Saving Forever (The Ever Trilogy: Book 3) (40 page)

He frowned. “I’m not sure you’re ever
okay
, or
over
things like that. I loved Britt. I was at least partially responsible for her death. That will always be a part of me. But…I can’t change what happened. And I can’t keep living in the past. I want to be
alive.
I want to be happy. I want to have a future. If I’m this silent shadow just floating through life living in a pattern, not really
participating
in my life, then what’s the point? Why don’t I just become a shut-in? Just give up. You didn’t intentionally do anything. You didn’t fix me. One person can’t fix another. I’m not trying to fix you. What you did was provide me with a reminder that there’s life out there. That I have something to say. I have desires. I have pet peeves and fetishes. Maybe not
fetishes
, that may not be the right word. I’m not into, like, feathers or whips and chains and hot wax. I just meant I like certain things and not others. My point is, you were a reminder that even though I’d lost someone I loved—still love, really, because that kind of love never goes away—I’m still alive, and I deserve to live my life. I have the guilt still, because that also never goes away. You make a mistake, do something wrong—it doesn’t just go away. You have to come to terms with it, Eden. Accept the guilt, acknowledge your fault. Then live. Learn from it, and keep going. You don’t forget, you don’t block it or bury it. You just…live. Don’t let guilt define you.”

I laughed bitterly. “You make it sound so simple.”

“It is simple. It’s just not
easy.
” Carter stepped away from me, moving into the kitchen and rummaging through cupboards. “Is what happened with Cade the only thing about you that I need to know? Is it the totality of
you
?”

“No, but—”

“Is having had a baby and giving it up for adoption to your sister and brother-in-law all of what makes Eden Eliot a person?”

“No, but—”

He set two wine glasses on the counter, rummaged in the fridge and pulled out a bottle of Chateau Chantal Riesling, twisted the top off and poured a big glass for each of us. Handed me one, and sipped at his before he continued. “Then who are you? What makes you,
you
?”

I stared into the pale gold liquid. Except for the tiny half-glass on Christmas, I hadn’t had a drop to drink for over nine months. I thought about the question. “How do you define yourself in a few words? I’m a cellist. I’m a twin. I’m a musician, a composer. I like to read romance books. The smutty, steamy, bodice-ripper kind. I like car-chase movies like
Gone in 60 Seconds
or
Fast and Furious.
I also like end-of-the-world movies, like
Armageddon
or
Day After Tomorrow.
” I sipped at my wine, closing my eyes and savoring the sweet, cold taste. I thought, and let whatever came to mind about myself emerge from my mouth. “I really, really like sex. I like it hard and fast, and slow and gentle. A little rough, but I don’t like pain. I like to be the instigator, and I like it even more when control is taken from me. But that rarely happens. I like wine, mostly white, and a few kinds of red. I hate light beer, and I like reds, like Killian’s. I hate whiskey. I love gin. I’m a gin snob. Don’t bother if it’s not Sapphire. I can’t sew, knit, crochet, or anything like that. I suck at cooking. I can burn water and chronically undercook chicken, overcook red meat, and I can’t ever seem to time my dishes to be done at the same time. Recipes confuse me, but I don’t have the instinct for improvisation. I love food. I’m a foodie. It’s why I work out so much. Dieting makes me angry, so I work out like a madwoman instead, so I can eat what I want. I was on a diet from the time I was thirteen till I was twenty, and then one day I just said ‘fuck it.’ I’m gonna eat what I want, when I want, and if I gain weight because of it, I’ll just work it off. But yet I still try to eat healthy, just not a diet. I had a baby, but I don’t identify myself as a mother.”

Carter’s eyes were watching my mouth as I spoke, but I knew he was cataloguing everything I said. He sipped his wine, his hooded eyes piercing sky blue over the rim of his glass, hot on me.

“I’ve never done anal, and I’ve always secretly wanted to.” I had no idea I was going to say that. It just popped out.
 

Carter sputtered and coughed, choking on his wine. “Jesus, wasn’t expecting that. Okay.”

I blushed. “Sorry. I—I’m not sure why I said that. TMI, probably.”

He chewed on his lip, and then shook his head. “No. Nothing is TMI. I’ve never done that, either.
 
With Britt, it—we weren’t like that. I’m not gonna go into details, but…it wasn’t like that.”

