Read Why We Get Fat: And What to Do About It Online
Authors: Gary Taubes
Doctors who understand why we get fat and what to do about it are obviously hard to find; otherwise, this book wouldn’t be necessary. The truly unfortunate fact is that even those doctors who do understand the reality of weight regulation often hesitate to prescribe carbohydrate restriction to their patients—even if this is how they maintain their own weight. Physicians who tell their fat patients to eat less and exercise more, and particularly to eat the kind of low-fat, high-carbohydrate diet that the authorities recommend, will not be sued for malpractice should any of those patients have a heart attack two weeks or even two months later. The doctor who goes against established medical convention and prescribes carbohydrate restriction has no such safeguard.
*
There are now innumerable diet books that preach carbohydrate restriction, not to mention cookbooks and websites devoted to low-carbohydrate eating, and even smart-phone apps that can be used for guidance. But it’s vital that doctors understand what I’ve discussed here, that they open their minds to these ideas and, more important, to the hard science that has too often been ignored. This is true of public-health officials, too, not to mention the obesity researchers themselves. As long as these authorities buy into the logic of calories-in/calories-out and dismiss carbohydrate restriction as a fad diet, we will suffer for it. We need their help, which is why this book was written as much for your doctors as for you. Until our doctors truly understand why we get fat, and until our public-health authorities do, the job of losing that fat and remaining healthy will always be far more difficult than it need be.
*
The South Beach Diet
(2003) is another best-selling variation on this theme, but with the emphasis on lean meats and fats from vegetable sources (olive and canola oil, avocados and nuts, for instance) rather than animal. In the one clinical trial of this diet, weight loss, as expected, rivaled the Atkins-like diets, but not the beneficial results for heart-disease and diabetes risk factors.
*
Kemp discussed his experience in a series of three articles published in the British medical journal
Practitioner
between 1963 and 1972, by which time he’d treated almost fifteen hundred obese and overweight patients. Lutz discussed his results in his 1967 book
Leben ohne Brot (Life Without Bread)
, which was republished in English and revised with the help of Christian Allan, a biochemist, in 2000.
*
In
The Carbohydrate Addict’s Diet
Rachel and Richard Heller argue, in effect, the exact opposite: that sustained weight loss is best achieved by eating one balanced “Reward Meal” a day that includes carbohydrates. This is another concept that may be true and is worth a try, but has never been adequately tested.
*
The same is true for the occasional elevation of cholesterol that will occur with fat loss—“transient hypercholesterolemia”—a consequence of the fact that we store cholesterol along with fat in our fat cells. When fatty acids are mobilized, the cholesterol is released as well, and cholesterol levels can spike as a result. The existing evidence suggests that cholesterol levels will return to normal, or fall even lower than what they were, once the excess fat is lost—regardless of the saturated-fat content of the diet.
*
As Blake Donaldson said in his 1962 memoirs, no matter how well someone does on the mostly meat diet that Donaldson prescribed, “any disaster that may overtake him, even to the extent of ground moles getting in his lawn, will be blamed on his diet.”
“No
Sugar, No Starch” Diet: Getting Started
This diet is focused on providing your body with the nutrition it needs, while eliminating foods that your body does not require, namely, nutritionally empty carbohydrates. For most effective weight loss, you will need to keep the total number of carbohydrate grams to
fewer than 20 grams per day
. Your diet is to be made up exclusively of foods and beverages from this handout. If the food is packaged, check the label and make sure that the carbohydrate count is 1 to 2 grams or less for meat and dairy products, 5 grams or less for vegetables. All food may be cooked in a microwave oven, baked, boiled, stir-fried, sautéed, roasted, fried (with no flour, breading, or cornmeal), or grilled.
WHEN YOU ARE HUNGRY,
EAT YOUR CHOICE OF THE FOLLOWING FOODS:
Meat: Beef (including hamburger and steak), pork, ham (unglazed), bacon, lamb, veal, or other meats. For processed meats (sausage, pepperoni, hot dogs), check the label—carbohydrate count should be about 1 gram per serving.
