Pauline Kael (70 page)
Authors: Brian Kellow
124
“When she was on somebody’s side”:
Author interview with Lorenzo Semple, Jr., October 5, 2008.
“When she was on somebody’s side”:
Author interview with Lorenzo Semple, Jr., October 5, 2008.
124
“I’m going to bring a friend along”:
Ibid.
“I’m going to bring a friend along”:
Ibid.
124
“a habit of hers when she went out to dinner”:
Ibid.
CHAPTER ELEVEN“a habit of hers when she went out to dinner”:
Ibid.
125
“the spray of venom”:
Pauline Kael, “The Current Cinema,”
The New Yorker
(September 27, 1969).
“the spray of venom”:
Pauline Kael, “The Current Cinema,”
The New Yorker
(September 27, 1969).
125
“grotesque shock effects”:
Ibid.
“grotesque shock effects”:
Ibid.
125
“the simple,
Of Mice and Men
kind of relationship at the heart of it”:
Ibid.
“the simple,
Of Mice and Men
kind of relationship at the heart of it”:
Ibid.
126
“What is new about
Easy Rider
”:
Ibid.
“What is new about
Easy Rider
”:
Ibid.
127
“a basic decency and intelligence in his work”:
Ibid.
“a basic decency and intelligence in his work”:
Ibid.
127
“really seem to have the style for anything”:
Ibid.
“really seem to have the style for anything”:
Ibid.
127
“facetious Western”:
Ibid.
“facetious Western”:
Ibid.
127
“destroys one’s sense of mood and time and place”:
Life
(October 24, 1969).
“destroys one’s sense of mood and time and place”:
Life
(October 24, 1969).
127
“The dialogue is all banter”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(September 27, 1969).
“The dialogue is all banter”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(September 27, 1969).
127
“Listen, you miserable bitch”:
Letter from George Roy Hill to Pauline Kael, September 26, 1969.
“Listen, you miserable bitch”:
Letter from George Roy Hill to Pauline Kael, September 26, 1969.
128
“Americans talk a lot about marital infidelity”:
Columbia Pictures publicity handout,
Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice.
“Americans talk a lot about marital infidelity”:
Columbia Pictures publicity handout,
Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice.
128
“I felt obliged to note that I did not believe”:
New York
Daily News
, October 6, 1969.
“I felt obliged to note that I did not believe”:
New York
Daily News
, October 6, 1969.
128
“When it was offered to me”:
Author interview with Elliott Gould, June 13, 2009.
“When it was offered to me”:
Author interview with Elliott Gould, June 13, 2009.
128
“unpleasant”:
The New York Times
, September 17, 1969.
“unpleasant”:
The New York Times
, September 17, 1969.
128
“I read Canby’s review”:
Author interview with Paul Mazursky, September 2, 2009.
“I read Canby’s review”:
Author interview with Paul Mazursky, September 2, 2009.
129
“
Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice
is a slick, whorey movie”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 4, 1969).
“
Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice
is a slick, whorey movie”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 4, 1969).
129
“taken the series of revue sketches”:
Ibid.
“taken the series of revue sketches”:
Ibid.
129
“looks a bit like Lauren Bacall and a bit like Jeanne Moreau”:
Ibid.
“looks a bit like Lauren Bacall and a bit like Jeanne Moreau”:
Ibid.
129
“Someone tapped me on the shoulder from behind”:
Author interview with Dyan Cannon, June 13, 2009.
“Someone tapped me on the shoulder from behind”:
Author interview with Dyan Cannon, June 13, 2009.
129
“probably the most sophisticated intelligence”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 18, 1969).
“probably the most sophisticated intelligence”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(October 18, 1969).
129
“the most insidious kind of enemy”:
Ibid.
“the most insidious kind of enemy”:
Ibid.
129
“
High School
is so familiar”:
Ibid.
“
High School
is so familiar”:
Ibid.
130
“Many of us grow to hate documentaries”:
Ibid.
“Many of us grow to hate documentaries”:
Ibid.
130
“Joe is a very soft-spoken, kind guy”:
Author interview with Frederick Wiseman, October 8, 2008.
“Joe is a very soft-spoken, kind guy”:
Author interview with Frederick Wiseman, October 8, 2008.
130
“The impression I had was that she felt I didn’t need her”:
Ibid.
“The impression I had was that she felt I didn’t need her”:
Ibid.
