War Against the Weak: Eugenics and America's Campaign to Create a Master Race, Expanded Edition (100 page)

BOOK: War Against the Weak: Eugenics and America's Campaign to Create a Master Race, Expanded Edition
9.59Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
51.
Paul Popenoe and Roswell Hill Johnson,
Applied Eugenics
rev. ed. (New York: Macmillan, 1935), p. 6. Baur, Fischer, and Lenz, pp. 554-555,557,590-591.
52.
R.A. Fisher, “New Data on the Genesis of Twins,” in
Eugenics, Genetics and the Family: Volume I: Scientific Papers of the Second International Congress of Eugenics
(Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins Co., 1923), p. 195. “Booth 2-Physical Anthropometry,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XVII (I932), p. 142.
53.
Alfred Gordon, “The Problems of Heredity and Eugenics,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XX (1935), pp. 50,52-53. “Identical Twins,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XIX (1934), p. 134.
54.
Letter, John William Draper to Charles B. Davenport, 30 December 1924: APS B:D27: Davenport - John William Draper #3. Letter, Charles B. Davenport to John William Draper, 9 January 1925: APS B:D27: Davenport - John William Draper #3.
55.
“Notes and News,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XII (1927), p. 164. “Twins With Tuberculosis (Rev. of Diehl and Verschuer,
Zwillingstuberkulose),” Journal of Heredity
Vol. XXVIII No. 3 (March 1937), pp. 91-96. “On the Inheritance of Darwin’s Tubercle,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XX (1935), pp. 3-4. See “Eugenics in Germany,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XIX (1934), p. 42.
56.
“Berlin: From Our Regular Correspondent,”
Journal of the American Medical Association
Vol. 106 No. 4 (23 January 1936), p. 308.
57.
Weindling, p. 555. “The Hereditary Aspect of Pathology,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XXI (1936), pp. 21-22. “Verschuer’s Institute,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XXI (l936), pp. 59-60.
58.
Paul Popenoe, “Twins and Criminals,”
Journal of Heredity
Vol. XXVII No. 10 (October 1936), pp. 388-390.
59.
“Universitäts-Institut Für Erbbiologie und Rassenhygiene Frankfurt a.M. Gartenstr. 140 (Deutschland).”
60.
“Bericht iiber die im Jahre 1938 bisher durchgeführten und für die nächste Zeit geplanten Forschungen,” 30 September 1938: BAK: R 73 Akte 15342.
61.
Ziel und
Weg
Vol. 14, No.9 (1939), p. 449.
62.
Tage U.H. Ellinger, “On the Breeding of Aryans,”
Journal of Heredity
Vol. XXXIII No.4 (April 1942), p. 141.
63.
Ellinger, pp. 141-142.
64.
Ziel und
Weg
Vol. 14, No. 9 (1939), p. 449. “Wehrmachtsauftragsnummer: S 4891-5378,” undated report: BAK: R 73 Akte 15342, Blatt 64.
65.
Müller-Hill,
Murderous Science,
p. 76. “Bericht iiber die Fortführung der erbpsychologischen Forschung,” 14 March 1944: BAK: R 73 Akte 15342, Blatt 66.
66.
“Wehrmachtsauftragsnummer: S 4891-5378.” Posner and Ware, p. 18.
67.
Lagnado and Dekel, p. 47.
68.
Lagnado and Dekel, p. 51.
69.
Lagnado and Dekel, p. 45.
70.
Lagnado and Dekel, p. 47.
71.
Lagnado and Dekel, p. 55.
72.
Lagnado and Dekel, p. 31.
73.
Lagnado and Dekel, p. 36.
74.
Posner and Ware, pp. 36,43. Lagnado and Dekel, p. 42. Nyiszli, p. 60.
75.
Nyiszli, pp. 19,23,56-58.
76.
Nyiszli, pp. 39-40.
77.
Nyiszli, pp. 31-32, 58.
78.
Posner and Ware, p. 27. Lifton, pp. 164-165, 342-343. Nyiszli, pp. 132-133.
79.
