On the Rocks (11 page)

“Our next session? You really think we’re going to be doing this a lot?”

“I have to get this stuff down. Maddy took a whole class to learn. I have you.” She turned her head to the side slightly.

I sighed. “Okay, what else do we need to find?”

“I think we have everything we need for the next few drinks I want to try.”

We’d already spent an hour taking shots of different liquors. The idea was to make sure we knew the taste of each one. It had sounded like a good idea at the time. We drank seconds of a few just to make sure we had the taste down. By the time we were ready to start mixing drinks, I was definitely feeling the last round.

She stood leaning over a dog eared page in a book. “Your favorite drink is a Long Island iced tea, right?”

“Yeah, but that’s a more complicated one. Are you sure you want to start with that?” I was trying to be nice.

“I know, but if I can master the harder ones, the easier ones will come, well easier I’d think.” Of course I needed to memorize the ingredients first. I downloaded two apps to help with that part while Macon pulled out the liquor.

“If you say so.” I sat back and let her take charge. I was only supposed to be helping.

She took out a glass and filled it with ice. I watched as she poured triple sec, rum, vodka, tequila, sour mix, and Coke in. She didn’t pour them into a shot glass first, she just eyed it. Maybe she was a natural at it.

“There.” She pushed the glass over to me.

I took a sip of the Long Island. There was a heck of a lot more alcohol than I was used to in it, but I couldn’t bear to disappoint her.

“Do you like it?” She hopped up on the counter. “I don’t drink those, so I don’t know what they’re supposed to taste like.”

“It’s uh, great.” I took another sip and swallowed hard.

“It’s awful, huh? I suck at this.”

“You don’t suck.” I set down the glass. “You just have to make sure you’re really precise with the measurements.”

She sighed. “This is starting to feel like science class.”

“Maybe, but how many science classes have you been to where you’ve been able to get blitzed?”

She crossed her legs at the ankles. “None that involved hanging out with a guy as hot as you.” She covered her mouth and laughed. “Ok, I probably shouldn’t have said that out loud.”

“I don’t mind. So, I’m hot, am I?” Wow, Carly was in an honest mood.

“Very.” She uncrossed her legs and sat forward. “And I can’t believe I’m telling you that.”

“If it makes you feel better I think you’re gorgeous.”

“You really think so?”

“Absolutely.” I reached behind her and pulled out the hair tie holding up her hair. It tumbled down in waves down her back. I ran my fingers through it. “So unbelievably gorgeous.”

She shifted and intentionally or not let me slip in between her legs. I leaned toward her. “We shouldn’t be talking like this.”

“Why not? Are you afraid of dirty talk, Macon?” She bit her lip and smiled. She was playing with me.

“Dirty talk? This isn’t dirty yet.”

“Then show me dirty.” She leaned forward and brushed her lips against mine.

“I don’t want to show you dirty.”

“Why not?” She said in a breathy tone.

“Because I’d rather show you other things.”

“What other things?”

“The kind of things I’d have to show you.”

“Show me.” She ran her teeth over her lip.

“Are you sure you want me to?”

“Completely. I’ll go first.” She used both hands to pull her black t-shirt up and over her head. She tossed the shirt.

I stared at her sitting there in a black bra and pajama shorts. There was something so incredibly sexy about the combination—at least on her. My resistance broke. I needed her, and she was offering herself to me.

“Aren’t you going to take your shirt off?” She smiled.

“You’ve seen me without a shirt on.”

“Yes, but not while I wasn’t wearing my own.”

I pulled off my t-shirt and tossed it on the ground next to hers.

“Thank you.”

“Did you just thank me for taking my shirt off?”

“Yeah, I think I did.” She blushed slightly.

“I guess that means I should be thanking you for taking yours off—but then again you aren’t exactly shirtless yet.”

“Technically I am.”

“Yeah, but you have on a bra. I don’t.”

“I wasn’t aware you usually wore bras, Macon.”

I chuckled. “You’re something else, Carly.”

“I already know that.” She grinned. “But back to what you were saying. Although I am technically shirtless, you may have a point that for a girl to be shirtless usually means she’s not wearing a bra.”

