Still Mine (2 page)

I’ll be in touch by end of day Friday, Malcolm said.

Clare digs out her wallet and camera, then stuffs all her belongings into the trunk and locks the car doors.

At the edge of the parking lot, a streetlamp casts a tidy beam to the sidewalk. The stoplight is red. To the north Clare spots a sign, blinking but lit: R
AY’S
B
AR AND
G
RILL
. A few teenagers smoke in a cluster by the door. They fall silent and stare unabashedly at Clare as she approaches, three boys and one girl sharing a cigarette in a closed circle. The girl wears army pants and a top cropped in a ragged line just under her breasts. One of the boys breaks from the group and holds the door open for Clare with an exaggerated bow, a mock gentleman.

The bar is empty, but music plays and Clare can see the waitress and cook shuffling around the kitchen. The stares from outside follow her until she chooses a booth and props the menu to block them out, setting her camera down on the middle of the table. When Clare looks up the waitress is hovering over her.

“Kitchen closes in five minutes.”

“What’s good?” Clare asks.

The waitress shifts her weight but doesn’t answer.

“Burger and fries?”

“To drink?”

Behind the bar, dusty bottles are lined up row by row.

“Club soda,” Clare says.

The waitress pinches the top of the menu and yanks it from Clare’s grasp. Out the window the teenagers swarm to the stoplight. The double doors to the kitchen flap back and forth and Clare tries to identify the song playing, something country, sounds like Patsy Cline but the voice is too young and too polished, not husky enough. Clare’s soda can is delivered without a glass. It runs cool down her throat as she gulps it. Only when she’s half-finished it does Clare spot the notice board on the far wall of the restaurant. She slides out of her booth and walks over.

M
ISSING
: S
HAYNA
C
UNNINGHAM
F
OWLES.

Below, the date she disappeared, two weeks ago.

T
IPS?
T
ALK TO
D
ONNA.

In the kitchen the waitress is in animated conversation with the cook. The grill hisses and flares. Clare pulls down the poster and stuffs it in her back pocket. Stapled to the lower corner of the board is another notice, this one yellowed with age. T
RAILER FOR
R
ENT
. F
URNISHED
. C
ONTACT
C
HARLIE
M
ERRITT.
Clare plucks the staples from the corners and folds this paper away too. By the time the waitress emerges with her meal Clare is back in her booth, napkin spread across her lap. The plate is dropped in front of her with a clunk.

“You that photographer?” The waitress nods to the camera.

“I am.”

“We heard about you showing up.”

Clare imagines the motel attendant bolting the door, then diving for his phone. One call to his wife or his girlfriend or his sister, the highest female in his particular pecking order, and word of Clare’s arrival would spread fast from there.

“What’s your name?”

“Clare O’Dey.”

This is the first time Clare has uttered this name aloud.

“Yours?” Clare says.

“Donna.”

Donna looks to be fifty, her hair bleached yellow and tied back. The burger on Clare’s plate sags out of its bun.

“I saw you making off with my poster.”

Clare shrugs. Not quite as stealthy as she thought.

“You got a reason to want it?” Donna asks.

“I wondered if I might know her.”

“You’re not from around here.”

“No.”

“Then how would you know her?”

“She looks familiar,” Clare says.

Donna slides into the booth across from Clare.

“You’re undercover.”

“I’m not.”

“Some kind of private detective, then. Or a reporter? Snooping around and stealing posters.”

Clare doesn’t break eye contact. Whatever part she is to play in Blackmore, she must hold to it.

“I’m honestly just curious.” Clare rests her hand on the camera. “It’s a hazard of the trade.”

“Well, there’s no big story here. She wasn’t eaten by a yeti. And she wasn’t murdered.”

“How do you know?”

“Shayna Cunningham was nothing but trouble. Popped some pills and wandered off a cliff. Down at the gorge. That’s where they go to party.”

One article in the file Malcolm gave her mentioned Shayna’s penchant for drugs and the town’s slide into addiction that followed the shuttering of the mine. Those interviewed claimed that Shayna was high the night she went missing, the consensus around here being, Clare can tell by the waitress’s tone, that her status as a junkie somehow mitigates the horror of her disappearance.

“Why make a poster if you know what happened?” Clare asks.

“No one knows for sure what happened,” Donna says. “I just figured. Had them printed on a trip to town. So I could feel like I was doing something.”

Donna leans in and lowers her voice, her mistrust quickly eclipsed by the prospect of a fresh audience. Clare was never one for gossip, could never understand the willingness to divulge secrets that didn’t belong to you. She sees she’ll have no choice but to engage in it here.

“I don’t mean to sound weird,” Donna says, “but sometimes I picture her down there. Her body. Maybe she survived the fall but couldn’t climb out or call for help. You can’t be sure what happened.”

“Until they find a body.”

“And they might not. Too much rain. We had flash floods deep in the gorge. She could be halfway to the sea by now.”

“Who’s looking for her?”

“You tell me.”

“The police?”

“Detachment closed last year,” Donna says. “There was a search party that climbed down the gorge as best they could. I’d guess her father’s looking for her. Her husband sure isn’t. He’s prancing around town like nothing’s happened.”

Clare offers the waitress some of her fries. Donna takes one and folds it into her mouth.

“So you know her family?” Clare asks.

“Sure. Grew up with her mom. We both still live in the houses we were born in. I guess that’s why I bothered with the poster. Her mom couldn’t.”