Lifton, p. 342. Nyiszli, p. 57. Posner and Ware, pp. 48, 49. Testimony of Vera Alexander at the Jerusalem tribunal of Josef Mengele, February 1985 as cited by Helena Kubica, “The Crimes of Josef Mengele,” in Gutman and Berenbaum, p. 324. Lagnado and Dekel, pp. 58-59,64,67.
80.
Lifton, p. 343. Posner and Ware, p. 45. Gisella Perl,
I Was a Doctor in Auschwitz
(New York: International Universities Press, 1948), pp. 110-111 as cited by Posner and Ware, pp. 46-47.
81.
Nyiszli, p. 58. Lagnado and Dekel, pp. 66, 70-71. Posner and Ware, pp. 36-37,40. Testimony of unnamed survivor at the Jerusalem tribunal of Josef Mengele; February 1985 as cited by Posner and Ware, pp. 37-38.
82.
Testimony of Vera Alexander as cited in Gutman and Berenbaum, p. 324.
83.
Lifton, p. 351.
84.
Nyiszli, pp. 59, 61, 132.
85.
Lifton, p. 355. Lagnado and Dekel, p. 61. Gilbert, p. 687.
86.
Lifton, p. 360. Nyiszli, pp. 56, 57, 102-103. Hermann Langbein,
Menschen in Auschwitz
(Vienna: Europaverlag, 1972) as cited by Lifton, p. 362. Lagnado and Dekel, p. 65.
87.
Lagnado and Dekel, pp. 59-60.
88.
Nyiszli, p. 61.
89.
Nyiszli, p. 11. Gilbert, p. 756.
90.
“Bericht iiber die Fortführung der erbpsychologischen Forschung.”
91.
Nyiszli, p. 63.
92.
Nyiszli, pp. 175-181.
93.
Nyiszli, p. 65.
94.
“Hereditary Eye Defects,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XVIII (1933), pp. 43-44. See “Twins: Like and Unlike,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XXII (1937), pp. 119-120. See 11. “Myopia in Identical Twins,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XXII (1937), p. 64.
95.
“Supplement to Schedule for the Study of Twins,” attachment to letter, Harry F. Perkins to Harry H. Laughlin, 29 May 1936: Truman D-2-4:2.
96.
Weindling, p. 560.
97.
Testimony of Jancu Vexler before Judge Horst von Glasenapp, 13 March 1973 as cited by Kubica in Gutman and Berenbaum, p. 326. “Israel Visions of Hell: Pursuing the ‘Angel of Death,’”
Time Magazine,
18 February 1985.
98.
Lifton, p. 362.
99.
Karin Magnussen, “Bericht iiber die Durchrihrung der Arbeiten zur Erforsonung der Erbbedingtheit der Entwicklung der Augenfarbe als Grundlage für Rassen-und Abstammungsuntersuchungen,” 15 March 1944: BAK: R 73 Akte 15342 Blatt 68.
100.
Müller-Hill,
Murderous Science,
pp. 171-172.
101.
“Vernehmung: Vorgeladen erscheint Frau Dr. Karin Magnussen, geb. 9.2.08 in Bremen, wohnhaft Bremen, Hagenanersrrasse 7,” 25 May 1949: Max Planck Archive Abt. I, Rep. 3, Nr.26.
102.
Also see Major Leonard Darwin, “First Steps Towards Eugenic Reform,”
Eugenics Review,
Vol. 4 (ca. April 1912), pp 34-35 as selected in G. K. Chesterton,
Eugenics and Other Evils,
edited by and including additional articles selected by Michael W. Perry (Seattle, WA: Inkling Press, 2000), pp 144-145. Also see “Berlin: From Our Regular Correspondent,”
Journal of the American Medical Association
Vol. 104 No. 23 (8 June 1935), p. 2110.
103.
Charles B. Davenport, “Research in Eugenics,” in
Eugenics, Genetics and the Family,
p. 25.
104.
“Fifth International Congress of Genetics,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XII (1927), p. 152. “Radiogram to Gregg, 13 May 1932: RF 1.1 Ser 7171 Box 10 Folder 63.
105.