130
“Dear Sir: I think I’ve figured it out”:
Letter from Cornelius Freeman to
The New Yorker
, November 28, 1969.
“Dear Sir: I think I’ve figured it out”:
Letter from Cornelius Freeman to
The New Yorker
, November 28, 1969.
130
“There was a time”:
Letter from Leslie E. Jones to
The New Yorker,
November 1969.
“There was a time”:
Letter from Leslie E. Jones to
The New Yorker,
November 1969.
130
“They’re looking for ‘truth’ ”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(September 27, 1969).
“They’re looking for ‘truth’ ”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(September 27, 1969).
131
“Grim”:
Author interview with Carrie Rickey, May 9, 2009.
“Grim”:
Author interview with Carrie Rickey, May 9, 2009.
131
“How’re you going to feed it?”:
James Poe and Robert E. Thompson, screenplay of
They Shoot Horses, Don’t They?,
1969.
“How’re you going to feed it?”:
James Poe and Robert E. Thompson, screenplay of
They Shoot Horses, Don’t They?,
1969.
131
“I’m tired of losing!”:
Ibid.
“I’m tired of losing!”:
Ibid.
131
“She doesn’t try to save some ladylike part of herself ”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(December 20, 1969).
“She doesn’t try to save some ladylike part of herself ”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(December 20, 1969).
132
“a good chance of personifying American tensions”:
Ibid.
“a good chance of personifying American tensions”:
Ibid.
132
“Somewhere along the line”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 3, 1970).
“Somewhere along the line”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 3, 1970).
132
“is alive to”:
Ibid.
“is alive to”:
Ibid.
132
“to be liberated from period clothes”:
Ibid.
“to be liberated from period clothes”:
Ibid.
132
“not using decadence as a metaphor for Naziism”:
Ibid.
“not using decadence as a metaphor for Naziism”:
Ibid.
132
“Visconti, though drawn to excess”:
Ibid.
“Visconti, though drawn to excess”:
Ibid.
132
“I have rarely seen a picture I enjoyed less”:
Ibid.
“I have rarely seen a picture I enjoyed less”:
Ibid.
133
“a B-25 pilot”:
Twentieth Century–Fox publicity handout,
M*A*S*H.
“a B-25 pilot”:
Twentieth Century–Fox publicity handout,
M*A*S*H.
133
“Bob had gotten fired from Warners”:
Author interview with George Litto, June 4, 2010.
“Bob had gotten fired from Warners”:
Author interview with George Litto, June 4, 2010.
133
“Did you hear that?”:
Author interview with Rene Auberjonois, September 2, 2009.
“Did you hear that?”:
Author interview with Rene Auberjonois, September 2, 2009.
133
“He was referring to a conversation”:
Ibid.
“He was referring to a conversation”:
Ibid.
134
“I remember the sound engineer”:
Ibid.
“I remember the sound engineer”:
Ibid.
134
“Donald Sutherland and I became very close during the process”:
Author interview with Elliott Gould, June 13, 2009.
“Donald Sutherland and I became very close during the process”:
Author interview with Elliott Gould, June 13, 2009.
135
“We were completely under the radar”:
Author interview with Rene Auberjonois, September 2, 2009.
“We were completely under the radar”:
Author interview with Rene Auberjonois, September 2, 2009.
135
“This picture wasn’t released—it escaped”:
Robert Altman, interview for Twentieth Century–Fox DVD release,
M*A*S*H.
“This picture wasn’t released—it escaped”:
Robert Altman, interview for Twentieth Century–Fox DVD release,
M*A*S*H.
135
“a marvelously unstable comedy”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 24, 1970).
“a marvelously unstable comedy”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 24, 1970).
135
“competence is one of the values the movie respects”:
Ibid.
“competence is one of the values the movie respects”:
Ibid.
135
“I’ve rarely heard four-letter words used so exquisitely well”:
Ibid.
“I’ve rarely heard four-letter words used so exquisitely well”:
Ibid.
135
“When the dialogue overlaps”:
Ibid.
“When the dialogue overlaps”:
Ibid.
135
“Many of the best recent American movies leave you feeling”:
Ibid.
“Many of the best recent American movies leave you feeling”:
Ibid.
136
“His pictures showed life taking its course”:
Author interview with Elliott Gould, June 13, 2009.
“His pictures showed life taking its course”:
Author interview with Elliott Gould, June 13, 2009.
