Authors: Xanthe Walter
Rick traced little circles on his sub's back,
wondering how the hell they were going to get out
of this mess. "Damn my fucking father," he
growled.
"Would have happened at some point
anyway," Matt muttered, looking up at him. "I feel
like we're sort of evolving, Rick. We were both so
new to being a dom and sub when we got together.
I'd never even experienced my true submission
until I met you, and you'd always been so scared of
fully embracing your dom side. We've opened up
parts of ourselves that are new to us and freak us
out; this was always waiting to happen."
"Yeah, you could be right. Difference is, you
always face your fears head-on, Matt, while I run
from mine."
"That's not true! Your dad raised you that
way, sure, but you're not him." Matt rested his head
on Rick's shoulder. "I didn't expect to feel like this,
Rick, but you unlocked something in me when you
collared me, and I'm discovering something about
myself every day. I had no idea I'd feel so strongly
about this; it's blindsided me."
Rick played with his sub's hair gently. "I get
that, Matty. It's the same for me. I've never really
taken responsibility for a sub before, and I don't
know how it works. Who knew relationships were
so complicated, huh?"
Matt sighed. "I know. I thought once you
found someone you were crazy in love with, and
who loved you back, then it'd all be easy after that.
Guess I was wrong."
"Yeah." Rick chuckled. "Seems like we both
still have a lot to learn. Look, I was thinking while
I was doing all that punching - how about a non-
physical punishment?"
Matt frowned. "Like what?"
"I dunno - you do all the cooking for a month,
maybe?" Rick suggested.
"That sounds more like a punishment for you
than me." They exchanged a brief smile at that.
Matt sat up and looked at him. "I know this is one
of yours worst fears, Rick. I know how you feel
about hurting subs and why. I can understand that,
and I hate that I'm putting you in this position."
Rick sighed. "It'll be okay, Matty. We'll figure
it out," he said, with more optimism than he felt.
"Will we? How?" Matt looked up at him
earnestly.
Rick thought about it for a moment. Matt was
right - he was floundering because of his own lack
of experience, and he needed some good advice
from a dom he trusted. Unfortunately, he'd never
had many of those in his life.
Rick dropped a kiss on his sub's head and
then disengaged himself and got up. "I'm going
out," he said. "Be here when I get back."
He made a phone call and then took a shower
and got dressed in a pair of black chinos, a thick
black leather belt with a fancy silver buckle in the
shape of an eagle, and a plain black shirt. He
shouldered himself into his black leather jacket,
grabbed his wallet, phone and keys, and left the
house.
He drove his Harley to the coffee shop and
went inside, looking around as he unbuckled his
helmet.
"Hey." A familiar figure stood up and waved
to him. "I got you coffee."
Karl pointed at the table, and Rick sat down
opposite him in the small, private booth. "I was
surprised to get your call. I know what newly
collared couples are like," Karl said, with a
knowing grin. "I'm amazed you've even come up
for air yet."
"Hmm. Yeah." Rick swirled his spoon around
in his coffee for a long time, wondering where to
start.
"So… why are we here?" Karl asked. "It
sounded pretty important on the phone."
"Yeah. It is." Rick swirled some more.
Karl sat back with a sigh. "In your own time,
O'Shea."
"Right."
They were silent for a long time. Karl clearly
wasn't going to make this easy for him by drawing
him out in conversation, and Rick didn't have a
clue where to start. He'd never had to deal with
emotional situations before; he'd always happily
avoided them.
"Matt wants to go to a punisher," he blurted
out suddenly.
Karl leaned forward again, looking startled.
"Uh. Okay. That was unexpected. I think you need
to give me some more information if you want my
advice. I take it that's why I'm here?"
"Yeah, I didn't know who else to ask. See, I
know a lot of doms." Rick thought of his old dom
friends, like Cilla and Hannah. "But they aren't
really serious doms, if you get my meaning. It's all
a game to them. I wanted to talk to someone real,
someone who gets it."
"So you came to me?" Karl looked both
pleased and surprised.
"Well, you've been kicking my ass about Matt
for the past few months, and your advice hasn't
turned out to be totally crappy so far." Rick made a
face. "So yeah, I figured you were the one to ask."
"A ringing endorsement if ever I heard one!"
Karl rolled his eyes. "Come on, mate - tell me
what's going on. Why the hell would Matt, of all
people, feel the urge to go and see a punisher?"
Rick told Karl the story slowly, trying to be
fair to everyone and get all sides included, so Karl
could appreciate the situation and give his
considered opinion.
When he'd finished Karl took a sip of his
coffee, looking puzzled. "I don't really understand
the problem here, Rick."
Rick frowned. "Do you need me to explain it
again?"
"Fuck, no! You've just spent the past half an
hour explaining it! I understand what you think the
problem is, I just don't see it that way myself."
"So what should I do?" Rick asked
helplessly.
Karl sighed. "Rick, being a dom isn't only
about keeping your sub happy in the bedroom or
thinking up fun games to play - although I'm sure
you're very good at that." He grinned. "Being a
serious dom, which is what you've just told me you
want to be - well, that's about doing the things you
don't particularly like, either. I understand that
punishing Matt is the very last thing you want to
do, but it's the right thing to do, mate. It's time for
you to dom up and give that sub what he needs."