Poultry: Chicken, turkey, duck, or other fowl.
Fish and Shellfish: Any fish, including tuna, salmon, catfish, bass, trout, shrimp, scallops, crab, and lobster.
Eggs: Whole eggs are permitted without restrictions.
You do not have to avoid the fat that comes with the above foods
.
You do not have to limit quantities deliberately, but you should stop eating when you feel full
.
FOODS THAT MUST BE EATEN EVERY DAY:
Salad Greens:
2 cups a day
. Includes arugula, bok choy, cabbage (all varieties), chard, chives, endive, greens (all varieties, including beet, collards, mustard, and turnip), kale, lettuce (all varieties), parsley, spinach, radicchio, radishes, scallions, and watercress. (If it is a leaf, you may eat it.)
Vegetables:
1 cup (measured uncooked) a day
. Includes artichokes, asparagus, broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cauliflower, celery, cucumber, eggplant, green beans (string beans), jicama, leeks, mushrooms, okra, onions, peppers, pumpkin, shallots, snow peas, sprouts (bean and alfalfa), sugar snap peas, summer squash, tomatoes, rhubarb, wax beans, zucchini.
Bouillon:
2 cups daily—as needed for sodium replenishment
. Clear broth (consommé) is strongly recommended, unless you are on a sodium-restricted diet for hypertension or heart failure.
FOODS ALLOWED IN LIMITED QUANTITIES:
Cheese:
up to 4 ounces a day
. Includes hard, aged cheeses such as Swiss and Cheddar, as well as Brie, Camembert, blue, mozzarella, Gruyère, cream cheese, goat cheeses. Avoid processed cheeses, such as Velveeta. Check the label; carbohydrate count should be less than 1 gram per serving.
Cream:
up to 4 tablespoonfuls a day
. Includes heavy, light, or sour cream (not half and half).
Mayonnaise:
up to 4 tablespoons a day
. Duke’s and Hellmann’s are low-carb. Check the labels of other brands.
Olives (Black or Green):
up to 6 a day
.
Avocado:
up to ½ of a fruit a day
.
Lemon/Lime Juice:
up to 4 teaspoonfuls a day
.
Soy Sauces:
up to 4 tablespoons a day
. Kikkoman is a low-carb brand. Check the labels of other brands.
Pickles, Dill or Sugar-Free:
up to 2 servings a day
. Mt. Olive makes sugar-free pickles. Check the labels for carbohydrates and serving size.
Snacks: Pork rinds/skins; pepperoni slices; ham, beef, turkey, and other meat roll-ups; deviled eggs.
THE PRIMARY RESTRICTION: CARBOHYDRATES
On this diet, no sugars (simple carbohydrates) and no starches (complex carbohydrates) are eaten. The only carbohydrates encouraged are the nutritionally dense, fiber-rich vegetables listed.
Sugars are simple carbohydrates.
Avoid these kinds of foods:
white sugar, brown sugar, honey, maple syrup, molasses, corn syrup, beer (contains barley malt), milk (contains lactose), flavored yogurts, fruit juice, and fruit.
Starches are complex carbohydrates.
Avoid these kinds of foods:
grains (even “whole” grains), rice, cereals, flour, cornstarch, breads, pastas, muffins, bagels, crackers, and “starchy” vegetables such as slow-cooked beans (pinto, lima, black beans), carrots, parsnips, corn, peas, potatoes, French fries, potato chips.
FATS AND OILS
All fats and oils, even butter, are allowed. Olive oil and peanut oil are especially healthy oils and are encouraged in cooking. Avoid margarine and other hydrogenated oils that contain trans fats.
For salad dressings, the ideal dressing is a homemade oil-and-vinegar dressing, with lemon juice and spices as needed. Blue-cheese, ranch, Caesar, and Italian are also acceptable if the label says 1 to 2 grams of carbohydrate per serving or less. Avoid “lite” dressings, because these commonly have more carbohydrates. Chopped eggs, bacon, and/or grated cheese may also be included in salads.