“Why not?”

“She’s gone batty. Dementia hit her early.” Donna frowns. “Her husband Wilfred’s out of his mind too. Too much, I guess.”

“Too much what?”

“Sometimes everything falls apart at once. You know?”

“I know,” Clare says.

“My husband mined with Wilfred for thirty years. They showed up in Blackmore looking for work right around the same time. Right out of high school. My husband hasn’t seen him in a year. Now I heard he’s building some kind of bunker up at their house. Dug a hole.” Donna leans in again. “My sister says it had to be the husband. Says maybe Shayna went off the cliff, but maybe her husband nudged her. Maybe.”

Stuffed in the file Malcolm gave her were a few photographs of Shayna and her husband culled online. In her wedding photograph a younger and healthier Shayna lay draped against her new husband, Jared Fowles, his arm wrapped right around her waist, his palm resting on her belly. The news article about her disappearance described the couple as estranged.

Of course he would be the point of gossip. A missing woman means a guilty husband, as Clare’s own mother used to say. Clare sat glued to the TV the summer her mother fell ill, her mother next to her, frail and wispy bald from the chemotherapy. A woman from two towns over had gone missing on her way to work, and Clare and her mother watched as the woman’s husband sobbed into a scrum of microphones and begged for his wife’s safe return.

Guilty, Clare’s mother said. You wait.

Days later, the news showed the flat hay field where the body was found and the police leading the handcuffed husband across his front lawn. Clare’s mother mustered the energy to stand and jab her finger at the TV.

It’s always the husband, she said. Always.

The french fries on Clare’s plate are soaked brown with oil. Donna picks another one up and eats it.

“So, photographer,” Donna says. “Where’d you come from?”

“A long way east of here. A small town.”

“Which small town?”

“I’m sure you’ve never heard of it.”

“Try me,” Donna says.

“Long Lake?”

An answer that told the asker nothing. In six months of driving Clare had passed through four towns with this same name, registering each of them and their features. But she’d always banked on one-off interactions, moving on before the questions got too probing. She will have to find another way to stem the inquiries.

“I didn’t like it there,” Clare says. “I don’t plan to go back.”

“Where’s your family?” Donna asks.

“I don’t really have any family.”

“So you just drive around taking pictures for a living?”

“It’s not much of a living. But it keeps me moving. I like to be moving.”

Clare takes hold of the soda can and squeezes it until it buckles. The give-and-take of conversation, the effort in calculating her responses, have given her a headache. All she wants is to finish her meal. Donna points a thumb over her shoulder.

“You took the ad for the Merritt trailer too.”

“I need a place to stay. The motel’s closed.”

“Well, you can’t stay in that trailer.”

“Why not? This Merritt guy isn’t around anymore?”

“Oh, he’s around.”

“So what’s the problem?”

“
He’s
the problem. Lost his family in the mine. Father and two brothers. His mother swallowed a loaded rifle a week later. He’s been on a rampage ever since.”

“Jesus,” Clare says.

“He’s taking the whole town down with him.”

“I don’t understand.”

“He’s supplying the junkies. That’s what I’ve heard. I know he’s selling his crap to kids a lot younger than you. Might as well be poisoning the town water. And that trailer’s in the middle of the woods. Right next door to the Cunninghams.”

Clare taps the poster again. “The Cunninghams? As in Shayna’s family?”

“Yep. All the town’s craziness is up on that ridge.”

It takes Clare a minute to absorb the implications, the stroke of luck. This trailer of Charlie Merritt’s sits right next door to Shayna’s family. Under the bun the meat of the burger looks gristly and gray. Donna heaves herself to standing.

“You like this kind of thing? Other people’s misery?”

“No,” Clare says. “I was making conversation.”

“If you leave now you can be in the next town before midnight.”

Clare keeps her head down to ward off Donna’s cautionary glare. Finally Donna retreats to the kitchen. What would Malcolm Boon do if he were here? He might tell her to be cautious, to sleep in the car instead. For six months it has been easy enough to deflect the attention of chatty strangers, gas station clerks or motel attendants or servers at diners like this one. Clare knew how to keep all conversation short. All along she’s pictured a terminus, a place that might swallow her whole, a place with enough scope to let an invented past go unchallenged.

Now she’s in a small town not so different from the one she left, and Clare can feel her past bubbling up again. The dread, the sense of abandon, of nothing to lose. Why not go knock on Charlie Merritt’s door? Out the window the street is deserted, the stoplight switching from green to yellow to red in deference to no one. Clare will eat the rest of her burger as slowly as she can. She will stay until the waitress kicks her out. The walk back to the car is only two blocks, but she is too awake after a day’s sleep. Who knows what sorts of people live here? The kind devoid of hope. The kind who refuse to leave a dying town. The kind who disappear.

It wasn’t swift. It took some time. I try to chart when my woes began. That’s what my mother calls them: woes. A quiet word, easy to bear. This is a cusp, I remember thinking as I swallowed what I’d been given. My fate was predetermined and I needed only to see how it would play out.

You told me. You warned me. You said we would all suffer, that people would start dying, that you wouldn’t tolerate it. But still, here you are.

My mother once said that there’s no rhyme or reason to who stays when things fall apart. It won’t be the people you expect. But I knew you would hang on. You can’t let go. You say it’s love, but I think it’s about control.

If I end up dead, then everyone will look at you and wonder. You’ll be the one to blame, and I’m not sure you’ll stand for that.