Tracy B. Kittredge, “Progress Report: Grant to Notgemeinschaft for Anthropological Studies of the Population of Germany,” 10 June 1933: RF 1.1 717 20 187. Letter, Norma S. Thompson to Schmidt-Ott, 14 November 1929: RF 1.1 717 20 187.
106.
“Genetics: Blood Groups of Twins,”
Eugenical News
Vol. XX (1935), p. 41.
107.
Paul J. Weindling, “From Philanthropy to International Science Policy: Rockefeller Funding of Biomedical Sciences in Germany 1920-1940,” in Nicolaas A. Rupke, ed.,
Science, Politics and the Public Good: Essays in Honor of Margaret Gowing
(New York: Macmillan Press, 1988), pp. 129, 133, 135. Letter, Raymond B. Fosdick to Selskar M. Gunn, 6 June 1939: RF l.l 717 16 150.
108.
Weindling,
Health, Race and German Politics Between National Unification and Nazism, 1870-
1945
, pp. 560-561.
109.
Müller-Hill,
Murderous Science,
p. 76. “Wehrmachtsauftragsnummer: S 4891-5378.”
110.
Unidentified survivor as cited by Posner and Ware, p. 37. Lagnado and Dekel, pp. 62, 66.
111.
Lagnado and Dekel, p. 37. Müller-Hill,
Murderous Science,
p. 128.
112.
Posner and Ware, p. 52.
113.
Müller-Hill,
Murderous Science,
p. 169.
114.
MiilIer-Hill,
Murderous Science,
pp. 169-1 70.
115.
David A. Hackett, ed. and trans.,
The Buchenwald Report
(Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1995), pp. 72, 369-370.
116.
See Joachim C. Fest,
The Face of the Third Reich: Portraits of the Nazi Leadership
(New York: Pantheon Books, 1970), p. 379 f. 44. See Heinz Höhne,
The Order of the Death’s Head: The Story of Hitler’s
SS
(New York: Coward-McCann, 1970), p. 157. See author’s communication with Harry W. Mazal, 10 February 2003.
117.
H. Nachtsheim, “Bericht iiber die im Halbjahr 1943/44 im Auftrage des Reichsforschungsrates durchgeführten Untersuchungen zur vergleichenden und experimentellen Erbpathologie,” 15 March 1944: BAK: R 73, Akte 15342, Blatt 61-63.
118.
Nachtsheim, “Bericht.”
119.
“Wehrmachtsauftragsnummer: SS 4891-5377,” undated report: BAK: R 73, Akte 15342, Blatt 65.
120.
Michael Shevell, “Racial Hygiene, Active Euthanasia, and Julius Hallervorden,”
Neurology
42 (November 1992), pp. 2214, 2216. Michael Shevell, “Reply from the Author,”
Neurology
43 (July 1993), p. 1453. Peter S. Harper, “Naming of Syndromes and Unethical Activities: The Case of Hallervorden and Spatz,”
Lancet
348 (1996), p. 1224. Müller-Hill,
Murderous Science,
p. 244. Jürgen Peiffer, “Neuropathology in the Third Reich,”
Brain Pathology
1 (1991), p. 127.
121.
Shevell, pp. 2216-2217.
122.
Letter, Thomas B. Appleget to Frederick Strauss, 14 April 1936: RF 1.1 7179 58. Weindling, “From Philanthropy to International Science Policy,” p. 133. Letter, Dr. Telschow to Dr. Hoffmann, 27 July 1938: Max Planck Archive I. Abt., Rep 1A, Nr. 1061/2. Kristie Macrakis,
Surviving the Swastika: Scientific Research in Nazi Germany
(New York: Oxford University Press, 1993), pp. 85-86.
123.
“Natural Sciences-Program and Policy: Past Program and Proposed Future Program,” pp. 79-80: RF RG 3.1 915 1 6. Diane B. Paul, “The Rockefeller Foundation and the Origins of Behavior Genetics,” in Keith R. Benson, Jane Maienschein and Ronald Rainger, eds.,
The Expansion of American Biolog;y
(New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1991), p. 266.
124.
“Natural Sciences,” p. 80.
125.
Lagnado and Dekel, pp. 89,92.
CHAPTER EIGHTEEN
1.