136
“After so many movies that come on strong”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 4, 1970).
“After so many movies that come on strong”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 4, 1970).
136
“Pauline Kael is my favorite movie critic”:
The New York Times
, undated.
“Pauline Kael is my favorite movie critic”:
The New York Times
, undated.
137
“While I miss the polemics”:
Ibid.
“While I miss the polemics”:
Ibid.
137
“One doesn’t want to talk about how Tolstoi got his effects”:
Pauline Kael, “Trash, Art and the Movies”:
Harper’s
(February 1969).
“One doesn’t want to talk about how Tolstoi got his effects”:
Pauline Kael, “Trash, Art and the Movies”:
Harper’s
(February 1969).
137
“By neglecting to analyze technique”:
The New York Times Book Review,
February 22, 1970.
“By neglecting to analyze technique”:
The New York Times Book Review,
February 22, 1970.
137
“About film art”:
Ibid.
“About film art”:
Ibid.
137
“In her youth, as the author avows”:
Ibid.
“In her youth, as the author avows”:
Ibid.
139
“I never adapted to New York”:
People
(April 18, 1983).
“I never adapted to New York”:
People
(April 18, 1983).
139
“for her film criticism”:
Citation from the American Academy of Arts and Letters and the National Institute of Arts and Letters, May 26, 1970.
“for her film criticism”:
Citation from the American Academy of Arts and Letters and the National Institute of Arts and Letters, May 26, 1970.
140
“Gimme a P, Gimme a G”:
Letter from Michael B. Pulman, Department of History, Florida State University, to
The New Yorker
, May 23, 1971.
“Gimme a P, Gimme a G”:
Letter from Michael B. Pulman, Department of History, Florida State University, to
The New Yorker
, May 23, 1971.
140
“could focus under the most intense sedation—alcohol”:
Author interview with Jane Kramer, February 24, 2009.
“could focus under the most intense sedation—alcohol”:
Author interview with Jane Kramer, February 24, 2009.
141
“My sense was that they stayed out of each other’s way almost intentionally”:
Ibid.
“My sense was that they stayed out of each other’s way almost intentionally”:
Ibid.
141
“My personal feeling—more than personally—is that Pauline did not have any respect, particularly, for Penelope”:
Author interview with Sally Ann Mock, February 27, 2009.
CHAPTER TWELVE“My personal feeling—more than personally—is that Pauline did not have any respect, particularly, for Penelope”:
Author interview with Sally Ann Mock, February 27, 2009.
143
“there was an obvious hunger for film”:
Toby Talbot,
The New Yorker Theater and Other Scenes from a Life at the Movies
(New York: Columbia University Press, 2009), 53.
“there was an obvious hunger for film”:
Toby Talbot,
The New Yorker Theater and Other Scenes from a Life at the Movies
(New York: Columbia University Press, 2009), 53.
144
“at one end of the table were the intellectuals”:
Author interview with Judith Crist, July 17, 2008.
“at one end of the table were the intellectuals”:
Author interview with Judith Crist, July 17, 2008.
144
“I always felt that there was an assumption”:
Author interview with Kathleen Carroll, February 25, 2009.
“I always felt that there was an assumption”:
Author interview with Kathleen Carroll, February 25, 2009.
144
“Headliners and by-liners help us do the job”:
The New York Times
, September 15, 1968.
“Headliners and by-liners help us do the job”:
The New York Times
, September 15, 1968.
145
“I have slept through more productions of this dated play”:
New York
Daily News
, June 1, 1973.
“I have slept through more productions of this dated play”:
New York
Daily News
, June 1, 1973.
145
“Well, when he shows up at screenings”:
Author interview with Judith Crist, July 17, 2008.
“Well, when he shows up at screenings”:
Author interview with Judith Crist, July 17, 2008.
146
“Pauline! Of course,
you
come to all the finest pictures”:
Author interview with John Simon, March 6, 2008.
“Pauline! Of course,
you
come to all the finest pictures”:
Author interview with John Simon, March 6, 2008.
146
“There were a lot of directors”:
Author interview with Paul Schrader, August 31, 2009.
“There were a lot of directors”:
Author interview with Paul Schrader, August 31, 2009.
146
“It used to be that understood that no matter how low your estimate of the public intelligence was”:
Pauline Kael, “The Current Cinema,”
The New Yorker
(October 3, 1970).
