Authors: Xanthe Walter
be just because we want it."
"I know that! I just thought I knew better than
you. Your language about your father was always
so extreme, and I guess I thought that maybe he was
your blind spot."
"Matt, I know you think that because you've
been around Hollywood for a few years and seen
some of its ugliness that you're worldly wise, but
you're really not," Rick said ruefully. "I hate to
break it to you, kid, but you had a pretty sheltered
childhood, and while you've got a temper on you
like a volcano, you're really one of the sweetest
people in the world."
"And I'm your sub, and you love me - I get all
that," Matt said quietly. "But those aren't good
reasons not to punish me."
"I don't want to punish you!"
"I know!"
They gazed at each other miserably for a long
time.
"I know," Matt said again, more gently this
time. "And honestly - I don't want to be punished."
Rick threw up his hands in exasperation.
"Then why are we even having this conversation?"
"Because I think this is one of those times
when it's the right thing to do," Matt said earnestly.
"I'm a sub, Rick. I'm your sub, and I gave you the
right to punish me when you collared me. I gave
that freely because I trust you, and the truth is…"
He paused, blinking, his blue eyes glassy. "The
truth is that I screwed up. I lied to you, I hid
something from you, and I hurt you; because you
are hurt - don't pretend you aren't."
Rick sat back on the sofa, wishing he was
anywhere but here right now, having this particular
conversation.
"And it was a damn big lie, Rick, not a little
one about whether you really look good in those
cowboy boots you love so much." Matt gave a tight
little grin.
"What's wrong with my cowboy boots?" Rick
grinned back wanly. "Look, Matty - you were
protecting me. I can't punish you for that."
"I was protecting you, but that's not all I was
doing. See, I let your father into the house in the
first place was because I was curious. The whole
situation about the box and your relationship with
him… it was messy; and you know how much I
hate things being untidy." Matt grimaced.
Rick rolled his eyes. "If I was going to punish
you for your OCD, then you'd never sit down
again."
"It's been a lot better since you collared me."
"I'd noticed. I also noticed it started up again
these past few days since my dad began pouring
his poison into your ears. I should have realized
what was going on earlier and done something
about it." Rick sat forward on the sofa. "The
minute that box showed up, I should have realized
this was one of his cons. I guess I was too busy
reeling from finding out about my mom to figure it
out, but I should have done. So really this is as
much my fault as yours."
"Bullshit."
Matt glared at him, and Rick glared back.
Stalemate.
Finally, Rick broke the silence. "Okay! I can
understand all the reasons why you think I should
punish you!"
"Thank you." Matt inclined his head.
"But the truth is, I'm not happy handing out a
punishment," Rick continued. Matt sighed and sat
back on his heels stubbornly. "Hear me out! I love
spanking your cute little ass for our mutual
pleasure," Rick told him with a little grin. "I love
holding you down and tormenting your body in a
hundred different ways that make you scream but
again, for our pleasure. I'm not happy hurting you
when there's no pleasure to be had from it, for
either of us. I know plenty of doms and subs have
that kind of dynamic and it works fine for them, but
it's not for me." He folded his arms over his chest,
feeling very definite on that point.
"And I really don't want to talk myself into
that kind of punishment, either." Matt sighed. "But,
the truth is, I feel really guilty, Rick, and I think I
deserve a punishment for what I did, even if I'll
hate it - especially if I'll hate it."
"Does that even work?" Rick demanded.
"See, I've been disciplined hundreds of times, Matt
- in juvie, in jail, at work, at the Justice Hall - and
all it ever did was make me feel resentful."
"That's how you work, Rick, but it's not me.
Besides, I think for punishment to work you have
to feel you deserved it, and you probably never
did."
"The only thing I felt I really deserved
punishment for was what I did to Sally," Rick said
quietly. "But I also knew no punishment would
really be enough for what I did to her."
"And you ended up punishing yourself for
years anyway," Matt pointed out.
Rick rubbed his jaw thoughtfully. "You're
saying that this is one of those times when you'll
feel worse if I don't punish you than if I do?"
Matt took a deep breath. "Yes," he said. "It
was a betrayal. I betrayed you, in a way, Rick, and
you're the one person in the world I'd never, ever
want to hurt. You've been through enough as it is,
and I just made it worse…" He broke off, looking
choked up, and bent his head down to the carpet
again.
Rick got up and went over to where Matt was
kneeling. He crouched down in front of him, lifted
his sub's face, and kissed him gently on the lips.
"I forgive you," he said softly. Matt made a
little sound in the back of his throat and leaned into
him. "Let's sleep on it and see how we feel in the
morning. It's all too raw right now."
Matt felt guilty when Rick ordered their
favorite take out. He felt guilty when Rick got out
his favorite movie on DVD, pulled him between
his legs, and they lay there together, watching it.
He felt guilty when Rick kissed him and told him
he loved him, and most of all, he felt guilty when
Rick took him to bed that night, bound his wrists
together with a red silk scarf, and made love to
him slowly and gently, like he was the most
precious thing in the world and not the liar who'd
deceived him.