Gerald L. Posner and John Ware,
Mengele: The Complete Story
(New York: Cooper Square Press, 2000), pp. 57-64,91,93,94. Office of Special Investigations, “United Nations War Crimes List, Number 8” as cited by Posner and Ware, p. 63. “Universitäts-Institut für Erbbiologie und Rassenhygiene Frankfurt a.M. Gartenstr.l40 (Deutschland),” memorandum circa January 1939: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer Nr. 4.
2.
Otmar von Verschuer,
“Bevölkerungs- und Rassenfrage in Europa,” Europäischer Wissenschaftsdienst,
1 (1944), pp. 11-14 as cited by Benno Müller-Hill, “The Blood from Auschwitz and the Silence of the Scholars,”
History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences
Vol. 21 (1999), p. 335. Müller-Hill, p. 348.
3.
Max Planck Archiv: Nachlass Nachtsheim as cited by Müller-HiII, p. 348.
4.
Generally see James P. O’Donnell,
The Bunker: The History of the Reich Chancellery Group
(New York: Bantam Books, 1978).
5.
“Vertriebene Wissenschaft: Deutsche Gelehrte, die ins Ausland gingen,” Die
Neue Zeitung, 15
April 1946. “Kunst und Kultur in Kürze,”
Die
Neue Zeitung, 3
May 1946. Müller-Hill, p. 350. Letter, Otmar von Verschuer to Paul Popenoe, 28 August, 1946: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4.
6.
“Personalien v. Verschuer.”: Max Planck Archiv: II Abt. Rep. 0001A as cited by Müller-Hill, pp. 350-351.
7.
“Personalien v. Verschuer.” as cited by Müller-Hill pp. 350-351.
8.
“Personalien v. Verschuer.” as cited by Müller-Hill p. 351.
9.
“Personalien v. Verschuer.” as cited by Müller-Hill p. 351. Müller-Hill, p. 351.
10.
Letter, Paul Popenoe to Otmar von Verschuer, 25 July 1946: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. Letter, Otmar von Verschuer to Paul Popenoe, (sic) 31 September 1946: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4.
11.
Verschuer to Popenoe, 28 August 1946.
12.
Von Verschuer to Popenoe, (sic) 31 September 1946.
13.
Letter, Paul Popenoe to Otmar von Verschuer, 7 November 1946: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. Letter, Fritz Lenz to Otmar von Verschuer, 14 September 1946: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4.
14.
Letter, Paul Popenoe to Otmar von Verschuer, 8 February 1947: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. Letter, Otmar von Verschuer to Paul Popenoe, 26 February 1947: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. Letter, Paul Popenoe to Otmar von Verschuer, 12 May 1947: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. See letter, Otmar von Verschuer to Paul Popenoe, 20 December 1946: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4.
15.
Letter, Paul Popenoe to Otmar von Verschuer, 29 October 1947: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. Letter, C.M. Goethe to Otmar von Verschuer, 16 April 1948: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. See letter, Otmar von Verschuer to Lee R. Dice, 18 September 1947: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. See letter, Otmar von Verschuer to Lee R. Dice, 12 January 1948: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. See letter, Lee R. Dice to Otmar von Verschuer, 27 February 1948: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. See letter, Otmar von Verschuer to Lee R. Dice, 21 April 1948: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4. See letter, Ottnar von Verschuer to the “Charles Fremont Dight Institute for the Study of Human Genetics,” 12 August 1948: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer, Nr. 4.
16.
Müller-Hill, pp. 351-352. Letter, von Lewinski to Heubner, 23 December 1946 as cited by Müller-HiII, pp. 351-352. “Abschrift. Denkschrift betreffend Herrn Prof. Dr. med. Otmar Frhr. v. Verschuer,” as cited by Müller-Hill, pp. 352-353.
17.
Müller-Hill, p. 355. American Society of Human Genetics, “ASHG Past Presidents, 1948-2004,” at
www.faseb.org
.
18.
Müller-Hill, pp. 354-355. Generally see Otmar von Verschuer and E. Kober,
Die
Frage der erblichen Disposition zum Krebs
(Mainz: Verlag der Akadernie der Wissenschaft und der Literatur, 1956).