“So I don’t need to thank you.” I gave up forcing my eyes to stay on her face. They were much happier studying the pale skin exposed by her bra. This one must have cut lower than her usual bikini tops, because there was a definite tan line. I was ready to see the rest of that tan line.

She reached behind her and unhooked her bra. She dropped it on the floor.

“Thank you.” I barely got the words out. I forced my eyes away from the absolutely perfect set of breasts in front of me. I knew we were treading into no turning back territory, and I needed to make sure she knew that. “I’m guessing you realize that I really want to touch you right now.”

“Macon. Hun. Generally when a girl starts stripping down in front of you and asking you to take your clothes off, it means she wants you to touch her.”

I laughed. “Is that so? I’m so glad you clarified that.” I couldn’t wait any longer. I lowered my mouth to one breast while my hand fondled the other. I ran my tongue over her nipple. She moaned, and I took it as an invitation to continue.

“Macon,” she moaned as she fumbled with my belt. While she worked on it I slid my free hand up her leg and into the opening of her shorts. I brushed my hand over her silky underwear. I wondered what color they were and decided I was going to find out. I momentarily released her breasts as I boosted her up slightly so I could slide her shorts down her legs. The blue material fell to the floor, and I took in the sight of the purple silk.

“Purple, nice.”

She’d finished with my belt and moved on to my button and zipper. I stepped out of my shorts, ready to have less between us.

“Red plaid, nice.” She giggled and nearly lost her balance on the counter. I steadied her.

That’s when reality set in. We’d both had a lot to drink. I wasn’t about to take advantage of her. I stepped back.

She gaped at me. “What’s wrong?”

“We can’t do this.”

“Why not?” She covered her chest with her arms.

I swallowed hard. Every part of me wanted her, but not like this. Not when I had any question of whether she’d regret it in the morning. “Because we’ve both had too much to drink.”

“I’m not drunk.”

“Carly…”

“I get it. Enough said.” Tears welled in her eyes,

“Carly, come on. I’m trying to do the right thing here.”

“Gotcha.” She slipped off the counter, picked up her skirt and bra and practically ran to her room, slamming the door behind her.

I bent down and picked up the t-shirt she’d forgotten. For a brief second I considered running after her, but I knew that would be a mistake.

I slunk down on the couch without bothering to get dressed. What the hell had just happened? I’d just fucked up everything. I should have put the brakes on way earlier, and I knew exactly why I hadn’t. I wanted her. I wanted to see, feel, and touch every damn thing she had to offer. Yet somehow that had ended in my making her cry. Fucking fantastic. I downed the rest of my Long Island without tasting it.

I was still sitting in the same spot when the front door opened at some point later. I was too out of it to even notice the time change.

“What the hell did you do?” Brody dropped his backpack as soon as he closed the door.

“What makes you think I did anything?”

“Let’s see. You’re sitting on the couch in your underwear holding a Surfside Grille t-shirt. Either you’ve got some t-shirt fetish I don’t want to hear about, or you slept with Carly. At the moment I’m hoping it’s the fetish.”

I looked down at the t-shirt still in my hands. “It’s neither.”

He sat down on the love seat. “Meaning…”

“What are you doing home anyway? Aren’t you supposed to be in Augusta still?”

“It was all crazy stressed out planning for my brother’s wedding. I left early, but don’t change the subject.”

“I didn’t sleep with her. I got close, and damn it I wanted to, but we’d been drinking. It seemed like a bad idea.”

Brody grinned. “Well I’ll be damned.”

“What?” I prepared myself for whatever smart aleck comment he had coming.

“You actually made a smart decision, and you did it for the sake of someone else. I’d have thought I’d see pigs fly first.”

“Shut up. I just hope she’ll talk to me tomorrow. She started crying and ran into her room.”

“Did you try to talk to her?”

I shook my head.

“Good. Give her some time and let her save face.”

“Save face?”

“I’m sure the whole situation was embarrassing for her.”

I groaned. “You’re not allowed to go away again.”

“What, you don’t trust yourself alone with her?”

“No. Obviously I shouldn’t.” I pulled myself off the couch. “I need a shower.”

“A cold one?”

“What other kind would I take?”