“It used to be that understood that no matter how low your estimate of the public intelligence was”:
Pauline Kael, “The Current Cinema,”
The New Yorker
(October 3, 1970).
147
“no contemporary American subject provided a better test of the new movie freedom than student unrest”:
Ibid.
“no contemporary American subject provided a better test of the new movie freedom than student unrest”:
Ibid.
147
“the recently developed political consciousness”:
Ibid.
“the recently developed political consciousness”:
Ibid.
147
“slanted to feed the paranoia of youth”:
Ibid.
“slanted to feed the paranoia of youth”:
Ibid.
147
“members of the audience responded on cue”:
Ibid.
“members of the audience responded on cue”:
Ibid.
147
“manipulation of the audience is so shrewdly, single-mindedly commercial”:
Ibid.
“manipulation of the audience is so shrewdly, single-mindedly commercial”:
Ibid.
148
“not caring, and not believing anything”:
Ibid.
“not caring, and not believing anything”:
Ibid.
148
“She
owned
Gina”:
Author interview with Charles Simmons, June 29, 2009.
“She
owned
Gina”:
Author interview with Charles Simmons, June 29, 2009.
149
“tone deaf about the effects of things on people”:
Author interview with Dana Salisbury, September 20, 2009.
“tone deaf about the effects of things on people”:
Author interview with Dana Salisbury, September 20, 2009.
149
“I think George lifted Barbra, in a way”:
Author interview with Buck Henry, April 27, 2009.
“I think George lifted Barbra, in a way”:
Author interview with Buck Henry, April 27, 2009.
149
“Were Hepburn and Tracy this good together”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 14, 1970).
“Were Hepburn and Tracy this good together”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 14, 1970).
149
“to see Streisand”:
Ibid.
“to see Streisand”:
Ibid.
149
“like thousands of girls”:
Ibid.
“like thousands of girls”:
Ibid.
150
“a good idea in theory, a bad one in practice”:
Kevin Brownlow,
David Lean: A Biography
(New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1996), 585.
“a good idea in theory, a bad one in practice”:
Kevin Brownlow,
David Lean: A Biography
(New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1996), 585.
150
“no driving emotional energy”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 21, 1970).
“no driving emotional energy”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(November 21, 1970).
150
“gush made respectable”:
Ibid.
“gush made respectable”:
Ibid.
150
“a lousy lay”:
Brownlow, 586.
“a lousy lay”:
Brownlow, 586.
151
“We’ll give you color”:
Ibid.
“We’ll give you color”:
Ibid.
151
“The book has been promoted from the start”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(December 26, 1970).
“The book has been promoted from the start”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(December 26, 1970).
151
“should bring joy to millions”:
New York
Daily News
, January 12, 1971.
“should bring joy to millions”:
New York
Daily News
, January 12, 1971.
151
“It deals in private passion at a time when we are exhausted from public defeats”:
Ibid.
“It deals in private passion at a time when we are exhausted from public defeats”:
Ibid.
152
“You don’t want to be a minister”:
Paul Schrader,
Schrader on Schrader & Other Writings
(London: Faber & Faber, 1990), 291.
“You don’t want to be a minister”:
Paul Schrader,
Schrader on Schrader & Other Writings
(London: Faber & Faber, 1990), 291.
152
“some cold chitchat”:
Ibid., 292.
“some cold chitchat”:
Ibid., 292.
153
“I don’t trust critics who say they care only for the highest and the best”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 23, 1971).
“I don’t trust critics who say they care only for the highest and the best”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(January 23, 1971).
153
“free-spirited”:
Ibid.
“free-spirited”:
Ibid.
153
“have been so sold on Pop and so saturated with it that they appear to have lost their bearings in the arts”:
Ibid.
“have been so sold on Pop and so saturated with it that they appear to have lost their bearings in the arts”:
Ibid.
153
“In most cases, the conglomerates”:
Ibid.
“In most cases, the conglomerates”:
Ibid.
153
“they understand that their job is dependent on keeping everybody happy”:
Ibid.
“they understand that their job is dependent on keeping everybody happy”:
Ibid.
154
“I don’t have any doubts about movies being a great art form”:
Ibid.
“I don’t have any doubts about movies being a great art form”:
Ibid.
154
“summery richness”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 20, 1971).
“summery richness”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 20, 1971).