"Would you always give in to a sub's request
for punishment?" Rick demanded. "As the dom,
that's my decision, isn't it? Supposing he's wrong
about wanting it? I don't want to fuck Matt up by
doing it if it then turns out to be wrong, and he
hates me for it."
"No, I wouldn't always give a sub a
punishment just because they'd asked for one - I'd
take each situation on its own merits, "Karl replied
thoughtfully. "But in this case, I think Matt's right.
He both deserves and needs this punishment, and
this isn't one of those times when you go easy on
him. In fact, this is one of those times when you
step up and show him that you'll catch him when he
falls."
Rick glanced up, startled. "That's what I
always say to him in the bedroom, when he's
struggling with his submission. I always promise
him I'll catch him when he falls."
"And you always have, I'm sure, but this isn't
about sex, Rick. This is about the kind of dom and
sub you both want to be."
Rick nodded slowly. "But that's just it - I
don't know that this is the kind of dom I want to be.
It seems more like the kind of dom Rule was, and I
don't want to be anything like him."
"Fuck that - I told you before, you're nothing
like Rule! Look, Rick, punishment isn't evil of and
by itself. I've punished subs before if they've asked
for it, or sometimes if I felt it was right and if
they'd freely given me that power over them. I
might not always have liked doing it, but then
again, I've sometimes asked them to do things they
don't particularly like, either." Karl shrugged. "It'd
be great if life wasn't so complicated, but it is."
Rick held up his hands helplessly. "I just don't
see what gives me the right to punish him when he
screws up, when I screw up all the time."
"Because you don't get anything from
punishment, but he does! You know how anxious
Matt can get, how he does all that counting, and
how he gives himself such a hard time. He was
always going to need some discipline in his life to
anchor him. You should have seen something like
this coming, Rick."
Rick shrugged. "I guess we were so happy
that I never even thought about it."
"You're both so spectacularly clueless that I
can believe that." Karl laughed at Rick's little
growl of protest. "Well you are! Look at how damn
long it took you to see sense and get together!
Look, I know about your past, Rick - I know how
hurting a sub is this great big fear in your life, but
did you ever think that you're hurting him more by
not giving him what he needs?"
Rick concentrated on scooping up some sugar
that had spilled onto the table, pushing it into neat
little piles with his spoon.
Karl leaned forward. "I understand where
Matt is coming from on this, Rick," he said quietly.
"See…" He hesitated, and then ploughed on. "I've
visited a punisher myself, a couple of times."
"What?" Rick looked up in surprise. "You?"
"Why not? Plenty of doms visit punishers
when they feel the need," Karl muttered, flushing.
"Oh, I know that - I'm just surprised because
you're so damn together all the time; always
handing out little pep talks." Rick snorted. "I can't
imagine you ever feeling the need to go to a
punisher; you always seem to have life so figured
out."
"Yeah, well, we both know that's not true,"
Karl growled. "If it was, I wouldn't be alone and
mooning hopelessly over the one sub in the world I
can't have."
Rick raised an eyebrow. "Daniel?"
Karl grimaced. "Is it that bloody obvious?"
"Possibly not to him."
Karl sighed and sat up straight. "Let's get
back to your problem - I'm always better with
other people's problems than my own. The way I
see it, Rick, is that you have two choices. You
either let Matt go to a punisher with your blessing,
or you dom up and take care of it yourself." He
finished his coffee in a single gulp and stood up.
"Now, I gotta go. Sorry I don't have an easy
answer for you, mate, but then again - I never do,
do I?"
He gave an apologetic little smile, and then
he left.
Rick wasn't ready to go home yet, so he rode
up to his favorite spot in the hills, where he used to
come as a kid and dream of a escaping his shitty
life.
He got off the bike and leaned against a rock,
looking down on the world below. He'd always
found a kind of peace up here, even in the darkest
times. Maybe if he sat here for a while, the answer
would come.
If he did this, it wouldn't be easy. He would
have to find an inner core of strength and inhabit
his dominant side more fully than ever before.
Any punishment had to be cleansing, cathartic and
meaningful. It couldn't be so little as to leave Matt
feeling let off, or so harsh that Matt felt harmed or
resentful. It had to be done with firmness but also
with love. Could he be Matt's disciplinarian as
well as his lover? Did he want both those roles?
He thought of Matt letting his father into his
house and lying to him about it. He remembered
his sub flinching away from him in guilt over that
lie, and how it had felt to come home and find his
father sitting in his dining room with his sub,
without his knowledge.
That jogged a memory, and he got out his
phone and listened to the voicemail message Matt
had left for him that day, urging him to return from
his run.
"Rick, I think I've done something stupid.
Please come home. Your father is here, and…
sorry… this isn't making any sense - just come
home now, and I'll explain everything."
He listened to it several times, trying to figure
out how he felt about it.
Matt was right. His father had taught him to
always outrun his pain - to deny it, push it down,