“You did the right thing, Macon.”

I turned back. “Then why do I feel so awful right now?”

“I said you did the right thing, not the easy or fun thing.”

“Maybe she’ll forget this ever happened.”

“Now that’s just called being delusional.”

I didn’t bother to answer. I headed down the hall to the bathroom. Even before I stepped into the shower, I knew the cold water was going to do nothing to cool my feelings for Carly. I had it bad.

Mortification. Mortification like I’d never imagined possible hit me like a freight train when I lay in bed the morning after my failed attempt at bartending. I guess I could add seducing Macon to my list of things I failed at too. I mean who couldn’t get Macon to sleep with her? I was an idiot to even try, but after a few shots I couldn’t help it. I was tired of pretending I didn’t have feelings for him. He’d seemed so into it, so ready to take things there, and then he’d stopped. His excuse was we’d had a lot to drink? Maybe I was a little buzzed, but I was sober enough to know what I was doing. Besides, I got this gnawing feeling that there was more. Something else was holding him back, and I was sure it had something to do with me.

As soon as the clock hit six o’clock I was up and out of bed. It was early enough that I could avoid seeing Macon, but late enough that I knew Colin would be awake. I didn’t bother with a shower, I’d just do that at Colin’s house. Thankfully, I’d kept his spare key. I’d also left some clothes there. Theoretically I could move back in with him, but what would that look like? Carly the screw up. I couldn’t even live with guys without making a fool of myself. I was going to slip out before Macon woke up to give myself one reprieve from facing him, but that was it. By that evening I needed to get over it and act like I didn’t even care.

I didn’t hear anything out in the main area, so I carefully opened my door. I took a few steps toward the kitchen. “Good morning, Carly.”

My heart sped up before returning to normal when I realized it was Brody. Wasn’t he supposed to be away?

“Hey. I thought you went back to your parents’ house.”

“I’m back early.” He walked over to the coffee maker. “Want a cup?”

“Oh, that’s okay. I’m going to head out.”

“Let’s go for a walk.” He didn’t say anything. He refilled his mug before filling another.

“I actually need to go by my brother’s house.”

“Just take a short walk with me.” He handed me the tall mug full of black coffee. A few months earlier I’d been all about the milk and sweetner, but I’d grown to prefer it black. It was so much simpler and potent that way. Maybe it was symbolic of my life. It had gone from sweet to bitter almost overnight.

“Why? Why do you want to go for a walk?” I asked suspiciously.

“Because I do.” He walked over to the door and slipped on his flip flops. “We can drink our coffee as we go.”

I weighed my options. Things were already insanely awkward with Macon, why make them weird with Brody? I assumed he’d talked to Macon. He wouldn’t have any other reason to try to get me talk to him. I grabbed my purse so I wouldn’t have to go back up.

“You want to drop that off in the trunk of your car?” Brody gestured to my small clutch as we took the stairs. My flip flops made their usual clatter on the way down.

“Oh, yeah. Probably.”

I stopped by my car and dropped off my bag. I went to pocket my keys, belatedly realizing I didn’t have a pocket in the skirt I was wearing.

“I can hold these for you.” Brody took them and slipped them into his pocket.

I stifled a groan. He was making sure I didn’t just storm off.

We walked down the empty beach in silence at first. I let out a few deep breaths and enjoyed the quiet I knew would disappear in just a few hours when everyone else woke up. I watched the waves move in and out. There was something so comforting about the rhythmic nature of it. Some waves crashed further up on the beach than others, but they still kept coming. Nothing stopped the cycle.

“I like you Carly.”

I felt a moment of panic. What? Was Brody about to admit he had feelings for me or something? I tried to compose myself.

“Wait. Not like that.”

“Okay, good.” That would have seriously complicated things.

He laughed. “That scary of a thought, huh?” he teased.

“Of course not.”

“You just want one normal roommate relationship, I get it.”

“I’m guessing you talked to Macon.”

“Yeah… I did.”

“Wonderful.”

“Carly?”

I looked up at him. “Yeah?”

“He likes you.” Brody’s expression was suddenly serious. “Let’s just get that part out of the way.”

“Kind of how you like me?” I gave him a long look.