unmarried, had been students together, forming a lasting intimacy. The imagery of their monument is confirmed in the words of their epitaph: ‘So that they who while living had mingled their interests, fortunes, counsels nay rather souls, might in the same manner, in death, at last mingle their sacred ashes.’
I was to remember that monument, twenty-five years on, when staying at the Venerable English College, the seminary for England and Wales in Rome. On the wall of the college chapel, again close to the altar, was a memorial to ‘the Reverend Nicholas Morton, priest, Englishman and celebrated doctor of sacred theology’. The inscription proclaims that it was ‘his wish to be buried in the same tomb with the Reverend John Seton with whom he fled from England for
the same cause, that of religion, and who came to Rome at the same time’. I later learned that the two priests died twenty years apart, but Morton’s love and determination on joint burial had survived the interval.
It was not until I read the late Alan Bray’s remarkable book,
The Friend
(Chicago, 2003), that I came to appreciate the potential significance of these three joint same-sex burials of friends. Bray not only cited the three examples known to me, but a wide circuit of similar tombs and graves involving religious people, both men and women, from England to the Middle East, spread across the entire second millennium. They included a joint tomb at Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge, and another in the chapel of Merton College, Oxford. Quoting the inscription on the Christ’s College monument, Bray argued that the text echoed Jeremy Taylor’s seventeenth-century
Discourse on Friendship
, in which he speaks of friendships’ ‘marriages of the soul, and of fortunes and interests, and counsels’.
3
Bray saw the Christ’s College burial, in the light of the monument’s inscription, as a form of ‘connubium’, or marriage in death. He produced evidence that such public commitments to special friendship were common in pre-modern times, and he rejected the contemporary tendency to project homoerotic desires where none may have existed.
4
In the final chapter of
The Friend
, published five years ahead of the attempted exhumation of Newman, Bray proposes that Newman’s wish to be buried with St John connected with traditions of joint same-sex burial that had been eroded and finally lost in the Enlightenment:
My argument has been that Newman’s burial with St John cannot be detached from Newman’s understanding of the place of friendship in Christian belief or its long history
… The Enlightenment put aside this traditional ethic with contempt and put in its place a Fraternity that it claimed would be ‘universal’, ‘rational’, even ‘scientific’; but as the nineteenth century drew to its end, that experiment was terrifyingly failing and Europe was moving toward a war that would engulf the whole world, in fire and blood.
5

 

Newman and St John lived and worked closely together for thirty years, but betrayed very little of the nature of their regard for each other save by unob-trusive public example. It was only following the death of St John, aged 60 in 1875, that Newman, then aged 74, recorded on 23 July 1876 his desire for joint burial. As he wrote, again and again, during this period of bereavement: ‘he loved me with an intensity of love, which was unaccountable.’

 

RUTH AND NAOMI

 

Among his many letters after St John’s death, Newman wrote to Lady Louisa Kerr, a convert to Catholicism, in thanks for her commiserations. The letter confirms a self-sacrificial devotion on St John’s part, familiar in relationships
where one partner supports an individual burdened with heavy responsibilities or demanding artistic toil. Newman accepted the support and service of St John as if it came from God. There is no indication that Newman returned the compliment of a supporting role in kind. He appears to have understood, in retrospect, however, that St John’s self-sacrificing partnership allowed him freedom and energy to achieve his great literary, polemical and missionary goals. At the same time, the letter indicates another, more intriguing and complex dimension of same-sex friendship, permeating their lives together. His letter to
Lady Kerr begins:
I praise God for having given me for 32 years not merely an affectionate friend, but a help and stay such as a guardian from above might be, as making my path easy to me in difficulties, and cheering me by his sunny presence, as Raphael took the weight upon him of Tobias. I cannot think how I could have done anything without him, and, as knowing how timorous and unready I am, therefore doubtless God gave him to me. Just when all friends Protestant and Converts were removed from me, and I had to stand alone, he came to me as Ruth to Naomi.
6

 

The drift of the letter is an admission that he was the passive recipient of St John’s initiating love and practical service. The parallels from Scripture are of contrasting interest: first, the Angel Raphael in the Book of Tobit comes down from Heaven to assist Tobias, including salvation from live burial, and returns when his work is done. As Newman, and indeed others would recollect, when Newman and St John arrived in Rome to prepare for Catholic Holy Orders after their conversions, Ambrose was known among the Roman clergy as Newman’s ‘Angel Guardian’, as much for his youthful face and golden hair as his role as faithful servant:
How I should ever in 1846 have gone to Oscott and then to Rome … how I should have journeyed to and fro, without him, I do not know and cannot fancy. At that time being young and fair he was even called by the Romans my Angel Guardian – and so on.
7

 

As we shall see, St John would not long retain his angelic looks. He put on weight early, lost those golden locks, smoked cigars, and tended to speak loudly and ebulliently. His support of Newman, however, was unremitting, and he used his forceful, practical personality to ensure that Newman’s every wish was fulfilled.
The second Biblical parallel, however, invokes the story of Ruth and Naomi. Naomi is an Israelite woman living in exile among heathens. She has lost her husband and two married sons, leaving her with two heathen daughters-in-law

Other books

Fast Life by Cassandra Carter
A Flower Girl Murder by Moure, Ana
The Love Shack by Christie Ridgway
A Dead Man in Barcelona by Michael Pearce
You Have Seven Messages by Stewart Lewis
Hacedor de mundos by Domingo Santos
Nan Ryan by Outlaws Kiss
Body of Truth by David L. Lindsey
Brooklyn by Colm Tóibín
Suddenly Last Summer by Sarah Morgan