19.
Author’s interview with Dr. Kurt Hirschhorn, 12 February 2003.
20.
“Personalien v. Verschuer.” as cited by Müller-Hill p. 351. Müller-Hill, pp. 351, 354, 355.
21.
“Universitäts-Institut für Erbbiologie und Rassenhygiene Frankfurt a.M. Gartenstr. 140 (Deutschland),” memorandum circa January 1939: Universitätsarchiv Münster: Nachlass Verschuer Nr. 4. Nachlass von Verschuer as cited by Müller-Hill, p. 348. Karin Magnussen, “Bericht iiber die Durchrihrung der Arbeiten zur Erforsonung der Erbbedingtheit der Entwicklung der Augenfarbe als Grundlage für Rassen-und Abstammungsuntersuchungen,” 15 March 1944: BAK: R 73 Akte 15342 Blatt 68.
22.
“Medical Experiments of the Holocaust and Nazi Medicine,” at
www.remember.org
. Peter Tyson, “The Experiments,” at
www.pbs.org
.
23.
Leo Alexander as quoted by Barry Siegel, “Can Evil Beget Good? Nazi Data: A Dilemma for Science,”
Los Angeles Times,
30 October 1988.
24.
Nuremberg Military Tribunal, Green Book, Volume I,
p. 421. Anti-Defamation League, “Library Won’t Be Named for Nazi Scientist, Air Force Assures ADL,” press release of 14 February 2003.
25.
“Library Won’t Be Named for Nazi Scientist, Air Force Assures ADL.” “Objections lead OSU to remove picture of Nazi,
” 
Daily Illini,
29
October 1993. Cable News Network, “U.S. News Briefs,” 24 September 1995.
26.
New Mexico Museum of Space History, “International Space Hall of Fame: Hubertus Strughold,” at
www.spacefame.org
. Author’s interview with New Mexico Museum of Space History, 13 February 2003.
27.
Michael Shevell, “Racial Hygiene, Active Euthanasia, and Julius Hallervorden,”
Neurology
42 (November 1992), pp. 2214. National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, “The First Scientific Workshop of Hallervorden-Spatz Syndrome,” at
www.ninds.nih.gov
.
28.
Rubin I. Kuzniecky and Bradley K. Evans, “Julius Hallervorden: To the Editor,”
Neurology
43 (July 1993), p. 1452. Peter S. Harper, “Naming of Syndromes and Unethical Activities: The Case of Hallervorden and Spatz,”
Lancet
348 (1996), pp. 1224, 1225.
29.
NBIA Disorders Association, “Welcome to the NBIA Disorders Association Homepage,” at
www.hssa.org
. Author’s interview with Patricia Wood, 12 February 2003. NBIA Disorders Association, “NBIA Frequently Asked Questions, “ at
www.hssa.org
.
30.
“The First Scientific Workshop of Hallervorden-Spatz Syndrome.” National Instirutes of Health, “NINDS Hallervorden-Spatz Disease Information Page,” at
www.ninds.nih.gov
.
31.
“Brain sections to be buried?”
Nature
Vol. 339 (15 June 1989), p. 498. Wolfgang Neugebauer and Georg Stacher, “Nazi Child ‘Euthanasia’ in Vienna and the Scientific Exploitation of Its Victims before and after 1945,”
Digestive Diseases
17 (1999), pp. 282, 283. Dr. William E. Seidelman, “Medicine and Murder in the Third Reich,”
Dimensions: A Journal of Holocaust Studies
Vol. 13 No. I (1999).
32.
Jürgen Peiffer, “Neuropathology in the Third Reich: Memorial to those Victims of National-Socialist Atrocities in Germany who were Used by Medical Science,”
Brain Pathology
I (1991), pp. 125-126.
33.
Peiffer, p. 129.

Other books

Ordeal of the Mountain Man by William W. Johnstone
Quatrain by Sharon Shinn
Love & Death by Max Wallace
Maggie's Door by Patricia Reilly Giff
Dark Prelude by Parnell, Andrea
Gold of the Gods by Bear Grylls
Unnaturals by Merrill, Lynna
The Tin Drum by Gunter Grass