154
“no emotional head of steam”:
Ibid.
“no emotional head of steam”:
Ibid.
154
“Our desire for grace and seductive opulence is innocent”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 27, 1971).
CHAPTER THIRTEEN“Our desire for grace and seductive opulence is innocent”:
Kael,
The New Yorker
(March 27, 1971).
156
“You have no say at all”:
Patrick McGilligan,
Backstory 2: Interviews with Screenwriters of the 1940s and 1950s
(Berkeley: University of California Press, 1991).
“You have no say at all”:
Patrick McGilligan,
Backstory 2: Interviews with Screenwriters of the 1940s and 1950s
(Berkeley: University of California Press, 1991).
157
“I hear you’re pretty good in seminars but boring as a lecturer”:
Author interview with Howard Suber, July 28, 2010.
“I hear you’re pretty good in seminars but boring as a lecturer”:
Author interview with Howard Suber, July 28, 2010.
158
“Why would the biggest film critic in America”:
Ibid.
“Why would the biggest film critic in America”:
Ibid.
158
“all the time, but not as a distinguished visitor”:
Author interview with Tom Mankiewicz, December 16, 2008.
“all the time, but not as a distinguished visitor”:
Author interview with Tom Mankiewicz, December 16, 2008.
159
“bitter experiences”:
Howard Suber interview with Sara Mankiewicz, housed at the Lilly Library, Indiana University.
“bitter experiences”:
Howard Suber interview with Sara Mankiewicz, housed at the Lilly Library, Indiana University.
159
“A brand-new bicycle”:
Ibid.
“A brand-new bicycle”:
Ibid.
160
“to write and produce a work of fiction”:
Deposition of Orson Welles, April 1949.
“to write and produce a work of fiction”:
Deposition of Orson Welles, April 1949.
160
“When an actor becomes the role offstage”:
Note written by Pauline Kael, housed at the Lilly Library.
“When an actor becomes the role offstage”:
Note written by Pauline Kael, housed at the Lilly Library.
161
“Well . . . it’s a trivial point”:
Author interview with Howard Suber, July 28, 2010.
“Well . . . it’s a trivial point”:
Author interview with Howard Suber, July 28, 2010.
161
“
Citizen Kane
is perhaps the one American talking picture”:
Pauline Kael, “Onward and Upward with the Arts,”
The New Yorker
(February 20/27, 1971).
“
Citizen Kane
is perhaps the one American talking picture”:
Pauline Kael, “Onward and Upward with the Arts,”
The New Yorker
(February 20/27, 1971).
161
“
Citizen Kane
. . . isn’t a work of special depth”:
Ibid.
“
Citizen Kane
. . . isn’t a work of special depth”:
Ibid.
161
“conceived and acted as entertainment in a popular style”:
Ibid.
“conceived and acted as entertainment in a popular style”:
Ibid.
162
“conventional schoolbook explanations for greatness”:
Ibid.
“conventional schoolbook explanations for greatness”:
Ibid.
162
“to miss what makes it such an American triumph”:
Ibid.
“to miss what makes it such an American triumph”:
Ibid.
162
“never been rivaled in wit and exuberance”:
Ibid.
“never been rivaled in wit and exuberance”:
Ibid.
162
“may for a brief period”:
Ibid.
“may for a brief period”:
Ibid.
162
“When I got into it”:
Ibid.
“When I got into it”:
Ibid.
162
“idiotic indiscretion”:
Ibid.
“idiotic indiscretion”:
Ibid.
163
“Men cheated of their due”:
Ibid.
“Men cheated of their due”:
Ibid.
163
“such worship generally doesn’t help”:
Ibid.
“such worship generally doesn’t help”:
Ibid.
163
“Welles isn’t in it”:
Ibid.
“Welles isn’t in it”:
Ibid.
163
“Gothic atmosphere”:
Ibid.
“Gothic atmosphere”:
Ibid.
Other books
Hour of the Wolf by Hakan Nesser
Always and Forever by Beverly Jenkins
Tempted by the Highland Warrior by Michelle Willingham
Road Trip by Melody Carlson
The School for Brides by Cheryl Ann Smith
Writing the Cozy Mystery by Cohen, Nancy J.
The Impossible Ward by Dorothy Mack
The Big Miss: My Years Coaching Tiger Woods by Hank Haney
Major Karnage by Zajac, Gord
Timbuktu by Paul Auster