“You don’t have to say anything, tell me anything, but just…you
can.
You can talk about her, if you want. Talking about exes is usually a no-no, but that’s different, I think. For me, at least.”

He didn’t answer right away. “We were eighteen when we met. We weren’t each other’s firsts, but almost. After your first, you’re sort of…you feel—I don’t know. Adult? Like you know what you’re doing? But you don’t, not really. That was us. It was always just…simple. Nothing adventurous or crazy. I think the craziest thing we ever did was sex outside, on a picnic. A blanket on the grass, under a tree.” He laughed self-consciously. “It was
so
uncomfortable. There was a root under the blanket, and the tree kept shedding those little helicopter things, you know? The seed things? They kept hitting me in the head. Landing on us. And ants had found our food and were freaking Britt out. But…for us, it was just…easy. Simple. Us together was all we needed. I don’t think we ever even thought about…I don’t know, trying stuff, I guess.”

I could see that about Carter. “There’s nothing wrong with that.” I set my glass down. “I’m not into anything weird, okay? Don’t get the wrong idea. I’ve never told anyone that before. About wanting to try…that. It was a sudden confession, I guess you could call it.”

Carter reached out and took my hand. “Since we’re talking about sex, I want to make something clear. I sort of said it earlier, but I want to say it again. I don’t have any expectations, Eden. None. I want you. I’ll be honest. Yes, I want that, with you. When it’s right for you. You’ve been through a lot, and I don’t want you to feel any pressure. You’re not physically ready yet anyway, but even after you are, I didn’t bring you here for that. Not for that alone, at least. I brought you here because I enjoy your company. I want to be around you all the time.” He pulled me against him. His heartbeat was a steady, comforting rhythm on my cheek. “I’ve gotten addicted to being around you. Especially over the past few weeks. You’ve become a part of my everyday. And I don’t want to give that up. I don’t see why I should, either. Our relationship may not fit into any easy boxes or categories, and I don’t care. Are we dating? I don’t know. Are we a couple? I don’t know. We’ve been together every single day for months, but we’ve never done more than share a couple of kisses. I’ve slept beside you more than once. I held your hand while you gave birth. You know all my secrets, and I know yours. But
what
are we? I don’t know. And I don’t think it matters. We are what we are. I want us to do what’s comfortable and right for
us
, regardless of whether it has a label or box or pigeonhole.” He touched my chin, a soft and tender smile on his lips. “That’s all I meant when I said ‘just be.’ It doesn’t have to be complicated. Just be you. Be yourself, in my home. Be yourself, in my life. That’s it.”

I felt an ache in my chest, a swelling of hope, the germinated seed of happiness sending a tendril up toward the sun that was Carter. “I can do that. I think.”

He smiled. “Good. That’s all I’m asking. Be you. Be open and honest and exactly who you are. Don’t hide your fears, don’t hide your insecurities. Don’t push me away because you’re afraid. I’m a little scared of this, too, okay? I haven’t been with anyone since Britt, either, and that’s scary. She was the last person I was with in any sense. So I’ve got my own set of nerves and fears. And I’m perfectly willing to share those with you.” He lifted his glass up for a toast. “To us, whatever the hell we are.”

I laughed and clinked my glass against his. “To us, whatever the hell we are.”

We sipped our wine, and Carter began taking food out of the fridge, assembling the makings for a meal. “Lucky for you,” he told me as he put pork chops into the oven, “I can cook. I’m no gourmet, but I can put some good food on the table. Mom made sure all of us boys could make real food for ourselves by the time we graduated high school. You wouldn’t think it, but Tommy is the best cook in the family.
He
can whip up some gourmet shit, lemme tell you.”

Carter made a salad of fresh spinach, walnuts, fresh strawberries, and gorgonzola cheese, as well as hand-mashed potatoes and broccoli with rice. I helped peel the potatoes and mash them—according to his instructions—and we sat in the hand-carved chairs on the small porch outside the kitchen. While waiting for the food to cook, we sipped our wine and talked of lighter things, the kind of casual, random conversation you can only have through mutual vulnerability, the familiarity of shared secrets.
 

Carter plated the food and carried it out to the gazebo, where we ate and watched the sun set, going through a second bottle of wine. I was loose and warm inside, comfortable and easy around Carter as always, but now there was a subtext of desire, the knowledge that eventually, someday, sometime, we’d act on the sexual tension that was building between us.
 