Matt lay awake all night, his head resting on
Rick's chest. He knew Rick wasn't asleep, either,
and they both lay there in silence, locked up in
their respective worlds as they each tried to come
to terms with the other's needs.
As dawn broke, Matt turned, rested his hands
on Rick's chest, and looked down at his dom.
"I'm being selfish. I know how you feel about
punishing a sub. I knew that when we got together.
I even told Sebastian…" He broke off as Rick
stiffened beneath him. "Sorry - I know you hate me
mentioning him - but I once told him that you don't
believe in discipline, and he was the opposite. He
didn't believe in pleasure spankings, only in
discipline."
"Well, he's a shit," Rick growled.
Matt grinned. "Yeah, we both know that.
Look, Rick, I can't ask you to do this, knowing how
you feel about it, but I also can't make myself feel
like I don't deserve it when I do. I feel guilty every
time you touch me, and I don't see that changing
anytime soon, so…" He took a deep breath. "I was
thinking that I should go to a punisher?"
Rick sat up so fast that Matt almost got
whiplash.
"No!" he snapped. "No other dom is going to
lay a finger on you, Matt."
"They won't touch me; it's just punishment.
You can come with me and supervise if you're
worried, and…"
"Absolutely not! Matt - listen to me; if you go
to a professional punisher, it would be far more of
a betrayal than you telling me that lie. I would
never be able to forgive you for it."
"Then of course I won't go." Matt sat back,
holding up his hands. "Sorry - I just thought it
might be a solution."
"Well, it damn well isn't! And now I need to
go punch something. A punisher?" Rick got up,
growling to himself under his breath and shaking
his head repeatedly. A few minutes later, Matt
heard him down the hallway, pounding into the
punching bag in the gym.
Matt had never been to a punisher, but he'd
read about them. He knew you discussed with them
what you felt you needed to be punished for, and
they gave their suggestions but ultimately the
choice was yours; all the punisher did was provide
the agreed punishment, for a fee. There was no
touching, no sex, nothing erotic about it all; it was
purely discipline.
Matt had never understood why anyone would
willingly go and submit themselves to that before,
but now he did. He needed some kind of
acknowledgement of his wrongdoing, to pay some
kind of penance, and to experience the catharsis
that came with that. Rick might have given him
forgiveness and absolution, but it had been too
easily won; Matt needed to feel he'd earned it.
He was at a loss as to what to do next. He
wanted his dom. He needed his dom, even if his
dom didn't want to be around him right now.
Matt got up, tiptoed along the hallway to the
gym, and leaned against the door, listening to Rick
furiously beating the punching bag into submission.
Matt could sense his anger and pain even through
the closed door. Whether Rick wanted to face it or
not, he was feeling hurt and betrayed, and his
determination to deny that was Rick all over.
Matt knelt down and rested his head on the
floor. Rick might not want or be asking for his
submission right now, but he needed to give it
anyway. The kneeling position helped relieve the
guilty ache in the pit of his belly and being near
Rick always calmed his anxieties. Matt zoned out,
trying to lose himself in his submission.
Why was this happening? He'd never felt this
way with any other dom. He'd taken discipline but
never asked for it, or wanted it, or even felt he
needed it. Often, like Rick, he'd just resented it.
When Rule had caned him, he'd felt nothing but
anger. So why did he feel this way now? Shouldn't
he be glad he had a dom in his life who wasn't like
Rule or Emily?
Since accepting Rick's collar, he felt as if
he'd gone on a journey into his own submission,
and the sub inside him was blossoming in ways he
hadn't expected. He was finding out so much about
himself, and surprising and freaking himself out in
the process. Now was when he needed a dom to
guide and help him on his journey, but Rick didn't
want to be that guide.
That dom behind the door, beating a punching
bag into oblivion, was the love of his life, but Matt
needed a dom who would challenge him, hold him
to his own values, anchor him, and keep him
grounded, even if it was hard on them both. Rick
would happily dream up a dozen different
scenarios to keep his sub happy in the bedroom,
but this was the one thing he'd always refused to
do. Maybe he could never be the kind of dom that
Matt needed him to be, in which case, where did
that leave Matt?
Matt didn't have an answer to that, and he
pressed his nose into the hallway carpet, feeling
completely lost.
Rick pounded away at the punching bag until
his rage at the idea of Matt going to see a punisher
finally faded.
Then he picked up his towel, wiped it over
his sweaty face, strode out of the gym… and
almost fell over the kneeling sub outside the door.
"What the…? Matt? You really have to stop
doing this. Not that I don't like the whole kneeling
thing, but it's more of a turn on in the bedroom than
when I fall over you in other parts of the house."
Rick tried to make a joke of it, but his sub
didn't say a word. He just knelt there, offering Rick
a submission that he didn't feel like taking. Rick
sighed and sat down on the carpet beside his sub,
his back against the wall. "Matt, come here." He
gently pulled his sub into his arms and held him.
"This isn't going to go away, is it?" He kissed
Matt's hair.
"I don't think so," Matt said into his tee shirt.