Fats, in general, are important to include, because they taste good and make you feel full. You are therefore permitted the fat or skin that is served with the meat or poultry that you eat, as long as there is no breading on the skin.
Do not attempt to follow a low-fat diet!
SWEETENERS AND DESSERTS
If you feel the need to eat or drink something sweet, you should select the most sensible alternative sweetener(s) available. Some available alternative sweeteners are: Splenda (sucralose), Nutrasweet (aspartame), Truvia (stevia/erythritol blend), and Sweet ’N Low (saccharin). Avoid food with sugar alcohols (such as sorbitol and maltitol) for now, because they occasionally cause stomach upset, although they may be permitted in limited quantities in the future.
BEVERAGES
Drink as much as you would like of the allowed beverages, but do not force fluids beyond your capacity. The best beverage is water. Essence-flavored seltzers (zero carbs) and bottled spring and mineral waters are also good choices.
Caffeinated beverages: Some patients find that their caffeine intake interferes with their weight loss and blood sugar control. With this in mind, you may have
up to 3 cups of coffee
(black, or with artificial sweetener and/or cream), tea (unsweetened or artificially sweetened), or caffeinated diet soda per day.
ALCOHOL
At first, avoid alcohol consumption on this diet. At a later point in time, as weight loss and dietary patterns become well established, alcohol in moderate quantities, if low in carbohydrates, may be added back into the diet.
QUANTITIES
Eat when you are hungry; stop when you are full
. The diet works best on a “demand feeding” basis—that is, eat whenever you are hungry; try not to eat more than what will satisfy you. Learn to listen to your body. A low-carbohydrate diet has a natural appetite-reduction effect to ease you into the consumption of smaller and smaller quantities comfortably. Therefore, do not eat everything on your plate just because it’s there. On the other hand, don’t go hungry! You are not counting calories. Enjoy losing weight comfortably, without hunger or cravings.
It is recommended that you start your day with a nutritious low-carbohydrate meal. Note that many medications and nutritional supplements need to be taken with food at each meal, or three times per day.
IMPORTANT TIPS AND REMINDERS
The following items are NOT on the diet:
sugar, bread, cereal, flour-containing items, fruits, juices, honey, whole or skimmed milk, yogurt, canned soups, dairy substitutes, ketchup, sweet condiments and relishes.
Avoid these common mistakes:
Beware of “fat-free” or “lite” diet products, and foods containing “hidden” sugars and starches (such as coleslaw or sugar-free cookies and cakes). Check the labels of liquid medications, cough syrups, cough drops, and other over-the-counter medications that may contain sugar. Avoid products that are labeled “Great for Low-Carb Diets!”
LOW-CARB MENU PLANNING
What does a low-carbohydrate menu look like? You can plan your daily menu by using the following as a guide:
Meat or other protein source (usually eggs)
Fat source—
This may already be in your protein; for example, bacon and eggs have fat in them. But if your protein source is “lean,” add some fat in the form of butter, cream (in coffee), or cheese
.
Low-carbohydrate vegetable (if desired)—
This can be in an omelet or a breakfast quiche
.
Meat or other protein source
Fat source—
If your protein is “lean,” add some fat, in the form of butter, salad dressing, cheese, cream, or avocado
.
1 to 1½ cups of salad greens or cooked greens
½ to 1 cup of vegetables
Low-carbohydrate snack that has protein and/or fat
Meat or other protein source
Fat source—
If your protein is “lean,” add some fat in the form of butter, salad dressing, cheese, cream, or avocado
.
1 to 1½ cups of salad greens or cooked greens
½ to 1 cup of vegetables
A sample day may look like this:
Bacon or sausage
Eggs
Grilled chicken on top of salad greens and other vegetables, with bacon, chopped eggs, and salad dressing
Pepperoni slices and a cheese stick
Burger patty or steak
Green salad with other acceptable vegetables and salad dressing
Green beans with butter
READING A LOW-CARB LABEL
Start by checking the nutrition facts.