The air was chilly still, and on the island there was a constant wind, but Carter kept blankets and extra fleece jackets in a hidden cabinet in the gazebo. I wore one of his old jackets, a faded, well-worn rust-orange Columbia that was several sizes too big, perfect for burrowing into, my hands tucked inside the sleeves. It smelled of him, of his natural scent, and it was deliciously warm and soft. When we finished eating, I curled up against him, his arm around me. I nuzzled into his chest, my wine glass nearly empty, full of good food and full of hope for the future.
 

For the first time since Ever’s accident, perhaps for the first time ever in my life, I felt totally at peace.
 

~ ~ ~ ~

He’d made it clear that I could choose where I slept. There were spare bedrooms, but I didn’t see the point. I slept with Carter, in his bed. He was a perfect gentlemen, offering me privacy to change, making sure I had my space in the bed if I needed it. I didn’t. I stayed modestly covered, wearing a T-shirt and boy boxers to bed, but when we slid into the blankets, I cuddled against him and enjoyed the feeling of being held.
 

He gave good cuddle. The bed was huge and soft, the blankets warm, and he was a solid, strong, safe presence. The knowledge that there were no expectations for sex made it easy. He just held me. I’d never been just held. Never. So at first, I was anxious, uncomfortable.

That first night, tipsy and nervous, I was tense in his arms. Eventually, his voice, sleep-muzzy, said, “Relax, Edie. Just sleep.”

So I let myself relax, I turned away from him and curled up as I would if I was alone. And, wonder of wonders, he let me sleep however I wanted. Yet, unexpectedly, I woke up in the middle of the night cold and feeling alone, and so I turned into him and his arm slid around me automatically and pulled me tight and held me close, and I fell asleep right away, tucked against his heartbeat and his soft warm skin and hard muscles. And I slept perfectly, dreamlessly, deeply.

We developed a domestic routine. He’d wake up at the ass-crack of dawn and work out, which I envied. I wasn’t allowed to do anything strenuous yet, and I desperately wanted to get back in shape. I’d taken up yoga, which wasn’t nearly as satisfying as a tough workout, but it was something to do with him while he lifted weights.

Those weeks were idyllic. Slow, peaceful, contented, calm. He taught me to cook; it turned out I was simply untaught rather than incapable. I watched him carve and build cabinets and rocking chairs and bookshelves for clients, sculpt blocks of wood into mammoths and succubae and lynx and marten and twisting spires of abstract beauty. I played, improvising merely for the delirious joy of playing Apollo. The dulcet golden notes from Apollo’s aged belly scattered across the bay, and I imagined someone on the distant shores catching faint strains of cello music from somewhere unknown.
 

We didn’t kiss, by unspoken agreement. We both knew if we kissed, if we touched, it would spark a fire that couldn’t be doused, once lit. So he held me and I burrowed and nuzzled into his warm embrace, and I held his hands, and it felt like being fourteen all over again with my first boyfriend, strolling the echoing marble halls of Somerset Mall, watching movies in my basement and cuddling and wondering when he’d kiss me.
 

I’d woken up next to enough men in my life to know what happened to them early in the morning, and I knew that was part of the reason Carter always woke up and got out of bed before me. I’d felt it, once in a while, as I drowsed in the pre-dawn gray, the hard thickness pressing against me. And then he’d stir, take a deep breath and yawn and stretch, and then he’d start gently. Slip out of bed, tug on a tank top, and hit the weight bench adjacent to the workshop. I’d get out of bed more leisurely, put on a sports bra and join him in the exercise room, put my mat down and stretch out. Basic stretches first, toe touches and lunges and palms planted on the floor between my wide-spread feet. Then I’d go into Downward-facing Dog, and hold it, pushing until I felt the burn in my muscles. I’d slide from one pose to another, and I always felt his eyes on me, especially if the pose required bending over. I liked his eyes on me, and I wasn’t shy about watching him, either.
 

As the weather got warmer, Carter began testing the water. He’d dangle his feet off the dock, and then he’d wade out to waist-high, coming in shivering and laughing. A week before my six-week appointment, he went for his first actual swim, a slow circuit of the island. I sat on the gazebo with a cup of coffee, the sun a half-circle on the water, and watched him do an easy crawl stroke, graceful and powerful. He emerged dripping on the dock, shaking, his lips blue, a triumphant grin on his face.